917 karma · joined June 1, 2012
Co-founder & Head of Research at NewLimit. Previously Principal Investigator at Calico, PhD at UCSF.
If you're in town, feel free to shoot me an email to chat about how cells work, aging research, the life sciences, startups, or the local coffee shop landscape. I'm always looking to learn from interesting people.
@jacobkimmel on Twitter et. al.
jacobkimmel@gmail.com
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp%...
Sickle-cell anemia is perpetuated by a trait that appears with strong correlation to the traits that create dark skin pigmentation. IE) Black people are more likely to carry the sickle-cell anemia trait. However, the color of a person's skin does not contribute to the sickle-cell anemia pathology in any way, it is merely correlated to the presence of sickle-cell trait. A light skinned person with sickle-cell anemia responds to treatment in the same manner as a dark skinned person, the dark skinned person is merely more likely to develop the pathology due to genetic correlation.
The same logic applies to this case-study, if it were not compounded by various other idiosyncrasies. The color of a person's skin (what we use to empirically determine race) does not change the effectiveness of most drug agents, and therefore is not biologically relavent in a pharmacological context.
When BiDil was patented, studies were carried out using _only_ African-American subjects, such that the race-specific efficacy was never actually tested. As such, the basis for the entire patent, which hinged on race specificity, has been challenged by some in the field. In my post above there's a link to a paper that came out one of the trials.
[1] - If you're interested, Ben Goldacre has a really interesting talk on the subject.
http://www.ted.com/talks/ben_goldacre_what_doctors_don_t_kno...
[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isosorbide_dinitrate/hydralazin... (BiDil)
There seem to be multiple studies indicating that 'neonic' pesticides are responsible for large portions of Colony Collapse Disorder (CCD) symptomology [1,2,3]. However, your skepticism is not entirely unjust. Other scientists have linked portions of CCD to various factors involved in industrial bee culture, including artificial insemination of queens and lack of biodiversity.
[1] - Assessment of the environmental exposure of honeybees to particulate matter containing neonicotinoid insecticides coming from corn coated seeds.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22292570
[2] - In situ replication of honey bee colony collapse disorder
http://stream.loe.org/images/120406/Lu%20final%20proof.pdf
[3] - Neonicotinoid Pesticide Reduces Bumble Bee Colony Growth and Queen Production
It seems to me that the key difference here would be that no one is harmed by overuse of SSL, whereas over classification of information can have far-reaching negative effects. Failure by the intelligence community to realize such, or a systemic issue that incentivizes over classification, lead to our current situation where a FOIA is required to read a parking ticket.
For years, it has been known that the number of neurons changes very little between lower-level mammals and humans, while the ratio of neurons:glia changes dramatically. We've also identified that direct mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) injection increased rodent cognition, and MSCs are known to differentiate almost entirely into glia in the presence of neurotrophic factors, such as in the CNS environment. Even base neuronal morphology changes little between mammalian species, while astrocytic morphology is readily distinguishable between species.
tl;dr - Nice to see it all come together, but I like to be pedantic and discuss where the impetus for this experiment came from.
That said, the fact that it was first introduced by a highly successful company doesn't lend it any merit in my book.
[1] http://blogs.msdn.com/b/bgroth/archive/2004/09/27/235071.asp...
Part of me agrees with your overall conclusion about the corollary nature of the research as a whole, but those are my two cents on that particular point.
If you're curious, here's a patent list and some background on the company:
https://www.celera.com/celera/intellectual_property
Your logic is definitely sound. It's just mind boggling to me that anyone could possibly be logging everything thrown through every port. Every single day. Just, wow.
I'm not very knowledgable as to the feasibility of such a device, and quite frankly don't know where to begin, but I would love to hear from someone who might know more.
As a back of the napkin, rougher-than-order-of-magnitude calculation, it seems more feasible for the government to tap into existing email providers' databases than to try and administer their own. Would it not simply be easier to file requests (perhaps in a quasi-legitimate manner) for data from Google/Yahoo/MS/Apple than to try and catalog the entire email history of the Internet?
In the case of Microsoft, this phenomena may be more pronounced. Software engineers/developers exist in a smaller subset of society than many other professions, and the compounded relative geographic isolation in Washington may make it difficult to see the forest through the trees during times of professional conflict. This is not to say that Seattle is by any means isolated, but the tech community there is indeed smaller than that of Silicon Valley, magnifying the overall degree of professional isolation.
However, as the school based subjects have broadened out from traditional liberal arts conceptualizations to include more serious discussion of alternative conceptualizations (CompSci being one example), the IQ test may be decreasing in efficacy of prediction even with regards to academic tests. I have no evidence for this, just an opinion. The issue you ran into seems to be a result of these differing conceptualization paradigms.
At the end of the day, it's an assessment of performance in a very limited subfield of life. I try not to take it too seriously.
[1] - I believe JBQ said this to the media once, but I can't find the source now.
Sound familiar? The entire team I worked with had a similar workflow, but we went by life science domain specific titles rather than "data scientist." I'm willing to bet that other professions have similar roles, merely called something else.
I think "data scientists" are out there in the sciences. They just don't go by the latest buzzword.
My point was mainly that there aren't very many of those high paying positions relative to the number of graduates in the field. The ratio of graduates : professors is not too different than the ratio of CS grads : CS professors, but unlike CS, biology doesn't have nearly as many high paying positions outside of the professorial field. Even within education, many very good life scientists have a hard time obtaining tenure.
Most jobs outside of education pay somewhere around 60k, and there isn't a whole lot of room for growth unless you move up into management at a biotech firm. This is in contrast to CS, where a non-manager software engineer has a pretty decent opportunity to make 6 figures if he works hard enough and has a decent level of talent.
I think this is a factor of latency in added value. It seems to me that higher salaries are often given to those who can provide immediate usable value in the short term (lawyers, stock traders, some programmers). Long-term value-add professions, such as biology and many other R&D fields, tend to get the short end of the stick salary wise. Perhaps this is tied into the immediate gratification complex of western culture; professions with a significant value-add prospect >~5 years in the future have a difficult time arguing their own worth.
As for GS's motivation, they're buying at a discount. Due to the time sensitive nature of Knight's predicament, they're probably trading the portfolio to Goldman at a reduced rate. Unlike Knight, Goldman has the cash to sit on it for a while and sell the shares directly out into the open market, even if it takes a few days. Given the discount they bought the shares at, they're likely selling with a decent margin.
However, I think the emphasis on a "personal network," is a little overstated, especially at this age. As a 2012 HS grad, I think I have a decent perspective on the types of networks most modern HS students have available. The OP seems to have gotten lucky with her CS teacher, but for a large number of students, those connections simply aren't available. My high school didn't even have a CS class, let alone a teacher with contacts at Valve.
I think it's worth mentioning that a large number of internships exist for high school students/rising college students in the public sector. Many of these internships are tailored toward recent HS grads/HS upperclassmen, and don't require a networking push or a special exception to get into.
A couple examples:
1. I'm a Cape Canaveral local, and I know for a fact that NASA offers a ton of really cool internship positions specifically geared toward high school students (they even brought in a bunch of the local valedictorians and tried to recruit us).
2. I'm currently interning at the National Institutes of Health, and they too have programs specifically targeting high school students. From the core research, to relocation, to social events, the program is designed with recent HS grads in mind. If anyone reading this wants to ask about the program, feel free to email me.
Short Version: Persistence = Good. Networking = not the only way. Internship programs for HS students = more accessible option.
It's fascinating to look into why the "inevitable," didn't come to pass. Likewise with many of the doomsday predictions we see here, the pivots that prevented many from occurring (arguably, fall of the USSR, massive public health efforts, sheer luck)are sweet spots in history. It'd be interesting to do some kind of meta-analysis of future predictions and these little events that seemingly held back the fates. I can almost groan about trying to assess the qualitative data now...
[1] http://www.amazon.com/New-Ideas-Dead-Economists-Introduction...
Most notably, his points about hiring "the best people" (around 20 minutes in) are extremely similar to the notes in the leaked Valve employee handbook on hiring, and the old Jobs quote about "A+ players." For everyone seeking a position somewhere in the industry, the emphasis placed on this element of business is really telling; good people at amazing companies don't want just another guy who can code in C++/Java/D-/ChaiTeaLatte, they want individuals with strengths in all aspects of engineering and business. Thanks for the link, and if Drew still reads HN even though he's in the big time, thanks for the talk and indirect educational advice.