HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jrajav

3,038 karma · joined May 23, 2012

http://stackoverflow.com/users/1013153/jrajav https://github.com/jrajav
submissionscomments
jrajav··on Inércia 2023
Most servers have something like an announcements channel. Muting everything but that is the equivalent of subscribing to an events / other big news mailing list for (Discord-centric) communities, these days. You'll only get notifications for that, and can still engage with muted channels on a pull basis whenever you want.
jrajav··on 'Weird Al' Roasts Spotify's Artist Payout System in Year-End Wrapped Video
The cited source there is some old Spotify PR. Which, if you dive into, eventually states:

> Our current payment agreements lead us to distribute (~)approximately 70% of our gross revenues to master recording and publishing rights (both mechanical reproduction and performance) holders. The precise division between these types of rights holders varies by territory in accordance with local laws and negotiated agreements.

So, 70% / 30% is actually just a self-reported figure, and also just a ballpark based on current agreements at the time. Also, I couldn't find a current version of this page, only the archived one cited. All current versions of this page seem to have nothing but deflection, which might indicate that their self-reported figure has become less flattering.

jrajav··on Adobe's buy of Figma is 'likely' bad for developers, rules UK regulator
I think 'software developers' in this sense refers to companies developing software (and thus employing designers).
jrajav··on 'Weird Al' Roasts Spotify's Artist Payout System in Year-End Wrapped Video
You're right, I didn't know this. I was under the impression that Spotify self-reported its split and that it wasn't really auditable in any way. Can you link to a source?
jrajav··on 'Weird Al' Roasts Spotify's Artist Payout System in Year-End Wrapped Video
Online app stores, craft stores (Etsy), contracting services (Fiverr), even some other streaming services with direct subscription sales (like Twitch). All also marketplaces where skilled creators are selling the actual value that drives it.
jrajav··on 'Weird Al' Roasts Spotify's Artist Payout System in Year-End Wrapped Video
I see your point, but it's mainly this part:

> subtract a percentage for themselves

Streaming platforms (let's not just pick on Spotify, though they also pay worse than others) just do this arbitrarily. They decide how much to skim off for themselves before graciously paying artists. This isn't how it works in basically any other industry where one group of skilled individuals create content that is then sold on some marketplace - instead, the sale price and proceeds are visible to all, and the middleman takes a well-defined, reasonable cut of that.

There's no need to compare streaming platforms to other models of paying musicians, in order to know they're getting a bum deal. This model is not fair in the slightest, and it's perfectly alright to be upset about it.

jrajav··on 'Weird Al' Roasts Spotify's Artist Payout System in Year-End Wrapped Video
Most artists these days self-distribute via platforms like Distrokid, not via a label. Distrokid just passes along streaming revenue, so they don't have any incentive to fight for it. And obviously, artists aren't in any position at all to collectively negotiate - you publish on Spotify, or you're unknown. The fault does, in fact, lie mostly with Spotify here.
jrajav··on Show HN: Perfect Pitch Puzzle – a musical Wordle daily ear training game
Great work! Had no trouble playing the game, and it's a well thought out concept.

I know you're invested in the 'perfect pitch' framing, since you mention that you have it in the family. Since it seems like your goal is to have this be a useful and accessible educational tool for those breaking into music, I would highly recommend pivoting this to have a strong focus on relative pitch, and specifically _intervals_, instead. Knowing how to distinguish intervals is both more accessible, and also much more useful for actually playing and creating music. As is, this tool clearly deprioritizes intervals with the fixed piano-key input and melodies in a key other than C. This will really only help one get better at this specific game.

If you haven't already, give Earmaster a try and see how they approach it - it's one of the most referenced and well-regarded training apps on the market. Earmaster, and others like it, start with a focus on relative intervals, then expand out from there to enhance instant recognition and memory of relative intervals across a melody - but the focus is almost never on absolute pitch 'across the piano'.

jrajav··on Show HN: Perfect Pitch Puzzle – a musical Wordle daily ear training game
It's possible but for anyone who would actually care to acquire it (i.e. musicians), relative pitch is just as useful for any task that matters and much easier to acquire. Most acquire it by accident. And arguably, perfect pitch isn't desirable anyway, since standard 12-tone equal temperament is not the "perfect" form of music by any measure. The tuning basis of 440hz is completely arbitrary, and there are plenty of examples of the tuning in any genre being changed (usually to a higher pitch) for excitements' sake. Plus, mathematically any form of dynamic just intonation is superior to fixed 12-tone equal temperament. Relative pitch remains useful in these contexts, while absolute pitch does not.
jrajav··on Dbrand Is Suing Casetify
It would be unsurprising if that was all intended from the start as a viral marketing campaign. I don't remember hearing that they ever got in any trouble with Sony, and they're pretty infamous for "taunting" others to sue them (and similar stunt language like "our lawyers told us we couldn't make this") in all their marketing.
jrajav··on OpenAI staff threaten to quit unless board resigns
I suspect it takes somewhat less time and process to hire somebody, when NOT hiring them by start-of-business on Monday will result in billions in lost stock value.
jrajav··on I deeply regret my participation in the board's actions
No, even this is just a darkly comforting illusion.

We like to feel that we as a species are still in control. That yes, we are gutting and destroying natural earth, complicit with modern slavery and war, and that's all terrible and we should do our best to stop it. BUT - at the very least, those bastards at the top know what they're doing when it comes to making money, so at least we'll have a stellar economy and rapid technological advancement, despite all that.

The painful truth here being that no, there's no cunning. There's no brutal optimization. Any value created and technological progress made is mostly incidental, mostly down to people at the bottom working hard just to survive, and a few good ideas here and there. The ones at the top are mostly just lucky and along for the ride, just as bumbling and lost as the rest of us when it comes to global happenings or even just successfully interacting with others.

jrajav··on Surveillance Tech Write Press Releases for Cops; News Agencies Are Publishing It
Were you planning to actually contribute something to the conversation, in terms of a counterpoint with additional data to consider? Or just be an aggressive naysayer?
jrajav··on Surveillance Tech Write Press Releases for Cops; News Agencies Are Publishing It
You're right, I missed that in haste. I do think it's still worthwhile to consider the minimum wage since it applies direct upward pressure on other hourly wages, and the question is "how many Americans are effectively broke." The purchasing power of the absolute average American doesn't really answer that question with growing wealth inequality.
jrajav··on Surveillance Tech Write Press Releases for Cops; News Agencies Are Publishing It
That is incorrect. They are at their lowest point in 75 years: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1065466/real-nominal-val...

There is also deeper nuance to consider, like the fact that essential goods such as grocery items have been inflating much faster than other markets, especially in most recent years.

jrajav··on Millennials aren't all worse off than Boomers, but the rich-poor gap is widening
Millennials were born centered around 1990. Most of them were in their late teens by the time social media as we know it today really entered the zeitgeist. Even if it's true that social media is distracting in a way that affects education and skill development, this would have an impact on younger generations, not as much millennials, who are used to the internet as a tool, not as an integral part of the world.

As for the premise itself, I find it doubtful. All of my friends below age 30 (i.e. past millennials) have a much stronger working knowledge of marketable skills than I did at a younger age, as well as more open and free resources to develop them. It is most often access and connections that block their career progress, not capability.

jrajav··on A Zoomer explains her generation's malaise to older generations
I'm sure the general hopelessness of younger generations has nothing at all to do with the facts that:

- They get paid less (in terms of actual purchasing power) than any prior generation in memory.

- They are saddled with mountains of education debt their elders told them to take on if they want a good job (which they usually never got).

- They cannot get the security and long-term investment that is owning a house, which was much easier for older generations.

- Food and college and other basics of survival and upward mobility are costing more and more every year, outpacing inflation, which itself is outpacing wages.

I really think this is a much simpler explanation for a generation-wide malaise than the popular (with older generations), but infantilizing, explanation of a social media addiction. Not getting paid a fair amount for your hard work, and it being so obvious that you are indeed not getting paid a fair amount, will be demoralizing to anyone of any background.

jrajav··on Why Cities: Skylines 2 performs poorly
Read the reviews and don't buy it. This works fantastically as a punishment already without ham-handed, opaque moderation.
jrajav··on Silicon Valley doesn't understand the concept of fun
That wasn't ever the topic to begin with, but good job proving the point that books aren't immune from righteous vitriol, now or then.

One other thing common between now and then is the pulpit beating about public decency and protecting the children.

Children will discover truths whether you try in vain to shield them or not. It's the duty of parents and communities to guide and teach children throughout that growth process, not to be lazy and bully other parents and communities into sharing and enforcing all their same values in depth.

jrajav··on BP to purchase $100M in Tesla Superchargers
BP's entire existence is based on burning fossil fuels, and they're responsible for one of the worst oil-based environmental disasters of the past 20 years. I think it's very fair to assume that any mention of being "green" by them specifically is complete lip service.
jrajav··on Ask HN: Why haven't you started your startup?
This is explicitly a startup focused forum run by a startup incubator. But I do agree with you, I wish there were more discussion of "boring" businesses here as much as there was railing about using "boring" tech.
jrajav··on What Is Login.gov?
I didn't know this existed! It should see much wider adoption by agencies, and I might even email my reps to say so.

It's beyond ridiculous that a for-profit company (ID.me) was awarded a juicy, logo-plastering contract with the IRS. The notion that verifying your identity for tax purposes is a valid insertion point for middleman enterprise is absurd.

jrajav··on React use C
At first, from the title, I thought this might be a clever solution to the problem just created out of thin air that 'official' React apps with Next now require "use client" on a large fraction of previously working modules that were always intended to run on the client by default.
jrajav··on Americans falling behind on auto loan payments at record pace
> Taco buyers tend to be a much more balanced and pragmatic sort of truck owner, and I seldom find anything obnoxious about them. Not sure why this is

I can tell you exactly why, in middle America at least. Buying a Toyota means you prioritize reliability and getting work done. Buying a Ford or Chevy (invariably a large cabin, premium leather comfort model wearing a pickup truck as a costume) means you prioritize image. Sure you might get work done with it - though I know way too many who don't - but it wasn't what you set out to purchase. It has to be American, it has to be big and have a fancy grille silhouette, and it has to be nice and cushy to sit in.

jrajav··on Discord is going to give out warnings instead of permanent bans
> So if someone shares CP on discord you think they should be given a warning and not permabanned?

"Think of the children" is consistently used as an escape hatch to avoid actually doing due diligence in enforcement and moderation. You aren't protecting anyone by lazily granting root to content moderation / surveillance / whatever system is under discussion. You're just making those systems worse.

jrajav··on Nature: Programming language to experience the joy of programming
I've sometimes wondered why not make `-` whitespace dependent to resolve this one. Signed numbers store the sign bit in their representation, so enforcing the sign character to be in the same word also seems reasonable - and is there anyone who would mind actually having to put at least one space around binary arithmetic operators? We've all agreed that that's the sane way to write them by now, yes?
jrajav··on OpenAI has quietly changed its 'core values,' putting greater emphasis on AGI
This is an issue with the productivity gains from automation being siphoned off in general, and we've been boiling that frog for a century plus. We're gonna have to figure out a more sophisticated economic model before too long but it will probably have to be a painful lesson.
jrajav··on Oil sector is lobbying for inefficient hydrogen cars to delay electrification
Source for either of these claims other than "just imagine?"

Of course infrastructure is a concern but I haven't seen any sources that claim we are unprepared to sustain significant EV deployment - and of course it will not ever happen overnight, so that's a strawman.

jrajav··on Web server 'hello world' benchmark: Go vs. Node.js vs. Nim vs. Bun
Just curious, how did you run integer math in JS to compare? Since it doesn't support it natively.
jrajav··on Strong static typing, a hill I'm willing to die on
I, too, find tools hard to use after I intentionally break them.

It's unfortunate that Typescript even provides this casting hack, though it's necessary for gradual, optional typing. The very first thing I would do on such a project is spend the time to fix those broken types, because it will pay back in full in productivity after a short time.

← PreviousPage 4 of 21Next →