HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jwarden

518 karma · joined July 6, 2020

Philosophical engineer. Algorithms to fix conversations on the internet. Jonathanwarden.com Social-protocols.org
submissionscomments
jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
The authors of the QF paper describe it as "an extension of the logic of quadratic voting." They involve similar formulas and both are theoretically optimal (or efficient), and have a single equilibrium. These properties are proven using somewhat similar math.

But they apply to quite different settings and are not really the same thing. With Quadratic Voting, people pay for votes (with cost determined by a certain formula). With Quadratic Funding, people contribute to projects (with matching funds determined by a certain formula).

QV also makes many assumptions that rarely hold in reality, just like QF does. I may write an article about this someday.

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
Yes, as you (sarcastically) imply people do indeed try to use QF to make actual decisions, not recognizing the proofs are based on assumptions that don't match reality.

There's nothing wrong with making proofs based on simplifying assumptions. A lot of incremental progress is made that way. The problem is not the QF theory, it is that people are using QF in the real world because they think it has all these great theoretical properties in the real world -- not recognizing that the underlying assumptions are unrealistic.

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
What straw man? The assumptions underlying the theory of QF are spelled out cleanly in the original QF paper. The article is just enumerating these assumptions and showing they don't hold in reality.

The numbers in the example are indeed impossible to measure. But QF is claiming *optimality* -- that it maximizes social welfare -- when certain assumptions hold. To show that QF does not maximize social welfare when these assumptions don't hold, it suffices to show a single hypothetical counterexample.

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
> Do you have any evidence that these supposed assumptions exist?

By existing, so you mean “hold in reality?”

The point of the article is that the assumption that underly QF do not hold in reality.

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
> Pillaging these funds seems like it's almost a trivial endeavor assuming

It is, and in fact the authors point this out in the original paper:

"…if the size of this group is greater than 1/α and the group can perfectly coordinate, there is no limit (other than the budget) to how much it can steal."

> I have to say that the biggest flaw I see isn't theoretical, it's practical.

Exactly. The theory is fine -- given all these assumptions hold. In practice, these assumption don't hold.

For example, one of the assumptions is absence of sybil attacks, fraud, or collusion. Obviously, these assumptions may not hold.

You can defend against sybil attacks in various ways. But how do you stop people from colluding (e.g. I $10 to 1000 friends, tell them they can keep $5 if they contribute $5 to my project)? There are collusion-resistant forms of quadratic funding, such as COCM, but these do not have the desirable theoretical properties (such as optimality) that vanilla QF has.

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
> accepting the social and individual utility of enjoying the arts, but denying any such utility for enjoying the saved lives

But in the part of the article you quoted above, the author (me) specifically acknowledges the utility of enjoying saved lives. But this is a critique of the quadratic funding mechanism, which is a public goods funding mechanism meant to maximize the utility each individual independently derives from enjoying public good.

The whole point of the article is to critique this assumption -- to point out that people's motives are sometimes altruistic (they derive utility just from knowing other people benefit), but the optimality of QF assumes this vicarious utility does not exist. As the article states "When individuals make contributions for purely altruistic reasons, they don’t directly experience the utility themselves. And yet the optimality of QF assumes that all utility is direct utility, benefiting the contributor only."

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
QF makes assumptions like this, but it's not because the authors assume these assumptions reflect reality. They are just simplifying assumptions that allow formal proof of properties like optimality.

Also this article is explicitly challenging these assumptions.

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
> levels the playing field by a factor of 10 versus the starting point.

Let's say there were only 10 poor people that contributed to the pipes. The total funding would be $10,000 -- a subsidy of $9,000. So 10x multiplier both for the pipes and the art.

Then let's also say that the marginal utility of $100 for a poor person is equivalent to the marginal utility of $1,000,000 for a rich person.

So we have the same number of contributors for each project, but a much higher marginal utility-per-dollar for lead pipes. But the socially optimal funding would be at the point where the marginal utility-per-dollar are equal for both projects (per the Equimarginal Principle).

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
Well it's also unfair if we assume large difference in the marginal utility of wealth -- for example to go to extremes, we might assume that a $10 contribution from a low-income individuals represents the same sacrifice as a $1,000,000 contribution from a high-income individual. If that were the case, a $100 contribution from a low-income individual represents 10x the utility of a $1,000,000 contribution from a high-income individual. So in that case the lead would pipes have both more contributors, and higher utility per contributor, than the art. So total utility would be maximized by giving more money to the lead pipes.
jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
Yes good point. We'd have to actually flesh out the assumptions about marginal utility of wealth for low-income vs. the high-income group (as well as assumptions about individual utility functions), to demonstrate that this outcome was not optimal. I didn't do that in this article because it gets too mathy.

However, the optimality of QF does assume wealth equality. When you drop that assumption and assume diminishing marginal utility of wealth, you can show that QF is not optimal.

But I think you are right that the example in this article doesn't necessarily show that clearly. The example leans heavily on intuition (or emotional appeal). I think I will try to improve that section.

jwarden··on Why Quadratic Funding Is Not Optimal
Oh right: (sqrt(.01) * 1000000)^2 = 1.0e10
jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
great quote
jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
Yep. QF basically assumes that subsidies are "free money", as discussed in the article:

https://jonathanwarden.com/quadratic-funding-is-not-optimal/...

In the original paper, the authors acknowledge this is a problem: "...once we account for the deficit, the QF mechanism does not yield efficiency.

jwarden··on Why quadratic funding is not optimal
In the example in the article, many more people did contribute to the lead pipes (100 people vs. 10 for the art museum). And they still get only a fraction of the funding that the art museum gets.

Agree, coordination is a larger threat to QF. But this issue has been discussed extensively. In this article I wanted to point out all the other assumptions behind QF and what happens when they don't hold.

jwarden··on Why Quadratic Funding Is Not Optimal
Total funding in this case would be: (sqrt(.01) * 1000000)^2 = 10 trillion dollars.
jwarden··on Why Quadratic Funding Is Not Optimal
Here's a very brief summary of what Quadratic Funding is (which is distinct from Quadratic Voting):

Quadratic Funding is a mechanism where individuals voluntarily contribute funds for some public good (e.g. an open source software project), and then these are matched such that the total funding amount is equal to the square of the sum of the square roots of the individual contributions. Under certain assumptions, this formula results in an optimal outcome, where each individual contributes an amount that maximizes their individual utility (given what others are contributing), and total utility for society is also maximized.

jwarden··on Derivation and Intuition behind Poisson distribution
I don’t use probability distributions in everyday life ;)

But it is the right distribution to represent uncertainty about the probability of binary events (eg a website user clicking some button). For example, if I have absolutely no idea the probability then I use the uniform distribution, Beta(1,1), which is the maximum entropy distribution. Then if I observe one user and they happen to click, I have Beta(2,1), and at a glance I known the mean of that (2/3) which is a useful point estimate.

jwarden··on Evolving OpenAI's Structure
Brand counts for a lot
jwarden··on Derivation and Intuition behind Poisson distribution
The way, I understand it is that with a Poisson process, at every small moment in time there’s a small chance of the event happening. This leads to on average lambda events occurring during every (larger) unit of time.

But this process has no “memory” so no matter how much time has passed since the last event, the number of events expected during the next unit of time is still lambda.

jwarden··on Derivation and Intuition behind Poisson distribution
> What am I missing?

Beta

jwarden··on How to live an intellectually rich life
I have never heard that book described as approachable.
jwarden··on What Is Entropy?
Here's my own approach to explaining entropy as a measure of uncertainty: https://jonathanwarden.com/entropy-as-uncertainty
jwarden··on Millions are visiting the European Alternatives site. What trends are we seeing?
When politicians pick fights with leaders of other nations, the people don't have to go along with them.
jwarden··on The Cult of the American Lawn
I am surprised by this negative attitude towards HOAs. In my experience they have been absolutely necessary and helpful. I own a condo. The HOA maintains the exterior of the buildings, the shared driveway including snow removal, the landscaping. Every cent I pay in HOA fees is accounted for. The HOA board are other owners who work for free.

I have also heard of badly run and even fraudulent HOAs, that take money and then don’t use it for the good of the homeowners. But I doubt this is the norm.

jwarden··on Layoffs Don't Work
This article’s main point is that companies who do layoffs subsequently have poor financial performance relative to companies who don’t.

Well obviously.

It’s like saying surgery doesn’t work, because people who have recently undergone surgery are more likely to be experiencing health issues.

jwarden··on The housing theory of everything (2021)
It sounds like you are not considering rental income (the argument I made in my original comment). You only need growth of rental income to exceed growth of cost for it to be profitable to be a landlord. Am I incorrect?
jwarden··on The Housing Theory of Everything (2021)
Okay but I think we’ve lost the thread of the argument.

I am arguing against the claim "Housing can be affordable or it can be a good investment. Not both."

You support this claim with the argument that “If something goes up more than inflation - it is a good investment” and therefore it can’t be affordable.

I am saying real estate can be a good investment even if it doesn’t go up more than inflation. Do you disagree?

Further, for landlords to make homes available to rent, housing must be a good investment. Do you disagree?

jwarden··on The housing theory of everything (2021)
> If something goes up more than inflation - it is a good investment

It’s not that simple. First, risk is a also factor. But a real estate investor is not just looking for capital gains. They are looking at rent yields against costs (taxes, insurance, maintenance, interest).

Real estate can be a good investment even without appreciation in real terms. And that is a good thing.

Real estate investors play an important role in society. Without landlords, it would be impossible to rent a home. So anyone without the ability to purchase a home would have to rely on friends and family or charity, or sleep in the street.

jwarden··on Trump will kill CHIPS Act by gutting NIST employees
Taiwan is not some small random island in the Pacific. It is a country of 23 million people, one of the best-functioning democracies in the world, and the only Mandarin-speaking democracy. It would be a tragic loss for the world if it were swallowed by the PRC.

Is it important enough to start WWIII. That’s another question.

jwarden··on Barcelona buys apartment building at center of eviction protests
I am Spanish, and I can tell you there is a lot of Spanish media claiming rent control is making things worse in the cities that implemented it. Just do a Google search from within Spain: almost all the results discuss negative impact.

Try this search search: control de alquiler barcelona efectos

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →