HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jstummbillig

6,608 karma · joined February 14, 2015

submissionscomments
jstummbillig··on MNT Reform is an open hardware laptop, designed and assembled in Germany
I wished it was easier to manufacture things. There is a reason that Apple is held in high regard, and looking at this makes abundantly clear, why.
jstummbillig··on AI Resistance: some recent anti-AI stuff that’s worth discussing
Yeah. That is the current angle. We have not setup another one and I don't know that any one institution can.

I think it's laudable (and unprecedented) that AI companies themselves are fairly gloom about some potential prospects, and give people opportunity to rally against them. Still needs work towards a solution, though.

jstummbillig··on AI Resistance: some recent anti-AI stuff that’s worth discussing
> The exact machine that will free you from your labor, when harnessed correctly, is the exact thing you hate.

I think this is easily explained: Sequencing matters. It I lose my job due to AI and it takes just 1-2 years for AI benefits to arrive at my door, that is plenty of time to be very anxious about my life. If I was guaranteed the AI benefits before I potentially lose my job, very different story.

That seems hard to set up, but alas.

jstummbillig··on Kimi K2.6: Advancing open-source coding
At this point it seems more like the result of a psyop to presume that a new anthropic model should be considered vaporware until released.
jstummbillig··on Kimi K2.6: Advancing Open-Source Coding
What?
jstummbillig··on OpenClaw isn't fooling me. I remember MS-DOS
> letting an AI into my comms

Idk, it's strange for me to think of it that way. It's tech. If it does something useful, that's cool.

Data protection is always a consideration. I just don't consider a LLM to be a special case or a person, the same way that I don't have strong feelings about "AI" being applied in google search since forever. I don't have special feelings or get embarrassed by the thought of a LLM touching my mails.

Right now for me, agentic coding is great. I have a hard time seeing a future where the benefits that we experience there will not be more broadly shared. Explorations in that direction is how we get there.

jstummbillig··on Banned by Anthropic?
> It seems that Anthropic is growing so rapidly that they don't really care about losing a few customers here and there with false positives.

While I am convinced that anything can be done better, it seems to me, that it it's close to impossible to do this well. If you look at ~customer service provided by ~FAANG (who had decades to build this out, and none of which had to deal with Anthropic level growth) it's never as good as we would like it to be.

Either they are all terribly incompetent at customer service. Or customer service at super big internal company scale, with tons of small-ish customers, is extremely hard.

jstummbillig··on Measuring Claude 4.7's tokenizer costs
I don't understand how people measure how much more or less work they need to do. It's not that gpt-4o was incapable of exuding enormous amounts of code quickly, it's that the tokens were relativ garbage.

How do you have an opinion on 4.6/4.7 here? It's less clear but I could totally see that 4.7 or beyond leads to project completion 20% faster, by removing dead ends, foot guns, less backtracking, etc.

How to tell / measure effectively? No clue.

jstummbillig··on Claude Opus 4.7 costs 20–30% more per session
"One session" is not a very interesting unit of work. What I am interested in is how much less work I am required to do, to get the results I want.

This is not so much about my instructions being followed more closely. It's the LLM being smarter about what's going on and for example saving me time on unnecessary expeditions. This is where models have been most notably been getting better to my experience. Understanding the bigger picture. Applying taste.

It's harder to measure, of course, but, at least for my coding needs, there is still a lot of room here.

If one session costs an additional 20% that's completely fine, if that session gets me 20% closer to a finished product (or: not 20% further away). Even 10% closer would probably still be entirely fine, given how cheap it is.

jstummbillig··on Cal.com is going closed source
The point is that, as the defender, you only have to find each hole once, while the attacker can spend an infinite amount of tokens trying to find more holes, that are increasingly harder to find and might, eventually, not exist at all. The defender can do that too, of course, but being in the defense, there is value in not being able to uncover new holes (your system keeps working, ostensibly) while as the attacker that's simply how you fail.
jstummbillig··on Cal.com is going closed source
> to harden a system you need to spend more tokens discovering exploits than attackers will spend exploiting them.

That can't be right, can it? Given stable software, the relative attack surface keeps shrinking. Mythos does not produce exploits. Should be defenders advantage, token wise, no?

jstummbillig··on Apple's accidental moat: How the "AI Loser" may end up winning
What world are you living in where the median piece of software has a million users? Or even a hundredth of that?
jstummbillig··on Apple's accidental moat: How the "AI Loser" may end up winning
Creating people able to do these optimizations costs human life, which is not spend on other things, like building the unoptimized version of another product.
jstummbillig··on Apple's accidental moat: How the "AI Loser" may end up winning
People get hung up on bad optimization. It you are the working at sufficiently large scale, yes, thinking about bytes might be a good use of your time.

But most likely, it's not. At a system level we don't want people to do that. It's a waste of resources. Making a virtue out of it is bad, unless you care more about bytes than humans.

jstummbillig··on Starfling: A one-tap endless orbital slingshot game in a single HTML file
Do tell? How did it play the game, did you watch? Just took forever with every shot, or how did that play out with the LLM induced latency?
jstummbillig··on Sam Altman's response to Molotov cocktail incident
> Violence like this is not the answer. However

Sigh

jstummbillig··on OpenAI backs Illinois bill that would limit when AI labs can be held liable
Man, this debate is both very interesting and highly confusing with different people oscillating between "It's just a tool" and "It's a human being+"
jstummbillig··on OpenAI backs Illinois bill that would limit when AI labs can be held liable
> I am very confident when I say that it keeps every single person that works at anti-terrorism units awake.

Wow, that's quite the statement about the excellency of our institutions. Does not seem likely but, what the hell, I'll take my oversized dose of positivity for today!

jstummbillig··on OpenAI backs Illinois bill that would limit when AI labs can be held liable
I am not sure what the other side of this argument looks like: Unlimited liability (i.e. liability no matter how poor an implementation and use of the tech is)?

The would be quite a novel burden, that no other tech (afaik) had to carry so far. We always assumed some operator responsibility. It's interesting to think of AI as a tech that could feasible be able to internally guardrail itself, and, maybe more so with increasing capability, no human can be expected to do so in it's stead – but, surely, some limits must apply and the more interesting question is what they are, as with any other tool?

jstummbillig··on ChatGPT Pro now starts at $100/month
I think you currently can't use pro inside codex, or can you?
jstummbillig··on ChatGPT Pro now starts at $100/month
That is not the "only" thing: You get access to GPT-5.4 pro.
jstummbillig··on Project Glasswing: Securing critical software for the AI era
> The demonstrated ones that they have on the red team blog are neat, the kernel chain is impressive and fun

So by your estimation, for rogue actors being able to uncover hundreds of this class in each major software product roughly for free would not be a big issue?

jstummbillig··on Project Glasswing: Securing critical software for the AI era
Can you explain why they are meaningless without more context?
jstummbillig··on Project Glasswing: Securing critical software for the AI era
> how every new iteration is going to spell doom/be a paradigm shift/change the entire tech industry etc.

It's much the dynamic between parents and a child. The child, with limited hindsight, almost zero insight and no ability to forecast, is annoyed by their parents. Nothing bad ever happens! Why won't parents stop being so worried all the time and make a fuss over nothing?

The parents, which the child somewhat starts to realize but not fully, have no clue what they are doing. There is a lot they don't know and are going to be wrong about, because it's all new to them. But, what they do have is a visceral idea of how bad things could be and that's something they have to talk to their child about too.

In the eyes of the parents the child is % dead all the time. Assigning the wrong % makes you look like an idiot and not being able to handle any % too. In the eyes of the child actions leading to death are not even a concept. Hitting the right balance is probably hard, but not for the reasons the child thinks.

jstummbillig··on Project Glasswing: Securing critical software for the AI era
What? The economic benefit of system critical software not totally breaking in a few weeks goes to roughly everyone. In so far Apple/Google/MS/Linux Foundation economically benefit from being able to patch pressing critical software issues upfront (I am not even exactly sure what that is supposed to mean, it's not like anyone is going to use more or less Windows or Android if this happened any other way), that's a good thing for everyone and the economic benefits of that manifest for everyone.
jstummbillig··on AI singer now occupies eleven spots on iTunes singles chart
How can you say that!? Compared to your GPU, you are terrible at crunching numbers.
jstummbillig··on Sam Altman may control our future – can he be trusted?
It's also not not democracy. It has little to do with a form of government.
jstummbillig··on Caveman: Why use many token when few token do trick
I notice that the number of people confidently talking about "burden of proof" and whose it allegedly is in the context of AI has gone up sharply.

Nobody has to proof anything. It can give your claim credibility. If you don't provide any, an opposing claim without proof does not get any better.

jstummbillig··on Caveman: Why use many token when few token do trick
What do you mean? The page explicitly states:

> cutting ~75% of tokens while keeping full technical accuracy.

I have no clue if this claim holds, but alas, just pretending they did not address the obvious criticism, while they did, is at the very least pretty lazy.

An explanation that explains nothing is not very interesting.

jstummbillig··on Qwen3.6-Plus: Towards real world agents
> Initial reactions are mostly anger from everyone who didn’t realize that the play along was to give away the smaller models as advertising, not because they were feeling generous.

The naivety around this has been staggering quite frankly. All of a sudden, people thinking that meta etc are releasing free models because they believe in open access and distribution of knowledge. No, they just suck comparatively. There is nothing to sell. Using it to recruit and generate attention is the best play for them.

← PreviousPage 14 of 34Next →