HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jlbnjmn

474 karma · joined March 27, 2020

submissionscomments
jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
I like to think incentives matter, always have and always will.

TV had "viewers", but how many were changing the channel during commercials?

Newspapers had "circulation", but how many were sitting in hotel hallways or mulching on driveways?

Direct mail had "addresses", but how many of those were left on the side of the road or tossed straight into the trash?

Radio had "listeners", but nobody believed those numbers anyway.

Etc.

Speaking of, by far the most popular "videos" on YouTube are music videos. How many of their so-called watch time metrics are actually people listening to music while they work? For me that's several hours a day.

So yeah, the crazy thing to me is how poor of a job our society has done at teaching people how to think for themselves.

INCENTIVES MATTER!

jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
Ah, I see what you're saying. Yes, you're exactly right.

Brand advertising has a much higher ROAS when done well. The challenge is doing it well, and knowing if you did. My experience has been that SMEs rarely have the appreciation for art necessary to do branding well, and without strong branding, brand campaigns are a waste of money.

And it's not just a lack money. They'd rather spend the money on ads than on people. In some industries, that's a better strategy, but for most they would benefit greatly from recognizing that all customers, both B2B and B2C, are in fact humans.

Founders have an advantage here, because they can operate on a longer time scale.

(Side note, GM spent $3140000000 on ads in 2018.)

jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
Because cable advertising sales reps take you out to lunch, give you box seat tickets to NFL games, and create all of your reports for you. Which is even easier.

Also, some people measure their self worth on the size of their company's ad budget. And those same people tend to have stupid amounts of money compared to their childhood peer groups.

So buying ads is like adding a set of metal balls to a truck hitch. Revenue was never the point.

Also, a lot of entrepreneurs have short attention spans and constantly change things out of fear, taking it from easy to do well to impossible to know.

jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
> Never underestimate how so much of bad advertising is because of clueless people in the chain of command.

Hello fellow person with in-house advertising experience.

jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
A lot of people use Google to find things. A lot of those people click the first search result that matches what they're looking for (low cost, certain feature, prestige, there's no right answer, just right answer for them).

Some of those clicks are for products and services with short buying/lead gen cycles. Once they've clicked, many are only going back if they don't like what they find.

The value of search ads is being the link they clicked. You can buy that click. You can literally insert your website into a demand/supply match. If you don't mess it up after they click, those clicks become transactions. In dollars.

Oil changes are a great example. Some of the people who type "oil change near me" in maps don't really care about the brand. They click the top result, schedule an appointment, and get their oil changed.

If the click was $3 and it took 10 people/bots clicking to set one appointment, that's $30. Now let's say the oil change is $39 so profit is ($39 - oil $7, - filter $3, - labor $5, - ads $30) = -$6 before the cost of skilled advertiser.

Are those ads profitable? It depends. If you can upsell 1/10 on replacing a cabin air filter for 10x cost, then yes.

Every other upsell becomes profit.

Also, at a car dealership you can sell 3-5% a car while they're there for a nice $1700-$3200 profit, which nicely covers the cost of the skilled advertiser.

jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
> The problem is that the outcome of some campaigns doesn't reflect in dollars, and still you have a winning campaign.

All winning campaigns reflect in dollars. The question is when. That's why it's imperative to separate markets entirely.

Radio ads for a "branding/awareness" strategy. Search ads for a direct response strategy. The majority of people viewing/hearing one should never hear/view the other.

If it takes 6 months to properly test a branding campaign, decide ahead of time whether your organization has the patience to wait. If not, just stick with direct response.

Also, Scientific Advertising was written in 1923.

jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
Running ads is like running a VC fund.

95% of your money is wasted, but if you do it right, that last 5% makes up for it.

jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
I bought Adidas...at Costco.
jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
I dislike ads and ad platforms as much as the next person.

But this isn't good journalism.

"Is online advertising working? We simply don’t know"

In study 5 (e-commerce) the answer was clear, and yet ignored.

Is there a bubble? Yes. Are ads magic? No. Do they work? For the right products, yes. Extremely well.

jlbnjmn··on The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019)
A copy of Scientific Advertising and some thinking are about all that's needed to do the job well.

There are essentially 4 rules for effective advertising:

1) ignore all metrics from online platforms (especially the ones that sell ads)

2) ignore all metrics from ad agencies

3) run tests that make sense*

4) measure in dollars

The hard part is convincing the founder/owner to stop messing with stuff long enough that you can actually measure the results. Also, companies tend to way overspend on ads and data scientists while underspending on skilled advertisers. (They can be forgiven for the latter, there are too few skilled advertisers, and lousy advertisers usually sell themselves as experts.)

*Example: your job is to advertise a business with 20 locations in 2 cities. You want to know if radio ads are better than search ads. So you do the obvious thing: buy radio ads in city A and search ads in city B, then compare sales. If the difference in sales is big enough that managers get defensive and start pointing out why the test wasn't valid, you may have a winner. Run it in both cities and see if it still works.

(Rule of thumb: if nobody is upset with the outcome, the variations were too similar. Run bigger tests.)

jlbnjmn··on Show HN: Estimate how much to charge for your SaaS side project
Love the UI, not the logic.

Supply based pricing is a poor communicator of value.

Substitute the cost to the founder with the cost of a substitute for the customer.

Example: I have a side project that takes me an hour or so each month but saves my clients $400/month.

Should I charge the $2/mo the calculator recommends or the $99/mo that I'm currently charging?

Every click costs Google essentially the same, so why charge 10x as much for the search "apartments for rent near me" than the search "knitting pattern for dog sweater"?

Again, love the UI!

jlbnjmn··on Citing revenue declines, Airbnb cuts 25% of workforce
In Germany, if an employee gets laid off after 2 years, they would get 50% monthly salary times number of years worked, so 1 months pay.

That means the Airbnb severance package is equivalent to a 6+ year employee, for every employee getting laid off.

That's generous by German standards, isn't it?

Then when you consider the median income for a software engineer in Germany is $54k, whereas in the USA it's $92k, and at Airbnb it's $200k+, that means that an engineer being laid off from Airbnb could be receiving the median annual income of a software engineer in Germany as severance, not including stock.

That, to me, is generous.

https://www.howtogermany.com/pages/termination-employment-co...

jlbnjmn··on Citing revenue declines, Airbnb cuts 25% of workforce
After rereading the article, it appears the layoffs are isolated to side projects. So it looks like just a healthy focus on the actual business.

And for everyone previously asking why they needed so many employees, the answer is apparently they didn't.

jlbnjmn··on Citing revenue declines, Airbnb cuts 25% of workforce
Good point. If they're wanting to part ways with 25% of the workforce now, covering 3 months of full salary and 12 months of expensive healthcare, they must be expecting fundamental market shifts.

Also, the debt they took on may have been partly to cover these lavish severance packages while also extending the runway.

And yes, this is extremely lavish. Paying severance that appears roughly equal to the median annual income in the USA.

jlbnjmn··on We are complicit in our employer’s deeds
A decade of it working is a success! It doesn't have to last forever to have been a great benefit to many people.
jlbnjmn··on We are complicit in our employer’s deeds
Well written, I agree.

I've been thinking a lot lately about two different aspects of this same problem.

We are complicit in our vendor's deeds. If businesses stopped buying ads and server time from these companies, the situation would change rapidly.

We are complicit in our entertainer's deeds. If individuals stopped viewing or engaging with content on these platforms, especially paid content, the situation would change rapidly.

What's someone with a 7-digit annual ad spend to do? (Avoiding social ads is easy, search ads are harder to replace.)

jlbnjmn··on Extremely disillusioned with technology. Please help
Plenty of remote therapists available.
jlbnjmn··on The housing market faces its next crisis as May rent and mortgages come due
Also, many of the lost jobs are in consumption and service industries. I'm not going to get extra haircuts, eat extra meals, or drive extra miles.

So business owners and workers in those industries aren't going to catch up.

jlbnjmn··on I sold $104,754 worth of videos and PDFs in 4 months
What does "where people interested in that topic generally hang around" mean?

And what counts as interesting?

jlbnjmn··on Ask HN: Any open-source projects need help?
Nice! Thanks for the tip. This could be a good fit. I'll try exporting my stranded Evernotes and see how it goes.
jlbnjmn··on Bye, Amazon
Here are a couple to get you started:

https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2011/c...

https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/research-summaries/education...

jlbnjmn··on I sold $104,754 worth of videos and PDFs in 4 months
If you were given a brand new Twitter account and had to grow it 1,000 real subscribers without using your existing brand, how long would it take you and why?

Oh, and no developer or social/digital media topics allowed.

jlbnjmn··on The inevitable has happened
Yeah, the shady/deceptive/misleading/false pricing you mentioned is foolish. ("Free delivery"* after undisclosed $10 platform fee and $4 processing fee.)

Destroying tech industry reputations and eroding trust is not a good long term play.

It's no better than infomercials touting free products with "just pay shipping and handling". Same sleaze, different generation.

jlbnjmn··on Ask HN: Any open-source projects need help?
Yes, this. I was doing local networking in February and March but that ended abruptly.

Switching to online for the time being.

jlbnjmn··on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (May 2020)
Quidsentio is a beautiful site! Cool concept, love the design, very well written.

Do you have experience with building comprehensive business intelligence dashboards?

jlbnjmn··on Ask HN: Any open-source projects need help?
Thanks for replying! I'll check it out.
jlbnjmn··on Ask HN: Any open-source projects need help?
Thanks for asking! I'm especially interested in appropriate technology and social enterprise stuff, so projects that help users and the economy.

Python is my preferred language.

Also happy to help with docs, copywriting, or websites.

jlbnjmn··on Failed SaaS post-mortem: validate your pricing model like I didn't
Software that provides a service to users.
jlbnjmn··on Failed SaaS post-mortem: validate your pricing model like I didn't
Well said. I saved this for future reflection. Thanks!
jlbnjmn··on It's Time to Build for Good
Institutions are groups of people with rules. People not following rules will ruin any form of governance, public or private.

The best way to improve any group of people is by being an example.

Thank you for your exemplary insight.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →