HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jjk166

8,522 karma · joined April 26, 2017

submissionscomments
jjk166··on The Myth of the Solo Unicorn
Extremely weak argument. Basically it's just asserting "AI can't make enterprise sales" which both is both a questionable claim on its own merits, and not relevant for many business models. If anything I am now much more certain of the inevitability of a solo unicorn than I was before I read it.
jjk166··on It seems that the age of reading might be a short anomaly in human history
https://xkcd.com/1227/
jjk166··on It seems that the age of reading might be a short anomaly in human history
> Yes, but do you only do things for pleasure if they're done quickly? Is your sex always over in a minute?

You do things for pleasure more often if they're done quickly. When was the last time you had a lovemaking session so long you could have read a book in the time?

jjk166··on GAO: DOE Is Prematurely Excluding Less Expensive Options for Nuclear Cleanup
This is an excellent example of how to communicate investigation findings. The summary is clear and succinct, there are illustrative examples readily understood by a layman, the recommendations are actionable and unambiguous, and the potential impact is quantified without promising some stupidly precise estimate. I've got some customers whose quality auditors could learn a lot from this.
jjk166··on Camera with transparent display launches for the equivalent of $29
Seems a lot easier to learn "it's accurate when it's about 8 inches from my face; it's this much off when it is 12 inches away" than to project out a virtual FOV from the camera at an arbitrary position onto the world.
jjk166··on China sentences official to death for taking $325M in bribes
It's the wielding of power which is intoxicating, the monetary amount just illustrates how many decisions he could personally influence.
jjk166··on Medieval-style fortifications are back in the Sahel
That was always a bit of a myth. Walls are not meant to stop things from getting destroyed, they are to prevent easy entry. Even in antiquity the ability to lob something over a wall existed, but if you were in range to do so, the defenders on the walls were in range to lob things at you, structures within the walls could be hardened to resist damage from things lobbed at them, and ultimately lobbing things over walls simply didn't win conflicts. Even the strategic bombing of WW2 wasn't sufficient to bring any side to its knees - only boots on the ground or the imminent threat thereof actually got the job done.

Further, the disappearance of walls does not coincide well with developments in weapons technology. Walls adapted to the introduction of gunpowder and explosives, with fortresses being key parts of strategy well into the 20th century. Even medieval fortifications with minimal upgrades still proved reasonably effective in modern conflicts. Walls are very good for their intended purpose.

The disappearance of city walls was not due to technological but rather social progress. The early modern period saw the development of strong central states able to field large armies. These states did not want a lot of fortified cities that could close themselves off easily from either a foreign invader or from their own government. Instead the national army would defend cities as needed, operating from fortresses in strategic locations and setting up temporary fortifications as needed. Cities were redesigned to make it easy to march an army into them. At the same time, population growth and changing economic systems meant cities rapidly grew, far outstripping the limited space available within medieval walls. Again, detached networks of mutually-supporting forts were simply more economical than contiguous walls. Finally, the changing world meant that you were simply no longer worried about wandering war bands pillaging settlements. Most of what walls were needed for could be done more economically with fences and legal markers.

jjk166··on AI can't be listed as inventor on patent applications, Japan's top court rules
Specifically for patent law, the distinction should be whether the entity is capable of genuine innovation, ie that it's not simply pulling existing information from its training set and passing things through some RNGs. It's not a matter of how advanced the AI is, it's a matter of the architecture.
jjk166··on AI can't be listed as inventor on patent applications, Japan's top court rules
> But, since the income of a patent office is determined by how many patents they approve, one can dream ...

The patent office also gets fees from applications it rejects. Reducing the examination costs could significantly increase profitability even if fewer patents are issued.

jjk166··on AI can't be listed as inventor on patent applications, Japan's top court rules
While I am unfamiliar with Japanese patent law, this would certainly be sound under the American system. Two requirements for patentability are novelty and non-obviousness, meaning the idea does not already exist nor is it such a trivial modification of an existing idea that anyone knowledgeable in the subject could come up with it. Anything an AI spits out is pretty much by definition something that either exists in their training set or which can be trivially deduced from something in their training set. They might be a useful tool for an inventor, but the creative spark which patents protect can not come from them.
jjk166··on Job seekers giving up: Labor force participation falls to lowest in 50 years
The 20-24 year olds seem to be at roughly the same point as since the great recession. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS11300036

Worth noting this is people who have a job, it includes the under-employed.

jjk166··on Job seekers giving up: Labor force participation falls to lowest in 50 years
It's likely not even people retiring early, just demographics shifting up the ages. The youngest baby boomers are 61. The percentage of Americans over the age of 60 increased from 22.8% in 2020 to 25% in 2025. Also the younger cohorts moving into the labor force are smaller as well.

https://www.populationpyramid.net/united-states-of-america/2...

jjk166··on Job seekers giving up: Labor force participation falls to lowest in 50 years
In other news, June worst full month since May.
jjk166··on The labor share of income in the US is at its lowest post-war level
They need fewer people to build and to maintain than older ones did. Further the jobs from building the factory are temporary.
jjk166··on US Supreme Court rules geofence warrants require constitutional protections
Or perhaps the standards of evidence established for a pre-industrial society when eye-witness testimony was the best that could reasonably be achieved is not necessarily the optimal system for a digital society where everyone carries a high definition video camera in their pocket at all times.
jjk166··on US Supreme Court rules geofence warrants require constitutional protections
At the same time though, a bunch of people who know each other and the people allegedly involved could very easily share the same incorrect testimony. You wouldn't believe in bigfoot if 5 guys drinking beers swore they saw him while they were camping. Sending someone to prison or worse is much higher stakes. DNA evidence might be too extreme, but I'd expect some sort of evidence to back up a testimony. "What if the witness was wrong" just seems like always a reasonable doubt, or at least the number of witnesses who would need to corroborate something such that it ceases to be a reasonable doubt is impractically high.
jjk166··on Pre-Modern Armies for Worldbuilders, Part III: Paying for It
Which is exactly the point I was making. For a particular emperor in Constantinople, paying tribute to an army outside the wall may have been, or appeared to have been, an economical option for achieving their personal goals, which may not have been aligned with the empire's, and thus the fact the action occurred can not be taken as evidence that it was a rational choice which served the interest of the Roman Empire. People in the past weren't dumb, but they weren't hyper-competent nor devoid of ulterior motives either. We should expect most past decisions to have been sub-optimal.
jjk166··on International investment and local rules push prices up faster than supply
The problem is real estate can not be looked at on a national scale. It is fundamentally local. In a country like the US, probably 95%+ of the land is absolutely worthless as an investment. You can get a residential plot in North Dakota for like $5k. But owning a very small portion of a country can have an extreme influence if it's that part of a country that people seek to live in. Further, the overwhelming majority of real estate in any given area is typically occupied by someone who has no interest in selling soon. Only about 3-4% of US homes are on the market at any given time. If an entity bought up every home on the market in the Bay area, they'd own a measly 0.009% of the US real estate market in terms of housing units, but they would be able to unilaterally set the price of housing for over 2% of the US population and over 4% of the US economy.
jjk166··on Trump cancels bipartisan housing bill, reiterates demand for SAVE America Act
That has nothing to do with pocket vetoes. A pro-forma session blocks recess appointments. It also doesn't occur each day, congress can adjourn for up to 3 days without recess.

Pocket vetoes have occurred during mid session breaks (known as intrasession pocket vetoes). In recent years appellate courts have ruled that congress can appoint an agent to receive bills when not in session which would thus make pocket vetoes impossible. This has not been put to the test. Given the current republican supermajority on the supreme court, if a president were ever to assert that agents are invalid it would be now.

jjk166··on Pre-Modern Armies for Worldbuilders, Part III: Paying for It
There is a wide gulf between arguing something happened on occasion and arguing it was a sound idea. History records ancient states performing human sacrifice to make the sun rise again. It's likely these people saw it as a good idea, and hey the sun kept rising for years, but you'd have a hard time convincing me it was economical compared to alternative options.
jjk166··on Pre-Modern Armies for Worldbuilders, Part III: Paying for It
It was also quite common for them to assassinate their emperors, to engage in civil war, to debase their currency so as to pay soldiers more, to hire barbarian mercenaries, etc. It is one thing to acknowledge these things happened, it is quite another to argue these were economically rational actions in the best interest of Rome.
jjk166··on Pre-Modern Armies for Worldbuilders, Part III: Paying for It
That people did things at some point or another in history does not mean those things were good ideas on any time scales. People both make bad decisions and face conflicts of interest. History is chock full of incredibly dumb things that nevertheless happened.
jjk166··on Pre-Modern Armies for Worldbuilders, Part III: Paying for It
Most likely not. The price to pay people to get them to do something must exceed the opportunity cost of them not doing that something. Raising an army from your people, if they don't fight alongside you they are probably facing a pretty suboptimal situation - their crops burned, their cities looted, their wives and daughters raped, foreign oppression, etc. This risk may be small, while stepping onto the battlefield has risks of its own, and it requires materiel which isn't cheap, so most people will not do it for free, and even if some will you probably want more and better soldiers as well. But you don't need that much to tip the scales.

On the other hand the adversary stands to gain a lot from pillaging your countryside, both gaining wealth from the loot they capture and security by knocking you out as a potential threat. In the most extreme case they may be looking at exterminating you entirely and taking your land and everything in it for themselves. They may be facing starvation and death if they don't take your resources from you. You fundamentally can't offer them more than they could potentially take. It is rational for them to accept less treasure for sufficiently reduced risk, but there is no guarantee you can offer enough that fighting for the rest isn't worth it in their eyes. Paying them to attack someone else is even harder - they still do not reap the full benefits of defeating you, but they still suffer the risk of fighting, and they have an additional enemy to boot. If they do manage to go for that option, you're almost certainly losing a potential ally (the enemy of your enemy is your friend) and whoever wins that conflict is going to be pretty pissed at you.

On top of this, paying your own people to fight for you strengthens your side. Yes war may not be the optimal use of resources but those dollars are flowing right back into your economy feeding your people, employing your smiths, etc. The strong army you raise both deters potential adversaries and can be used to extract demands from neighbors. Conversely, paying tribute to the adversary makes them stronger - they can afford more men, better weapons, deeper war chests. You may buy yourself time but the fundamental grievances that made war possible in the first place have gone unaddressed; it is reasonable to expect you will wind up in the same situation again at some point, but the next time it will be more expensive to bribe them while you will have less money to raise an army for yourself. You can't repeat this cycle too many times.

All this assumes your adversary is rational. Unfortunately that's not a safe assumption. For the right price you'll be able to raise an army, but whether it be a holy crusade or a fight for freedom or a face launching a thousand ships, a particular army might be fighting for something they consider priceless.

jjk166··on Trump cancels bipartisan housing bill, reiterates demand for SAVE America Act
> If he fails to sign or veto it then in about two weeks, it will automatically become law anyway.

This is inaccurate. If the president fails to sign a bill within 10 days (not including sundays) while congress is not in session then the bill does not become law. This is known as a pocket veto. Congress is out of session the next 2 weeks, so Trump does need to sign the bill for it to become law.

jjk166··on NSA director: 'Mythos "broke into almost all of our classified systems in hours"
> The concept of infinity claims that the dog eventually becomes Shakespeare.

The ability to reproduce an exact copy of hamlet does not make one Shakespeare. A monkey on a typewriter may very well generate Shakespeare eventually, but it wouldn't understand Shakespeare then any more than it could immediately. Likewise a dog may put together some string of text that includes a derivation of calculus, but at no time will it be able to apply that derivation to solve mathematical problems.

jjk166··on Fossil Fuels Are 40% of Freight Shipping Tonnage, but Half Its Fuel Use
Transmission losses are orders of magnitude lower than transportation energy costs. You both get dramatically less loss per kilometer, and you have way fewer kilometers to travel. Transmission does get less efficient over longer distances; if you had a 20000km long transmission line it would be less efficient than shipping fossil fuels, but you simply don't need to do that.

You have conversion losses to generate motion but these are again substantially less than the conversion of chemical energy to motion that occurs inside a combustion engine. Powerplants+electric motors will have conversion efficiencies around 30%; internal combustion engines will have conversion efficiencies around 10%.

With the exception of some remote locations or emergency situations with backup generators, you are almost certainly not consuming a fuel that requires refining to generate electricity. If you're burning coal or gas, it's coming from much closer, and it's being transported in bulk to the powerplant. Trucks taking fuels to the local distribution centers and ultimately gas stations are by far the largest transportation energy expense for petrol.

jjk166··on I used sound waves to make espresso. It could cut coffee‑brewing energy use by ¾
A very similar process does a lot more than just coffee

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YlQT4ptwLKs

I was inspired by the above video and have been playing around with ultrasonically aged drinks for quite some time now. It's quite fun. Still haven't brought myself to try ultrasonically aged milk yet though.

jjk166··on Israeli firm BlackCore suspected of meddling in New York and Scotland votes
I would argue serving 19 years in the US Senate is a far more impressive political accomplishment than being elected mayor of a city, even one as prominent as New York. Bernie has had immense political success, even if his attempt at being nominated for the presidency was narrowly thwarted. Cuomo may have been an insider, but he was a disgraced insider; there's no comparison to the political figures who beat Bernie.
jjk166··on Israeli firm BlackCore suspected of meddling in New York and Scotland votes
> Probably second behind the swastika itself.

Definitely not. SS bolts, the nazi eagle, the iron cross, the fasces, hitler's mustache, etc are all immensely more recognizeable.

The fact that in the skit they say "we've got skulls on our caps" rather than referring to the actual symbol or even accurately describing it tells you the lack of general familiarity. We all know Nazi's had skulls on their caps, no one knows there are even crossed bones there, nonetheless the particular styling. Normal people don't closely examine Nazi uniforms. Further, this is a comedy sketch playing up the absurdity of the situation for laughs; in reality it was not a Nazi symbol of how evil they were, it was a symbol that had been used in the Prussian and other German armies for centuries and then the Stormtroopers of WW1. In the interwar period it was used by the Freikorps and eventually by the SS, trying to invoke that same imagery. It has become a hate symbol well known amongst white supremacists, but not the general population.

jjk166··on Switzerland wil have a referendum to cap population at 10M
The scenario was not one person on earth, it was one person on an island. There are plenty of other people who could potentially immigrate to the island.

People also tend to give ridiculous answers when they're wrong.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →