HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jimmybot

660 karma · joined April 25, 2009

submissionscomments
jimmybot··on Google proposes standard for making Ajax crawlable
Why is Google telling people to run a headless browser just for their crawler? Sounds way too complicated for any small-scale website. Why doesn't Google run the headless browser themselves? It sounds like they are offloading parsing costs onto websites, but then they have a cheating problem they have to deal with.

Somewhat related: It's not AJAX, but I remember hearing Microsoft Research a couple of years ago talk about parsing CSS. They wanted the page as an image so that they could analyze pictorially what was a menu, what was a header, what was main content, etc. It seemed fairly neat for the time, although I think there are much simpler heuristics for when you are after just the main article type content of a page that will work for most blogs/CMS's out there.

(No, they didn't use IE. I asked. Yes, they tried. They said it was slow and crashed too much.)

jimmybot··on Google proposes standard for making Ajax crawlable
Are you sure it's XOR? Anything wrong with doing it through an iframe? You use javascript to control which is displayed and for responsiveness (your cycling), but each testimonial also has its own page.
jimmybot··on Franz Kafka Selected Shorter Writings
Since this was posted: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=846746

I haven't had much exposure to Kafka but am enjoying what I've read so far.

jimmybot··on Internet Explorer 8 runs ten times faster with Google Chrome plug-in
But if that's the case, isn't that likely because they have internal applications that are IE only? It seems more like a marketing thing--Overcome people's inhibitions by letting them feel like they "only" installed a plugin and are still running IE.
jimmybot··on Netflix Prize Movie Similarity Visualization
Scrolling actually does what you think it would do. Yeah, that's really nice. I like it a lot. Thanks for the link, hadn't heard about Seadragon before. I was also alluding to the fact that you can't text search the visualization for movies ie "New York, NY" ~ "Better Luck Tomorrow", both points on an image. Maybe easier said than done, but the whole point of the visualization is to give people a better understanding of the information.
jimmybot··on Netflix Prize Movie Similarity Visualization
Cool. Needs a Google Maps interface.
jimmybot··on How twitter helped a technology consultant escape from an evil hospital
I do to from time too, but I asked because personally, I rarely see people get questions answered on Facebook the way they regularly do on Twitter. But then again, the people that Twitter and get questions answered quickly are probably your blogger, big personality types too.

And then yet back on the other hand, as you say, there is no friend requirement so those big personality types could really only amplify their voice in that way over Twitter.

jimmybot··on How twitter helped a technology consultant escape from an evil hospital
Three other people were injured that day from jumping, and the ambulance that was called wasn't even called for the heroine of our story. I don't know what the denominator is, but it doesn't sound good.

I do agree though, that jumping or not wasn't the main issue here.

jimmybot··on How twitter helped a technology consultant escape from an evil hospital
Are people that responsive on Facebook?
jimmybot··on Yeah Ok, So Facebook Punk’d Us
Is it me or does it seem that Facebook is working hard to generate a lot of news/publicity these past few days? What are they looking to accomplish?
jimmybot··on Ask HN: Best Unix Tricks?
It's not a bash tip, but if you want something that generally makes command line navigation easier without the need for heavy amounts of customization or memorization, you might consider using the Friendly interactive shell (Fish shell).

Smart history-based autocompletion, advanced tab completion, optional cd, simplified syntax, among other features.

Not as hackerish as some of the other tips mentioned here, but it's a much lower barrier to entry than the other commonly used shells out there.

Also submitted it here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=811113

jimmybot··on Fish Shell: A User-Friendly Shell or Like a Heavily Customized zsh
Some nice features:

1) Advanced tab completion

2) History-based autocomplete (type and press up)

3) Optional cd (.. to go to parent directory)

4) Syntax highlighting

5) Simplified and streamlined syntax

There's also an overview in the Wikipedia article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fish_shell

And the author wrote an introductory article way back: http://lwn.net/Articles/136232/

jimmybot··on Ask HN: Good looking news/social media sites?
Since a couple aggregators were listed--the thing that troubles design for aggregators in my mind is that they are all just lists. You can put some color, some thumbnails on a list, but in the end, it's still a list.

What I find much more attractive and intuitive, when it comes to news, is a real front page, that echoes the old print newspaper front page, but pulls in extra real-time information boxes from other parts of the paper. There is a clear idea of a headline story, the size of each summary is varied, and it's full use of 2D space, instead of just going linear straight from top to bottom.

What I'm thinking of in particular is the New York Times http://nytimes.com ; since its last major redesign it has become very attractive and I have found myself spending more time clicking around within the site whenever I read it.

For comparsion, check out this old twin-list front page version of NYT: http://web.archive.org/web/20031203020804/http://www.nytimes...

This does also have to do with their strategy for fighting the aggregators (so it's not just a design question): 1) writing their own blogs and 2) syndicating blogs where they are short. Sort of out-aggregating the aggregators.

jimmybot··on 2,000 students at Washington State University report flu symptoms
"In the grand scale of things, the number of people likely to die from it seems miniscule compared to other threats."

What are other threats are you thinking of?

What other diseases are estimated to cause half the US population to be infected, one million hospitalizations, and 90,000 deaths? Even if most people who get it are fine after a few days, it's a pretty big deal if half the population is going to come down with it; H1N1 sure is going to get a lot of chances to kill even if it's not so deadly for any one individual.

jimmybot··on Share your ideas
I totally agree; it's a problem I've thought about as well, and it's not just HN either. People scan news headlines (whether on news media outlets or on news aggregators) always looking for something shocking or moving or hilarious or despicable. But after the initial reaction, often it fizzes out and there's no follow up. I would say though comments fairly quickly, the discussion can and does continue at times through a second or third link posted that gets voted up. But yeah, not enough times, and it's not even obvious often what it was posted in response to.

Well, I'd be interested in looking at that long essay if you end up posting it somewhere.

jimmybot··on NY Transportation Authority Cites Schedules as Copyrighted Material
It's stated in the article that tables of facts/data are not copyright-able.

But additionally, aren't publications of the government by law automatically made a part of the public domain?

jimmybot··on MSNBC.com acquires EveryBlock
Really? Is MSNBC still owned by Microsoft? When it comes to the Internet, Microsoft seems like one of those companies that really doesn't mind investing lots of money for a long time as long as they hold a glimmer of hope.
jimmybot··on The United States is not the nation of small businesses
Contradictory things are being advocated. Health care reform at least intuitively looks pro-small business. But mandatory vacation days and high unemployment benefits? If they are paid out by the hiring company? I doubt that is helpful for small businesses, who can't shift around workers as easily and will be discouraged from hiring if the costs of firing are so high.

And France isn't a nation of small businesses. Their best industries seem to be those really complicated infrastructure ones that require a lot of state intervention (bullet trains, nuclear reactors) and luxury goods (LV). It may have been nice to have that welfare cushion during the financial crisis, but that's a separate and potentially contradictory goal to encouraging small businesses.

And then there's Taiwan. It has always been a country of small and medium sized businesses, and to my knowledge, there was no uptick in this when national healthcare was implemented in the 90s. It could be high at a percentage for other reasons, though, and that it was so prevalent made it difficult for there to be any additional uptick.

jimmybot··on Deletionists slowing Wikipedia's growth
Agreed, but it's not just a motivation problem. Deletionists get an upper-hand over inclusionists when the article is deleted because the history is not available, and you have to start all over. You can't just revert to a previous state of the article (that may not have been far from a state where it had enough references and content to avoid being questioned for notability).

Here's a particularly interesting self-referencing article that was deleted and previously discussed on HN:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=518508 And here's the deleted page--with no options to look through the history and see what it used to look like: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikiid

If you could continue to help edit an article that was made invisible for most users, articles would have a lot more time to prove their notability.

One interesting question is whether Wikipedia is legally even allowed to hide the history of deleted articles. It's not even available in the database dumps, which wouldn't be a realistic format for the vast majority of users anyways:

http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Data_dumps#What.27s_not_avail...

Content is licensed under GFDL or CC-SA so you'd think they are required to make it available somewhere.

jimmybot··on You Deleted Your Cookies? Think Again
If you want, you can delete your flash cookies using the BetterPrivacy Firefox Add-On: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/6623

Should delete globally so you can use it even if you don't use Firefox.

jimmybot··on Vitamin D slashes risk of cancers by 77 percent (2007)
Okay, I didn't think of the funding aspect, which would be a reason they were limited to that group, but again, regardless of why they were limited, the fact that it was a limited group still casts some doubt on the broader applicability of the study. As the PI admits, they want to study men, different ethnicities as well. But then there's also that quote where the PI suggests that everyone should be taking vitamin D.

But you bring up the point about there being no a priori reason for why it shouldn't be applicable to other groups. OK, I can understand the argument, but...

Older, post-menopausal women have higher requirements for calcium than other groups. The amount of supplementation at 1500mg is 50% higher than RDA of calcium for men. In men, if that calcium isn't going to the bone as it presumably would be in these women, then where does it go or what effect does elevated levels of calcium have?

Also, as I already stated, calcium has been found to increase prostate cancer in men. That's not obviously not going to show up in women.

Hmm...

I searched real quick. Besides studies showing increased risk of prostate cancer in men with higher calcium intake, it looks like there are studies that show calcium is not associated with total cancer in men, but increased intake is associated with lower total cancer women (as in this study).

jimmybot··on Vitamin D slashes risk of cancers by 77 percent (2007)
What the heck? I didn't misunderstand the study by only looking at the headline. The full paper confirms what I said in my comments.

My criticism of the study as possibly being of limited applicability (older, white women) still stands whether you only looked at the summary article or the original paper. That the PI agrees means that she knows her study is flawed (or let's say limited).

Read the other comments; people are taking it as if it applies to them. Some of the people voting this link up also may have thought something similar.

There was a suggestion made that it doesn't matter whether it's vitamin D by itself or vitamin D + calcium because you could just take both. My criticism was calcium isn't necessarily good, especially for men, because too much calcium is associated with basically bad nerves and prostate cancer.

What about what I said is a misunderstanding of the study or "failure" to lookup the original paper?

jimmybot··on Vitamin D slashes risk of cancers by 77 percent (2007)
Wha...? Wait a second. The title for the link submitted is: Vitamin D slashes risk of cancers by 77 percent (2007)

If what you're saying is true, that calcium + vitamin D confers the greatest benefit, then the link title is still wrong. But what in the study says that calcium + vitamin D conveys the greatest benefit? (ie Vitamin D alone wouldn't convey as great a benefit) It may be true, but it's not obvious from the article that was linked, and it's still not obvious from the original paper that you linked to.

The article and you are assuming that what is having the anti-cancer effect is the calcium, and the vitamin D helps you absorb the calcium, thus enhancing that effect.

First, I don't assume what you do, which is that supplementing calcium is always a positive. Second, what if vitamin D has some action other than help you absorb calcium. Even if I'm not an expert in this, I find it hard to believe that medical researchers have completely precluded vitamin D from having any action other than help your body absorb calcium, and if it alone helped prevent cancer, it may be really nice to know, especially if you don't want to be increasing your calcium.

I don't get the attitude. I was talking about the information was provided by the article. There may very well be a study about men 20-40 years old, of varying ethnic backgrounds, who take just vitamin D (no calcium) and it's found to decrease cancer versus control, but that's not the information provided here by the article or the original study.

Your point about actual vitamin D supplements on the market mostly coming with calcium suffers from the same logical problem. The article headline (original or on HN) should tell me what exactly is decreasing the cancer risk, not some assumption about what consumers will end up buying and what they'll likely also end up supplementing with additionally. If the conclusion had been vitamin D alone decreases the risk of cancer, do you think there wouldn't be manufacturers churning out pure vitamin D, without the calcium?

EDIT: Okay, parent has updated post. I appreciate that you softened your tone. Sure, I know it says that they aren't sure of the generality of the study in the article. I think it's worth pointing out because again, there's that disconnect between the title and the content. Title says "TAKE VITAMIN D" without qualification. Article says different.

Responding to your new point about the generality of the study--if the requirements for men and women really are the same (I don't buy it), then why study post-menopausal white women in Nebraska? I can see age for the cancer risk, but why not men, and why not of different ethnicities? If you're going to tell me that post-menopausal white women 55 and older are more likely to be deficient in calcium and vitamin D, then well, maybe the effects are exaggerated and other groups don't need the supplementation.

PS Computational biology is cool, I did programming work in a bio lab trying to identify splicing sites back in undergrad.

jimmybot··on Vitamin D slashes risk of cancers by 77 percent (2007)
Can it? What evidence is there that the placebo group or the calcium group were vitamin D deficient? One group taking vitamin D beyond their normal daily requirement does not mean the other groups were deficient.
jimmybot··on Vitamin D slashes risk of cancers by 77 percent (2007)
Sorry guys, don't get excited yet. Bad, misleading headline.

What?

"Subjects were randomly assigned to take daily dosages of 1,400-1,500 mg supplemental calcium, 1,400-1,500 mg supplemental calcium plus 1,100 IU of vitamin D3, or placebos."

It's not vitamin D. It may be vitamin D or it may be vitamin D + calcium. Why didn't they have a group that was supplementing only vitamin D and not calcium? I don't know, but since they didn't test that, there's no way to know that it is just vitamin D.

Who?

"The four-year, randomized study followed 1,179 healthy, postmenopausal women from rural eastern Nebraska."

Given the age, male-female ratio on HN, it's not clear that vitamin D supplementation would be beneficial to the average HN reader. Also, all the women were 55 and older.

Besides that, as the article mentions, skin color and other genetic heritage also matters. If you are a woman and Caucasian, this study is more likely to apply to you; if you aren't, who knows?

In case someone considers going out and supplementing with both calcium and vitamin D on account of this study, I want to point out that unnecessary calcium supplementation can be detrimental, and it can contribute to things like stress, poor sleep, and prostate cancer (if you have one).

jimmybot··on Which Search Engine Do You Choose In The Blind Test?
Might have something to do with not respecting nofollow.
jimmybot··on Markov & statistical models unlock ancient script
Agree about the bad title; but it does resolve an important question, which was whether the script was a language at all. Establishing that it has the regularities of human language was a necessary first step.

Here's another interesting example. The Luwian script's directionality couldn't be established. It was not certain whether it was up-down, up-down or up-down, down-up or various possibilities. This paper established using Expectation-Maximization the correct order of reading for the script:

Discovering the linear writing order of a two-dimensional ancient hieroglyphic script http://www.csie.ntu.edu.tw/~sdlin/publications.html

Luwian script: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hieroglyphic_Luwian

jimmybot··on Markov & statistical models unlock ancient script
Modern statistical machine translation works by training on large amounts of already translated data, called parallel corpora. Monolingual data is helpful and can help you fix grammar, choose words that are more likely, but it won't work without that parallel corpora. Basically, you need a Rosetta stone, and if you had that, the humans could slowly deduce all sorts of things from only a small amount of data that would probably be useless for an MT system. Actually, scanning, or OCR, is a similar process--you train first on text that already has been properly transcribed, then you have a model that can be used to do OCR on new data.
jimmybot··on Apple Wants To Build A PayPal Killer, Say Wall Street Gossips
They also mentioned Facebook. Are payments really big on Facebook? With tons of customers and experience with processing payments for real-world goods, I would think Amazon would have a better shot at it than Facebook.

Also, out of Apple, Facebook, and Amazon, I would guess that Amazon customers are the most likely to be spending money elsewhere as well.

But in all these cases--Pay Pal, Apple, and the rest--they are wrappers on a bank account or a credit card. Why wouldn't the banks and the credit card companies themselves want to get in on all this?

jimmybot··on The Omnivore's Delusion: Against the Agri-Intellectuals
I get what you mean, but if they were priced correctly, they'd just be internalities. Internalities?
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →