HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jimmybot

660 karma · joined April 25, 2009

submissionscomments
jimmybot··on Who’s not getting gzip?
From the referenced Google Code Blog http://googlecode.blogspot.com/2009/11/use-compression-to-ma...:

Anti-virus software may try to minimize CPU operations by intercepting and altering requests so that web servers send back uncompressed content. But if the CPU is not the bottleneck, the software is not doing users any favors. Some popular antivirus programs interfere with compression. Users can check if their anti-virus software is interfering with compression by visiting the browser compression test page at Browserscope.org.

Serious? Anti-virus software that is doing that is acting almost like malware doing what the user didn't ask it to do. Does compression have any even minor security implications that would legitimize this? And anyone know which anti-virus does this?

jimmybot··on Malcolm Gladwell's response to Steven Pinker's review of his new book
Come on, Malcolm Gladwell isn't being ghostwritten. Anyone that good doesn't need a ghost writer, and if his ghost writer is that good, he's not going to be ghost writing instead of writing his own stuff and building his own name. Even if he were using a ghost writer, Gladwell didn't go back and read through?
jimmybot··on Coin-operated Borgocrat goes to Google, acquires whole new set of opinions
Let's say he is being honest, and we believe that he really is actually acting on new information. So working for Microsoft completely blind-sided him to how useful Gmail and Google Docs are? He really didn't know about Gmail's spam filtering and conversation threading? You're not going to be a very good advocate if you don't know your competition.
jimmybot··on Experiment HN: Idea Day Results
Ah yes, engagement is the word. Interesting. I'd imagine the query expansion should also work across the author dimension--include and rank matches from the same blog higher, even if according to my history, I haven't read that post.
jimmybot··on Statements by many lawmakers ghostwritten by lobbyists working for Genentech
Cynical, but likely true. But we shouldn't just throw out everything that's in the congressional record.

If we have "spam detection for members of congress", we'd usefully know who's doing the saying, and what was said that was at the behest of lobbyists. If we have way to recognize who's "clean" and who's not, then we can call them out on it and vote accordingly.

Or else how do we improve the situation?

jimmybot··on Statements by many lawmakers ghostwritten by lobbyists working for Genentech
I would think that this is more common, and they only got caught because it was so egregious this time. Someone should take plagiarism detection software and turn it on the congressional record. Then we'll know for sure.
jimmybot··on Experiment HN: Idea Day Results
Do you use Zotero? If so, how does it or does it not fit your needs?
jimmybot··on Experiment HN: Idea Day Results
I've thought about number two as well. How about a combination of caching all pages you read and how long you are spending on each page (and maybe if you scrolled as well)?

The idea is to save enough data that you can have an algorithm that will automatically differentiate between stuff you closed within a couple of seconds and didn't really read and stuff that interested you and you actually read through. And the reason for doing this automatically is it seems very difficult to have the discipline take an action every time you see a page that you may want to save so that you can search through again (such as clicking a box for every such page).

Whatever mechanism it is, it needs to account for stuff read through readers and over multiple computers/devices too. I don't want to miss a search result just because I was reading it on an iPhone or in my Google Reader.

Or instead of caching locally, a search interface that would accept a long list of urls to look through.

jimmybot··on The Suicide of the East?
Fair enough--I should have said inspired by rather than wholesale copied. I do see a remarkable parallel there between the KMT having lost one country due in part to extreme economic disparity, redistributes wealth to maintain control in a second; and the later economic disparity you eloquently describe between China and Taiwan that inspires the reverse.
jimmybot··on The Suicide of the East?
"Democracy Wall" writers in this transition period referred to the example of Taiwan as a basis for criticizing the Communist Party regime in China.

So China had no choice but to loosen economic regulation and tacitly reject orthodox Marxist-Leninist-Stalinist-Maoist doctrine to catch up to Taiwan.

I agree with the original article's limited claims about market reforms, but since you seem to reference more than economic reform:

China only made the market reforms, and politically, Taiwan was still at the time, an authoritarian, one-party Leninist state. Many Chinese Communists were former members of the Kuomintang and their similarities weren't just superficial; they both learned their bag of tricks--propaganda, how to organize their party-state-military structure, how to suppress dissent, how to control the larger population--from the Soviets. To this very day, Taiwan still has political military officers stationed at all public high schools and colleges (though thankfully their role has changed a lot). If Taiwan was showing China anything, it was that they could keep around the party and the authoritarianism and open up their markets at the same time. As you are well-aware, martial law wasn't lifted until 1987 and Taiwan wasn't even really anything you could even nominally call democracy until the 90s.

So basically 1) Taiwan was still Leninist and 2) I don't get what the Democracy Wall writers are inspired by when Taiwan wasn't a democracy then.

Ironically, one foundation for economic prosperity in Taiwan was the land reform the Kuomintang copied--although they would not admit it--from the Communists and implemented after they occupied Taiwan after World War II. They forced all the big landlords at gunpoint to trade in their land for largely worthless stock in state-owned companies. Prior to that, much of the population were landless tenant farmers. The possibilities for entrepreneurship change quite a bit when you go from being a tenant farmer to a small time farmer with your own land.

jimmybot··on The Suicide of the East?
Right. What works for Hong Kong, Macau, Singapore, the Isle of Man, and other low tax city states just does not work for the rest of the world--it doesn't scale.
jimmybot··on Facebook iPhone Dev Quits Project Over Apple Tyranny
Nice, I literally read "philosophy" as "ideology" as well:

"however I am [ideologically] opposed to the existence of their review process."

(I wouldn't take ideology in necessarily a negative way)

jimmybot··on Are Google employees being discouraged from using Python for new projects?
Anyone have numbers on how much faster V8 is than CPython?
jimmybot··on Amazon Kindle for PC Beta Launched
One of the things I really like about Ubuntu is that I can download and install the right version of a wide variety of program for my machine very easily. And it lets me keep up to date without thinking about it. A lot of programs don't update automatically and those that do are doing it right when I don't want it to--when I start the program up. If there was a similar system for Windows, I would definitely consider switching back.

If developers have a good distribution system, there's greater incentive to invest more in making better software. There's a chicken-and-egg problem here since unless the platform has worthwhile programs, no one is going to install it, but Steam is one example, and Microsoft could do it themselves and that would guaranteed to be adopted, if there's no legal problems there.

Distributing free programs (How about keep my Python and Notepad++ up to date?) would be a way to bootstrap as well.

EDIT: Firefox Add-ons also looks like it's moving towards a store with donations as a preliminary trial, and remember add-ons can also be standalone applications running off of xulrunner: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=892073

jimmybot··on Amazon Kindle for PC Beta Launched
More broadly, a software store with automatic updates on the Windows-PC platform could be huge.
jimmybot··on Fighter Pilots Face A Dismal Future
Alliances can easily decrease the risk of small scale war, but this is at the cost of systematic risk (alliance vs alliance war or world wars). Perhaps we've only managed to decrease the risk of medium-sized wars at the cost of increased risk for that very rare, very big one. It wouldn't be too different from the recent financial crisis or power distribution networks in the US.
jimmybot··on Excuse Me, But Where Did Google's Organic Search Results Go?
Unfortunately you gotta do this these days: +django +video +tutorial

http://www.google.com/search?q=%2Bdjango+%2Bvideo+%2Btutoria...

There's probably a Greasemonkey script for this somewhere that can automatically get this old behavior back for you.

jimmybot··on Scamville: The Social Gaming Ecosystem of Hell
What was the original vision?
jimmybot··on Peace.facebook.com
The assumption here is that peace between nations can somehow be resolved by just communication among private citizens and individual friendships; that conflicts are just misunderstandings or that we are too prejudiced or don't have enough sympathy. I can see how that is sometimes the case, but I don't see how that is always or even commonly the case. In many conflicts, there are very real underlying issues that need to be resolved and unless those fundamental imbalances are addressed, then there will not be peace.

For example, it looks like China is on a possible collision course with India and Southeast Asian nations over water rights. China's north is heavily populated, rapidly growing, and severely short of water. Tibet on the other hand is very rich in water resources that are upstream of major rivers in India, Laos, Vietnam, etc. As we speak there are gigantic projects diverting water from China's south to the north. It's likely not to be enough, and if China moves on to divert and dam rivers that cross international borders, there will likely be war.

This is just one example, but my guess would be that a resource-driven conflict that incites national pride on both sides will break those friendships rather than the other way around. If the fundamental reasons driving a conflict are not resolved, it's hard to see why friendships will be able to prevent war.

jimmybot··on How Google Maps deals with border disputes: Two Countries, Three Maps
I don't doubt the dispute about whether it should be a part of India or China is real. But currently it is a part of India. Maybe China has legitimate claims. Maybe it doesn't. That's what I took your "should" to mean.

What's different about Tibet? China claims Tibet is a legitimate part of its territory, but others claim that China is an illegal occupier. However, at least for now, Tibet is a part of China.

jimmybot··on How Google Maps deals with border disputes: Two Countries, Three Maps
No one disputes that Arunachal Pradesh is currently a part of India, just whether or not parts of it should be.
jimmybot··on Cheating for $20: Why collusion and price fixing is difficult to do
Yup, repeat games are a different situation that may lead to different outcomes. If you can enforce the agreement, it's a different kind of game.

But then consider situations where information is unreliable:

- Cheating because you can't trust others not to cheat, i.e. to protect yourself, and everyone ends up cheating, as in Prisoner's Dilemma.

- In a lot of situations, you may not even know who is cheating and by how much, but you might be sure someone is cheating. This will feed back into your own incentives to cheat. I believe OPEC suffers from this a lot.

jimmybot··on Cheating for $20: Why collusion and price fixing is difficult to do
It only takes one cheater for the collusive agreement to collapse.
jimmybot··on The Lost Lesson Of Instant Typing
How about they start with telling you that it's turned on? I don't see anything in the web interface that tells me that others can also see my live typing.
jimmybot··on Asians may face tougher college admission process, study finds
"Anti-Asian quotas aren't anti-Asian."

They are going to be in a lot of trouble if they are using upper-limit quotas outright. Quotas, then intangibles and geographic diversity were once used to limit the number of Jews at top universities (Jews being largely in urban areas in the Northeast and the West Coast). There'd be a huge uproar if it could be shown that similar policies were being used to limit the number of Jews at top universities today.

Some kind of sense of fairness in the admissions process, even accounting for considerations of diversity is still something that colleges strive for, and if they discriminate, in some forms it is illegal and even when it's not, there's so much public money involved that they would still have to consider public opinion.

There's also a straw man in your Latino example. Set aside groups that are treated favorably for reasons of diversity. Probably the two largest groups we're left with are whites and Asians. Whites aren't underrepresented, but this study is implying that it probably is significantly easier for someone white to get into a top school than it is for someone Asian. How do you choose between the two based on diversity when neither is underrepresented?

jimmybot··on Asians may face tougher college admission process, study finds
True and nicely put. But, I would say the "surprise" here is not that it's harder for Asian Americans to get in relative to African Americans. You'd think that if you are guaranteeing or biasing towards a certain number of select groups, then the unselected groups would be equally biased against. But that's not what this study is finding. It's pointing towards the possibility that Asians are not just disadvantaged relative to their fellow minorities; they are disadvantaged relative to whites as well.
jimmybot··on GitHub discontinues building gems
I haven't, though I haven't had the need for one either. But if they exist and they're decent, you don't think I would find them if I researched for a git host?

I don't argue with you that freemium works in the short and probably medium term, and it's great advertising. You have a great service going, and I think in your case, you build a lot of good will among developers hosting public code for free. But in the long run, in the general case, and assuming no network effects, I think there's a way to undercut such business models by focusing 100% on the paying customers.

jimmybot··on GitHub discontinues building gems
Isn't that exactly the danger of running on a freemium business model?

Everything goes according to plan, you establish a new market, lots of free customers get introduced to your product and love it and you skim off the cream that want power or enterprise features as your paying customers. What stops a new competitor from swooping in and saying they have something very similar, they aren't going to be spending anything supporting free customers, and with presumably lower costs, charging their customers less? With complete focus on paying customers, they might provide a better product too.

jimmybot··on A catalog of wealth creation mechanisms
I don't think you could argue that. Finance encompasses a lot more than questionable trading practices. I said finance, and not say banking, since I meant any kind of banking and investing. And there is an equivalence between debt (loans, bonds) and equity ((yc,angel,VC) x investments, stock offerings) since from the perspective of the company, you are paying rents on capital in both cases.

Do I need to argue the importance of loans and efficient allocations of capital? If you don't like thinking about this with money, what about with loans of goods?

jimmybot··on A catalog of wealth creation mechanisms
"I'm pretty sure this is a comprehensive list. Can anyone think of anything I've left out?"

Seems like an overly confident statement that has low probability of being correct. Is this purposely to provoke people into trying to prove you wrong? If so, maybe it's genius, though dishonest.

Here's my shot:

The comments on the post also mention finance was left out. Well, if we take finance to be a combination of moving things and storing things, it sort of covers part of what's going on, but there's a missing key: lending things. Taking it in reverse, lending by itself wouldn't be enough either, since without moving things and storing things, you can't lend out anything you don't already have.

Anyways, I'm pretty sure I came up with an airtight metaphor for finance. Can anyone think of how the metaphor breaks down?

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →