1,896 karma · joined March 14, 2009
What about this is embarrassing? Do you fee that women don't deserve the same high paying jobs as men?
It seems you are demonizing an article for saying the exact same thing that you are...
Maybe you're suggesting the wolves would forget how to hunt because they are constantly being fed by ranchers? This might be possible.
Either way, the key to implementing a policy like this would be testing it out with a small subset of Wyoming and measuring it's effects. Also, one should be careful not to over incentivize ranchers towards feeding wolves, but compensate them justly.
The EFF seems like a good choice. In general you would need to pick an organization that does not have a vested interest in using exploits.
I'm not a professional researcher, but here's what I gather from reading other articles:
One major problem with image recognition in machines is that while they are generally able to recognize real images correctly, they are 1) Easily fooled 2) Unable to have human-type image understanding. For example, you can recognize an animated character as a human, even though you may never have seen that particular style of drawing before.
One major problem that people realized is that deep neural networks have a tendency to recognize individual facets, for example, a nose. So if you want a neural network to believe something is a human, pepper it with as many noses as you can. It knows that humans have noses so the more noses the more human it must be. Of course, if we saw an image like this we wouldn't think that it was a human because we know a human has only one nose.
To me it seems the primary thrust of this research is to generate a NN that can recognize, like a human, that if an entity has 10 eyes, it's probably not a cat. This is alluded to with the house of horrors cat photographs at the beginning of the article. You can see that when passed an image of a cat with 3 eyes, this neural network correctly removed one of the eyes to make it more realistic.
Here is an article explaining this problem: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1412.1897.pdf
In fact I remember talking to an ML guy with a PHD who was working on one of these types of problems and I asked "why not try NNs on this problem". He looked at me with disgust and said something akin to "it's provable that NNs can never do better than BOOST, so why use them?"
However, boosted decision trees don't work on image analysis at all, so these types of problems have become the standard for NNs.
It is also worth noting that people are more likely to try image problems if everyone else is trying image problems, because then it is easy to compare multiple algorithms together.
You have to wonder whether Sony is using the same strategy to generate more long term interest in a product that was "sold out" and "scarce".
> unavoidable byproducts of enzyme function, for example, or of protein-to-protein interactions, errors in DNA transcription or translation.
One would surmise that aging adds "bad chemicals" to your body at some set rate. If you ALSO eat old things, that are already full of these "bad chemicals", your body will acquire these bad chemicals faster (because of the extra source).
In short, this research shows that there is some byproduct of the aging process that can be transferred from one organism to another and cause aging in the second organism.
Part 1 (How I made my manager hate me): I insisted that we have better performance and everyone told me to f* off, so I went above my manager and now she hates me. (This is reasonable of her)
Par 2 She asks me to commit a crime and I raise it with HR, etc.
There are around 100 billion neurons in the brain and 100 trillion synapses. This indicates to me that synapses may be more important to biological neural networks than neurons are, and yet most ANN research has been focused exclusively on neurons (I once asked my teacher which neurons to connect to each other and recommended using a GA, which is not a bad idea but it indicates to me we have a very poor understanding of how synapses aught to work to make better ANNs.)
I disagree with the overly pessimistic view of this article however. To say that our standard neural networks are not nearly as complex as biological ones would be accurate, but this hardly means that ANNs are doomed forever, we just need more research into the things that matter.
Sometimes when I'm programming at work I need to add log messages to every method on a large interface (or several interfaces). It is obvious to me that there needs to be some tool or library that adds these very simple log messages to these methods for me (like "Entering method getUser(UserId=2701, SessionId='AABCF')").
The tool we have at work uses runtime generated code to add these messages to methods automatically. Besides the performance hit this is fine, except for one problem. Sometimes it doesn't work; and it is impossible to figure out why. You turn on the tool, add all the right metadata, and nothing happens. You could argue that it is a tool problem, but I think one of the big things is that runtime generated code is just vastly inferior to compile time generated code.
If I were using go, my tool would open the code, read the interfaces, and spit out a nice implementation of logging in a .generated.go file and if it doesn't work for some reason I can actually go look at the generated code and see why. Trying to figure out why an implementation isn't working by looking at it's dynamically generated bytecode or .net clr is not fun at all.
http://thebestforumever.com/community/threads/tachyon-pistol...
Also, I've never understood how the Novikov self-consistency principle would work in reality. Causality violations can be a lot simpler than killing your grandfather. Say, for example, you set up a pool table with a pool ball and hit it through a time machine such that it went back in time and hit itself, making it miss the time machine? Would the pool ball be suddenly acted on by some invisible force? Would it explode? Would the universe just end? The whole scenario seems so implausible that addressing this theoretical concern is a lot more relevant than worrying about the energy levels required to manipulate space time.
This author seems to believe that experience in programming essentially boils down to experience in a language. That a 10 year veteran java programmer will have to start over from scratch if they switch to programming in c#. Totally untrue. Experience in programming makes you better at design, project planning, professional relationships, and project delivery. None of these have anything to do with what language you use.
Perhaps what he's trying to say is that if you are a terrible programmer with very low intelligence, your experience won't get you very far. And with that I agree. This author has done little but show he has low skill in the field, so it's unsurprising he finds his work to be below par.
Of course, there are some things for which no amount of apology could ever bring about true forgiveness (think godaddy). I personally don't feel this is one of those times, but everyone is entitled to their opinion.
EDIT: Switching "amoral" to "immoral"