HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jimmy1

1,377 karma · joined February 12, 2018

All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.
submissionscomments
jimmy1··on Losing My Perfect Job
Your intention seems honorable, and I am glad you are passionate about keeping your employees jobs. But if I was an investor in your company, I would be concerned that your first focus is not to keep the business afloat. What good are giving employees jobs if you have no business?

Also I think it's a tad naive to think one can possibly know the enumerable circumstances that would force your hand. Suppose you are a company dependent on logistics. Bam, Iraq war. The price of a barrel of oil skyrockets. Your shipping costs have quadrupled. You can keep to your principles and vow to not lay off a single employee, because as you said, this would "demonstrate failure", or you can keep your business and regrettably let go of a few workers in order to keep up with costs. You can try rising your prices, but pretty much a forgone conclusion that a 4x price increase will net you a significant decrease in customers, unless you are a rare unicorn, some good or service one cannot simply be without.

(the above scenario is basically what happened to my father's small business in 2005. Could not keep up with the rise in transportation costs, and cheaper, less quality competitors moved in. Consumers went with the cheaper option. It happens.)

jimmy1··on Losing My Perfect Job
The problem is what justification and whose justification? Under what standard? Additionally, what employee is ever going to feel like their firing is justified?

"Oh shit, well yeah, I guess I would have fired me too."

A mature response for sure, but a highly unlikely one.

jimmy1··on Norway Is Walking Away from Billions of Barrels of Oil
A government of the people by the people. Such a wonderful ideal, one I wish more strived towards.
jimmy1··on Losing My Perfect Job
On the flip side, imagine being a business owner, and having absolutely no options left but to make this decision and salvage what you can left of your business. Should the business risk bankruptcy and cause 100% of the workforce to be jobless, or is it better if just 25% lose it? The company could rebound, and hire an additional 50% on top of the original 100%. It's the circle of business life.
jimmy1··on Hedge-fund billionaire Ray Dalio says capitalism is failing America
By your standard then, Stallinism and Maoism is socialism.

The rest of this comment is beyond ridiculous.

jimmy1··on Making Video Games Is Not a Dream Job
Really I don't think you need unions at all, at least not now in the information age. If all employees across various industries simply shared salary figures (adjusted for cost of living, of course, to be fair), it would have the same effect as most of the benefits of union membership. That knowledge by itself would be incredibly empowering. The late Alan Kruger pointed this out when reflecting on the famous "Card and Krueger" experiment.
jimmy1··on Hedge-fund billionaire Ray Dalio says capitalism is failing America
Crony Capitalism is failing America. Capitalism is succeeding the Globe.

It is responsible for the most prosperity, the lifting up of poverty, and improvement in living conditions and life expectancy in the history of literal history.

I hate how capitalism has become a political boogeyman now. Fortunately, it has actually served to unite some of the left-wing and right-wing thinkers and forge some unlikely alliances.

Probably completely off-topic, but having listened to many of his interviews, it's also one of the main reasons why Howard Schultz chose to run as an independent instead of a democrat.

jimmy1··on Correctness – A paradigm for sustainable software development
> idiomatic Haskell is going to be much faster than what most people are using.

I am not trying to be pedantic, but your point is moot if you consider what "most people" are using are not dynamically typed interpreted languages like Python Ruby or PHP, but rather statically typed, compiled languages like Java, C#, and C++. Java by itself dwarfs Python and Ruby combined.

jimmy1··on The IRS Tried to Take on the Ultrawealthy – It Didn’t Go Well
> but also by virtue of being a powerful enough to tackle corruption.

After all, it was tax evasion of all things that brought down Al Capone.

jimmy1··on Making Video Games Is Not a Dream Job
The easiest way to debunk your claim that it is purely propaganda is to give easy counter-examples. In this case, may I present to you New York's finest: The MTA and LIRR. where rampant abuse of the system is everywhere and somehow, amazingly, have one of the highest disability claim rates out of any group of workers in the country.

Either working for the MTA or LIRR is one of the most dangerous jobs in the country, or this is quite literally "organized crime"

And who could forget this story? Is this "25 years of propaganda"? https://nypost.com/2013/12/20/ex-lirr-union-boss-in-gravy-tr... https://nypost.com/2014/08/06/nearly-all-lirr-workers-have-d...

Anyways, not saying there aren't good, hard working people in unions out there, and they don't provide some functional value, but like anything in life they have become corrupted.

Unions can certainly succeed if the the employee side also has a vested interest in the success of the company just as much as the company has, and that balance is maintained. Then, you truly have a collective.

jimmy1··on Show HN: I made a platform for journalists to “open source” their fact checking
For an excellent book on your points, see "The Righteous Mind" https://righteousmind.com/
jimmy1··on Show HN: I made a platform for journalists to “open source” their fact checking
> Whether they were harassing is a matter of opinion

But when you report it as a matter of fact in an editorializing headline, then it is a problem.

> Whether there was a confrontation is a matter of fact

This was not the narrative portrayed, in the slightest bit. Had this been the headline and narrative, I would have had no issue with it, either. The stories that day were "Boy in MAGA hat harasses Native Americans" period.

jimmy1··on Errors – Gotta Catch 'Em All
> while ignoring the ridiculous notion that you can know every possible error that every function can trigger now or in the future.

If you have a statically typed language, and defined error types that are only thrown in certain situations, can you please explain to me why it is so ridiculous to think you cannot know every possible error that will occur? If function a calls function b, and function b throws errors x y and z, why is it I cannot check for x y and z in function a? Additionally, say there are some additional outside runtime errors that can occur such as out of memory errors, again these are ideally known ahead of time, and you can use a constrained runtime to minimize them. Taking this a little further, if you cannot know every possible error, then you cannot possibly have any sort of remote closeness to formal verification, and that means our software systems that rely on more stringent verification methods are a lie. (I hope you don't write any medical device software!)

I am making an assumption and maybe think you are just trying to say this heuristically ? Like maybe we are all writing web software, and meh, close enough if you handle most errors, and "meh" for the rest of them? I mean I certainly think that works for the majority of development that happens, but more and more we are becoming keenly aware that our software has real world impact on people's lives and maybe some added stringency is what we need.

jimmy1··on Show HN: I made a platform for journalists to “open source” their fact checking
The most recent and obvious case in my mind: Covington Catholic Incident: almost every major mainstream media outlet ran with the narrative that the boys were harassing the Native Americans which was based solely on one video clip. No traditional investigative work was done. No one was interviewed (until the damage had been done). Nothing was fact checked. It was just one video, and boom: instant headlines.
jimmy1··on Less Pizza, More Yoga: E-Sports Embraces Traditional Training Methods
I think this takes away from the professionalism of these individuals. At a certain level, we are all doing things we want to be doing, otherwise we would be looking for ways to do other things. If you follow a lot of top eSports players in LoL challenger, for example, they all love the game, but you can tell the difference in professionalism even in their online personas towards the game. There's no doubt QTPie loves the game, but it's also no secret that the reason he isn't a top tier ADC anymore is because he doesn't want to deal with the grind and just wants to enjoy himself (and more power to him for it -- this isn't a character judgement, just pointing out the difference)

Most probably love the game, but having been a semi-professional CS player myself in the past, it very much feels like "work" sometimes.

> it's what you would do anyhow if you weren't being paid for it.

Much different scrimming for fun or playing matches with your buddies/team mates/pub stomping versus practicing very detailed specifics or scenarios, or testing different team compositions and strategies over and over and over again.

jimmy1··on Errors – Gotta Catch 'Em All
Exceptions are clearly inferior to an alternative strategy of handling errors as values rather than something exceptional to catch. Exceptions to me started off as a humble concept (if something truly exceptional happens, do x y or z, but in 99% of cases you will probably just want to abort or crash)

Instead exceptions have become every day errors. Like the article defines,

> The handling of exceptional cases; perhaps a service failed for an unexpected reason like a network failure

Really? A service failure or network failure is an exceptional case for you? This should be planned for, and built into the architecture! Plan for the network always failing! Recover gracefully! That is what retry strategies like exponential backoff are for, and circuit breakers, idempotent requests so you can simply cancel and try again, so on and so forth.

Instead of treating everything as exceptional, when you treat errors as values, they lend you down the path of actually handling them. As a side effect of this, you build more robust systems. Bubbling up an error to the top when errors are values are seen as an anti-pattern, only to be done in the most rare of circumstances.

Again, from the article,

> All other exceptions - Signifies my server has a bug

Then your server should crash! Take it out of the load balancer, stop the damage! If you truly can't classify it, it's truly unknown or exceptional, abort!

jimmy1··on Glassdoor Research 2019: Progress on the Gender Pay Gap [pdf]
https://fee.org/articles/harvard-study-gender-pay-gap-explai...
jimmy1··on How Big Tech Built the Iron Cage
It was a claim by extension I must admit: You could technically say each American that dies, dies for our freedoms, one of which is our constitutional right to privacy. A specific example I had in mind was those who lost their lives fleeing East Germany and the Stasi: deciding to cross the wall or even talking about it often time resulted in your untimely death. Many people were gunned down trying to climb over. A general "people who died for privacy" netted some decent results as well.
jimmy1··on How Big Tech Built the Iron Cage
> Only no one cares about that.

I really wish people would stop saying this. It is a completely idiotic statement. There are hundreds of people throughout history that quite literally gave their lives for privacy, as recent as one generation ago. Complacency and the silent majority does not equate to "no one cares about that" otherwise, you wouldn't have so many privacy centers and advocacy groups throughout the country.

> Most people don't have anything to hide from advertisers.

"'I've Got Nothing to Hide' and Other Misunderstandings Of Privacy" https://scholarship.law.gwu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=... It's a good read, and I hope it convinces you otherwise that privacy is as important as ever, even in lieu of fallacious "nothing to hide" arguments.

From the paper, the easiest way to debunk the "nothing to hide" argument is to ask easy questions.

"I've got nothing to hide." "OK, so why do you have curtains or blinds in your home?" "OK you have nothing to hide, so can I see your past credit card statements?"

If we all have nothing to hide, why don't those interested in our private lives show us theirs? It's the ole "Show me yours and I’ll show you mine" adage.

jimmy1··on Google’s constant product shutdowns are damaging its brand
It's better than the situation at most companies I have been at: It's basically the personal gain trumps all, but without the actual results. You just have a bunch of populists that talk up a good game, but when it comes time to execute or actually launch something, they are the last person you really want at the helm, but because they have built up a reputation with the higher ups, they are impossible to displace.

From my perspective, this appears to be the situation of most "Health IT" corps and VP of Engineering and above. I've since "sold out" and moved to a digital marketing firm, but in many ways the work here is much more honest than what happened at places I worked at in the name of "health"

jimmy1··on What comes after open source
> Strongly agreed. Exposure to a History & Philosophy of Software course might reduce the amount of wheel reinvention that plagues our industry.

I agree that wheel reinvention is an issue that needs addressing but not to the extent as you describe (a "plague").

I also believe this comment misunderstands why it happens. As it stands today, it is a feature, not a bug. You don't see reinvention a lot in traditional engineering disciplines because you have something concrete and functional that takes years of research and hours of construction. Any hacker with a laptop can pick up a language and start building stuff. This ease of access is what creates the "wheel reinvention" situation, that and an endless amount of choices and a limited amount of discoverability of what is out there. Exposure to history and philosophy of software would do nothing to address that.

Finally, reinvention is seen as virtue in this industry, not a plague. To some degree, I agree: software is never complete. And even if you think so, the software built underneath your software may change, thus changing your software. Some level of reinvention may come with new considerations that were not considerations of the past.

jimmy1··on Apple Arcade – Game subscription service
One can even say it is so egregious they could and should face legal challenges.
jimmy1··on Rust is not a good C replacement
I would say if you rewrite it and have more bugs, you must have no understanding of the existing codebase, or understand so little of it you shouldn't be the one rewriting it regardless.

All the rewrites I have done have resulted in leaner codebases with fewer potentials for bugs. I think people take some article one software developer wrote almost two decades ago as gospel, but "second system syndrome" doesn't have to be a syndrome.

This "rewrite" fear is exactly why our banks are stuck on 1970s and 80s code with an almost 60 year old programming language and no one left to take over maintenance. Eventually we need to get over this fear.

jimmy1··on This is Your Brain on Exercise (2017)
> exercise has a positive impact on the creation of new neurons on the brain. The idea that we're born with a limited number of brain cells has been debunked.

I'm not being a typical HN'er, I am legitimately curious, do you have some good sources that describe this? My current understanding is that new neurons aren't so easily formed because your brain is actually so efficient, it will simply form new pathways between existing neurons to do the same thing it once did with lost or damaged neurons. Would like to know that this is incorrect or not.

jimmy1··on Human Contact Is Now a Luxury Good
Luckily for me, they still sell legos! And you best believe my daughter will be playing with them as soon as she is old enough.
jimmy1··on Defining a Distinguished Engineer
That is bad leadership. You still need to craft roles and titles in a manner that allows ownership and autonomy.

At my large company that I have been with for 4 years, you are given a title. The title has a certain baseline level of expectations. If you want the next title, you start acting like it. Then you are given it. You are given freedom and autonomy on how to act like it. For example, an expectation of a senior is to mentor. You can mentor in hundreds of different ways: run a workshop, do one-on-ones, pair programming with a junior, have lunch with people, and so on. Seniors are expected to demonstrate technical prowess. The baseline is delivering results on your immediate team, but if you want the next level up, you can branch out and impact the wider organization: you can do this through refactoring a large portion of a legacy system, improving the performance of a current system, adding better test coverage to a project you are not on, contributing to open source, or having a talk accepted at a conference. Just one of many examples.

I think this way works the best from my experience with two other systems: the ones as you describe, and then the mythological flat org.

jimmy1··on Defining a Distinguished Engineer
> They make people think in labels.

That's because people do think in labels. Mother, Father, brother, teacher, sister, uncle, boss, manager, CEO. More primitively, tribe member, tribe leader, enemy, scary cat thingy, dangerous crawling thingy. It's part of our evolution.

> then assign it to the individuals, rather than define the work based on the individuals.

I would imagine this is impractical trying to run or build a large org then because you need to be able to define the work you have to do first, then assign it, it doesn't work the other way around.

jimmy1··on Ad Fraud Scheme Drained Users’ Batteries By Running Hidden Video Ads In Android
> This fingerpointing points to one of the core problems of the ad industry: They created a system where nobody knows who's responsible for anything,

This sounds like a lot of industries...

jimmy1··on Amazon to Launch Mobile Ads, in a Threat to Google and Facebook
If you pull out a big enough "ethics" magnifying glass, you will find ethical flaws in every corporation. One can make the argument, depending on where on the "woke sliding scale" you may lie, that shopping at Walmart is better for the environment than Amazon: they already have a streamlined, efficient supply chain and logistics operation. Amazon relies on a myriad of logistical networks, with many inefficiencies still yet to be solved. But again, not the reason I am shopping/not shopping there.

It has nothing to do with sticking it to anyone. Amazon doesn't have the same value proposition as it once did. I realized I was using it just to use it, among other reasons.

jimmy1··on Amazon to Launch Mobile Ads, in a Threat to Google and Facebook
As someone currently doing this: I miss nothing. Walmart offers free 2-day shipping on most goods I would typically order from Amazon, and often cheaper. Best Buy has whatever tech thing I want, I get it same-day, and price-matched at Amazon, and I know it isn't counterfeit. Most book publishers (my original reason for using Amazon) have long ditched the platform and directed me towards ordering direct from them which usually nets me reduced price/shipping. Apple music is better than Amazon Music. Audible is separate anyways, having Prime didn't help me out much there. Netflix is better than Amazon streaming, and so on.

The biggest benefit so far? I am generally ordering less stuff overall. I felt like I had to order x amount of stuff to make my prime membership "worth it", but it was never "worth it". It just resulted in me spending more money with Amazon, even if I had better alternatives around me.

← PreviousPage 2 of 17Next →