HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jtbigwoo

2,243 karma · joined April 20, 2010

submissionscomments
jtbigwoo··on Death to the Gamer
You make a good point, so I'm going to try to refine mine. You're right that a small minority of readers and gamers actually follow criticism compared to reviews. I think the influence of criticism on authors is much much larger than the influence of criticism on game designers, though.

It has to do with the way we train people to write books as opposed to how we train people to make video games. English degree programs often spend as much time on literary theory as they do on the practical aspects of composition. Most CS and video game design programs are almost entirely practical. I think this has allowed literature to move alongside and even in front of the culture at large while video games lag the rest of the culture.

Maybe this explains why we've gotten used to plenty of topics and themes in books that are still stunning in video games. Think about how shocking it was to some people that we could play a gay character in Fable or Bully. Nobody even notices when a best seller has a gay protagonist.

jtbigwoo··on Death to the Gamer
I heard an interview with Ed Begley, Jr. where they talked for twenty minutes about his eco-friendly lifestyle. His house has super-insulated windows, walls, and doors, recycles rainwater, generates power from solar cells and a wind turbine, and has a stationary bike that generates electricity for the kitchen. His yard is planted with drought-tolerant garden of California-native plants. He rides a hybrid-electric bike whenever he can.

Toward the end of the interview, the interviewer, seeming overwhelmed, asked, "Well that's great for you rich guys, but what about us ordinary folk?" (I'm paraphrasing both sides of the conversation here.) Begley said, "You think we started with solar panels in the 1970's? We didn't have any money. I started with rolls of insulation in my attic. Saved me thousands of dollars. Start with something small and inexpensive."

You don't have to be an activist, but if you don't like the way things are, pick one thing that can help. You're right that picking fights with strangers probably won't help. Maybe you have a friend who's a dick online. You and a couple friends can ask him to tone it down. Maybe decide to only offer helpful criticism to newbies for a week and reserving taunting for friends. Pick something small and make the world a little better.

jtbigwoo··on Death to the Gamer
There's a difference between the culture of literature and the culture of gaming. I think it boils down to the difference between reviews and criticism. Games, for the most part, get reviewed. Reviews are functional and focused on consumption. A review seeks to answer a few questions about its subject: Does it work as intended? Is it entertaining? Is it a good value?

Books, on the other hand, sometimes are subject to criticism. Criticism explores, interprets, and analyzes. It asks "why" and "how" questions. The best criticism expands and changes its subject. Literature as a culture has its roots in both original work and criticism. Almost as soon as there were works to read, there was literary criticism. (The Talmud springs to mind as an early example.) Certainly, most readers and many critics are more interested in reviews than criticism, but the feedback from criticism has been fundamental to the development of literature.

This balance makes literary culture much different from gamer culture. Even with games aspire to be art, the reviews go like this:

The game explores themes of identity and abandonment. Who are we and how are we separate from each other? It might be art. The controls are a bit laggy and the game is only two hours long, which isn't great value for $10. I give it an 8 out of 10.

I've read a few game reviews that go farther but these are few and far between. Maybe the recent controversies will start us down a new path.

EDIT: I wish HN had a preview button.

jtbigwoo··on Where does Ruby go from here?
If you're writing a manifesto, you should be able to test future decisions by running them past the criteria in the manifesto. The first four statements are great in that regard, but the next six are a little fuzzy.

It might help if the manifesto is clearer on what you don't value. Mission and vision statements are often meaningless because you can stretch a positive statement to include almost anything. The Agile Manifesto is great because it uses contrast to clarify what it values most.

In some of the statements, the contrast seems to be implicit and that's fine. ("I value an environment conducive to all levels of experience." I assume that means we don't want an environment for only beginners or only experts.)

Other statements, though, are harder to figure out. ("I value software development as a craft." Does HDD cater to "craftsmen" as opposed to hobbyists? Or is this in opposition to "professionals"? Or are we talking about relationships and apprenticeship?)

I think this concept has a ton of potential. Can't wait to see where it goes next.

EDIT: It appears tmorton was thinking the same things and used far fewer words to say it.

jtbigwoo··on Late Bloomers: Why do we equate genius with precocity? (2008)
Many competitive sports are strongly context-dependent, though--just like art. Part of the beauty of basketball, for example, is we will never know if Wilt Chamberlain or Michael Jordan or LeBron James is really the greatest basketball player of all time because they played in different eras. Athletic training was so much different in Chamberlain's era that it's tough to predict if he'd be as dominant today. Even in the early years of Jordan's career, plenty of players didn't lift weights for fear of becoming too bulky.

Sports where competitors are measured against a clock or a tape measure are easier to compare across eras but even then equipment changes make it difficult. Pole vaulting, for example, became a completely different sport when flexible fiberglass poles were introduced. Major track events were still being run on cinder tracks into the 1970's.

jtbigwoo··on Why Working at Google Is Not My Dream Job Anymore
I have first hand experience with the first set and agree. Companies that are paying for dry cleaning, gyms, food, etc. are often expecting to make up for that investment with free labor.
jtbigwoo··on Why Working at Google Is Not My Dream Job Anymore
We often don't understand is that our inaction communicates just as much as our actions and speech do. The difference is that the recipient can interpret inaction to mean whatever they want it to mean. In an interview process, I could interpret silence from HR to mean that the company has moved on when the truth is that the recruiter is on vacation.

Google can obviously get away with this because they're still one of the richest company in the world. When they piss off a candidate, they've got twenty ready to take her place. For those of us at smaller companies, it's crucial that we over-communicate during delays and move decisively when hiring.

jtbigwoo··on Comcast training materials require a "sell" phase, even in support calls
As it's spelled out, I'm not sure I see the problem, either. When I cancelled with Comcast a few years ago, the woman spent a couple minutes inquiring about my issues and offering to take another shot at fixing them. I didn't think that she was being unreasonable. I get more annoyed when the tellers at my bank try to get me to "talk to a banker" every time I stop by. (I'm already in your bank, surrounded by your bankers. Why would I need to be reminded that I could talk to one?)

What I'd like to see from comcast is how they've structured their evaluation metrics and rewards. I suspect that some clever call center folks are artificially inflating their numbers by simply never allowing a customer to cancel.

jtbigwoo··on Scheduling Technology Leaves Low-Income Parents With Hours of Chaos
It's a good thing for you (and all of us) that most people think you're nuts. If the threshold for having a kid was $1MM in the bank, our population would crash and our economy would be doomed.
jtbigwoo··on A Reminder To Investors
Nope. The implication of quid-pro-quo would make any potential date/relationship/other an ethical mess.
jtbigwoo··on Backblaze is building a 270 TB storage pod
I always look forward to backblaze's posts.

Does anybody know if drive manufacturers pay attention to their posts about reliability? I know when I worked with mainframes we sent every bad drive back to IBM for failure analysis, but would Backblaze's aggregate data be useful to somebody like Seagate?

jtbigwoo··on We got our first Delaware tax bill: $74,018.74
>> Even in the case of minor fraud, they would likely spend more in manpower than they could possibly reclaim from such a low-earning outfit.

I think they're counting on the fact that you'll straighten things out and continue paying faithfully for many years after this. Plus, there's a deterrent effect on others who hear the same story.

It's not necessarily worth paying for a security guard to catch the one guy who tries to steal a case of beer. The store pays for the guard to deter theft rather than catch thieves.

jtbigwoo··on We got our first Delaware tax bill: $74,018.74
For me it wasn't even that expensive. I was a one-man operation who did some of my own bookkeeping to keep costs down, but I never spent more than $2000/year on both my accountant and my lawyer.
jtbigwoo··on We got our first Delaware tax bill: $74,018.74
When I was looking, I printed out a list of 5 independent accountants nearest me and set up a half-hour to talk to them. Some have "packages" where they charge a set amount for certain services like helping with quarterly tax filings. In my area, the prices were pretty similar whether they offered pre-set pricing or not. I ended up mostly listening for whether their risk tolerance was the same as mine. Several of them were quite eager to explain the ways that they would stretch the rules to save me money.
jtbigwoo··on I'm getting screwed with my stock options
The OP's language makes it seem like the relationship is already strained and he is isolated from the founders ("half-baked", "shit money", "feeling helpless") while still wanting to continue with the company. This negotiation is wrapped up in two things: 1) the financial issues and 2) the OP's value to the company. I think point 2 is the trickier part. Others have already suggested a few ways that the financial issues could be resolved, but he also has to get his relationship with the founders into a better state. If the relationship stays strained, it's only a matter of time before the next issue sets this whole process off again. Especially when we're feeling isolated, rearranging our own mental state often starts the process of claiming the power to fix the relationship.

Let's say they negotiate and his equity stake is cut back to 8.5% while the others give up 5.25% each. His narrative of the negotiation could be, "They tried to screw me again and I barely held on" or it could be "They gave up more money, I gave up a bigger proportion." Even though the finances don't change, the first response maintains the status quo while second response starts the process of reclaiming the relationship.

(Sorry for the male pronouns if you're not a male, OP. Writing he/she is annoying and I'm lazy.)

jtbigwoo··on Matt Cutts and other tech donors launch CounterPAC
> this has pretty much always been around.

Yep, the difference now is that it's less predictable. In the past if you were a part of the existing power structure you could expect to be safe, even if the political landscape changed under your feet. For example, plenty of powerful white men held pro-segregationist views in the 60's and recanted in the 80's without getting blacklisted.

In constrast, those outside the power structure were not safe. Any views or actions from the past could be resurrected to get them fired or worse when the landscape changed. The beginning of the Hollywood blacklist, for example, was as much about getting rid of Russian Jews as it was about finding communists.

Now it seems that nobody is safe and our political landscape is changing more quickly than ever. That makes it more frightening to step out, especially for those of us like myself (white guys) who had previously been protected implicitly.

jtbigwoo··on Matt Cutts and other tech donors launch CounterPAC
I think the criticism is reasonable, though.

Roemer has been a self-declared Republican for 23 years. Painter seems reasonable and thoughtful, but when making political judgements it's tough to overlook his connection to the Bush administration. Centrist and liberal observers can be forgiven for being suspicious of a committee with two Republicans and a techno-liberal.

I don't envy the people who had to organize this, by the way. Either you set up an odd-numbered panel and expect a bunch of criticism or you setup a even-numbered panel and prepare yourself for stalemates and ineffectiveness. (I suppose you could have a very large odd-numbered panel and hope that the law of averages helps you remain balanced.)

jtbigwoo··on Hachette Puts out Response to Amazon Statement
Unless you own a Kindle Paperwhite.
jtbigwoo··on How Much do Boston UberX Drivers Make in a Night?
Is that 30-40 hours per week or over 12 weeks?
jtbigwoo··on How Much do Boston UberX Drivers Make in a Night?
It's interesting that Durkosh didn't say, "the average driver who works 40 hours/week makes $54,000." I wonder what the average income of those who actually try to work 40+ hours/week are.
jtbigwoo··on How Much do Boston UberX Drivers Make in a Night?
Uber doesn't check up too carefully on its drivers' insurance situation, which helps keep costs down. From other articles, it appears that Uber drivers in general don't pay for appropriate insurance.
jtbigwoo··on How Much do Boston UberX Drivers Make in a Night?
The article did seem oddly biased. It talks only about revenue for the Uber driver and only about costs for the traditional cab drivers. Some costs would be difficult for their driver to figure out (like depreciation), but couldn't they have asked about gas?
jtbigwoo··on Self-storage: The men who got rich selling empty space
I've a storage unit when selling my home. Apparently buyers like to look at nearly-empty shelves and closets.
jtbigwoo··on Self-storage: The men who got rich selling empty space
Downtown Minneapolis had/has the same thing.

The interesting part is that most of the parking lots are owned by groups of moderately wealthy folks (doctors, mid-level corporate execs) who had bought super cheap in the 70's. The income they are able to make risk-free is a huge obstacle to redevelopment.

As an example, there's lot next to my old office that gets about 250 cars into a half-block lot. At six dollars/car/weekday plus extra money on weekends that's about $400k/year before taxes split among a dozen investors. (An incredible yearly return when you consider they probably paid less than $250k to buy a run-down building and level it back in the 70's.)

If somebody wants to buy that lot to build apartments, they're going to have two hurdles.

First, all of these guys are probably retired, so they're looking for risk-free income rather than capital. With interest rates below 3%, they're going to ask for $12 - 15 million so they can invest it in bonds and still get the same income. That's a ton of money just to buy land.

Second, most of these partnership agreements are drafted such that every partner has to agree to sell rather than a majority. If one guy holds out for $20 million, it could scuttle the deal.

Slowly but surely the parking lots are being replaced, but it's happening much more slowly than it should.

jtbigwoo··on Why Bitcoin Can No Longer Work as a Virtual Currency
The IRS doesn't have much leeway here, I suspect. IANAL, but it's my understanding that U.S. laws specify dollars as the only currency of the U.S. If people can invent other currencies that the government is then required to accept as currency, I suspect it would take an overhaul of our laws. (And isn't there something in the constitution about the federal government having sole minting power?)
jtbigwoo··on Why Bitcoin Can No Longer Work as a Virtual Currency
The IRS isn't that concerned about the guy in the next cubicle who owns 2.8 BTC. (Though they'll certainly go after him if they find out he's cheating the government.) This is aimed squarely at:

-big investors (like Goldman Sachs, for example)

-businesses that are trying to do business in bitcoin and might be inclined to push the limits with their accounting

-criminal enterprises trying to hide transactions. Remember they got Capone for tax evasion.

jtbigwoo··on Why Bitcoin Can No Longer Work as a Virtual Currency
The last couple paragraphs of this article are kind of ridiculous.

If the IRS decides that bitcoins are like stocks and bonds, the IRS will accept an average cost basis rather than the user having to account for each individual bitcoin (or fraction of a bitcoin).

If it works like inventory, then the taxpayer will have to decide between several accounting strategies (last-in-first-out or first-in-first-out for example) when deciding cost basis. It's complicated, but it's an order of magnitude easier than what the author is suggesting.

jtbigwoo··on Steve Jobs's response after getting a Google employee fired.
We're getting off-topic, but...

I suspect a decade living like the normal rules don't apply to you will make you think that the rules don't apply to you. Brin, like most executives, probably has an group of people around him invisibly smoothing out his problems and shuttling him past all sorts of obstacles.

I'm basing this on a couple conversations with a retired telecom CEO (Charles) I used to know. Here's what he had:

-If he mentions that someone is bothering him, that person is removed from his presence. (Charles wasn't even aware that this was happening for the first five years of his tenure as CEO--his wife pointed it out to him.)

-There are people who prepare him and make him look good in every conversation. If he doesn't know the answer to a question, he says, "I'll get back to you." Someone else writes the question down and a thoughtful, well-formulated answer appears on his desk the next morning.

-A medical plan that includes a 24/7 on-call doctor. The doctors in his plan specifically take very few patients so Charles and his family can get appointments almost immediately.

-If there's a line or waiting list, he is ushered around the line or someone waits in line on his behalf. Charles literally never waited in line for anything for 15 years.

Charles was thoughtful and empathetic and was lucky to have a wife who kept him grounded. (She would say some variation of, "Don't screw it all up today," as he left the house each morning.) I suspect that most people wouldn't be able to keep a healthy perspective.

Edit: removed an extra word

jtbigwoo··on Steve Jobs's response after getting a Google employee fired.
>> That tells me he's doing the right thing for his company and his shareholders.

Except when he does something illegal that leaves his company vulernable to a massive class-action lawsuit from his own employees. That doesn't seem like the right thing for his company and his shareholders.

Plus, in order to get this conspiracy off the ground and keep it running, he had to produce documentation of the conspiracy that would be embarrassing and possibly incriminating when it was made public. I'm not sure that he did the right thing for his company there.

It's now clear to current and future employees that he has conspired against them with other companies. That doesn't seem so good for his company either.

jtbigwoo··on NSFW Jobs
The most generous I've ever seen in a big company was Wells Fargo offering a 100% match on the first 6%.
← PreviousPage 4 of 17Next →