HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jlgbecom

318 karma · joined August 11, 2010

submissionscomments
jlgbecom··on Security Lessons Learned From The Diaspora Launch
There are a lot of lessons to be learned from Diaspora, beyond the (brilliant) points made about security.

1. When media hype provides you with $200k, you're still best served by bringing people's expectations down to earth. There was no way they were going to be able to build anything approaching a Facebook killer in 3 months, and it would have been best if they would have made that clear in the beginning.

2. There are a number of projects like Diaspora that have been working for years towards the same exact goal. The only way Diaspora could have succeeded where those have failed (or not-yet-succeeded), is if they had properly articulated where they would go right where others had gone wrong. If you can't do that, you probably don't have the perspective necessary to take on such a huge project.

3. We all need to be less susceptible to the story of the "boy wonders" taking on the establishment. Between Diaspora and Haystack+, these should be sobering lessons about the dangers of hype and a good human-interest story when the result we need is stable, well-written code.

+ http://blog.jgc.org/2010/09/myth-of-boy-wizard.html

4. Open source isn't magic. Rails isn't magic. Having a good idea and a whole lot of heart isn't magic. It's true that the software world isn't exactly a meritocracy, but at the same time, we need to recognize that you have to be able to build something generally usable, and if you can't, there's nothing that will save you except for harder work and learned lessons. Some bugs will be fixed by the interest in Diaspora, but there are big architecture questions here that need to be resolved, and coordinating that democratically through the internet in a sea of strangers is a logistical nightmare. And while rails does provide a lot of functionality out-of-the-box, a project of this size isn't held up by how long it takes to write the photo-uploading code, it's held up by the big-picture stuff that rails can't really help you with. In the end, programming is programming. You need specs, mockups, user stories, documentation, all kinds of unsexy stuff.

I think we'll probably see Diaspora stabilize into something usable at some point. But I'm very doubtful that will be anytime soon, and I'm especially doubtful that it will be before the other projects (Elgg, Appleseed, OneSocialWeb, StatusNet, etc) mature into the facebook killer people want to see.

Building the kind of open source social networking software necessary to take on Facebook at it's own game is such a massive, complex undertaking, and it's such undiscovered territory, that there really is a big disadvantage to being the new kid on the block.

jlgbecom··on Security Lessons Learned From The Diaspora Launch
I've always thought it would make more sense for CS degrees to be for computer scientists (ie, people who want to do more high-level theoretical work), and that software development was more of a trade school, where you learned the languages, and were soon thrown into real-world style projects and apprenticeships.

Imagine if your nurse came out of college having never stepped foot into a hospital, having only read about how to take vitals and such, but never having done it on a live human being.

jlgbecom··on Why Our Schools Suck, The Movie
The most successful schools in the world are in Finland, Americans need to look at their model, put aside our prejudices, and adopt it's best practices.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB120425355065601997.html

jlgbecom··on Trouble with Diaspora
There's a ton of them, and they're all pretty mature. I'm hoping this does have a windfall effect on the ones that have already proven themselves from a code standpoint, and could use the hype that Diaspora has

http://opensource.appleseedproject.org

http://www.onesocialweb.org

http://www.gnu.org/software/social

http://www.elgg.org

jlgbecom··on Trouble with Diaspora
My guess is that the startups get VC funding, and then they hire professionals who take it from there. The "wonder boys" that started it are mostly just figureheads at that point.
jlgbecom··on Why vertical farms are a crock.
No soil.
jlgbecom··on Why vertical farms are a crock.
Using grow lights 100% of the time? No, that's definitely not going to work, unless major gains in efficiency are made. But using led grow lights to supplement passive solar and elongate the grow cycle is what I'm referring to, and designing low-rise greenhouses to capture the sun's energy for the light hours. If you capture excess solar energy, store it, and use it at night, then the energy pull from the grid for night-time grow lights is reduced, and then it's an economic question of cost of energy versus sale potential.

I'm not specifically thinking about staple crops (ie, wheat, rice, etc), but supplementary crops like tomatos, lettuce, cucumbers, etc. Mostly, what Thanet Earth is growing.

jlgbecom··on Trouble with Diaspora
Even asking for $10,000 was major hubris that made me skeptical they were up to the task. But they could have been more honest about their capabilities, timeline, roadmap, etc. in order to put things into perspective and bring the hype down a notch. They most definitely over-promised, even if they had only received the original $10k
jlgbecom··on Why vertical farms are a crock.
Vertical farms are kind of a crock, kind of. The idea of indoor agriculture is not, however (just look at Thanet Earth), and there is an advantage of building up a few floors and using grow lights to supplement the loss of passive lighting.

A series of low-rise warehouses using hydroponics in the outer rings of a city makes a lot of sense.

However, the architectural games people are playing with huge spires in the center of Manhattan, those are ridiculous, and always have been.

jlgbecom··on Trouble with Diaspora
Momentum can die as fast as it builds, while maturity is lasting. All these projects are in active development, and it'll be very difficult for Diaspora to catch up.
jlgbecom··on Trouble with Diaspora
And more importantly, if you're going to rewrite, why help Diaspora, and not a more mature option?
jlgbecom··on Trouble with Diaspora
They could have saved themselves some grief if they didn't over-promise in order to get money for a project before they had a single line of code.
jlgbecom··on Code for open-source Facebook riddled with landmines
At first, I thought those comments were a CYA distancing from Diaspora, since their release has been so abysmal, but then I watched their presentation to Pivotal again, and it really does seem like everyone there knew about as much about Diaspora as we all did on Sep 14th.
jlgbecom··on Code for open-source Facebook riddled with landmines
If anyone thinks that, they would be best served talking to the Joomla or Drupal (or any other popular, large-scale, user-facing, and general purpose open source project out there) and get their perspective on how that actually works out in reality.

I know we have this sense that open source software development is one big happy stone soup where everybody pitches in, but at some point, people have to make architectural and system design decisions and map out a direction in order to make any sense of those changes.

In other words, "many eyeballs" don't make all bugs shallow, they make them more noticeable. Which in Diaspora's case, is more of a problem than a benefit.

jlgbecom··on Code for open-source Facebook riddled with landmines
No matter how many programmers this attracts or momentum the project has, if the underlying software design is bad, people need to either do a rewrite with a better design, or make a patchwork mess of it all until it becomes unmanageable, in which case you do the rewrite you should have done in the first place.

The problem is, there's a lot of eyeballs that are looking at the code right now, and that does help to identify bugs, but if the bugs we're seeing are deep seated architectural issues, then it's not very easy for someone to just go in and fix them. Then Diaspora has to determine if the fixes are worth including, and whether they fit into their system design (assuming they have one). Basically, in order to actually utilize the community interest in any practical way, they need to be solid managers. At 20 years old, with no real world software development experience.

This is something open source doesn't seem to understand, and why even the biggest projects end up being a small-ish team of dedicated professionals, instead of the "bazaar" we imagine.

jlgbecom··on Code for open-source Facebook riddled with landmines
When did Facebook release an open source version? And where is it, if they did?
jlgbecom··on Introducing the Go Playground
I've been really excited about Go, but I've been stuck in one of those dilemmas where I don't really learn a language until I work on a tangible project with it, and I can't seem to come up with anything I need to write in Go.

I'm sure something will surface eventually, and I hope soon, because everything about Go makes me very excited about programming.

jlgbecom··on Public Diaspora Seed is up, but buggy.
As far as I can tell, there isn't even an admin interface for administrators to remove your account from Diaspora.
jlgbecom··on Diaspora Revealed: Sparse, But Clean; Source Code Released
PHP caught on because it was the right hammer for all the nails people had. It wasn't marketing and hype, but momentum.

Open source projects may have to market themselves as well, but that doesn't mean the more savvy amongst us have to get swept up with the crowd.

jlgbecom··on How Reddit Kicked Digg’s Ass
I used to read digg way back when, but someone alerted me to the whole situation and I watched it crumble, and it was... spectacular. It was like a cyberpunk novel. People didn't just move to reddit, they moved to reddit, and then salted the earth behind them.
jlgbecom··on Diaspora Revealed: Sparse, But Clean; Source Code Released
Why do they deserve attention? Because they have better, more mature code-bases and more experienced programmers developing them. Other than publicity, what does Diaspora have going for it, and why do they deserve attention just because of their marketing? This is open source we're talking about, not startup companies, and open source works best when it's meritocratic. And if we're talking about which open source project to build a startup with, then we're talking about merit, nothing else.
jlgbecom··on Diaspora Revealed: Sparse, But Clean; Source Code Released
Other open source social networking projects:

Appleseed (http://opensource.appleseedproject.org) Elgg (http://elgg.com) OneSocialWeb (http://onesocialweb.org)

I realize everyone's hyped up about Diaspora, but we have a long haul before we have anything usable by the general public, and there are projects that are much farther along that deserve attention.

jlgbecom··on Diaspora Developer Release
Appleseed and Elgg are both in PHP, if you're looking to help out with an open source social networking project.
jlgbecom··on Diaspora Developer Release
There are a bunch of open source social networking projects out there. One is Appleseed, which has been in active development since 2004, open source since 2005, and has had four releases in the past 3 months.

http://opensource.appleseedproject.org

For all the attention Diaspora is getting, the other projects will be usable by average users way before they will.

jlgbecom··on Self-Control Matters Far More Than Raw Intelligence
That's the best way to come up with ideas. But at some point you have to implement them, and that's where discipline comes in.
jlgbecom··on Self-Control Matters Far More Than Raw Intelligence
I would add that genius is more defined by an extreme tenacity than intelligence.
jlgbecom··on Revolution OS [video]
Wow, ESR. Haven't heard from him in a while.

Someone should write an updated counter-point to the cathedral and the bazaar. A lot of it's theories seem dated nowadays.

jlgbecom··on Ask HN: What makes a programming language 'hard'?
Consistency can be an issue, languages which break from standards, or even what you're used to can be difficult. I grew up on C/C++, and it was the first real language I learned, so anything in that realm (Java, PHP, Perl, etc) is like riding a bike. For that same reason, Ruby was kinda hard to grok for me.

But I think documentation (books, available source code, tutorials) is the biggest issue. Finding a practical PHP or Ruby tutorial is way easier than a Scala or LISP one. I'm the kind of person who learns by reading other people's code, so I've never been interested in the more obscure languages because of that.

jlgbecom··on Reddit ‘excited’ about chance to eat Digg’s lunch
It's not usability that has turned people off, it's the change in underlying functionality. It's no longer a community site.

People can get used to UI changes, even radical ones. But fundamentally changing the way people interact with a site (and the value of that interaction) will guarantee that people will leave in droves.

jlgbecom··on Reddit ‘excited’ about chance to eat Digg’s lunch
I feel like there's a lesson for the companies operating within the social web here somewhere. I don't know, something like "if your business model is based on making your users happy, don't make crassly commercial usability shifts that make them really unhappy." Can't quite put my finger on it, though.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →