HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jimwhite42

89 karma · joined January 22, 2023

submissionscomments
jimwhite42··on The UK’s tortured attempt to remake the internet
> unless something changes, I won't be voting.

I encourage anyone who feels this way to spoil your ballot paper. This sends a different signal than not voting: if there were lots of spoilt ballot papers this would be received differently to low turnout.

jimwhite42··on Geoffrey Hinton leaves Google and warns of danger ahead
> What I can fairly easily imagine in the next few years with improved hardware is something like an open version of ChatGPT that has a 200 IQ and "thinks" 100 times faster than a human.

It seems unlikely that if we can achieve "200 IQ and thinks 100 times faster than a human" in the next decade or two, it going to be on cheap and widely available hardware. Perhaps such an AI could help optimise the creation of hardware that it can run on, but this also isn't going to be quick to do - the bottlenecks are not mainly the intelligence of the people involved in this sort of thing.

jimwhite42··on Why some researchers think I’m wrong about social media and mental illness
I think that when people are angry, they are more open to suggestion if you do it right. So this is a way to make people more receptive to buying a particular product or subscription, or to supporting a political cause, etc., if you don't make them angry about something first and do nothing else different, you get less conversions. And of all the different ways to improve in this kind of metric, the make-people-angry method one is relatively easy and requires relatively less competence.
jimwhite42··on Carl Braun on communicating like a grown-up (2016)
I think when you don't "pretend assume good faith", you end up making less convincing counter arguments, and communicate less well in general, plus many other negative things.
jimwhite42··on How Should Compilers Explain Problems to Developers? (2018) [pdf]
I thought this paper was very interesting on the topic: "Mind Your Language: On Novices' Interactions with Error Messages".

One of the things that comes up, is that if the error message suggests a change, one of the risks is that such an edit can make the error go away, but the code will not be correct. By making a concrete suggestion, it tempts the programmer to just apply it without thinking.

This is really interesting to me because it makes sense, and goes against many common ideas about how to make good error messages.

jimwhite42··on A Brief History of Time is ‘wrong’, Stephen Hawking told collaborator
I heard Robert Wright talking about this sort of idea, I think he was inspired by Smolin.

> Smolin thinks our universe may itself be a product of a kind of evolution: maybe universes can replicate themselves via black holes, so over time — over a lot of time — you get universes whose physical laws are more and more conducive to replication.

from here: https://evolutionnews.org/2017/01/robert_wright_a/

A wikipedia article describes Smolin's "Cosmological natural selection" as an alternative to the anthropic principle.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_natural_selection

jimwhite42··on More than five whys and “layer eight” problems
Good comments, I mostly agree with them.

> I think if you view developers through the prism of chasing dopamine highs from the pursuit of novelty, you can much better manage them.

I think the crux of it for me is that you cannot really ever know someone else, nor can you try control them like a puppet and it work. So you have to accept that you will often fail at trying to manage people in situations like this (and to understand your bosses, etc.), and you need strategies that work in the face of these factors.

But from another perspective, I'm not all that convinced about viewing developers the way you say, trying to indulge them then find a way to use the output. My alternative is to spend more time giving people good context - a programmer may be less inclined to chase their own technical novelty compulsions if you can give them an understandable and non-fake view of e.g. specific sales processes that need to be supported by development and what the significance is, company strategy, what the operations team is dealing with, etc. One of the simple older ideas in this area is having developers sit in on sales/customer meetings.

So I guess this is a kind of argument that alienation is part of the story of why technical people can often be totally unaligned with their company's goals and this is a barrier to improving this.

This may be a perspective coloured by my experience mostly working in small companies, not sure how well it translates to big ones.

jimwhite42··on More than five whys and “layer eight” problems
> I guess you just have to ask why people have these motivations and why they hide them.

> It feels like people would act dishonestly first to seek survival (job security), but then also to seek power (promotion/influence).

The first place I go to is to see that people aren't always doing good strategical thinking, then they get hung up on mistaken goals, or ineffective ways of achieving them, and aren't very good at communicating what they are doing or hoping to achieve, and this often leads to what looks like subconscious (or sometimes very conscious) obfuscation.

In the technology area, I've worked with many coders, through to product people, sales, marketing, directors, etc., who get hung up on particular technical ideas - and claim these are strategic product or architecural decisions, and the same happens with people getting hung up on ineffective project management - especially when it's an approach that worked in another situation much better than it's working in the current situation.

jimwhite42··on More than five whys and “layer eight” problems
I like to think about this sort of stuff in terms of strategy. The definition I use is 'strategical goals' are the things you are trying to achieve, and 'strategy' is the 'why, how, what's the rationale for these, when do we revisit the goals and the strategy, etc.'. Strategical goals can be high level or low level. In some cases you can take part in a big picture company strategy process. In other cases, the strategical goals you have as an individual are to support the goals/ways of working of your boss, and the other people you work with, which you can only comprehend in a very blinkered way.

In all these situations, it seems like some of the time, and for a critical part of what you do a lot of the time, you have to have strategies that take into account other people having hidden motivations, and particularly people who don't think strategically and cannot be reasoned with on the basis of strategy, or they refuse to be open with these sorts of things with you in particular, or will be evasive, or say they will do things and then not do them, etc.. A lot of the time you cannot fix these things, you can only take them into account and/or find workarounds. And it seems reasonable to say that this is the part of the picture where you have the most leverage to make a difference, or to reduce things like the amount of bullshit you deal with, or the amount of wasted effort you put into things.

You can also have the insight that other people will see you the same way - as someone who is obstructive, or fails to be clear, or isn't persuing the right goals, etc..

jimwhite42··on Shells are two things
Maybe I'm missing something, but the example at the bottom, you can do just as much type checking with the terse command-line syntax as with what he calls the 'typed interface'.
jimwhite42··on Some gut bacteria appear to communicate with the brain
Humans need a lot of nutrients for brain operation, so it makes sense that we would have a sophisticated system for working with the gut flora and fauna to support them so that they can help us digest food effectively. If this is the case, in a sense we then we invite the gut inhabitants, and ask them what they want so they can help us. I think it's reaching a bit to describe this as 'gut bacteria control the brain'.
jimwhite42··on The Dawn of Everything challenges a mainstream telling of prehistory
Not sure exactly, he's done some level of anthropology, but isn't currently an academic as far as I can tell, not sure if he used to be one. His channel is about politics from an anthropology angle.
jimwhite42··on The Dawn of Everything challenges a mainstream telling of prehistory
This is a good review, on the What is Politics channel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oJIHWk_M398&list=PLU4FEuj4v9...

But it isn't a summary, it goes into a lot of detailed critique. I think each video description links to a bibliography and transcript too.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2