We are Registered Investment Advisor (RIA) regulated by the SEC.
1,507 karma · joined March 22, 2009
We are Registered Investment Advisor (RIA) regulated by the SEC.
As for taxes, we provide a yearly summary for realized gains and losses that most tax professional can plug into their software.
And for TLH, yes for larger portfolios (above 20 tickers) we create a factor model of the portfolio using 4 factors - Momentum, Value, Quality and Min Volatility. When a stock is identified for TLH purposes, we will sell it and try and bring your overall portfolios factor exposure back in line. This provides for a much more flexible and robust way to do tax loss harvesting because not every stock has a relevant pair (for example a stock that just recently merged with another business might have no clear comparables)
I found this PDF from State Street quite informative on the topic. We are working on our own data here as well and aim to share that down the line.
https://www.ssga.com/library-content/pdfs/etf/au/spdr-au-etf...
"Bid/ask spreads of the underlying securities directly impact the costs to market makers to trade ETFs" from this .pdf: https://www.ssga.com/library-content/pdfs/etf/au/spdr-au-etf...
We are working on getting some more ESG focused portfolios directly live but it's very very do-able right now.
This is our current latest filed with the SEC:
https://files.adviserinfo.sec.gov/IAPD/Content/Common/crd_ia...
Apex Clearing's website is here: https://apexfintechsolutions.com/ They have 19M brokerage accounts and a lot of brands you've heard of got their start with Apex (Robinhood, Wealthfront)
We're US based and regulated a RIA by the SEC.
We do not charge trade commissions. There are some SEC fees charged for trading across most major brokerages. The national best bid offer (NBBO) means you will get executed at the current best price for a given security across all exchanges.
Robinhood and Wealthfront both started their business on Apex as well.
Longer term, we think there are additional revenue streams we can enable that are similar to existing broker-dealers like Robinhood, Fidelity and Schwab. That means things like cash float, margin lending, stock lending and payment for order flow. Currently we are not a broker-dealer.
Also right now we only support fractional securities and about 3% of VTI is not currently fractionable by our custodian.
With an ETF there is still a tax impact it's just shifted to the holder of the instrument who gets to decide when to sell or buy.
I think we have a few extra features as well and would love for any M1 users to check us out.
Short answer for your simple scenario is yes it would rebalance. The longer answer is it depends on the output of our optimization engine.
Our optimizer tries it's best to make the portfolio better, taking into account drift, trading costs and taxes and potentially holding costs for etfs and a factor model for broad diverse portfolios. Wash sales also play a large part because by default we prevent any wash sales from taking place.
These objectives can compete against each other (tax harvesting is generally good but in your example requires selling AMD not buying it). We run an optimization to try and balance these and come up with trades that make the portfolio better. By default we rebalance if the optimizer thinks the portfolio will get better above a threshold we set.
We have the ability to rebalance based on naive weight drift as you discussed at the end of your comment - right now it's not enabled by default. We are hoping to add a setting so users can enabled the optimizer to only trade if x number of stocks have drifted more than y%.
Please check out this article to learn a bit more: https://help.double.finance/en/articles/9718142-portfolio-op...
The guts of this get a bit complicated and I want to make a blog post about how we achieve this for adjustments.
By direct indexing you get a lot more flexibility to customize the index on a stock/sector/factor level.
Thanks for checking us out.
Would love to chat about any hard learned lessons along the way if you're up for it - founders@double.finance
I have!
But I understand that yes this is a hard thing to get people to move and trust, safety and trading mechanics are incredibly important. We are trying to be as transparent as possible on all those factors. I would love for you to try us out with a smaller amount first to see observe all the mechanics before making a larger move. We support full and partial ACATS transfers of existing stock positions (meaning you don't have to sell anything).
The fraction of a stock you can buy is currently based on a dollar amount. In our case right now it's $5.10 per stock ($5 with $0.10 of room to allow for fluctuations in prices). We are looking to lower this over time though and as our daily trading volumes grows this should come down significantly.