HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

johnthedebs

1,656 karma · joined October 9, 2009

Software engineer & gardener, among other things

johnthedebs@gmail.com

submissionscomments
johnthedebs··on John Siracusa's OS X 10.8 Mountain Lion Review
I'd strongly recommend getting that extra 1GB if you're looking for a cheap way to boost performance (even if you have to buy 2x2GB sticks). It's not marginal by any means if your OS is swapping - it will probably be a dramatic increase in performance!

Also, regarding doctoboggan's comment about SSDs: SSDs are still an order of magnitude slower than system RAM. The reason they're so nice is because they're an order of magnitude faster than traditional HDDs, but that doesn't mean you can get away with skimping on RAM.

johnthedebs··on Fred Wilson is wrong about “Free”
Some criticism of the App.net project, which I hope is constructive:

It took a bit of reading between the lines, but from what I understand Dalton is trying to build a paid version of Twitter which is beholden to users and developers rather than advertisers. He refers to it as a "realtime feed platform" and is asking for $50/member/year (or more for the Developer and Pro tiers).

If that's the case, the first big question is: Would I pay $50/year for Twitter? It's hard to say for sure, but I'm not sure I would. This makes committing $50 to something that may not work out difficult – I need to be convinced of the value of this project.

The second big question is: Would everyone else pay $50/year for Twitter? Given that Twitter is only useful because of the network of people on there, if they don't come along then my $50/year is for naught even if this project does get funded. I need to be convinced that the value of the network will be there and I just don't see how that's going to happen.

The last piece of criticism is at the messaging. It's been rubbing me the wrong way and I'm not sure exactly why; I feel like when I read about it I'm being told how much I should care, but I haven't been convinced yet that I should care that much. More specifically:

"audacious proposal" - It won't happen unless the support is there, so what's so crazy about it?

"service we all wish existed" - I hadn't really been wishing for this, even though the steps Twitter has taken recently have been a bit disconcerting.

"I'm putting my money where my mouth is" - Your money? That's our money! Again, it only happens if it gets funded.

The funding doesn't seem to be moving along too quickly, so I can only assume other people have reservations about the idea, or haven't been convinced of the value. I'd be interested in knowing whether other people agree with the reasons I laid out.

johnthedebs··on Mozilla Firefox 14.01 release notes...
The problem that remains in Mountain Lion is that you can only use 1 display at a time when in full-screen mode.

It's better than Lion in that you will be able to choose which of your displays is used to go into full-screen mode, rather than always just using the 'main' display.

Disclaimer: I haven't actually tested in Mountain Lion, but this is the only consistent explanation I've been able to gather from careful reading of people's complaints and Apple's description of the feature change.

johnthedebs··on Mozilla Firefox 14.01 release notes...
FWIW, Mountain Lion will fix this and comes out in about a week.

It doesn't fix the fact that you're left with one (or more) useless displays in full screen mode, but it does let you choose which display to do the full screening on.

johnthedebs··on Hewlett-Packard to Cut About 30,000 Jobs (9% of workforce)
Also, morale. Remaining employees will have a hard time focusing if they're worried about losing their jobs.
johnthedebs··on New: Apply to Y Combinator without an Idea
The response to this seems mixed so I think it's worth saying: it's very important for them to at least try this.

The current YC model may have been met with the same response when first proposed (I expect it wasn't even this good, I don't know the history) but all indication is that the model works very well. And if they don't look for ways to improve further on that model, someone else may come in and eat their lunch. YC is a business too, you know.

Besides, if "execution is everything" then doesn't it make sense to not worry about the idea and focus entirely on the team? Even if it doesn't work out, I think there's no question that they should give it a shot.

johnthedebs··on Python 2.8 Un-release Schedule
For what it's worth, it was intended to be a slow transition (3-5 years) since it's a chicken/egg situation because of backwards compatibility.

The good news is that adoption should pick up very quickly after this fall. Python 3.3 will make it easier to port Python 2 projects and provide more incentives to upgrade. There's also nearly a critical percentage of major packages ported, and Django (which is still on Python 2, and is a deal breaker for many people) will have experimental support for versions up to 3.3.

I expect that by this time next year, the default for most new projects will be Python 3.

johnthedebs··on How PyPy works
For those interested in how PyPy works, I highly recommend watching these presentations by Dave Beazley about RPython:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GjnRLG8ATn4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkt_BtR9Kzk

Also, for those going, I believe he'll be talking about this in his keynote at PyCon.

johnthedebs··on Louis CK inspires Jim Gaffigan to sell comedy special for $5 online
It shows you that it's not about: price, protection, or availability. Many times it's just because people want it for free and are not willing to part with their hard-earned money.

It's entirely about price, (lack of) protection, and availability.

There will always be those who pirate it – ignore them. How do you make the most money from people willing to pay? Make it cheap, let them own it, make it easy to obtain.

johnthedebs··on Walter Isaacson’s ‘Steve Jobs’
Really, what's the problem?

If you can look past the fact that Jobs didn't kiss the customer's ass you may realize that a CEO of a Fortune 500 company was personally responding to the customer's problem in the most effective way he could at the time.

johnthedebs··on Walter Isaacson’s ‘Steve Jobs’
In my eyes there's a huge difference, they just look the same if you don't bother to listen to what he said and don't pay attention to Apple's response in the context of the way they run their business.

It wasn't a friendly response, but it was the solution to the problem. And when they only gave out cases later after complaints (announced during a special event to talk openly about this issue, after they had taken the time to look into it themselves) it was because the only problem was the media reaction. Millions and millions of people bought and loved the iPhone 4 even after they stopped giving out free cases a few months later. They all had the option of returning it for a full refund.

How many companies do you do business with that provide this level of service, big or small? I honestly can't think of any.

johnthedebs··on Walter Isaacson’s ‘Steve Jobs’
One of the most frustrating examples of people telling lies about Jobs is the meme that he told an iPhone user that they were "holding it the wrong way" when they complained about the iPhone 4 antenna. What he actually said was (and this is the entire email): "Just avoid holding it that way."

Sure it's terse, but it's a long way from telling them they're doing it wrong. Jobs isn't known to be always nice and given this person's situation his suggestion is the best way to fix the problem in the short term. Apple later made amends here, too; admittedly only because people complained, but if the success of the iPhone 4 is a good indication (you can decide) this really was never really a problem.

johnthedebs··on The Audacity of the iBooks Author EULA
The crucial difference here being that Microsoft had a monopoly.
johnthedebs··on Poll: Do you think HN should go dark in protest of SOPA?
I see your point, but disagree. I think it makes a lot more sense for HN to do whatever HN believes is the most effective thing, rather than do what reddit did.

I see it as fake work. We would being doing something ineffective to prove a point and distracting from something potentially more useful (which may or may not also prove that point).

johnthedebs··on Google’s Jaw-Dropping Sponsored Post Campaign For Chrome
It may be that they're gaining market share so quickly in part because of this advertising.
johnthedebs··on How I Write Django Reusable Apps
I agree: great topic but light on details. If you're considering ideas for additional posts, I'd personally love to see case studies from Pinax itself to see exactly how/why to use the techniques you talked about.
johnthedebs··on Louis CK's self distributed special up to 1MM revenue in 12 days
Just wanted to add to this (not that it's needed to make the point): Louis C.K. isn't your child.
johnthedebs··on Smoke Screening: Journalist tests TSA
You seem to be looking at this the wrong way. Instead, consider that once a person has decided they want to cause terror so much that they are willing to blow themselves up, they'll go to great lengths to make sure their one opportunity to do so succeeds.

These chances of passing these screenings aren't independent. They aren't just die rolls where a terrorist needs to roll 6 five times in a row for their plot to succeed. If they can improve their chances on one screening they can and will improve their chances on the rest (which was the point he was trying to make).

Now consider how much time and money is spent for each additional screening that's put into place, both for those putting it in place and the millions that have to jump through all the extra hoops each day to travel. Worth it?

johnthedebs··on Bingo Card Creator (etc) Year In Review 2011
Hey Patrick, first of all congrats on your engagement and your business success.

Secondly, I was wondering if you could share a bit about how you decide which ideas to invest your time in. Why did BCC and AR make the cut, while other ideas didn't (I assume you had a lot of other probably-good ideas along the way)?

johnthedebs··on Louis C.K. "I've never seen a check from a [TV] comedy special"
I think I've seen Gumroad before (here on HN?) and thought it was an awesome idea. Just took a look at your other work and I've gotta say - thanks for building such great stuff!
johnthedebs··on Louis C.K. "I've never seen a check from a [TV] comedy special"
The best way to scale this down to lesser-known acts is to reduce the barriers to entry for both the comic and the audience.

More specifically, if comics had a free service or tool that allowed them to set a price, upload some content, and have a promotional site like he had for his show it could work wonders. YouTube does this pretty well, but what he's done is much better (though there's a lot of benefit to having lots of videos in one place with good discoverability). Recording and editing is also getting cheaper every day.

To lower the barrier for the audience, shows for new acts would need to be even cheaper or free. Once they build a following they can start charging more.

The iTunes model is almost certainly the one to follow here: sell it cheap and go for volume. If the content is good and the barrier is low, people will eat it up and the artists will get their fair share and more. The middlemen in this equation are really the biggest problem right now (for so many reasons).

johnthedebs··on What Tools Developers Actually Use
I've seen...really smart developers use notepad...there's probably a lesson to learn.

I find that really hard to believe, and I can't imagine what the lesson would be. It's akin to a NASCAR driver driving a Camry. It's true that the tools don't make the dev, but if what you say is true those devs are just hampering themselves.

johnthedebs··on Facebook settles with FTC, under privacy watch for 20 years
I think what it means is that, in this case, the FTC gets to watch and make sure Facebook complies. If they don't, they get penalized for it. FTA:

The proposed order also contains standard record-keeping provisions to allow the FTC to monitor compliance with its order.

and then further down:

Each violation of such an order may result in a civil penalty of up to $16,000.

I really hope that's up to $16,000 per person for each violation.

johnthedebs··on GitHub for Mac 1.1
Looks like a great update (line-by-line committing ftw). I mainly use GitX for git GUI duties, but this looks like it's ready to replace GitX.

It's very handy to be able to switch between projects easily from within the app, and the direct GitHub integration is icing on the cake. The only not-awesome thing I noticed is some general lag and flickering, but hopefully that'll get worked out soon. The team at GitHub is doing some fantastic work.

johnthedebs··on Jeff Bezos Owns the Web in More Ways Than You Think
Seems more of a trade-off than an improvement.

That's exactly the point. Instead of trying to compete directly with the iPad, Amazon is serving a different part of the market.

johnthedebs··on Tim O'Reilly: I am really starting to hate Mac OS X.
If you're going to criticize it, at least do so in a constructive way. In your list of 7, I see 2 real complaints.

1) Agreed, this can be annoying.

2) The buttons are visually smaller, but have the same target click area.

3) It behaves the same way it did before, so this isn't any worse.

4) The new scrolling takes a day or two to get used to, and then is better. If you really don't like it, there's an option to toggle it off. This isn't an issue.

5) Agreed, it is arguably slower and tends to drain the battery faster. It's also doing more. It sucks, but that's the price of progress.

6) As I see it, FireVault is a huge plus and not at all a drawback. Was there anything 'terrible' about the process other than that it was lengthy? And really, a one-time conversion cost for such a huge improvement to this feature was a problem for you?

7) This happens with practically every desktop OS upgrade ever and, as you mentioned, isn't a problem anymore.

So besides #1 and #5, are there other real complaints?

I'd personally add "really botched multi-touch gestures" to the list, but I'm genuinely curious if it's actually that much worse or people are just piling onto this rant.

johnthedebs··on A little game to demonstrate timing attacks.
While this seems like a reasonable solution at first, it doesn't fix the vulnerability. It should be obvious when you consider that the attacker already deals with natural variation in network speeds and server load.

Turns out it's very straightforward to use statistical analysis to get rid of the noise and adding a little more doesn't do anything useful. The most reliable way to throw off the attacker is to make sure you do the same amount of computing in every case.

"It's stuff like this that makes building secure systems very hard."

johnthedebs··on iPhone 4S First Weekend Sales Top Four Million
Even if the iPhone 4S would've been a worse phone than iPhone 4, they would've still sold at least a million units in first weekend. I think everyone knows that.

No, I don't think everyone knows that. If we learned anything from the past few Apple product launches, it's that customers aren't shy about complaining even if they aren't completely sure what they're complaining about.

But this sales boost will confirm to Apple that it's ok for them to just release the same phone for 2 years with some spec upgrades in the 2nd year.

It is okay. The economics behind producing this many millions of a devices doesn't allow them to change the design every single year without jacking up the price. And for what?

A "tick tock" schedule, like the one Intel has adopted, makes tons of sense for Apple too. You just can't completely rethink a product design every year once it's matured.

johnthedebs··on Bitbucket now rocks Git
This is great news, very exciting for people who need a nice place to stash all their private git repos but didn't want to upgrade their GitHub plans for not-that-important projects. Very interesting that they've decided to compete directly too.

I wonder if/how GitHub will respond. I strongly prefer their UI and already have a paid plan, but I find myself shuffling repos within the confines of that plan rather than stomaching the (admittedly not very big) upgrade cost since many of the projects aren't super important. I understand why they do it, but I just don't like that they place an arbitrary restriction on the number of private repos.

johnthedebs··on YCNYC: A lost opportunity
I didn't know what they did until I approached them.

After thinking about it for a while that night, I came to the conclusion that this was the point.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →