HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jstevens85

406 karma · joined June 2, 2009

submissionscomments
jstevens85··on Apple removes Scratch from iPad/iPhone/iTouch
It would be great if someone could copy the text of their post. My developer account recently expired and I don't really want to pay $99 just to view one forum post.
jstevens85··on Australia to censor AppStore etc.?
>it is hard to imagine the opposition Liberal Party ... opposing it.

My understanding is that they opposed ISP level filtering while in government.

Here are some comments made by Senior Opposition Frontbencher Joe Hockey a few days ago:

“What we have in the government’s Internet filtering proposals is a scheme that is likely to be unworkable in practice. But more perniciously it is a scheme that will create the infrastructure for government censorship on a broader scale,” said Hockey in a wide-ranging speech on freedom to the Grattan Institute last night.

Hockey said that “of course” people wanted to stop unlawful material being viewed on the internet, and that there were appropriate protections that are in place for that. “But I have personal responsibility as a parent,” he added. “If I want to stop my children from viewing other material that I feel is inappropriate then that is my responsibility to do something about it – not that of the government.”

“Protecting liberty is about protecting freedoms against both known and future threats. Some may argue that we can surely trust a democratically-elected government in Australia to never try to introduce more wide-spread censorship. I am not so sure!”

http://www.itwire.com/it-industry-news/strategy/37527-hockey...

Nick Minchin, the former Opposition Communications Minister, was also strongly against the Internet filter. Here's an opinion piece he wrote for the SMH.

http://www.smh.com.au/news/opinion/big-brother-filter-plan-i...

jstevens85··on Australia to censor AppStore etc.?
Although that may appear to be the case, the reality is that censorship has remain unchanged in Australia for a quite a long time.

If you're referring to video game censorship, that's not a recent problem, but something that's existed for a couple of decades now.

If you're talking about the internet filter, that's just the pet project of the Minister for Communications. He has yet to receive the support of the Government to introduce the legislation into parliament, so it'll be interesting to see what happens over the next six months or so (if he manages to introduce legislation into parliament, and if he does, how the opposing parties will react).

jstevens85··on Opera Mini approved for iPhone
Does anyone know how Opera makes money from this version? Surely the bandwidth and computational costs of processing, compressing and sending out webpages would exceed revenue from Google search, right?
jstevens85··on Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself
sigh. So this is the level of maturity we're to expect in the future from news.ycombinator?

There are obviously features beyond in-app buying and iAd that differentiate iPhone OS from the rest of the smartphone market.

jstevens85··on Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1
>I can't help but think that what Jobs means here is "intermediary layers that aren't ours automatically produce inferior products".

Is that not true though? In most cases, apps that use an intermediary layer will not be as polished or usable as an app developed using the native tools.

jstevens85··on Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1
I think perhaps what the parent meant is that Apple wants to maintain the current barrier to entry. I think perhaps they're worried about the shitload of crap apps that will end up being submitted for approval once Flash CS5 is released.
jstevens85··on Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1
>like Jobs claimed that 'nobody reads anymore' and some time later Apple now sells iBooks

The point Jobs was making was that a device used exclusively for reading would never be successful. He wasn't suggesting that it would be pointless to participate in the ebook market, just that it would need to be on a general purpose mobile platform.

jstevens85··on Why the iPhone Simulator is Awesome
> I just don't want to rent my right to develop and deploy on my device

>I am not opposed to Apple keeping its OS closed. I am fine with the Apple Store distribution "choke point".

These two statements contradict each other. A closed OS means that the consumer can only load applications on their device that have been approved by Apple. If people weren't required to rent the right to deploy on the iPhone, then anyone could freely load arbitrary non-Apple approved code. Therefore, by arguing for rent-free development, you are demanding a non-closed OS.

jstevens85··on The Moderate's Position on iPad Openness
>the device launched with a PHP IDE in the App Store on day one, amongst other code-related applications.

I can't seem to find any of these applications (I'm not sure how to browse for iPad specific apps in iTunes). Does anyone know which apps he's talking about?

jstevens85··on "The iPad is a LEGO set that can only be assembled into what's drawn on the box"
Think of the iPad as the Macintosh 128k. It provides a glimpse of how we will interact with computers in the future, yet at the moment is undeveloped and lacks the features and software of mainstream computers. The Mac 128k lacked a hard drive, multitasking, enough RAM to be usable, and the huge range of productivity software available on MS-DOS machines. Over time, the Mac (and Windows) matured and the feature set exceeded that of command line driven OSs.
jstevens85··on Doctorow: Why I won't buy an iPad
>but that Apple and others are trying to create a future where closed systems are the default, and open systems are either illegal or heavily marginalized.

I myself find it difficult to imagine a future where the vast majority of applications are not web apps hosted on private servers. If you take that to be the likely future, then what you can and can't run natively on your computer (with the exception of the browser) becomes irrelevant. Debating whether or not you have the freedom to run arbitrary native code will be like arguing over having the freedom to install your own BIOS.

jstevens85··on US State Dept questions Australia's planned Internet Filtering.
>with no accountability whatsoever.

The legislation has been delayed so that the government can implement "transparency and accountability" measures.

>It's a great way for a government to get its foot in the door into controlling what information is acceptable for its citizens to consume.

Get its foot in the door? The scope of the internet filter censorship will be identical to what already exists for traditional media - books, magazines, films and video games. The government already has its foot in the door. What's happened is that since 1996 they've started to lose grip, and this legislation is an ineffectual attempt to regain the control the government had 15 years ago. However, as the trial report and Conroy himself have stated, the filter will be trivial to bypass.

jstevens85··on Hope you reserved your iPad. Apple just ran out.
Some reports suggest that Apple is having trouble sourcing touch panels.

http://www.macrumors.com/2010/03/26/apples-ipad-touch-panel-...

jstevens85··on House Passes Health Care Reform
I believe part of the reason for the existence of Silicon Valley in the US is Stanford and Berekely. You have two great schools that attract the smartest engineers from all over the country.

That doesn't exist in Europe. Firstly, there is an economic disadvantage to studying in a different EU country, and most importantly there are cultural and language barriers. Instead of having a concentration of the smartest engineers studying within a couple of colleges, you have smart people being distributed rather sparsely over quite a large area.

jstevens85··on The Obesity-Hunger Paradox
>It's highly constructive when the prevailing mode of discussing the issue blames public policy and business practices, as this article does.

I've reread the article and I don't think that the author is blaming public policy. The article states some reasons why obesity may be more prevalent amongst poor communities, and also explains some proposed policies that may help to address the problem.

Really, there are two options here. One is to say "haha look at those stupid fat people" and watch the obesity rate climb. The second would be to realise that many of these people are on taxpayer funded Medicare, and then realise the logic of supporting cost-effective government policies that help reduce obesity and in turn the cost of government healthcare.

jstevens85··on IPad thoughts from Ben Fry (creator of Processing)
You should include Google along with Apple. I understand that Chrome OS won't allow any native apps whatsoever. The only native apps that will run are Google developed apps. So by your logic, Google is even more evil than Apple, right?
jstevens85··on Be lucky - it's an easy skill to learn (2003)
I don't think the author was implying that stopping when the note is found implies a "lucky" personality. I think Dr. Wiseman was looking for personality traits that are common amongst "unlucky" people. The newspaper test demonstrated that unlucky people are more tense and anxious than normal, and this could explain why they may not spot new opportunities.
jstevens85··on CyberLisp: A Lisp to JavaScript compiler
Am I right in saying that a tool like ANTLR would take care of most of these steps? Although I'd love to learn compiler theory someday and do everything myself, I'm constrained by time right now. What tools, frameworks could help speed this thing up for a beginner?
jstevens85··on CyberLisp: A Lisp to JavaScript compiler
Could someone explain to a non-CS major (Maths) what would be the simplest, quickest way to implement a BASIC to JavaScript compiler?
jstevens85··on Australian Government wants Google to filter YouTube like it does for China
There is only one worldwide version of Fallout 3; the Australian version is identical to the US copy. The item Morphine was renamed Med-X to pass through the Australian Classfication Board. The name change was also applied to all other international versions of the game.

A better example would be a game like L4D2. However that should be perfectly fine. Although video games lack an R18+ rating in Australia, such a rating exists for television and film. Therefore, a video of a RC computer game should be fine (as long as it is within the constraints of the R18+ rating for film).

I think it's unlikely that YouTube would a host a video on crime instruction that would be severe enough to be considered RC. I may be wrong. Perhaps someone could try uploading a euthanasia how-to video on YouTube describing explicitly the steps involved in performing euthanasia - the drugs required, how to obtain and smuggle such drugs through Australian customs, and the dosage required. I suspect that YouTube would probably take it down.

jstevens85··on Australian Government wants Google to filter YouTube like it does for China
The full interview can be seen here, and is worth watching:

http://hungrybeast.abc.net.au/stories/stephen-conroy-extende...

Conroy wasn't talking about YouTube specifically, but about Google and high-volume websites in general that currently aren't possible to filter through software. I'd be surprised if YouTube did contain material that the OFLC would consider Refused Classification.

jstevens85··on Australian Government wants Google to filter YouTube like it does for China
"What's going on down there? There's been a burst of these sorts of stories lately."

Nothing. There hasn't been a burst of censorship recently. As far as I'm aware, censorship laws have remain unchanged for quite some time. What's happened within the last year or two though is that through social media, Americans have become aware of the strict censorship laws that exist within Australia. Many of these people have mistakenly come to the conclusion that such censorship in Australia must be a recent development.

The truth is that if anything, censorship has become less severe. The video games that pass through the Classification Board today without a problem are far, far more violent than what used to require modification a decade ago.

In regards to Internet censorship, it seems consistent with the current legislation. If a government believes that it is the will of the people that extreme porn and violent video games be banned, then the legislation is ineffective if such material is easily accessible via the Internet.

jstevens85··on Australian Government wants Google to filter YouTube like it does for China
It obviously isn't to Chinese standards. China censors dissent and political opposition. The Australian Constitution protects freedom of political communication. Therefore, any laws that restrict the ability of residents to discuss and criticise political decisions and issues would be unconstitutional.

In regards to euthanasia, it is perfectly fine to discuss the philosophical and political arguments on each side. However, it is currently illegal to provide explicit how-to instructions on performing euthanasia. This has led to the disappointing decision to ban The Peaceful Pill Book, written by Australian euthanasia advocate Philip Nitschke.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Peaceful_Pill_Handbook

The proposed Internet filter will limit access to extreme porn, excessively violent material and instructions on how to commit crimes. It's regrettable that the government is even proposing such legislation, but it doesn't help anyone to make inaccurate comparisons to countries like China and Iran. A more sensible comparison would be to Denmark, which already has an operational internet filter.

jstevens85··on Anonymous hacks Australian Government in response to Internet censorship
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2008/12/01/2433845.htm?si...

This is probably the only article I've read that is pro-filter.

"Oh, and the ones with the government contract to implement the filter."

The government body ACMA will maintain a list of blacklisted websites (which already occurs, although pointless at this stage). I understand it will be the responsibility of the individual ISPs to choose how to block those websites.

jstevens85··on The App Store: Quality control without the quality
The obvious problem of allowing arbitrary programs on the iPhone is that it opens the door to piracy. That's the main reason why Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo spend a huge amount of resources trying to prevent hackers from opening up their game consoles.

Considering that Apple is going hard for the games market, they need to enforce strict control to get games publishers on side.

jstevens85··on TechCrunch Intern Admits To Asking For Compensation For Writing Posts
I don't think this is a major lapse in judgement. It's standard practice for newspapers/magazines to ask for a certain number of pages of advertisements in exchange for a feature article. In fact, I know that for many smaller trade magazines, the articles are actually written by the marketing staff of the featured company.
jstevens85··on Courts determine Australian ISPs not liable for users piracy.
What would corruption have to do with censoring the Internet?
jstevens85··on IPad Snivelers: Put Up or Shut Up - Engineers
I'm growing less concerned about it actually. If you believe that the world is moving towards web apps, then what programs you can install on your device becomes irrelevant. Google Voice runs well as a web app, and the $30 unlimited AT&T 3G plan means that users can treat web apps the same way as a local app - you don't have to worry about bandwidth or availability.

Compare iPhone OS to Google Chrome OS. I understand that the browser will be the only application that can be installed on Chrome OS. Why isn't Google receive equal (or deservedly more) criticism for restricting the freedoms of its potential users and developers?

jstevens85··on Amazon indicates they'll accept Macmillan's terms
> When I hear publishers talking about windowing books on my Kindle to protect their no-longer-relevant-to-me hardcovers and physical distribution systems, I get a little upset.

It's important to note that Macmillan was only considering windowing books on the Kindle because Amazon was forcing them to sell their books at a price below what they believed was profitable. Had Amazon been more flexible in allowing publishers to set prices for the content they own, then this never would've happened.

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →