HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jimzvz

410 karma · joined December 27, 2012

submissionscomments
jimzvz··on Adria Richards: ‘I’m staying safe’
>Can you see the difference?

No, I can't because every man is not a rapist. Your scenario assumes that the men are malevolent and the women benevolent. If you remove this prejudice, you will see the scene as I do. The same thing.

>Just like you can tell your boss a joke where someone's getting fired, but you could feel uncomfortable if he was the one telling the joke.

The comparison is flawed in three ways. Firstly, every boss can potentially fire an employee but every man is not a rapist. If two known rapists came and sat next to me at a bus stop and started making sexual jokes, I would feel scared even as a man.

Secondly, sexual jokes describe any joke that is related to something sexual. A joke where someone is getting fired is very specific and has a victim. You cannot compare the two (unless you are imagining a small subset of sexual jokes that have a victim but this is not what we are talking about).

Thirdly, In your bus stop scene the two men are engaged in private conversation. In your office scene, the boss is telling the joke directly to the employee.

jimzvz··on Adria Richards: ‘I’m staying safe’
Yes, treating people differently will almost certainly result in people being treated the same. Not really though, it has never worked and will never work probably because it is illogical.

This is part of the reason why so called "male privilege" is actually bullshit. There are so many double standards and exceptions negatively effecting males that they are actually at a disadvantage in a rapidly increasing number of areas.

jimzvz··on Adria Richards: ‘I’m staying safe’
>Again, context matters. When a man makes a sexual joke and a woman makes a sexual joke, it's not the same thing because there are different implications to it.

My brain cannot even comprehend how you can believe such bullshit. I feel like am living in some kind of satirical novel when these incidents happen and people defend it with these type of statements.

jimzvz··on Adria Richards: ‘I’m staying safe’
>I bet...

>...probably...

>And it IS...

Believe it or not, your opinion isn't fact.

jimzvz··on Wanted: People Willing to Die on Mars
As a citizen of a so called third-world country, your post is extremely condescending.
jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
haha, okay.
jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
Sexism is discrimination based on sex. Please look up the definition of sexism. No, it does not depend on the motivation or context, everyone who discriminates believes that their motives justify it but they don't. Your sexism is no different from anyone else's.
jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
No, I am saying that people don't like being segregated (not that they should not like, do not try to put a different spin on it) and as a person who has interacted with other people my whole life I do have a right to say that. Yes, women are people so I believe this includes women. Maybe there are people that like being singled out based on their gender in this context but I have definitely not met any.

>they can tell us themselves if they feel this way

Yes and they do. I am not sure if you realise this but this actually what the female author of the article says:

"I also have grave concerns regarding activities and events that are for “girls only”. These events instead enforce the stereotype, segregating girls and giving them (and everyone) a message that they are different. It is a band-aid attempt at a solution to a problem that starts at a much younger age, and seriously neglects those girls (and women) who don’t want to be segregated (many of whom never even come out to such events, and whose voices are sadly never heard). Children do not grow up into a segregated world, so why are we reinforcing that message? Why are we not just creating a variety of activities that may appeal to boys or girls or both? I can see taking issue with creating explicitly sexist activities, but there is nothing inherently sexist about having activities that may attract more of one gender than the other, especially when we make the available to everyone. "

jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
Is this not true?
jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
Please explain to me where I made an assertion about how women should feel. I said that girls will wonder why they are being treated differently and I said that people do not like being segregated. What words am I putting in whose mouths? What type of argument?
jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
Yes but there is a difference between forced segregation and self-segregation.
jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
Well perhaps, at the moment, she is only interested in it because it is what you do and is using the argument that it is a boy's thing to convey that to you.
jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
Are you suggesting that we cannot debate this issue unless we are female? Because, if so, then you need to copy and paste your comment on 90% of the comments in this thread including your own. (I assume you are not a women because you said "Can WE please let the women speak for themselves?")

Or are you suggesting that us males are only not allowed to debate when we believe that special treatment of women is actually detrimental to them and everyone else?

jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
The problem is that it is using discrimination to fight discrimination.

What about the boy who can't afford the tuition for the computer science course, his best friend, a girl who he has just introduced to programming, gets a bursary to the course just because she is female? The boy feels that he is not wanted in the cs community because of this discrimination so he begins to pursue something different and the girl feels that she was given an unfair advantage over her friend and does not want to ruin the relationship so she pulls out of the course.

Anything like this that isn't based on merit or interest can be pretty devastating.

jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
>The contexts for the two groups are completely different, thus a simple "swapping the two labels and seeing what results" gives absolutely no insight.

This is an argument that has been used by most proponents of discriminatory practices.

jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
Why immediately assume that the idea comes from environmental factors?
jimzvz··on On being a girl in computer science - a confession
>Kids are very perceptive, they notice the apparent differences in acceptable behavior very early on

Yes and if young girls' early exposure to the industry consists largely of "Girl-centric CS activities" then they will immediately wonder why they need such special treatment. People do not want want to be segregated, even if it is, supposedly, for a good cause.

jimzvz··on Could the eagles have flown Frodo into Mordor? (2000)
Perhaps Gandalf feared the power the ring would have over the eagles. Not during the trip, as discussed in the article, but at the moment when it needs to be destroyed. If the eagle changed its mind at that point, there would be nothing they could do about it.

He did not even trust himself with the ring. The ring corrupting a powerful being would be far more devastating than the corruption of a hobbit or man so perhaps he thought that the less involved such beings were in the actual destruction the better.

It's a pity Tolkien isn't around because he must have thought that the reason was trivial enough not to warrant an explanation.

jimzvz··on Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift minimum wage
>Of course, and those would be the people who choose to work in order to earn more than the guaranteed minimum. The result would be more available jobs with more relaxing hours, giving people more time to spend with their families, on side projects, or on creative pursuits that enrich our culture.

I don't follow this logic. The easier it is for people to skate through life without working or working effectively, the less incentive they have to contribute. The people that pay for this life will decrease and quality of life will decrease for everyone.

jimzvz··on Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift minimum wage
>The more time goes on, the more I think maybe a minimum guaranteed income is the solution that makes the most sense.

Why? Someone has to pay for it.

jimzvz··on Rejecting industry dogma, Costco backs calls to lift minimum wage
Higher labour costs just push business overseas. Is this not true?
jimzvz··on Fostering Female Friendly Companies
I would think that the obvious thing is to stop differentiating between men and women. Stop treating women as some special case that need gender specific forums, consultants, hackathons, events et cetera. If you want to stop sexism, stop perpetuating it.
jimzvz··on Heroku COO on RapGenius, legendary hires, and developers’ woman problem
This marketing fluff failed to communicate anything useful to me but did make me decide that I no longer like heroku. Actually, I guess that is useful.

>"Ultimately, our stances always come from a place of respect. If you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all."

>"I think it’s great when someone provides feedback , positive or negative, but we need to do it in a respectful way. When these things come up — and they will always come up — just treat everyone involved with respect."

>Two years ago, he told me, the word “respect” wasn’t on that list. Today, it defines how Heroku will respond to RapGenius and the rest of its customers.

What? This guy sounds like a politician.

If you accidentally (or deliberately) hide the way a major part of your product works and it just so happens that this means that to get a certain performance from your product, your customers will have to pay a lot more than they think, do not give an interview talking about "respect" (shouldn't that be a given!?), apologise and tell us how you are going to fix it.

jimzvz··on The Glass Bicycle
I agree but why is the tesla roadster in that list?
jimzvz··on Ask HN: A patent troll is targeting my transit app
>My apps use the API provided by NextBus who apparently licensed these patents.

Since you are using their api, surely your app is covered by NextBus' licenses? I would get legal opinion on this though because even though this would be logical and expected, the fact that such trivial forms of telemetry can be patented shows that the system is certainly not logical or expected.

This type of thing is seriously depressing. Good luck.

jimzvz··on Spotify and Facebook: Is that phishing?
So reactivating the facebook account and adding the app to the facebook account without the user agreeing to either is fine for you?
jimzvz··on Highcharts 3.0 Beta released
This error is rather worrying.

jtablesession::Store Failed DB function failed with error number 1226 User 'highcharts' has exceeded the 'max_updates' resource (current value: 36000) SQL=INSERT INTO `jos_session` ( `session_id`,`time`,`username`,`gid`,`guest`,`client_id` ) VALUES ( '','1361463235','','0','1','0' )

jimzvz··on Google Glass
Haha, not exactly what I had in mind.
jimzvz··on Thrown Off a United Airlines Flight for Taking Pictures
If flight attendants got everybody that they didn't like kicked off flights, it would seem[1] that there would be barely anyone flying.

If I pay for a service and it isn't delivered there better be a damn good reason. A lie about me doing something that I wasn't or me stating that I am not a terrorist are not good reasons.

[1]http://longhaulflightattendants.tumblr.com/

jimzvz··on Thrown Off a United Airlines Flight for Taking Pictures
>...you'll get a more thorough check of your car (trunk and backseat), plus a more in-depth check of your car's plates and your ID - because you just made a seemingly unrelated statement about a horrible thing (kidnapping) when the cop pulled you over for something trivial (not obeying speed rules).

Not in a normal society.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →