HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jmj42

718 karma · joined June 30, 2011

submissionscomments
jmj42··on When "What Do You Do?" Is Taboo
Agreed. I've had down times (a certain financial disaster and a silicon valley startup comes to mind), and friends and family were there to give us the support, financially and emotionally, we needed to get back on our feet.

If I have the means, I never hesitate to help a friend or family member in need, and rarely ask for anything in return, I would never ask for interest, and rarely even place any expectations on such a loan. "Pay me what you can, when you can," is common terms of repayment for loans such as these.

jmj42··on USPS Discrimination Against Atheism?
I live in IL, and have had exactly 0 USPS packages go missing. In fact, I take the opposite stance. I prefer USPS, both when receiving and when sending.
jmj42··on Python.org Redesign Preview
Completely unrelated, but I love the "certain pink rock" phrase.
jmj42··on Procrastination is Not Laziness
I disagree as well. My reasons for procrastination tend to fall around artificially creating a high stress situation. You see, I perform very well (very high productivity) under stress, to the extent that high performance may actually be a stress coping mechanism for stress.

I certainly do not procrastinate because I'm lazy, or have poor work ethic, or even risk averse. You can ask my family about that one. None of them would describe me as risk averse.

For me, it really comes down to stress as a motivator. Procrastination means doing things at the last moment, which creates an artificially stressful situation.

It may also be interesting to note that I do not suffer from any traditional high stress related health issues. My doctor recently commented that I am in exceptional health for my age (mid-thirties)

jmj42··on White House Response to “Make Unlocking Cell Phones Legal”
The same reason you pay sales tax on a car you finance. Just because you are paying for the phone over 2 years does not mean that you get to defer sales tax.
jmj42··on The Extraordinary Science of Addictive Junk Food
I've not found it difficult to get my kids (2 teenage daughters) to consistently eat healthy foods. Hell, we can't keep fresh fruits and vegetables in the house. A one pound bag of baby carrots lasts about a week, one pound bunch of bananas: about 3 days, a pint of blue berries: About an hour (blue berries never last long at our house). The list goes on, but that's not the point.

I don't think it's really a responsibility thing. I don't know any parent that _want_ their kids eating junk, but fresh fruit and vegetables are actually quite expensive and far more difficult to keep than your average junk snack. That's the hard part: justifying the higher cost and spoilage when you're just barely making the bills.

Most of my childhood was spent right at the government assistance threshold. During the down times, our health increased, and our dit included more fresh fruit and vegetables. During the times above that line, with no assistance, the high cost of fresh produce meant meant that it wasn't around.

So, to answer your question, "Why aren't parents more responsible for their children's health?" Because they can't afford to be. Though there are many factors that contribute to the obesity problem, claiming it's poor parental responsibility is a useless over-simplification.

Btw, I've been parenting for 18 years now. When is it supposed to get hard?

jmj42··on Obama Calls for Patent Reform to Topple Trolls
> As a university, they have no business being in the medical products business.

Why? While this line of reasoning might carry some weight if Northwestern were a public university (though I'd still require some convincing), Northwestern is a private non-profit institution, with a highly ranked medical school and clinic.

Supplementing their income with drug sales instead of higher tuition seem like a perfectly logical thing to do.

jmj42··on Linux can now run on UEFI Windows 8 PCs
I believe the Windows 8 certification _requires_ that the user be able to disable secure boot on x86.
jmj42··on It could happen to you too
I'm not sure the fees are _necessarily_ useless. Banking is a service, and services cost money to provide. I suppose an argument can be made that the fees are higher than they need to be, but then, banks aren't non-profit entities either.

As for me, I've been a Chase customer since 2004 when they merged with Bank One, and a Bank One customer since 1990. I've tried a few local and regional banks, and brief stint with BOA as Bank One didn't have any branches in San Jose circa 2002. I've been quite happy with my Bank One/Chase experience to date. Far more than any other bank if tried.

jmj42··on When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber?
Maybe, but no joy getting state wide franchising in Illinois. In fact, 65 ILCS 5 (Illinois Municipal Code) Section 11-42-11 specifically grants municipalities under 2M people (i.e. the entire state except Chicago) the authority to negotiate and execute CATV franchises.
jmj42··on When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber?
Fun anecdote: Both my home town (Pop. 6,000, central Illinois) as well as my work town (Urbana, IL; Pop. 41,000) have actually had recent success using this line of reasoning. In both cases the cities were looking for improvements in the public access facilities provided by their respective cable providers (Mediacom/Comcast). Urbana had a slightly longer fight, but in the end, both cable companies caved.

It was Urbana's fight in which I came to understand the power of that one bargaining chip and that cable contract negotiations really are weighted in favor of the municipality.

jmj42··on When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber?
> There's zero reason these fat profiteers are still protected businesses. They're simply parasites on the networks the taxpayers paid for.

It's interesting that you should mention this. Most cities actually sign contracts with service providers. The contract grants the provider access to easements and, generally, exclusivity for the type of service (i.e. only one cable provider/local telephone carrier) allowed to operate in the city).

Convincing providers to bump up speeds and lower costs is going to require cities to kill the exclusivity clause, and encourage competition. Alternatively, allow the cable provider to retain exclusivity, but require fiber upgrades.

This kind of tactic may work better in smaller towns, like mine (Pop. 6000) as residents have very direct access to their city officials, but it's one approach that may work.

jmj42··on Systemd: The Biggest Myths
Very true, and, to be honest, I'm not advocating for systemd. Though according to the original article this isn't quite the issue that it's claimed to be (I'm not actually familiar enough with systemd to be able to have an opinion on it), see point 20.

My assessment on the systemd debate, though, is that it feels a bit like neophobia and the technical justifications (against systemd) are a bit on the weak side.

jmj42··on Systemd: The Biggest Myths
> but given that developer time is a bounded resource, we can't really expect to get both fewer restarts and faster restarts.

Your're going to have to clarify, as this statement doesn't make any sense.

You're right though. In this instance, system startup was already highly optimized. In fact, the order of startup was shifted around to get Oracle (the DB in this example) up and operational as early as possible.

On the other hand, with the introduction of SMF, that "need to optimise" largely went away. Sure, SMF didn't make much a difference in this particular instance, but parallelisation does make a difference when you're talking about total system (not service) startup time. Further it can make a difference on system that run multiple services. If 5 services have the same dependency set, then a parallel startup means that services 2-5 become available earlier versus a linear startup.

Finally, shaving 5 seconds off of service startup _does_ make a difference. While the above example means $350, there's a few things to consider.

1) a $350 loss is stil a loss. From a business perspective, a loss, no matter how small, is still to be avoided. There's other considerations as well, such as the impact of the extra 5 seconds on my budget (the SLAs mean that the loss comes out of my budget).

2) In the realm of big enterprise, this is a relatively small outage cost. In fact, I've managed system with an order of magnitude larger failure cost (SLAs are bitch).

3) It's difficult to factor soft costs. Things such as customer confidence, indirect productivity loss, etc. 5 seconds, again, means services are available sooner, lessening the impact of these soft, and difficult to quantify, costs.

jmj42··on Systemd: The Biggest Myths
> The goal should be to restart less often, not to restart more quickly.

No! These are not mutually exclusive. The goal should be to restart less ofter, but restart faster when it is necessary. Systems have to restart. Well run/maintained/designed systems may not need to restart ofter, but they do need to restart.

Consider: Many moons ago I was responsible for (among other things) the company's CRM systems. These were a couple of mid-range Suns that were extremely reliable. On an anual basis, the business operations department issues downdown cost estimates for business critical systems (these were used to develop inter-departmental SLAs), and estimated that the CRM database server cost the company about $250K per hour of down time, or, almost $4200 per minute. Or read another way: a 10 seat license for our software in a saturated (niche) market.

The point is, outages happen (no you can not account for all possible failure scenarios), and startup times matter.

jmj42··on Hugh Laurie: Wodehouse Saved my Life (1999)
Interestingly, I was introduced to Hugh Laurie by way of Blackadder.

When I wan in high school our local public television satiation (WILL) would run episodes of several 1970s and 80s british sitcoms. Among them were Blackadder, Are you being Served? and Fawlty Towers.

jmj42··on University of Wisconsin to offer degrees based on tested ability
But that can still be part of the credentialing process. Consider the medical field. A medical degree is only small part of the credentialing process. In addition, you'll usually need an internship, a residency, then board certification (optional).

Even at the low end of the medical field, here in Illinois, EMT-I and EMT-P (paramedic) require both clinic time and a practical (live simulation) exam.

You simply implement something similar for engineering.

jmj42··on Unlocking Cellphones Becomes Illegal Saturday in the U.S.
> At the very least, AT&T should be able to sue you for the breach of contract and get their $350 back.

That's exactly what they do, except that a lawsuit isn't necessary. It's already part of the contract. Specifically, AT&T charges $350 - ($10 * <number of months used>).

And, I agree, that's actually quite fair.

http://www.wireless.att.com/learn/articles-resources/early-t...

Edit: Added link to AT&T termination fees

jmj42··on School district builds own software to handle student data, defies doubters
See below. The accounting problem is a far greater challenge that security. Interestingly school information systems are notoriously bad at security, so hitting par won't actually be that hard. Accurate accounting may be a huge challenge, though.

Either way, mentoring would be key, and no system developed vy students should be allowed into production at a scholl without a complete review. But that that's part of the process. Even in a private company/OSS project, code shouldn't be allowed into production without a review. I do have access to many people with the right skill set to be able to develop such a system on their own (my self included) in addition to the fact that I work for an information security research institution, so I have access to folks who know a whole lot more about trusted systems than I.

Of course, HS students will make mistakes, but the mentors will be there to review the work, and make suggestions, while keeping "bad code" from hitting a production system.

In the end, I'm not sure that I'm convinced that a student developed system is any different from one developed by some outside company.

jmj42··on School district builds own software to handle student data, defies doubters
I've actually thought of proposing such a project for our school district. I'm not sure what we pay our current software, bu my thought was to develop a summer STEM program and give HS students the opportunity to participate is a real project with real consequences, etc.

Many of the school people (administrators/teachers) were very unhappy with the previous system, so I expected it to be a reasonably easy sale. Unfortunately I didn't have the necessary free time to pursue it much further than "thought experiment." Since, the school district has purchased a new system that school officials actually like.

That said, our school district (like most in Illinois) is facing some serious budget crunch due to the state failing to make payment on time (or at all), so maybe it's time to dial up this project again, and pitch it to the school board.

jmj42··on Ill-founded arguments about grammar
But language _is_ an arbitrary construct subject wholly to societal agreement. That's why language evolves over time, why different dialects of a given language develop, etc.

Edit: Spelling

jmj42··on The Headphones Rule
>I can appreciate individuals who don't have the capacity to swap context throughout the day, but only when they can be mature enough to explain themselves to me like an adult...

But even that is a context switch, and context switching is expensive. Your 30 second interruption results in 15 minutes of lost productivity (these are just made up numbers). A passive signal that you are not to be disturbed at this time sends the same message without the context switch or, more important, the need to switch back into the work.

For me, there's no workplace behavior more obnoxious than someone walking up to my desk and blabbing on about something while I'm in the middle of a critical section of code or on the verge of a breakthrough (these are the cases when I'm usually wearing headphones). Headphones, at the very least, signal that you should get my attention before speaking, and that I'll be with you in a moment because I can't afford an immediate context switch for your "problem."

Edit: Spelling

jmj42··on The Headphones Rule
i do this a lot too, specifically because it signals that I'm busy. I generally enforce the headphone rule, and even when not listening to something, the fact that it signals that I'm not to be disturbed is exceptionally useful.
jmj42··on Lego Goes Linux
She is. I'm of the opinion that you can never start early enough. My daughters (I have 2) have been playing with "engineering toys" since about age 3. One latched onto engineering big time (see above) and, at 12 years old, has even selected her preferred universities (in order: MIT; UMich; UIUC; CMU)

edit: grammer

jmj42··on Lego Goes Linux
Yup, familiar with the program. I actually spoke with the STEM outreach director for our middle school about a year ago. She was interested, but school policies would have made it difficult to get an FLL team up and running (she had looked into it in the past).

I may take another stab at an FRC or FTC team next year as I now know (personally) the chairman of the school board. He's an engineering prof/researcher at UIUC so I expect it to be a fairly easy sell, and as a school board member, may be able to "grease the wheels" a little.

jmj42··on Lego Goes Linux
I did! My youngest daughter (12) has an interest in robotics, so the excuse was perfect. I've played with the NXT kit as much as she has, and we're already talking about getting an EV3 kit for her birthday. (I'm excited).
jmj42··on How to quit your job: An Employers opinion
Actually, I found both of those suggestions to be perfectly reasonable. I try to shoot for 4 weeks when giving notice. If my employer doesn't want me hanging around that long, see point 3. Note: I've never been contractually obligated to give any notice.

As for feed back, the fact is, you're leaving for a reason. You're, so to be, former employer really is, generally, interested in the reasons for your decision. Especially if it's "I don't like being managed by person X." Sometimes it's just an isolated personality conflict, often, though, there's bigger issues and your employeer isn't interested in loosing more good employees due to poor management.

I've also been in a situation where one of the reasons was "I don't like being managed by person X," and conveying that in a polite, non-judgmental, way wasn't difficult. While my exit interview was with that manager, I also requested a meeting with the CEO (small startup, so it really just a matter of "Hey, <CEO>, can we do a one-on-one before I leave).

In fact, I would argue that the most important point on this list is the one about feedback.

jmj42··on Lego Finds Discontinued Set For Boy Who Saved Up For 2 Years
I agree. We bought a mindstorms kit for me daughter a year ago (she has engineering aspirations).

I have to confess, I've had as much fun with it as she has.

jmj42··on Auto Dealers Whine That Tesla Stores Are Illegal
>What they are scared of is that Tesla sets a precedence for other manufacturers to follow suit which would then put a lot of people out of work.

No. What they're afraid of is that Tesla sets a precedence for other manufacturers to follow suit which would then move revenue out of the dealer's reach. Or: It's not about jobs, it's about money.

jmj42··on How to tear down the walls of your echo chamber
I can't up vote this enough. Things from _way_ outside of my confort zone, just from the last week due to my kids (I have 2 teenage girls):

Coaching Softball (I generally dislike base/softball) Sewing Marathon training teenage interpersonal relationships

Kids are great for new experiences. Especially if you encourage _them_ to take on new experiences, invariably you will also get to experience new things.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →