HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jsherwani

1,473 karma · joined July 14, 2009

Co-Founder/CEO Screenhero (YC W13, acquired by Slack).

Now building pop (https://pop.com).

submissionscomments
jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
Hmmm I got this response when I submitted the form:

pop.com is not blocked by this blocklist

Probable causes:

- An other blocklist blocking it? - Regex? - An older version of this list contained it? > Make sure you are using the latest version.

Not sure what happened!

jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
Thank you! Looking into this now...
jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
Glad you liked it! We have plans to make it easier to get into a circle (one person elects to start a circle, and others elect to join).
jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
Glad you liked it! Please keep the feedback coming.
jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
We haven't yet measured audio latency, but our main product (https://screen.so) is all about low latency screen sharing, so we're very interested in reducing lag of all sorts. Performance is something we'll focus on in 2021 in a big way.

Monetization: very similar to what everyone else in this space does. Free for social users, paid for business users, and finding a good way to segment the two.

jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
Since our company is personally bootstrapped by me, answering this will divulge more of my personal financial situation than I would like to share.

However, I can say that I worked with https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=ted0 who was AMAZING at helping find and acquire the domain. I can strongly recommend him as an amazing person to work with for anyone interested in buying a high-value domain.

jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
Thank you! I really appreciate it.

I wrote this elsewhere:

We bought this domain a few months ago, and you're probably right, since Gmail seems to mark our outgoing emails as spam. I'm not very well-versed in how to undo the reputation the previous owners seem to have created for the domain, so if you have any recommendations, please let me know!

jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
Not at all! We'd originally bought pop.com to be the new home for screen.so, but once we made this new product, we wanted to launch it asap.

Our plan is to merge the two in the near future, and work on the intersection between 2D and 3D calls.

jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
We bought this domain a few months ago, and you're probably right, since Gmail seems to mark our outgoing emails as spam. I'm not very well-versed in how to undo the reputation the previous owners seem to have created for the domain, so if you have any recommendations, please let me know!
jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
That's a fair point, here's a little more information: https://www.producthunt.com/posts/pop-9
jsherwani··on Show HN: Pop.com – Video Calls, in 3D
Pop founder here. We’re a team of 5, and folks from our team have built products like Screenhero, Slack Calls, and most recently, Screen.so.

Pop lets you have a video call in 3D, with positional audio. It works in a browser, without any download. The experience is surprisingly fresh, and the social dynamics are quite fun.

You can feel like you’re part of a group, you can see who’s looking at you, you can go to the side with someone and have a separate conversation, without interrupting the current conversation. You can share a screen that floats in space (and always faces the viewer). You can even bow to say hello!

We use Mediasoup for the WebRTC backend, Ionic/Angular for the frontend, and BabylonJS as our 3D framework.

Also, as an experiment, we’re hosting a virtual launch party at [EDIT: 6 hours later, and we're done! Thanks to everyone who came by!].

Happy to answer any questions here too, of course!

Edit: there are more screenshots here: https://www.producthunt.com/posts/pop-9

jsherwani··on Zoom fatigue is real
If the theory is correct, Zoom fatigue exists because videoconferencing is a worse experience than in-person conversations. Media quality, latency, the inability to use most of our motor/sensory apparatus, all contribute to micro-frustrations which accumulate over the course of a meeting.

On the other hand, screen sharing with interactive control when working together on a shared task is actually better than sitting next to someone on their computer. In person, I can only talk and point at their screen. With interactive screen sharing, I can click, type, and even draw live on their screen.

I spend hours a day in interactive screen share sessions (quasi-pair programming but not really) and never feel the effects of Zoom fatigue. But when I have to use a product without the ability to easily draw or interact, or have a meeting where it’s just about faces in boxes, I immediately feel extra “drag”.

I’m curious to hear if anyone else has had the same experience.

If this is correct, there may be a way to sidestep the issues of Zoom fatigue with better tools and processes (e.g. don’t talk about work, instead do the work together).

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
We’re looking into this: https://screen.canny.io/bugs/p/linux-single-screen-selection...
jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
In 2015, when we joined, Slack’s Mac app was using "MacGap" (i.e. the PhoneGap/Cordova model but for Mac). Electron was being used for Windows only, and it was a lot later that it became the platform for Slack’s Mac, Windows and Linux apps.
jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
You can disable global shortcuts from the Settings menu (when you're not in a call). But yes, we'll be improving this!
jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
A/V set up: good point. We can definitely improve this, although we’d need to be mindful to not add too much clutter to the already-dense minipanel.

Digital multiplayer whiteboard: we sort of do. You can draw even outside of a screen share — just draw during a video call (or even voice (or even no media at all!)). But I’m curious if you meant something else? There are a number of websites that do digital whiteboards, and we didn’t want to reinvent the wheel.

Bug: this is an intermittent bug we’ve heard about from some users but have had a hard time reproducing. Thank you for letting me know — we’ll try to figure out a better way to log the error to help us reproduce and solve it.

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
Thank you! I’ve just pushed the following change to the site (will be live in <10 mins):

>Neither Screen nor these third parties store or record media data as part of the Service, nor process it other than for the purpose of providing the Service to you.

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
A simple fix for the specific issue you mentioned is to stop sharing your screen for however long you want, while still staying in the meeting. You can then turn it back on whenever you’d like.

Having said that, I’ve heard this request a few times now, and we will likely get to this soon. But I am curious whether the workaround would work for you for the time being.

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
The specifics of the speed gains are our secret sauce, I’m afraid! But at a high level, we reduced the time taken in every step of the pipeline between capture > encode > send > receive > decode > render that we could, while still remaining WebRTC compliant.
jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
Check out our roadmap, with the two items for virtual office. One has a small screenshot, and the other has a Figma prototype that walks you through the idea. Please post any feedback there so we can have it in one place, and so you can be updated as we make progress.

https://support.screen.so

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
It’s exactly as you described — no one in the chain is analyzing the content of the data being transferred. Both our infrastructure providers (Daily is our primary, Twilio is an opt-in secondary) care deeply about security, and both are used even in healthcare settings.

If you have suggestions of what we can say and do to make this better, please let me know. I will be looking into improving the language before we do our GA launch.

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
If text editing is all you need, and both sides are comfortable with the tools, then what you’ve suggested is definitely faster than Screen (tmux sends text, we send pixels).

But if the guest needs to see something else on the host’s computer (if you’re working together on a webpage, or a desktop app), then whole-desktop screen sharing is the best approach.

Screen definitely isn’t the best tool for every job. But it’s great for when you want everyone on the same page, seeing the same thing, and able to talk about the content of your screen and even control it together.

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
I felt the same way, and then decided to build Screen!

Your bike shedding comment made me laugh out loud :D

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
Yes! We’ve been laser focused on getting the product right, so the discount model hasn’t been fully fleshed out, but you can expect something similar to what other SaaS companies do in this space, but leaning to the more-generous side of that spectrum. I don’t know exactly what other companies do just yet, but that’s the philosophy we’ll use when we get to this. For now, it’s free for everyone, of course.
jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
We don’t want to reinvent the wheel. Slack is great for what it does! And if you read through https://screen.so/about, I have lived the experience that it’s impossible to do two things well. So in an ideal world, Slack continues to innovate on the messaging side, we continue to innovate on our side, and we mindfully integrate with each others’ platforms to give our users the best possible experience.
jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
Sure!

WebRTC server: Daily (primary), and Twilio (secondary)

There’s no shortcut to the performance side of things, so we had to do a lot of custom work on Mac, Windows and Linux to get screen sharing to be super fast. The high level bit there is the boring-but-correct advice: measure everything, start with the biggest bottleneck, optimize, repeat.

The desktop apps follow a Slack approach (with a slight twist). Like Slack, we use Electron, but in our case, we’ve heavily modified it to make screen sharing super fast. We then use the standard Electron model to have main & renderer processes. The renderer process fetches the UI from our website (hosted on Firebase).

Almost everything (other than our custom node module) is in a monorepo. Even our modifications to Electron are stored as patch files, which just makes it easy to keep things aligned between our app and our modifications to Electron.

Our website/webapp (they are one and the same) are built on Ionic/Angular (we started before Ionic supported React). We used Ionic because I didn’t want to have to create new different UIs for each platform — I think the user is served by having a low cost product where the effort is spent mainly on performance and quality, rather than a slightly different UI for each different platform (which has significant cost). We’ve tried to maximize code re-use wherever possible, which is how a 2 person engineering team was able to build this product (granted, it took almost an entire year, or more if you count the project we pivoted from).

Happy to dive into details if you’d like!

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
Thanks for being a supporter! I hope Screen can take the place left by Screenhero.
jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
So happy to hear this <3
jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
Sorry about that!

Looks like a bug in our Linux multi-monitor code. I'm going to look into this right now! It’s been a while since we touched that code, and it’s likely that bugs may have crept in since then.

Also, corp level user management is something we’ve got in the works, but we wanted to get the product out so that people could start using it, and then add admin tools on top of that. For instance, if you’re on G Suite, everyone should be able to OAuth in. But I hear you on the need for better tooling around users.

Were you able to try screen sharing from your Mac to his Linux computer?

jsherwani··on Show HN: Screen – screen sharing for remote work, by the cofounder of Screenhero
Good catch! Hopefully our product is better than my math :D
← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →