HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jgowdy

595 karma · joined January 12, 2017

submissionscomments
jgowdy··on Facebook and Google hit with $8.8B in lawsuits on day one of GDPR
I know case law disagrees with me on shrink wrap licenses, but I'm going to state my argument that T&C aren't really a contract. If the language is inaccessible to one party who also doesn't have representation, and they plainly aren't reading it, and they're clicking "I agree" mindlessly rather than signing, then I don't see how you can claim there's any sort of meeting of the minds.

When prenuptial agreements are signed for example, if one party has an attorney, the other party should have an attorney if they expect the agreement to hold up later.

I believe the case law around shrink wrap licenses is nothing more than a pragmatic recognition of a business "need" (desire) to have complex legal terms to defend themselves against claims. I believe it falls short of what we should recognize as a valid contractual agreement as a society.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meeting_of_the_minds

I also don't think "the right to pay me money and use my service" is really valid consideration.

But I'm not a lawyer and that's just my opinion about the way things should be, not how they actually are in today's varying jurisdictions.

jgowdy··on Facebook and Google hit with $8.8B in lawsuits on day one of GDPR
Cue the apologists claiming this isn't going to be a money grab very largely targeting American tech companies, and that GDPR regulators are going to be very gentle, rational, and friendly in shepherding companies towards privacy compliance.

I agree with the GDPR in principle, but the manner in which the enforcement was setup, and the way it didn't phase in the aspects over time, and the way the fines are subjective from painful to destructive without any clear guidance as to how they will be levied, and considering the regulations were written in such a way that people seem to have a very poor understanding of what the actual rules are unless they have legal teams giving them the answers leaves me with doubts that this isn't yet another European regulatory money grab at the same time that it's a much needed advancement on privacy reform.

What's even better is all the non-lawyers posting blog posts saying STOP FREAKING OUT!!! Stop interpreting the rules wrong!!!

When you create a system that could amount to a severe financial risk, in the way this was done, I can't exactly rest easy given the advice of Jon Q. Blogspam Esq attorney from Wordpress School of Law.

If GDPR were clearly and rationally written, if it had a explicit grace period and progressive fines rather than instant potential massive liability, if regulators had front loaded more of the official clarifications prior to it taking effect so that everyone wouldn't have to pay law firms to ask the same questions, etc then we wouldn't all be flooded with stupid emails and misfires by every company we do business with. And saying that anyone who is afraid of GDPR is doing something bad with user data is just unfounded slander.

I am extremely pro-privacy and what they're trying to do for privacy here is great. The execution could have been much better. And I highly doubt the apologists will be around to explain why they were wrong when people operating in good faith, trying their best to be compliant are fined for non-compliance in an audit.

jgowdy··on Google helps Pentagon analyze military drone footage
Literally all of the equipment used to kill people, from the rifles, to the bullets, to the fighter jets, to the parts to repair the fighter jets, are manufactured by private companies in the United States. So I’m confused by your confusion in thinking that Google’s assistance in the drone program is somehow the first private company to participate in providing goods and services that are directly involved in killing people. Is Google somehow more culpable than the companies that make the bullets or bombs? How is providing software and computing power for that any different? You don’t think a private company writes the software that targets things for jets and missiles?
jgowdy··on Xennials, the micro generation between Gen X and Millennials
Toddler is what was said, so toddler is what I was correcting. I didn’t make the statement in your question, “toddler is the age you use to consider whether someone grew up with a game console.”
jgowdy··on Xennials, the micro generation between Gen X and Millennials
NES released in North America in 1985. Toddlers are 1-3 years old. I don’t mean to be pedantic but as someone born in 1979, your statement didn’t match my experience.

I agree though, I already had significant time on my Atari 2600 and on my father’s Intellivision before NES came out.

jgowdy··on Best Alternative to DigitalOcean?
I’ve had a good experience with SSD Nodes
jgowdy··on California-Grown Coffee Is Becoming the State's Next Gold Mine
Per month. Very small yard. Fake grass in the back.
jgowdy··on Debian developer revisits FreeBSD after 20 years (2015)
You don’t need to honor the “premise” of the OS, nor do I think the developers of the OS care which software I prefer to run. Run whatever you’re comfortable with.

If it was such an issue for them, I’m sure they’d remove the GNU packages they pre-build and host for you. The premise of BSD is you don’t have to use the GNU tools. But they give you the choice.

jgowdy··on California-Grown Coffee Is Becoming the State's Next Gold Mine
No it is not. The water districts are extremely powerful, and the biggest usage districts are held by agricultural interests. They have staggered elections to stop water board takeovers and ensure that they can shift water costs from usage based to per-meter fees. Captive homeowners in agriculture controlled water districts can end up with $200 a month water bills for a family of four.

Source: Lived in a water district for 7 years with some of the cheapest water in the state (sub $3 a unit) yet a water bill for a family of four with fake grass and small yard of around $180 a month. If we used ZERO water, the bill would have been about $120 in flat fees. We were subsidizing the massive avocado groves and other major agricultural producers in the water district. They brushed off our complaints and the fact that we pointed to neighboring cities with $40 water bills.

jgowdy··on Debian developer revisits FreeBSD after 20 years (2015)
And the main solution for that is just install the GNU tools you prefer from ports or packages. Super simple.
jgowdy··on Rusty Russell: The Corrosion of Ethics in Cryptocurrencies
In my humble opinion, burning fossil fuels to create electricity to “mine” this “currency” is unethical because it literally has no net gain to society, not even entertainment. The same goes for the manufacture of the electronics used to mine. You hear a lot of condemnation for businesses willing to pollute to create wealth, but many of those same people don’t see that cryptocurrency mining is exactly that.
jgowdy··on Chrome 68 will mark all HTTP sites as “not secure”
The people who are pushing back against HTTPS really bug me to be honest. They say silly things like “I don’t care if people see most of my web traffic like when I’m browsing memes.”

That presumes that the ONLY goal of HTTPS is to hide the information transferred. However, you have to recognize the fact that you run JITed code from these sites. And we have active examples of third parties (ISPs, WiFi providers) inject code into your web traffic. When browsing the web with HTTP you are downloading remote code, JITing it, and running it on every site you visit if you aren’t 100% noscript with no HTTP exceptions. You have no way of knowing where that code actually came from.

Now consider that things like Meltdown and Spectre have JavaScript PoCs. How is this controversial?

jgowdy··on Google Won’t Take Down ‘Pirate’ VLC with Five Million Downloads
You have to offer the source code to the people you give the binaries to. For example, if your product isn’t free, you only owe source code to those who you sell your product to (assuming that’s exhaustively who you distribute it to). You don’t have to offer the source code to everyone in the world, nor to the authors of the parent work in particular.
jgowdy··on LinuxBoot: Linux as Firmware
Are you aware that the Linux Foundation employs Linus Torvalds? And that a very vast majority of Linux (and most other) open source development is done by developers who are paid employees of major corporations like Red Hat, IBM, Oracle, etc? Some people seem to have the idea that it’s developed by hippie volunteers living in a commune, but the fact is, open source development is done by interested parties who are typically employees of corporations who stand to benefit from their work. And that’s okay.

As a donor to the Linux Foundation, I don’t find it creepy. Same goes for the Cloud Native Computing Foundation.

jgowdy··on Why we're underestimating american collapse
Enumerate a number of unfortunate circumstances in the United States of America today. Check.

Insist that these instances of these happenings are quite different than they ever have been before. Repeatedly emphasize how historic and unprecedented these events are. Preemptively brush off any precedents that might be raised. Check.

Make the leap from a bombastic enumeration of America's social failures to the clear and obvious conclusion that America is about to collapse. Never mind the number of times that claim has been made before. No real effort at arguing why the one follows the other. Just do some textual hand waving and presto, collapse!

Now let's wrap it all up in a ribbon by implying that the collapse is so inevitable that while it may not have occurred yet, it may as well have. So let this be an object lesson from any nations who think to emulate the United States of America. You too will find yourselves inexplicably leaping from "has some significant social problems and failures" to "the entire nation will collapse and the rubble will bury your children."

jgowdy··on The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem
Of course the US can and will continue to hide from its extreme poverty. There’s not nearly enough attention for any serious action to take place. It’s already well known to those who care, and unknown or forgotten by those who don’t particularly care.

The few articles I’ve seen lately and over the years about how expensive it is to be poor don’t even begin to reach the critical mass needed to take even the smallest token action.

I appreciate the topic and I care, but the headline is nonsense. The situation will continue and likely it will worsen.

jgowdy··on Apple prepares macOS users for discontinuation of 32-bit app support
They aren’t dropping fat binaries. ARM desktops and laptops are on deck. They might make sense next year or in three years or never, but Apple is going to leave that door open. They’ve learned the lesson not to be locked to a single CPU architecture.
jgowdy··on Taking Equifax to Small Claims Court
A judgement against someone else is a civil affair, not a criminal issue. Law enforcement officers enforce criminal law as a matter of course. In a lawsuit when one person owes money to another due to a judgement, that debt is private and you have to bear the costs of the state in enforcing your debt using law enforcement officers.

Just like police officers at a concert aren't staffed for free, even though their only purpose is to enforce the laws and/or facilitate traffic. You could argue that enforcing those laws and facilitating that traffic is their job, but those putting on the concert are creating the need for extra law enforcement and want them on hand, so they have to pay.

jgowdy··on Taking Equifax to Small Claims Court
It's not a fantasy. Uncollected judgements can be enforced through direct property seizure if you follow your State's laws. Typically you call law enforcement first and pay them a fee for an escort to seize the property. For businesses, you typically schedule the law enforcement escort for the end of the day so you can seize the cash in the cash register. If I remember correctly, it costs around $75 to have our local county sheriff escort you for property seizure for a judgement.
jgowdy··on Taking Equifax to Small Claims Court
Important point you touched on there. In the case of businesses you should always use zero balance accounts for checks, EFTs, ACHs, etc. The smaller your business, the more you're at risk of an existential threat if someone takes money from your master account unexpectedly or for the wrong amount.
jgowdy··on An Amazon Order Might Lock You Out of Trusted Traveler Programs
I’ll jump in here. I believe the constitution does provide a right to travel both domestically and internationally.

When I choose flight as my mode of transport, and I choose to do business with a private company, (entering into a private contract with that company to convey my body from one location to another), I believe the government demanding that I be searched and inspected and scanned in order to allow the private company and I to conduct our private business of providing me with transportation is unconstitutional. The federal government does not have an affirmative grant of power over my right to travel, and two because I have the right to travel. All powers not granted to the federal government are reserved for the states or the people.

I feel like this fallacy that travel is a privilege comes from the whole “driving is a privilege” concept. But keep in mind, while driving is a privilege (under STATE law), riding isn’t a privilege, it’s a right. I may need the blessing of a STATE government to drive a car across state lines, but I don’t need the blessing of state or federal government to ride as a passenger in a vehicle across state lines. In the case of the flight, I’m not engaged in a regulated activity of flying a plane, I’m merely a citizen exercising their right to travel.

jgowdy··on Dropbox Developer Terms and Conditions
Which is funny because in the past and in other legal areas, a contract requires a meeting of the minds, requires that everyone have adequate representation available, etc. Yet with click through contracts you have none of that. You don’t even have any sort of validated identification of the party that supposedly “signed” the “contract.” You have lopsided terms that do nothing to create equity between parties or indicate that informed negotiation took place. It’s just one party dictating terms to another party, with the ability to rewrite those terms on a whim with some petty opt-out period.

EULA / TOS click wrap and shrink wrap licenses make a mockery of contract law out of convenience, transferring effectively what was supposed to be a reasonable agreement between two identified and informed parties and making it a completely one sided agreement dictated to one party, which nobody has actually identified until a claim arises.

The alternative is to not have license agreements. License agreements just end up including terms that companies wish they could change about the law but can’t. So instead of having to get politicians to ban reverse engineering, they just include it in their license. Instead of having to get policiticans to ban or limit class action lawsuits, they just force you out of the courts.

jgowdy··on [dead]
I prefer Linode in a lot of ways, but the current best price/value for me is SSD Nodes.

https://www.ssdnodes.com

jgowdy··on Do we really need a new BGP?
> At some point, you'll need to interoperate with those horribly dogmatic vendor hugging networks that serve the majority of traffic on the internet.

And this has been their defense all along. It serves the status quo to imply that transitions must be difficult. IPv6 being the most obvious example today. Of course as DJB pointed out, backwards compatible IPv6 would have already rolled out by now, at the cost of a single /64. Dual stack was literally the most difficult way to accomplish IPv6.

Now let’s look at the BGP situation. As long as the outcome is the same (same routing tables result in nominal situations), any two ISPs could choose to use a different protocol for their interconnection. Same thing that has happened with a lot of supplemental networking protocols.

There are BGP alternatives on deck. What we don’t need is high profile network engineers speaking out against them and in favor of the status quo. The truth is, networking is the one part of the industry that isn’t improving at the same pace as the rest. And all the improvements that are happening seem to be related to single links and switching, whereas the defense of networking dogma is related to routing. According to the holy bible of networking, switching is easy, routing is hard. Routers must be memory restricted with small memory footprints to artificially create SKUs. Routers must operate on multi-minute timers rather than seconds. Building routing tables is an insanely intense and time consuming process. Blah blah blah.

The reality is, almost all of these problems are contrived to maintain the status quo and so network vendors can ignore the pace of hardware and instead set SKUs at resource levels that force you to use the “appropriate” piece of hardware for the appropriate task.

Another smell that should make this obvious to everyone is that almost every major company has had high level engineers make some statement of how network companies are ripping you off, and explaining how they bought white box network solutions that route layer 3 at wire speed, converge rapidly, and have tons of memory. Not to mention the vast improvement something like well designed SDN can provide.

The network companies rely on the fact that most companies don’t have the labor or expertise to use white label solutions. But that doesn’t disprove the point. That proves the point that the state of hardware is “super cheap components provide all the switching and routing performance and memory needed for almost 99% of networking purposes.” Companies like Cisco are playing the Intel +25Mhz game. Supposedly disrupting companies do so at an awfully measured pace. And the network staff generally will open up to off brand switches but start to shy away at routing, especially edge routing.

As an industry, networking needs to be disrupted and it needs a severe model change. People involved in networking need to get on board, and those who don’t and insist on fighting for the status quo need to be left behind.

jgowdy··on Do we really need a new BGP?
I have to disagree with the primary point being offered up in this post. In my career I’ve met quite a few network engineers who don’t think sufficiently outside the box. They typically say “this is how it’s done, this is how it works.” The idea that we can’t come up with a better protocol than BGP to manage the interconnections of the Internet is absurd. We don’t say “well security isn’t a programming problem, it’s a human problem, so there’s no point in making safer programming languages.” BGP is a ridiculous system of complete trust just like many older protocols.

If we sat down and started designing a routing protocol to handle the advertisement of routing tables on the internet, would we come up with BGP again? Would the new protocol potentially offer up fixes for some of the most common and obvious problems with BGP? Then there’s potential for improvement.

The network industry resists and slows the horribly needed disruption in several key areas through the dogmatic defense of the status quo that we typically hear from its constituents.

This is why so many of us pray for SDN. It’s the only way to wrest control of networking away from those who typically have dogmatic vendor based training rather than a “network science and theory” education that leads to innovation.

jgowdy··on Intel Analysis of Speculative Execution Side Channels [pdf]
Agreed, which is why I’m worried about retpoline as it’s a rather hacky (but obviously pragmatic) solution that isn’t compatible with shadow stacks that mitigation strategies won’t be compatible with.
jgowdy··on LLVM patch to fix half of Spectre attack
The problem I see with this concept is ROP mitigations like Intel’s control flow enforcement don’t seem compatible with intentionally using tweaked addresses with ret. The address they inject won’t match the shadow stack and the program will be terminated.
jgowdy··on iMac Pro Available Now
When is Apple going to recognize that we want Nvidia GPUs? Come on Apple. People are literally buying outdated MacBook Pros to have a CUDA compatible GPU.
jgowdy··on Ask HN: Is Amazon “dumping” streaming video and should it be prevented?
There’s a fine line here between dumping, bundling, and loss leading. Amazon bundles video with a Prime subscription. Not all customers under that promotion have to be profitable, and not all of them have to be profitable in the same way (based on usage pattern and the associated costs). Loss leading is also a legitimate technique to drive customers into the funnel for up sales.

For this to be properly considered dumping, Amazon would have to be intentionally putting price pressure on Netflix and Hulu by under pricing their offering significantly.

jgowdy··on Two Factor Auth List
But support for raw sockets is going to destroy the internet! Steve Gibson warned us! Now it’s too late!
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →