HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jqgatsby

437 karma · joined September 22, 2010

john a fries gmail
submissionscomments
jqgatsby··on If I could bring one thing back to the internet it would be blogs
How would you recommend they change it to help low-traffic stack exchanges?
jqgatsby··on Questioning the Clampdown
There isn't consensus on whether "ok, boomer" is a slur vs a protest or criticism. It seems inappropriate to me to ban accounts for using that phrase.
jqgatsby··on Engineers crack 58-year-old puzzle on way to quantum breakthrough
The localization claims in this article seem very exciting. Could someone with a background in quantum computing provide some context for whether this is something likely to be important in the future?
jqgatsby··on Federal Judge Upholds Harvard's Race-Conscious Admissions Process
I don't think "fixing income inequality" needs to mean that everyone is paid the same amount. It's reasonable to believe that <insert billionaire here> isn't a million times more productive than their median employee, and that factors other than pure merit allowed them to amass that much wealth. Even if you did think that they were that meritorious, you could still make an argument that "fairness" should involve balancing both merit and utility (in this case referring to the diminishing marginal utility of money).
jqgatsby··on The Y Combinator
@ProfHewitt, I have to say I think you did a lot of people (including myself) a disservice by polluting Wikipedia with promotions of your original research on the Actor model of computation.

Modelling concurrent computation is not the place for an intellectual "land grab"; if your work has value, I think it's time to let other people promote it for you.

jqgatsby··on Substack
I'm guessing it is a portmanteau of 'ginormous' (itself a portmanteau that has legitimately replaced 'enormous' for my kids' generation, much to my chagrin) and 'humongous'? Maybe with some relation to 'mundo' as well.
jqgatsby··on The wrong kind of trees: Ireland's afforestation meets resistance
I agree with you 100%, ralusek. This sounds like a particularly infantile form of nimbyism to me. Apologies to the folks living there that the forests suck, but with the fate of the planet at stake you get very little of my sympathy. Yes, in the long run, let's plant something more pleasant, but we are dealing with an immediate climate crisis and your concern about the view and local walkability are just not important compared to that.

If these shitty trees do the best job of quickly soaking up carbon, then that's what should be planted. It's not about you.

jqgatsby··on Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of student loan debt
That's a common fallacy. Places that have high paying jobs usually have high cost of living. You can't typically command high salaries in cheaper areas, but people seem to think that just by virtue of living in a certain area you are defacto well-off.

Anyway, this hypothetical guy isn't helping my case, because we can either add or subtract virtues to make him more or less sympathetic. As someone who matched this description personally, I can tell you I did not feel "upper middle class" by any stretch of the imagination, which is what I was responding to.

jqgatsby··on Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of student loan debt
Your example of the guy who has $100K in student loans and is making a $100K salary in New York is a good example, but I think we very much disagree on how he should be treated. If he's living in NYC, his take-home is about $68k after taxes and he's laying out $3500/month in rent for a one bedroom and paying $1k/month for the loans. That leaves him $1100/month for utilities, medical, and, you know, food if he wants to eat. I know there are plenty of people who are worse off, but this guy is working a non-trivial job just to tread water. Why do you have so little sympathy for him?
jqgatsby··on Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of student loan debt
Is it the case that you are coming at this from a point of view that is opposed to progressive liberalism in general? That would have been helpful to mention up front, because the article you cite is actually arguing from the view of Sanders' proposal being insufficiently progressive. It seems disingenuous to me to cite it without clarifying that your own reasons for opposing the proposal are completely different.
jqgatsby··on Bernie Sanders to unveil plan to cancel all $1.6T of student loan debt
This kind of excessive fixation on perfect fairness is exactly what got us into this mess. They thought they could help the poor attend college by giving them grants, then the middle class would have loans, and the rich had to pay their own way. Then it turned out that both the poor and the middle class had to take out loans because grants were too expensive, and the "rich" were fine anyway. Here's a crazy thought: if these debt holders are so well-off, why haven't they paid off their debts yet? Being in debt is a huge psychological burden, and forces people to choose high-paying jobs in expensive areas (which makes them appear to be well-off), instead of doing work that is more meaningful and socially beneficial.

It's good to remember in these situations that the perfect is the enemy of the good, and what Sanders is proposing has the advantage of maximum simplicity. If you listen to the advice of perfectionists like David Leonhardt, you're going to neither eat nor have your cake.

jqgatsby··on Self-Taught Mathematician; an Impossibility?
Wait, "redefine derivatives to be based on multiplication"? That sounds really interesting, could you please expand on that?
jqgatsby··on Inflammation might be the root of preventable disease
I'd be very curious to hear what you think of the interleukin 17A and 23 blockers, like taltz and tremfya. They're being sold as miracle drugs for psoriasis, but how sure are we that they don't somehow screw up your heart or bones over the course of 10 years?
jqgatsby··on The Army thought a veteran faked his health issues while having lead poisoning
Plastic is the new lead.
jqgatsby··on Ask HN: Physicists of HN, what are you working on these days?
I am not a physicist, but one thing I've noticed is that the physicists I know tend to be very good at Mathematica, and if they happen to transition to a data science role, then Mathematica is sort of this secret weapon that they have.

I've been learning it for the first time recently, and there are data science problems that are somehow tractable in Mathematica that were very hard for me to do in Python. Some of this stuff, like FindDistribution, seems only to have been added in the last few years. The random process library is really amazing as well.

jqgatsby··on Mumble – Open source, low latency, high quality voice chat software
That really sounds like an indispensible feature. Is Mumble the only voice chat system that provides this kind of hierarchical linking of channels, or is it available on other systems as well?

If it's not available on, say, Discord, why is that? Do people just somehow make do without it? Or is there some other compensating feature?

jqgatsby··on Mumble – Open source, low latency, high quality voice chat software
I don't have any experience with gaming so this is a bit hard for me to understand. Are nested channels used as a way of grouping channels in a hierarchy in the UI? Or does the hierarchy affect what people hear? In the latter case, I'm imagining something like: "Everyone in subchannel can hear everything said in parent channel, but not vice versa".
jqgatsby··on Mumble – Open source, low latency, high quality voice chat software
That sounds like a really interesting feature! Trying to find some documentation on this specific feature but it's hard to find exactly what you're talking about.

1) Can you elaborate how "hierarchical chat room" works and how fleets in Eve Online use this?

2) Do other game chat apps like Discord implement anything similar?

jqgatsby··on Farewell from Paradise Bay
I was wondering this myself. Does anyone know anyone at King games who can comment? This game seems to have a real community. The Paradise Bay YouTube channel lists Clint Tasker as the lead designer, but I don't think he's at King Games anymore.

https://youtu.be/AzATnBlxrcU

jqgatsby··on Farewell from Paradise Bay
My wife has been playing this game on her phone for years, and is super sad that they are closing it down. She's probably bought a fair number of "gems" from them too, to beautify her island and trade fruit, I guess.

Some of the comments are funny, in a heartbreaking way. People really invested a lot in this game, emotionally and financially. They are wondering who is going to feed the pets they bought to live on their digital island.

The funniest/saddest thing about it is that, as a last hurrah, the maintainers of the game gave everyone 10 million gems to spend as they see fit in the remaining 2 months that the game is online. On the one hand, the players are kind of pissed off at the belated awareness that the gems they were hoarding were always fundamentally worthless, but on the other hand they want to buy the final superpet or whatever for their island before the volcano blows up.

jqgatsby··on Principal component analysis: pictures, code and proofs (2018)
That's very interesting. Can you please clarify "if you have a low-magnitude high-dimensional signal corrupted by highly-correlated noise"?

I don't understand what "highly-correlated noise" means. I thought noise was uncorrelated to the signal by definition.

Also, I understand that PCA is not scale invariant, but I'm having trouble relating that to "low-magnitude, high-dimensional signal".

Thank you!

jqgatsby··on How WeChat faded into the silence in India
Personal anecdotes have value in situations where data is sparse. Often one has to extrapolate from a small number of use cases when developing a new product. I found his comment valuable.
jqgatsby··on DuckDuckGo Traffic
That's an astute observation. Can you add a link?
jqgatsby··on DuckDuckGo Traffic
I think a lot of the people here raving about how great duckduckgo is do not understand that it's just a layer on top of Bing results. You could run Bing (or Google for that matter) in an incognito window and get the same effect.

What I'd like to see is an ad-free search engine that is open-source or subscription-based. DDG doesn't solve any of the fundamental problems with the search ecosystem.

jqgatsby··on Notes on Nationalism (1945)
The term that popped into my head was "tribalism", which seems related to but distinct from partisanship.
jqgatsby··on YouTube Accounts Of Famous Singers Hacked. Despacito video deleted.
Is that official HN policy? I understand the desire to not make people feel unwelcome, and it is fairly rare that a conversation about technology needs to bring in religion. However, one could argue that challenging beliefs is a part of HN culture as well.

I admit I'm not unbiased in this regard. There's a part of me that respects religion and there's a part of me that feels it's the one of the worst things in the world. There's a part of me that does want to give people a hard time for holding beliefs that I consider to be insane, and there's a part of me that has better things to do with his time and isn't sure he could offer anything practically better than what he would tear down.

jqgatsby··on ‘Testilying’ by Police: A Stubborn Problem
No, jurors have to swear to tell the truth when answering questions during jury selection. However, in practice if you express any reservations about police testimony you will very likely be struck from the jury by the DA.

My own limited experience on a jury is that, because of the way jurors are selected, they tend to be fairly deferential to authority (especially the judge's authority). Arguing for jury nullification or any similar concept is at a minimum going to freak your fellow jurors out, and I wouldn't be surprised if in practice they might ask the judge to kick you off the jury and use one of the alternates (regardless of whatever the legality of the situation calls for).

jqgatsby··on Is software development really a dead-end job after age 35-40?
If you are looking for a smooth transition, get on a large team that is under-managed (say, >14 people and only one manager/tech-lead), and in addition to doing your regular tasks, start getting heavily involved in sprint planning and technical & product specs. Gradually do more and more of that and less individual work. Voila, you are a manager!
jqgatsby··on Information Geometry
I've been hoping to find a rebuttal to Skilling's paper from someone who understands information geometry. Anyone here able to provide one? Or are his critiques viewed as legitimate?
jqgatsby··on Show HN: Inside – The network of email newsletters
Jason, I've been a big fan of your work ever since Mahalo days. Love what you and Lon are doing with Inside.com. Ping me if you ever want to discuss tech strategy, I think your format is uniquely well-suited to a machine learning approach with a couple modifications.
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →