HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jstummbillig

6,608 karma · joined February 14, 2015

submissionscomments
jstummbillig··on Only 16 Percent of Americans Think AI Will Have a Positive Impact on Society
Here is a simple and possibly clarifying thought experiment: Would you be willing to switch your standard of living with the standard of the median person living on this planet? (And I would urge you to look up what that looks like, in case you are unsure).

As long as you are not (and I sympathize) I have zero clue how to justify any delay in getting everyone at least to our current level.

I understand that there are risks and we should work hard to guard against them. But no society has seriously considered giving up driving while we figure out global warming. People want a good life, that's just the selfish fucks we are, and it's upon those with clout to will it for everyone.

> Why go from something objective/provable to something that does "strange things", when we already have former?

Because it does something different. It's not from/to. LLMs are subbing in for humans, not for deterministic computing. Replacing deterministic computing with LLMs for tasks that have be perfectly solved without LLMs would be wasteful and silly.

jstummbillig··on Only 16 Percent of Americans Think AI Will Have a Positive Impact on Society
All software written will not disappear. There is nothing keeping us from using partly undeterministic software (see: humans) to write deterministic programs.
jstummbillig··on Only 16 Percent of Americans Think AI Will Have a Positive Impact on Society
By trying! How else is it going to happen? Are we going to deny the immense potential? Nobody needs to draw up a specific plan for that to hold true, we are good at figuring shit out and using tools.

I am not saying it's going to work but we are not getting much smarter right now, and we really need all the help we can get to accelerate more complicated stuff.

And it is accelerating! Will it be as useful as I hope it will be? That is entirely beside the point. This post was not at all about me assigning any chance of the good outcome. Just that there is no other ethical option.

jstummbillig··on Only 16 Percent of Americans Think AI Will Have a Positive Impact on Society
Reality is non-deterministic (not actually, but in practice). We do strange things to balance this out all the time. Thinking that computer software must be exempt from that mess as a goal is just strange, and concerns itself too much with the ideal of a tool and not enough with the more important question: What if our lives get much, much better? Roughly everyone wants more out of life including the top one percent (and I don't mean the top 0.0001%, just your ordinary industrial nation doctors). How could we possibly morally justify denying everyone the best shot to get at least to that level, and I mean living people RIGHT NOW, ASAP not in a few hundred years? Who would be okay to say "yeah but you know, artists, copyright" and deny those who benefit most from this the opportunity?

How could we not take this shot? I understand perfectly well that a lot of things will need reconfiguration and that it's going to be painful, but dear lord, let's focus on making it go well instead of ending it.

jstummbillig··on The founder's playbook: Building an AI-native startup
Why would that be true? Successful founders have to be unsentimental by nature. If you make it harder on yourself than it has to be, you just get killed by people who don't.
jstummbillig··on Stop Killing Games fails to secure EU law despite 1.3M signatures
Why would 1.3M signatures be enough to secure EU law? That is entirely unreasonable and undemocratic, given the small section of the entire EU population that number represents.

The "despite" certainly creates an interesting expectation, though.

jstummbillig··on GPT‑NL: a sovereign language model for the Netherlands
"Champions of a European AI model should ask themselves if a European effort would be more effective than Meta, which this year will spend more on chips ($125 billion) than Germany spends on defense ($114 billion) and offer salaries of over $100 million to attract the best researchers, and is still failing to catch up. Elon Musk tried and failed to build a good AI model."

https://www.siliconcontinent.com/p/nineteen-thoughts-on-ai-a...

jstummbillig··on SpaceX to buy Cursor for $60B
Customers, talent, training data, an increasingly competitive coding model and now a fuckton of compute.

So, you know. Couple of things.

Specially given that coding turns out to not be all that complicated, in the grand scheme of AI things: I don't think it's going take much more advances at the frontier before code writing will be as good as it need to be. At that point Composer (their model) catches up, what, 6 month later and they good.

jstummbillig··on Hetzner Price Adjustment
They are on the linked page?
jstummbillig··on It used to be hard
Why would it? You still need to be able to understand and describe a problem (if the space is complex, that usually means: many connected problems) and that requires good thinking.
jstummbillig··on It used to be hard
I think it mostly got harder? You had relatively clearly defined paths to build a skill that would be valuable. And now you don't. So the skill that you need to learn now is, roughly, figuring out what to do when nobody tells you what to do.
jstummbillig··on Not everyone is using AI for everything
I disagree. Everyone will be using AI for everything, but, increasingly, people won't think about whether they are using "AI" – just like they don't think about using databases.

Nor should they! It's such a shit thing to be emotionally invested in. Imagine people would have been upset about databases. It's really fantastic software and we should be happy to have it, and now go and make the most of it, for all of us.

jstummbillig··on How to earn a billion dollars
So if one finds a way to do it and not hire people they actually earned the money by that definition? We presume that people at large would be ready say "Oh yeah, in that case: You earned that billion dollars for sure, nothing wrong with any of that, go you"?

Whereas: If they hire a single employee to help with, idk, responding to support tickets that would get them into "well maybe you did not earn it"-territory?

Because if that is the depiction we are going with: I have my doubts.

jstummbillig··on How to earn a billion dollars
What if I build and run a SaaS?
jstummbillig··on How to earn a billion dollars
I think this is super interesting (because the answer is not at all obvious to me): What do you mean by "through work alone"? Can it only be work if I can map a human hour cleanly onto someone paying an invoice for that hour?
jstummbillig··on GLM 5.2 Is Out
> When it comes to architecture or complex problems it does noticeable worse but I don't think anyone expected anything else.

So it's not really similar to opus in January?

jstummbillig··on Statement on US government directive to suspend access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5
The EU has elected Orban about as much as the world has elected Trump.
jstummbillig··on If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human effort
This seems akin to hating on a toddler because they can't talk, with the only alternative being pretending that they are great conversationalists. It's a category error.

I don't need a human to be particularly good at anything to like them. Maybe that is how you work, but the idea is just misplaced to me.

jstummbillig··on A low-carbon computing platform from your retired phones
> Phones don't actually get slower, or, they shouldn't, if they are reasonably well maintained.

Relative to ever rising hw requirements of apps they obviously get slower. That is why I personally buy new phones.

jstummbillig··on Statement on US government directive to suspend access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5
Not in the same way, no, because they have not been targeted, while they should have if the same rules applied, according to Anthropic's depiction of the situation.

This is potential tyranny aimed at Anthropic, specifically.

jstummbillig··on Statement on US government directive to suspend access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5
> Anthropic got the most rewarding hype ever in the history of mankind.

What? Anthropic is not a TikTok sensation. It's a business tool. Businesses need to know their tools work reliably.

When you are situated in a banana republic and the chief banana is out to get you (and demonstrates that they can and will on a whim) that is not great hype but a potential death sentence for you as a service provider.

You are one degree away from becoming forever branded as unusable. (Theoretically until people trust that a sane administration is in control again, but that might as well be forever on current AI timelines, given how much cashflow you need just to keep going)

jstummbillig··on Slightly reducing the sloppiness of AI generated front end
I don't think that is true, in the way that it always wasn't: How would you be able to tell when it's done properly?

Think WordPress installations: Depending on how it's done you can either tell at a glance (probably ~90% of WP installations at some points in time) or you have no clue until you look at the html source.

Of course, when given the option to not do it properly is always alluring and then you can tell.

jstummbillig··on If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human effort
That is not how it will play out.

Everyday AI writing was not a thing with GPT 3.5. It happened more around GPT 4o. And now some people are entirely comfortable with using AI writing and not even trying to hide it (while, I would agree, it's obviously still fairly garbage and easily identifiable, which helps with triggering strong averse reactions).

However the models are getting better at everything, including writing for the past years. Why would that stop now? It's reasonable to assume that the makers also know about bad writing, dislike it, and thus the models will get trained to get even better at it.

Eventually how will you be able to tell? You won't. You can't. And that goes for the rest of us. And I suspect everything will just feel somewhat nicer.

jstummbillig··on If you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human effort
I increasingly find that I don't care whether I am talking to an anonymous AI or an anonymous human, and believe that we will increasingly stop caring.

Because why not? AI will simply on average be nicer to talk to than most humans, with clearer thinking and better arguments, less contradictions, and easier to comprehend.

I don't know how humans could compete with that (but it also does not seem all that horrible, given that it will be available to every human.)

This is not to say that this idea is uncomplicated or comfortable, in different ways. Just that I think it's true and that it might even be good.

jstummbillig··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
> Then what is it they are trying to guard against, if its not simply protecting their moat ahead of their IPO?

Let's just assume it was "only" that?

It's unreasonable to assume they are aiming to upset people who are just giving them money in the way they want. It makes no business sense, for any company. So that has to be a byproduct.

Model training is one of the more expensive undertakings in the world right now and distilling models from competitors against the TOS is apparently something that is going on for very little money. Why would they not "just" try to take measures against that?

jstummbillig··on Anthropic apologizes for invisible Claude Fable guardrails
> paternalism isn't a good look.

In isolation it's not, but I think it's somewhat lazy to not talk about what they are trying to guard against, when we are supposedly giving the absolute maximum benefit of doubt.

Are we just concluding "their concerns were never real"? Because that probably runs counter the things that they have been observing and concluding.

jstummbillig··on Why AI hasn't replaced software engineers, and won't
Things are changing at rapid speed, there is nothing "classic" about any of this, and you should at least be able to understand that much if you want to advise people.
jstummbillig··on Claude Desktop spawns 1.8 GB Hyper-V VM on every launch, even for chat-only use
All of these are outstanding! In so far they are not singular or new anymore, well... If for the past ~20 years nobody has come up with something clearly better, then I would say that speaks to how outstanding the product that are being copied are to this day.
jstummbillig··on Claude Desktop spawns 1.8 GB Hyper-V VM on every launch, even for chat-only use
How are Google products anything but outstanding in their categories? What are you comparing to?
jstummbillig··on Claude Fable 5
Eh. Not to me, rest assured. I find humans both comically tragic and incredibly precious.
← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →