HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

johnecheck

466 karma · joined September 8, 2024

Game Dev (https://stargamb.it)

Sucker for epistemology, systems, and languages.

@7hird.dev

submissionscomments
johnecheck··on The Death of the Middle-Class Musician
Only tiny fraction of a billionaire's wealth tends to be the fruit of their personal labor. It's the labor of their employees and machines that create the wealth. To my understanding, this is broadly accepted.

Now, billionaires do supply a different key ingredient to the wealth creation - risk. Without investment and risk, wealth cannot be created. In terms of $ investment, billionaires take on the vast majority of the risk and deserve the bulk of the rewards, the argument goes. Workers take on far less risk with their guaranteed* paycheck .

But which is the bigger risk? A billionaire's $100,000,000? Or your home, your health, and your retirement savings were you to lose your job in a bad market?

I'm interested in company structures that incentivize distributing risk, profit, and power across a larger group than we tend to see in modern companies.

johnecheck··on Show HN: I'm building an app to replace Overleaf and Notion
Looks cool, though it sadly isn't the open-source notion/obsidian competitor I've been waiting for.

Also, your images and carousel element don't look right on android Firefox

https://imgur.com/a/kOfPYea

johnecheck··on Seven replies to the viral Apple reasoning paper and why they fall short
Because that would prove absolutely nothing. There are numerous examples of tower of Hanoi explanations in the training set.
johnecheck··on Meta Invests $14.3B in Scale AI to Kick-Start Superintelligence Lab
I use Messenger but not Facebook. There's a big "Ask Meta AI or Search" bar at the top of the app's main page.
johnecheck··on OpenAI o3-pro
OpenAI started strong in the naming department (ChatGPT, DALL-E) then fell off so hard since.
johnecheck··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
That was a pretty funny little maneuver from Google.

Google: Look at our new chatbot! It's called Bard, and it's going to blow ChatGPT out of the water!

Bard: Hallucinates JWST achievements when prompted for an ad.

Google: Doesn't fact check, posts the ad

Alphabet stock price: Drops 16% in a week

Google: Look at our new chatbot! It's called Gemini, and it's going to blow ChatGPT out of the water!

johnecheck··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
Oh no! I'll get left behind! I can't miss out! I need to pay $100/month to an AI company or I'll be out of a job!
johnecheck··on Human coders are still better than LLMs
Of course it can push a red button. Trivially, with MCP.

Setting up a system to make decisions autonomous is technically easy. Ensuring that it makes the right decisions, though, is a far harder task.

johnecheck··on AI: Accelerated Incompetence
That's fair. My definition is probably broader than most.
johnecheck··on AI: Accelerated Incompetence
That's fair, but don't sell them short. A 3d printed gun just killed a CEO. Ukrainian drones are using 3d printed parts to drop bombs.

Between that and the changed game for hobbyists, the world is meaningfully different.

Most world-changing inventions do so subtly. Atom bombs are the exception, not the rule.

johnecheck··on AI: Accelerated Incompetence
Great analogy. 3d printing is awesome and incredibly useful tech. Truly world changing. But injection molding is here to stay.
johnecheck··on AI: Accelerated Incompetence
Great engineers can quadruple their productivity with LMMs? Strong claim.

If their whole job is throwing together disposable demos and 1-use scripts, I could believe 4x. But in the normal case, where the senior engineer's time is mostly spent wrangling a legacy codebase into submission? I just don't see LLMs having that level of effect.

johnecheck··on AI: Accelerated Incompetence
Nonono you've got it all wrong you clearly need to try [model name] with [coding product], it 100x'd my productivity!
johnecheck··on Ask HN: Anyone struggling to get value out of coding LLMs?
"At most 3 months away"

This is a strong claim. I'm not aware of any AI model or system that can consistently and correctly make complex changes in existing codebases. What makes you so confident that you can achieve this, alone, in the next 3 months?

johnecheck··on John Carmack talk at Upper Bound 2025
You misunderstand the bitter lesson.

It's not about specialized vs generalized models - it's about how models are trained. The chess engine that beat Kasparov is a specialized model (it only plays chess), yet it's the bitter lesson's example for the smarter way to do AI.

Chess engines are better at chess than LLMs. It's not close. Perhaps eventually a superintelligence will surpass the engines, but that's far from assured.

Specialized AI are hardly obsolete and may never be. This hypothetical superintelligence may even decide not to waste resources trying to surpass the chess AI and instead use it as a tool.

johnecheck··on Writing that changed how I think about programming languages
Mmmh yes and no. Some languages truly do have more/less restrictions.

For example, a garbage collector is the compiler/runtime taking on more work to avoid the restrictions of proper memory management.

This is in some sense analogous to the C++ vs Rust debate. Borrow checking allows the compiler to statically verify whether the program is memory safe. Like statically verified types, it turns a class of undesirable runtime behavior into a compilation failure. Ofc, this is a restriction that may be undesirable, which is why you can turn it off with 'unsafe'.

Python and Java though... do you really have that much more to worry about in Java?

In my eyes, you've got your problem. Regardless of your language choice, you can write a pseudocode algorithm for it. Terms in your algorithm have types already.

When we translate this algorithm into python/Java, the types of the program need to match the types of our pseudocode. Regardless of whether we get feedback on errors at runtime or compile time, we just need to get the types right. I'd prefer my error at compile time. The benefit is tiny for short scripts, but becomes massive when working on a large code base.

What about Java (being a "systems" language) makes you worry about so much more than Python (the "scripting" language)? There are definitely differences, but I don't think they stem from this systems/scripting dichotomy that's intrinsically linked to whether you check your types at compile or run time.

johnecheck··on Writing that changed how I think about programming languages
Solutions to any given problem are necessarily described with types. You can check those types at runtime or you can check them at compile time, but meaningful programs are typed. If you've got a function that takes a string and your type system lets you run a program where you pass an int to it... did it just allow you to 'quickly iterate'? Sure, you're running a program sooner, but you're going to run into the same type error (function expects string, not int).

Maybe in a larger code base you could argue that the effort involved in satisfying typechecks meaningfully slows down iteration, but even then it's clear that being able to compute the list of type errors you introduced elsewhere (via static typing semantics/analysis) is valuable.

johnecheck··on Writing that changed how I think about programming languages
Limited experience may have been the wrong phrase. What I meant was limited perspective, given that he's writing this in 1998.
johnecheck··on Writing that changed how I think about programming languages
Hmm, I disagree with Ousterhout's dichotomy and conclusions.

First, my understanding of his points - a language is either a systems language like C or a scripting language like TCL or python. Systems language have "strong" types and are for data structures/algorithms, scripting languages are "typeless" and are for "gluing things together".

The main claim is that scripting languages are more concise and allow for faster development when gluing due to their 'typeless' nature.

In his example, he creates a button in Tcl.

button .b -text Hello! -font {Times 16} -command {puts hello}

He goes on to say:

With C++ and Microsoft Foundation Classes (MFC), it requires about 25 lines of code in three procedures. 1 Just set- ting the font requires several lines of code in MFC: CFont *fontPtr = new CFont(); fontPtr->CreateFont(16, 0, 0, 0, 700, 0, 0, 0, ANSI_CHARSET, OUT_DEFAULT_PRECIS, CLIP_DEFAULT_PRECIS, DEFAULT_QUALITY, DEFAULT_PITCH|FF_DONTCARE, “Times New Roman”); buttonPtr->SetFont(fontPtr);

Much of this code is a consequence of the strong typ- ing[...] In Tcl, the essential characteristics of the font (typeface Times, size 16 points) can be used immediately with no declarations or conversions. Furthermore, Tcl allows the button’s behavior to be included directly in the command that cre- ates the button, while C++ and Java require it to be placed in a separately declared method.

End quote.

We've come a long way, and examples have made clear that this dichotomy is a false one. Ousterhout's view was colored by his limited experience, resulting in him misunderstanding what he actually likes about Tcl.

Let's talk about syntax. His exact Tcl code as presented could be parsed and compiled by a language that does static type analysis. It's not, because he's running it in an interpreter that only checks types at runtime. But the point is that whether code is compiled or interpreted is an implementation detail that has very little to do with the syntax. He likes his syntax because his syntax is obviously better than C++, nothing more.

And types: he claims that 'typeless' languages allow for faster development because of fewer restrictions. This is, ofc, nonsense. The amount of restrictions you have is a function of your problem, not your language. If it feels like dynamic typing is letting you develop faster, that's because you're putting off encountering those restrictions til later.

It's better to guarantee we encounter all type errors before the program even runs. But since you can do static type analysis for any language, why don't all languages do that?

Because it's hard. Type theory is complicated. Not all type systems are decidable, we need to pick one that is for practical reasons. Ones that are may require annotations or complex algorithms/semantics restrictions like Hindley-Milner.

As a PL designer, it's a whole lot easier to just give up and only check types at runtime. And that makes a whole lot of sense if your priority is just embedding a usable language ASAP. But let's not pretend that it's because it's actually better.

johnecheck··on Prolog's Eternal September (2017)
This idea feels obvious enough that people must be trying it. It's probably just hard to train such a model that performs as you'd want it to.
johnecheck··on Structuring Competency-Based Courses Through Skill Trees
Modeling mastery as a set of skills to be acquired with prerequisites and requirements is clearly valuable. Visualization can serve as a map that guides learners.

Universities employ this on a larger scale - degrees require classes that require passing grades and prerequisites. I like the idea of using it for smaller-scale learning like lessons, classes, and job training.

johnecheck··on Marijuana hospital visits linked to dementia diagnosis within 5 years – a study
This is a common myth. Cannabis absolutely can cause physical dependence in frequent users. Withdrawal isn't going to kill you like alcohol might, but it's very real.

https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/marijuana-wee...

johnecheck··on Google is winning on every AI front
I'm not saying you'd be wrong to blame the bad leader - just that blaming them doesn't achieve much.

The CEO takes the blame, the board picks a new one (Unless the CEO has special shares that make them impossible to dismiss), and we go on hoping that the king isn't an idiot this time.

My reading of history is that some people are fools - we can blame them for their incompetence or we can set out to build foolproof systems. (Obviously, nothing will be truly foolproof. But we can build systems that are robust against a minority of the population being fools/defectors.)

johnecheck··on Intentionally Making Close Friends (2021)
Okay story time.

A friend in college is sitting at a bus stop. Somebody sits next to him, says "hey I like your shoes", strikes up a conversation. Ends up inviting him to a business/networking seminar.

My friend goes, comes back with a book and is saying all kinds of stuff about passive income and how you gotta take control of your finances.

I google the book name, the second result is a reddit thread about how somebody at a bus stop had their shoes complimented and then got recruited for the same thing. Turns out it was Amway.

So, yeah. 'I like your shoes' works well enough as a conversation starter that it's literally in the pyramid scheme manual.

johnecheck··on Google Is Winning on Every AI Front
If the king/ceo is great, autocracy works well.

When a fool inevitably takes the throne, disaster ensues.

I can't say for sure that a different system of government would have saved Kodak. But when one man's choices result in disaster for a massive organization, I don't blame the man. I blame the structure that laid the power to make such a mistake on his shoulders.

johnecheck··on The Dire Wolf Is Back
Spot on.

If Disneyland claimed to be helping fix world problems like biodiversity loss and climate change, that would be worth criticizing as well.

johnecheck··on The Dire Wolf Is Back
Lmao 'wealthy people bad' was definitely the substance of the critique, thank you for your valuable insight.
johnecheck··on The Dire Wolf Is Back
Agreed, engineering our environment is hardly the worst thing. But it comes with some real risks that we shouldn't take lightly.
johnecheck··on The Dire Wolf Is Back
Presumably those expenses will be a lot higher than a regular zoo, at least in the short/mid term.

I'd assume that translates to relatively costly ticket prices, right?

johnecheck··on The Dire Wolf Is Back
iPhones are very expensive.

If you own an iPhone, you're already wealthier than a large chunk of the planet.

← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →