HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jgranby

140 karma · joined June 23, 2008

Hi. I write Macintosh software.

http://deadbeatsoftware.com

submissionscomments
jgranby··on Stupider Than You Realize
Having ability to learn and having learned are quite obviously different. For example, I was good at languages in school, and could easily have gone on to a language degree at a good university, but decided to do law instead. 3 years later and my French is very out of practice. It is (unfortunately) easy to have a talent for something and fail to cultivate it.
jgranby··on Ask HN: What apps are essential for mac?
I second OmniWeb. It's the best browser there is. The tab implementation is second to none, in particular the ability to discontiguously select multiple tabs. Site-specific preferences are also incredibly useful.
jgranby··on Ask HN: What do you eat?
Absolutely. Inexpensive cuts of meat are by no means 'worse' than expensive cuts. Certain cuts are always going to be expensive, such as fillet of beef, rack of lamb, but more under-appreciated (and cheaper) cuts can be just as good.

As for examples, pork belly is still very cheap, even since it came into fashion a few years ago, and is much more flavoursome than other cuts. Chicken legs are much cheaper than chicken breast, despite the former having more flavour. Rump steak is more flavoursome than Sirloin. Offal can be delicious, too, and despite its cheapness it is used in the very best restaurants without compunction. You simply have to know what you're looking for.

jgranby··on Thought police muscle up in Britain, soft totalitarianism arrives
Non-hysterical?! It compares modern-day Britain to East Germany and the October Revolution, on the basis that Britain criminalises hate speech (lots of other countries do, too). The author is Australian, and doesn't live in Britain as far as I can tell, so I'm not sure why he's purporting to lecture about how life is here. Ironically, hate speech is also a criminal offence in Australia, and the Australian section is the longest in Wikipedia's Hate Speech article. The sort of trivial, tabloid-type stories he tells (but doesn't link to) aren't really enough to make a serious case that the UK is some sort of North Korea-esque totalitarian regime.

Anyway, I won't flag you -- I'd be interested to read what others think -- but I don't think it's a very good article.

jgranby··on Conservatism and cognitive ability are negatively correlated
The definition of Conservative used is laughable. Religious belief has nothing to do with whether you're a conservative or not, and there's no mention of small government, lower taxes, which are what conservatism is about. The definition seems to be a caricature of America's religious right, but the sample is of foreign students in the US. In other words, the definition is based on a subset of American conservatives, which has no equivalent in many of the countries that the students will have come from.
jgranby··on Ask HN: Critic as Artist
Perhaps. Although there is, I would suggest, an element of problem solving with programming that doesn't seem to apply with poetry. Most projects I start are chosen because I feel that that particular app needs making, that the problem in question needs solving. I enjoy programming by itself, but whenever I do it there is almost always a sense of purpose, if not of necessity.
jgranby··on Safari 4 beta released
It still works for me. Are you just referring to keyboard shortcuts, or can you not cycle through using the menu bar either? If you're trying to use cmd-shift-arrows, it won't work when a text field has focus, because they're the keyboard shortcuts used for selecting from the cursor until/from the end/beginning of the line. This changed a while back. Best to use cmd-shift-[ and cmd-shift-] instead, or the crazy new ones described in the menu. I'm not sure what the situation is for Windows.
jgranby··on [dead]
Anthropogenic global warming hasn't been "proved" either. And the agreement by peer review of however many climatologists, whose jobs also depend on global warming's acceptance, doesn't really lend it any credibility in my eyes.

Of course one month is anecdotal, and you're right to say it is -- it undermines the anti-warming camp's credibility rather than helping it. But every year up until this one, any mention of the hot summers on the BBC (I live in the UK) was always attributed to global warming. So the pro-global warming guys don't hesitate to promote anecdotal evidence that favours them, too. The sooner both sides drop it, the better.

My own opinion is that the 150 years or so that the global warming discussion centres on is insignificant looking at the bigger picture. Just look at the MWP, which happened on its own without fossil fuels, etc. Trends like the one that's happening now have always happened; there's always been warming and cooling. Add to that the ~15-year periods of cooling in the 50s and 90s, and I'm hardly convinced there's correlation with CO2 output, let alone causation.

But even after that big rant, I still wish people would keep this stuff off HN. It doesn't belong here -- keep it to Reddit or wherever.

jgranby··on Adobe UI Gripes
I don't think it would be anywhere near as funny without such over-the-top profanity. There is clearly plenty of tongue in cheek, and I found the whole thing hilarious. Don't evaluate it as a serious critique but rather as an amusing skit of Adobe's frustratingly clueless UI design.

My favourite one is "Nice bug you bunch of bellends".

jgranby··on Ask HN: Which school do you attend?
Durham
jgranby··on Earth on the Brink of an Ice Age
It amuses me the great lengths people go to trying to downplay 70s global cooling. You're doing it yourself -- a few scientists, a few publications. If it really was only a few publications, and as trivial as you insist, then why does everyone remember it so well? And if it really was a crackpot minority getting undeserved media attention, where was the backlash from the alleged majority of scientists who didn't believe it? The majority these days are pretty quick to discredit anyone who questions global warming. It doesn't seem to me that there were many scientists back then labeling it a crusader's diversionary tactic.
jgranby··on 2008 was the year man-made global warming was disproved
You've hit the nail on the head -- our CO2 output has been going up all the while, which suggests that (dare I say it?) the increase in temperature isn't caused by man. CO2 output didn't decrease in the 50s, either, when we had our last decade-long period of cooling.
jgranby··on Why you should support Mac OS X and Linux
It isn't just about how many early adopters there are -- it's that, with Linux and OS X, they make up a much larger proportion of users. There are probably a lot more savvy Windows users, but the high proportion of early adopters in Mac/Linux markets makes it easier to be recognised by those types of user if you're targeting them.
jgranby··on Ask HN: Can someone explain to me why all languages don't try to have the same syntax?
Because the people who designed them didn't agree on what was the best solution for the problem. And the people who use the various languages don't agree, either. Do you really think that you could sit down with a Lisp fanatic and a Java fanatic and get them to decide on a single syntax that they'd each rather use than their own favourite? They'd each prefer to do it their own way.
jgranby··on Ask HN: Can someone explain to me why all languages don't try to have the same syntax?
Analogy with human languages isn't ideal, because they have almost all grown up organically, whereas programming languages are, to a large extent, designed. The reason that every language doesn't use the Latin alphabet is, amongst others, geographic -- so many others grew up in isolation from the West, they'd never come across that alphabet before. The same isn't really true of programming languages.
jgranby··on IPhone Dev Spends $500k on Development, Still Not Approved by Apple
This isn't the average iPhone app. As the article mentions, this requires actual hardware infrastructure -- not something your average iPhone indie is worried about.

Even if the $500k wasn't overspending for what they wanted to do, the part that seems crazy to me was that they spent that money before getting the green light from Apple and with full knowledge that the approval process is opaque, often lengthy, and sometimes seemingly arbitrary.

Of course Apple's policy is wrong and unreasonable for developers. But these guys knew that this was the case, and they seem to have acted as if they had no idea.

jgranby··on IPhone Dev Spends $500k on Development, Still Not Approved by Apple
It is indeed, but it's clear from the interview that they knew how opaque and unpredictable Apple's policies are. I'm baffled as to why they went and spent so much money before they knew they'd be accepted.
jgranby··on Ask HN: What do you think of Objective-C?
horrid and butcherous hack

Obj-C, unlike C++, is a strict superset of C. All C code works in Obj-C (bar the new keywords), unlike with C++. I really think you're missing the point here. Apart from the controversial syntax, Objective-C's elegance sets it apart from C++ more than anything else. Objects and classes are really C structs. It's all introspectable, and it's all admirably simple (2.0 additions aside).

C++ is a convoluted, over-wrought solution to a problem which Objective-C solved with minimal additions to C. And Cocoa is leagues ahead of anything you have in C++.

jgranby··on IPhone Dev Spends $500k on Development, Still Not Approved by Apple
Compared to the average iPhone app budget, I'd bet that it is a lot of money.
jgranby··on Simple iPhone Interface for Hacker News
The main thing I dislike about this is that the domain isn't shown. But neither this nor iCombinator does as good a job as the main HN site at displaying a lot of information in a small amount of space. There is no need for iCombinator to have three lines per entry, and I think that your one needs to display more information.
jgranby··on Ask HN: Is it worth switching to a Mac?
A good deal of OS X is open source, but that's beside the point. I don't really care that XNU, etc, are open source, because I don't want to develop an OS -- I want to develop for that OS. If you're so bothered about everything being open, then I suppose you are using OpenBSD, not Linux or anything else, because it doesn't contain binary blobs? Seriously, I don't understand why you're so bothered about things being open that you'd never change anyway.

On the other hand, Cocoa is a better API than anything available for Linux or Windows, and that does matter to me. So do the consistent and logical keyboard shortcuts across all apps, the high level of UI design absent on almost every other OS, how all my hardware just works without having to edit configuration files, and loads of other detail that Apple pays attention to. There's a lot more to good design than being grandma-friendly, and not many people except Apple get it right.

jgranby··on Not My Gorilla
That isn't the case, because his site isn't broken in IE. All he said was that he doesn't care to check any more. I used to access it when I was at school and IE was the only option, and the only thing that didn't work was the unicode character he uses to return from a footnote to where it is referenced. The reason that IE's share is so low is the nature of the web site and the type of people who read it.
jgranby··on Ask HN: what tunes are you working to at the moment?
Nice to see someone recomending dubstep. The more minimal, techno-influenced stuff is good for working to, particularly anything on Skull Disco. Also check out the Millie & Andrea 12".
jgranby··on Ask YC: Apple sent me a takedown notice - what should I do?
Exactly. DRM is usually there to make it difficult to do something that is illegal anyway. With music, it's just as illegal to copy (copyrighted) non-DRM music as it is to copy DRM-protected music. The reason the DRM is there is because people still share music, even though it's illegal. It's the same reason we put locks on our doors: if everyone were law-abiding law, we wouldn't need them, but we do need them because people do break the law. It's not about freedom at all -- it's about stopping people breaking copyright (and other) laws, laws which still apply even when DRM isn't used.
jgranby··on Flip Title ( ǝlʇıʇ dılɟ) : write upside down
I could see this being pretty popular for Facebook statuses, etc. I'd change the download links suggestion for one about Twitter, though.
jgranby··on Ask YC: Apple sent me a takedown notice - what should I do?
The whole point of DRM to to remove people's freedom; therefore Apple clearly are taking people's freedom away.

No, it's not. Apple don't use DRM because they're anti-freedom. Is this really what you're suggesting? That Apple looked at DRM and thought, "Hey, what a great way we can take away some freedom, let's do that!"? They do it to protect their interests against competitors, pirates, etc. Perhaps they don't need to take all the measures they do, and opening things up a bit more wouldn't harm them. But they're perfectly entitled to try to stop people from doing these things.

jgranby··on Ask HN: Can the iPhone play videos on websites?
Apart from YouTube videos, it can play some H.264 videos with its built-in Quicktime player, which can be launched automatically from Safari. This is how BBC's iPlayer (on-demand) service works with the iPhone/iTouch. I don't know too much about what types of video are allowed, but this might help:

http://www.apertureprofessional.com/showthread.php?t=2957

jgranby··on Open-source your product
I write a small Mac shareware program. Perhaps the suggestion isn't aimed at me, but if I open sourced the whole thing, one person with enough knowledge could compile it and distribute to everyone else for free. I have little doubt that sales would be hit very hard.

Web apps might be a bit more suited to it once they have momentum and users. If Facebook released its source code (security issues aside), it wouldn't make a difference to them -- people join and use Facebook because all of their friends use it, and that's got nothing to do with the source code.

jgranby··on A Letter from Iceland: A World without Money
Use this link to bypass the "register to read the whole article" rubbish:

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/66c87994-aec1-11dd-b621-000077b076...

jgranby··on [dead]
He didn't say no one can refute a religious belief, he said that no one ever wins religious arguments, which is pretty much on the mark. I have a suspicion that you won't leave this discussion with a changed opinion about global warming, and I doubt that anything anyone's going to say here will make you change your mind.

Personally, I agree with you that mankind could do something that would have a permanent effect on global temperature. I am simply of the opinion that there's nowhere near enough cogent evidence that this is what is happening. A paltry 150 years' worth of possibly inaccurate data, containing two decade-long periods of cooling? If you take away all the media hype and bias, there's not a lot there to convince me.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →