Some criticism of the App.net project, which I hope is constructive:
It took a bit of reading between the lines, but from what I understand Dalton is trying to build a paid version of Twitter which is beholden to users and developers rather than advertisers. He refers to it as a "realtime feed platform" and is asking for $50/member/year (or more for the Developer and Pro tiers).
If that's the case, the first big question is: Would I pay $50/year for Twitter? It's hard to say for sure, but I'm not sure I would. This makes committing $50 to something that may not work out difficult – I need to be convinced of the value of this project.
The second big question is: Would everyone else pay $50/year for Twitter? Given that Twitter is only useful because of the network of people on there, if they don't come along then my $50/year is for naught even if this project does get funded. I need to be convinced that the value of the network will be there and I just don't see how that's going to happen.
The last piece of criticism is at the messaging. It's been rubbing me the wrong way and I'm not sure exactly why; I feel like when I read about it I'm being told how much I should care, but I haven't been convinced yet that I should care that much. More specifically:
"audacious proposal" - It won't happen unless the support is there, so what's so crazy about it?
"service we all wish existed" - I hadn't really been wishing for this, even though the steps Twitter has taken recently have been a bit disconcerting.
"I'm putting my money where my mouth is" - Your money? That's our money! Again, it only happens if it gets funded.
The funding doesn't seem to be moving along too quickly, so I can only assume other people have reservations about the idea, or haven't been convinced of the value. I'd be interested in knowing whether other people agree with the reasons I laid out.