HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jivatmanx

1,417 karma · joined October 10, 2012

submissionscomments
jivatmanx··on Can We Trust Monsanto with Our Food?
A species, the lowest taxonomic classification on the tree of life, is defined by the ability to crossbreed. [0]

Previously, any crossbreeding between plants, by necessity had to belong to the same species. Since this is the lowest taxonomic classification, the vast majority of the genome was shared.

Now, a plant can be crossed with any other species on the tree of life. That's a significant difference.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Species

jivatmanx··on Can We Trust Monsanto with Our Food?
>Humans began genetically modifying plants to provide food more than 10,000 years ago.

There's a difference between selecting and breeding specific plants in your corn crop, or crossing corn with a slightly different variety of corn, and crossing corn with a fish, ginkgo tree, or bacteria.

jivatmanx··on Democratic establishment unmasked: prime defenders of NSA bulk spying
>All of this goes to support Greenwald's thesis (given at the beginning and the end, so I'm not sure how you missed it) that the real warfare in Washington is between establishment authoritarians, and those who have become weary (and wary) of the unchecked national security state, not between Republicans and Democrats as is frequently portrayed in the media.

"The real division is not between conservatives and revolutionaries but between authoritarians and libertarians. " -George Orwell

jivatmanx··on As Feds Demand the Keys, Preparing for the Death of Public-Key Encryption
What if there is malware in USB keys?
jivatmanx··on White House Seems Afraid NSA Defunding Law Could Actually Pass Today
I agree with social security, as it's simply a direct monetary transfer program, and I personally view these, such as progressive taxation, as vastly preferable to Federal control of services for many reasons.

But, Medicare is a state-owned Insurance company, and if I remember correctly, constitutes around 50% of the country's health spending.

Also, Do your numbers include contractors? My understanding is that there is a trend of using contractors in all areas of the federal government, and I personally consider contractors to be defacto federal employees. They have the advantage of not being able to belong to public unions, which I consider anti-democratic, but the disadvantage of losing the sense of being a patriotic public servant participating in the betterment of the Republic.

jivatmanx··on Snowden asylum still under review, stays in airport for now
War is politics by other means.

When a war ends without the politics being settled, the seed of conflict remains.

However, most either people lack this longer term vision and falsely perceive a physical wins as an ultimate "victory", or don't care because they won't be around then.

"This isn't a peace, it's a twenty year truce!" - Ferdinand Foch, regarding the Treaty of Versailles

As an aside, the U.S's failure to predict the Collapse of the USSR was probably their greatest intelligence failure, with the consequence being Russia beginning a hurtling into the Abyss, arrested by Putin, and a partial reversal of the Democratic trend of Gorbachev. I don't think Demonizing Putin is really going to be helpful. Ignorance of the historical circumstances of Russia brought him in power is analogous to the belief that a Utopian Democracy could simply be imposed on Iraq from above. Take a Spherical Cow in a Vacuum, add some Democracy...

jivatmanx··on Feds put heat on Web firms for master encryption keys
Few men could be moral when offered the combination of unrestricted power over others, total secrecy, and lack of consequences for actions, that is so often the state of these agencies.

That's why we need their power to be limited and defined, as open as possible, and have legitimate avenues of redress for grievances. They are supposed to be public servants, not rogues.

jivatmanx··on Rep Justin Amash: Strip NSA Of Power To Collect Phone Data On Innocent Americans
There are legitimate questions of the necessity of a permanent military complex. Classical liberals opposed standing armies.

Switzerland has an alternative to a standing army.

And, as the other commenter pointed out, the Industrial complex was created from scratch during WWII, which is clearly an argument that it didn't need to be Permanent.

Yes, it continued during the Cold War. But that's over. And China or Russia aren't the USSR.

jivatmanx··on Rep Justin Amash: Strip NSA Of Power To Collect Phone Data On Innocent Americans
I would hope that congress could be united in perturbation at what seems to be a clear pattern of contempt officials of the Executive branch has shown for them, starting with the last presidency.

And I'm not referring to the president or his political appointees, but the permanent security state. In particular, "Emperor Alexander" and the fiefdom he has accumulated [0], without anyone noticing, and unprecedented for any American military official, and clearly contrary to basic republican principles.

If we continue the pattern of echoing the Executive's contempt for Congress, clearly intended as the principal branch of our democratic government, it will just continue it's pattern of delegating increasingly vague and arbitrary powers to that Executive, and offering no oversight whatsoever. And those powers are going somewhere. To "Emperor Alexander" or his successor.

I don't like to see so many people echo of the contempt the executive has shown for congress. It doesn't help Democracy to attack it's principal branch.

[0]http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/06/general-keith-alexa...

jivatmanx··on Against Cynicism: A philosopher's brilliant reasons for living
I think it's possible to believe that a cause is lost, and yet still believe in the categorical imperative of fighting for it.

Cicero is immortal as both the greatest and last defender of the Roman Republic.

jivatmanx··on This week in press freedoms and privacy rights
Why can't charges be specific and limited to the actual crime of 'unauthorized disclosure of classified information'. As a coder, this bothers me. Intuitively this reeks of slippery slope.
jivatmanx··on ‘America has no functioning democracy at this moment’ – Jimmy Carter on NSA
Not when you lose to Canada.
jivatmanx··on ‘America has no functioning democracy at this moment’ – Jimmy Carter on NSA
Life as a Spanish Colony wasn't so hot. Anyways, these areas were granted U.S. citizenship and autonomy soon after.

Earlier, Simon Bolivar, who liberated most of Latin America from Spanish control and laid their democratic foundations, loved the American founding fathers, especially Jefferson, and even sent his nephew to the University of Virginia.

jivatmanx··on ‘America has no functioning democracy at this moment’ – Jimmy Carter on NSA
Cuba was a Spanish colony, and the U.S. gave them formal independence just four years after the war ended. It could easily have been permanently annexed.
jivatmanx··on ‘America has no functioning democracy at this moment’ – Jimmy Carter on NSA
The military-industrial complex was basically created from scratch in WWII (The U.S's industrial contribution to WWI was a joke). This was never de-mobilized because the Cold War began immediately after, and Europe was in no position to defend itself.
jivatmanx··on ‘America has no functioning democracy at this moment’ – Jimmy Carter on NSA
I often see quotes by Peter T. King in these articles saying things like that, or like - "no American Muslim leaders are cooperating in the war on terror,", or "80-85 percent of mosques in this country are controlled by Islamic fundamentalists .... This is an enemy living amongst us."

It's interesting to note that he was an actual terrorist financier:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_T._King#Support_for_the_I...

jivatmanx··on Obama wins back the right to indefinitely detain under NDAA
The idea of separation of power has, I believe, a flaw. Instead of considering the branches co-equal, it should be considered that the primary job of both the Legislative and Judicial is to limit the power of the Executive.

It should be obvious, but there was never any danger of the Judicial or Legislative to have too much power for itself.

At the moment, the Supreme Court/Judiciary is being usurped by by the use of secret FISA court as a sort of rival supreme court. The Legislature is essentially viewed with contempt and lied to with impunity by by the executive(Clapper, Alexander, etc.)

jivatmanx··on Police May Know Exactly Where You Were Last Tuesday
Yep, this is why "Stranger Danger" fear-mongering is counterproductive. The kidnappers are usually familiar, and Strangers are really one's greatest chance of help.
jivatmanx··on Email exchange between Edward Snowden and former GOP Senator Gordon Humphrey
Hamilton argued at the constitutional convention for an elected monarchy. He admired Caesar above all others, and throughout his life held a profound disdain of the lower class. - “the people are turbulent and changing; they seldom judge or determine right. Give therefore to the first class a distinct permanent share in the government.”

Read his Caesar letters, or his constitutional convention speech, or other writings, as these views aren't really apparent in the Federalist papers.

Madison is interesting, but he didn't hold to a single consistent political philosophy through his life.

jivatmanx··on Email exchange between Edward Snowden and former GOP Senator Gordon Humphrey
"Some aspects of Snowden's story do NOT look like a thoughtful plan to defend freedom and fair play around the world, but rather a haphazard rash move by Snowden to see what he can get away with."

I think you're enormously overestimating the capacity for planning that any single individual could be capable of. Jason Bourne exists in the movies, not in real life.

jivatmanx··on 19 Groups Sue NSA Over Data Collection
"Back in the 1950s, the State Department was asking people to promise they weren't communists before granting them a passport so they can travel abroad. The amount of information they can get on people has grown exponentially since then - and that doesn't mean we have to be less careful with it."

We do have a disadvantage this time. Prior to the internet era nearly anyone could easily understand exactly what was being done, as wiretapping was the most complex instrument used.

This time, one can attempt to abstract this as far as possible, and bury arguments with technical jargon. "Metadata isn't data", etc.

jivatmanx··on Email exchange between Edward Snowden and former GOP Senator Gordon Humphrey
Which is only convention, not by law, and in any case, just an arbitrary number.

FDR threatened to pack the court with lackeys if they didn't vote in favor of his programs.

Which raises the obvious question of, since that event, has the Supreme Court really even served as a check on executive power?

I suppose, at least, FDR would have had to answer to public opinion if he had actually carried out that threat. Unlike, say, if the secret FISA court were so threatened.

jivatmanx··on For NSA chief, terrorist threat drives passion to "collect it all" observers say
Germany's Enlightenment was the most abstract and apolitical, compared to France or Britain, and exemplified by Kant, and tracts like "Critique of Pure Reason".

The majority of the figures of "Classical Liberalism" were from Britain. France also had political figures like Rousseau, but they tend to somewhat more Romanticism and less practicality.

Germany's tradition of antisemitism owed most to Martin Luther, who explicitly envisioned a genocide/enslavement of Jews in his "On The Jews and their Lies", a book beloved by Hitler.

jivatmanx··on Things Most Americans Don’t Know About America
Fully 30% of Jefferson's Original Declaration was truncated. It explicitly denounced slavery and blamed it on Britain.

That caused him great trouble. Till his death, he insisted that be the version preserved for posterity.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Declaration_of_In...

jivatmanx··on The Case for Abolishing the DHS
Yes, In fact, warantless wiretapping actually began 7 months before 9/11

http://digitaljournal.com/article/352455

jivatmanx··on The Case for Abolishing the DHS
I have heard Dianne Feinstein use the word "Homeland" outside of the context of the department itself. I'd guess that Lindsey Graham and others are also doing this.

The more traditional phrase, Republic, used by Benjamin Franklin, and in the pledge of Allegiance is, as your article points out, more closely ties the U.S. to certain philosophical principles, whereas the term homeland is restricted to the physical, geographic location and the individuals in it.

If the lexicon is reduced to physical protection, than it's less vulnerable to arguments of lost liberty.

jivatmanx··on Things Most Americans Don’t Know About America
1215. There is actually a lesser known document called the "Charter of Liberties" from 1100. It was entirely ignored but was critical influence for the Magna Carta.

The Magna Carta was also basically ignored, but was utterly critical for the English Bill of Rights, which really has been followed, till this day.

jivatmanx··on For NSA chief, terrorist threat drives passion to "collect it all" observers say
"Imagine a world where most want to... x"

What a majority want or do not want is entirely orthogonal to whether it's moral or not.

jivatmanx··on For NSA chief, terrorist threat drives passion to "collect it all" observers say
A General should not have been allowed to attain this much political power. Or repeatedly lie to congress without repercussions.

Yet more checks and balances that are clearly out of whack.

jivatmanx··on About the Reuters article
But, few congressmen had any idea of the true extent of this; and Clapper has already admitted to being untruthful to them.

Which leaves the president. You can't believe that providing 1 bit of information every four years is sufficient to maintain a democracy, can you?

While there are allowed exceptions, a Republic operates on a default assumption of public access and transparency in government, and the liberty and privacy of the individual. The converse system, where there is a presumption of secrecy in government, and transparency of the individual, is a tyranny, as government, the people's servant, has become their master.

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →