HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jxcole

1,896 karma · joined March 14, 2009

I had a dream, which was not all a dream. The bright sun was extinguish'd, and the stars Did wander darkling in the eternal space
submissionscomments
jxcole··on Arrest of WannaCry researcher sends chill through security community
I don't think that's what these researchers are saying. I think they are saying more along the lines of: "Hutchins has shown that he is a security researcher through his work on wannacry. As a security researcher, he probably has researched other problems as well, possibly including Kronos. The fact that he was arrested with little to no evidence could be showing that the DOJ is willing to arrest people who have copies of virus source code on their computers, even if they only accessed it for research purposes. In fact he may have updated Kronos code or written some part of Kronos as part of research to validate a hypothesis or test a theory. Such actions are ordinary actions for researchers, so this puts at risk most computer security research across the world."
jxcole··on When all job differences are accounted for, the pay gap almost disappears
You summarize the exact point of the article perfectly: women are paid less not because they have the same job and are paid less, but because they are offered different jobs which pay less. To address sexism we should focus on making sure women have the same opportunities to do the same job that men do, rather than just trying to make sure everyone in a certain job category is paid the same.

What about this is embarrassing? Do you fee that women don't deserve the same high paying jobs as men?

It seems you are demonizing an article for saying the exact same thing that you are...

jxcole··on Pik – a new lossy image format for the internet
Can anyone explain if there is something particularly new or interesting about this image format? Or do I have to read the source code?
jxcole··on Wyoming's War on Wolves
It wouldn't really be a Cobra Effect. In the Cobra Effect, the net number of Cobras (which were trying to be eliminated) was increased instead of decreased. If farmers start breeding livestock intentionally to be eaten by wolves, it's hard to see how this would have a net negative effect on the wolf population.

Maybe you're suggesting the wolves would forget how to hunt because they are constantly being fed by ranchers? This might be possible.

Either way, the key to implementing a policy like this would be testing it out with a small subset of Wyoming and measuring it's effects. Also, one should be careful not to over incentivize ranchers towards feeding wolves, but compensate them justly.

jxcole··on Thousands of Veterans Want to Learn to Code But Can’t
But what you're talking about is more like a club for new coders (which is a good idea). This guy was specifically looking for coding schools, which I assume are online only (so no classroom atmosphere).
jxcole··on What Happens When You Send a Zero-Day to a Bank?
While it may be true that in this particular instance the FBI might act benevolently, the idea was that it would be nice if there was an organization you could go to with any zero day bug. Even if the FBI is not mismanaged and always tries to protect Americans, you could easily imagine a scenario where someone reports an exploit to an OS where anyone can remotely install a key logger. The FBI wouldn't be a good organization to report this to because they may want to use this to track down criminals which, they would no doubt feel, would greatly outweigh the cost to Americans that the zero day represents.

The EFF seems like a good choice. In general you would need to pick an organization that does not have a vested interest in using exploits.

jxcole··on Teaching Machines to Draw
TLDR: The point is to correct a known flaw with image recognition algorithms.

I'm not a professional researcher, but here's what I gather from reading other articles:

One major problem with image recognition in machines is that while they are generally able to recognize real images correctly, they are 1) Easily fooled 2) Unable to have human-type image understanding. For example, you can recognize an animated character as a human, even though you may never have seen that particular style of drawing before.

One major problem that people realized is that deep neural networks have a tendency to recognize individual facets, for example, a nose. So if you want a neural network to believe something is a human, pepper it with as many noses as you can. It knows that humans have noses so the more noses the more human it must be. Of course, if we saw an image like this we wouldn't think that it was a human because we know a human has only one nose.

To me it seems the primary thrust of this research is to generate a NN that can recognize, like a human, that if an entity has 10 eyes, it's probably not a cat. This is alluded to with the house of horrors cat photographs at the beginning of the article. You can see that when passed an image of a cat with 3 eyes, this neural network correctly removed one of the eyes to make it more realistic.

Here is an article explaining this problem: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1412.1897.pdf

jxcole··on Unpaired Image-to-Image Translation using Cycle-Consistent Adversarial Networks
There are many good answers already, but my two cents is that there are many standard statistical methods that work on basic "data" type problems. If your data is spreadsheet type data, where it has some number of basic float inputs that lead to some float result, you will probably use ordinary statistical methods like boost. NNs might be able to achieve the same results but they probably won't do much better.

In fact I remember talking to an ML guy with a PHD who was working on one of these types of problems and I asked "why not try NNs on this problem". He looked at me with disgust and said something akin to "it's provable that NNs can never do better than BOOST, so why use them?"

However, boosted decision trees don't work on image analysis at all, so these types of problems have become the standard for NNs.

It is also worth noting that people are more likely to try image problems if everyone else is trying image problems, because then it is easy to compare multiple algorithms together.

jxcole··on Popularity of Sony’s PlayStation VR Surprises Even the Company
There is a known strategy in politics to intentionally book rooms for speeches that are too small for the number of people who will show up. That way the next day the newspapers will talk about how people were standing in the aisles just to see the politician.

You have to wonder whether Sony is using the same strategy to generate more long term interest in a product that was "sold out" and "scarce".

jxcole··on Seven earth-sized planets discovered circling a star 39 light years from Earth
It's 39 light years so no fewer than 39 years from our perspective. The closer to the speed of light the travelers are the less time will appear to have elapsed from their perspective. If you had rockets that could instantaneously accelerate to infinitessimally close to the speed of light, no time at all would appear to have elapsed from the travelers perspective (or no time that they would notice), but this is very unlikely.
jxcole··on “Old” Food Reduces Lifespan
Not really a specialist or anything, but I surmised that aging creates what you could call "bad chemicals" in your body.

> unavoidable byproducts of enzyme function, for example, or of protein-to-protein interactions, errors in DNA transcription or translation.

One would surmise that aging adds "bad chemicals" to your body at some set rate. If you ALSO eat old things, that are already full of these "bad chemicals", your body will acquire these bad chemicals faster (because of the extra source).

In short, this research shows that there is some byproduct of the aging process that can be transferred from one organism to another and cause aging in the second organism.

jxcole··on Letter to Amazon Board from Fired Ad Exec
That's right he didn't. The OP didn't quite do the TL;DR right, really the letter goes something like this:

Part 1 (How I made my manager hate me): I insisted that we have better performance and everyone told me to f* off, so I went above my manager and now she hates me. (This is reasonable of her)

Par 2 She asks me to commit a crime and I raise it with HR, etc.

jxcole··on Jeff Hawkins on the Limitations of Artificial Neural Networks
I am by no means an AI professional or neurobioligist, but I have read recently that a major problem with neural networks is that they do not have glial cells which, among other things, move synapses around and helps with synapse growth.

There are around 100 billion neurons in the brain and 100 trillion synapses. This indicates to me that synapses may be more important to biological neural networks than neurons are, and yet most ANN research has been focused exclusively on neurons (I once asked my teacher which neurons to connect to each other and recommended using a GA, which is not a bad idea but it indicates to me we have a very poor understanding of how synapses aught to work to make better ANNs.)

I disagree with the overly pessimistic view of this article however. To say that our standard neural networks are not nearly as complex as biological ones would be accurate, but this hardly means that ANNs are doomed forever, we just need more research into the things that matter.

jxcole··on Pianist asks Washington Post to remove review under 'right to be forgotten'
You cannot actually be harmed by speech, and you certainly can't be harmed by a piano review. The EU has ruled wrong in this case.
jxcole··on What if successful startups are just lucky?
Sorry, not an expert and I have never been an entrepreneur so forgive me if I am misunderstanding, but doesn't YC give them money? In order for this statement to be true either (1) having startup seed money has no bearing on success or (2) YC gives the same money to people it rejects as to people it accepts.
jxcole··on The 19-year-old jailed for the crime of sarcasm
Hate to downvote an otherwise very informative post, but tech literacy is not an issue here. If this was a hundred years before facebook existed and someone joked "Oh yes I'm insane, I am going to stab a hundred babies...ha ha ha" it would be the exact same issue.
jxcole··on Why I Like Go
I would like to add one other thing I like about go: There is a parser and an abstract syntax tree in the standard library.

Sometimes when I'm programming at work I need to add log messages to every method on a large interface (or several interfaces). It is obvious to me that there needs to be some tool or library that adds these very simple log messages to these methods for me (like "Entering method getUser(UserId=2701, SessionId='AABCF')").

The tool we have at work uses runtime generated code to add these messages to methods automatically. Besides the performance hit this is fine, except for one problem. Sometimes it doesn't work; and it is impossible to figure out why. You turn on the tool, add all the right metadata, and nothing happens. You could argue that it is a tool problem, but I think one of the big things is that runtime generated code is just vastly inferior to compile time generated code.

If I were using go, my tool would open the code, read the interfaces, and spit out a nice implementation of logging in a .generated.go file and if it doesn't work for some reason I can actually go look at the generated code and see why. Trying to figure out why an implementation isn't working by looking at it's dynamically generated bytecode or .net clr is not fun at all.

jxcole··on Microsoft's HTML5 Games Resource
An aside: I find that this site looks absolutely beautiful on my phone.
jxcole··on Warp Drive May Be More Feasible Than Thought, Scientists Say
A lot of people responding to this thread do not understand relativity. The OP is correct, the fundamental problem is causality, relativity and FTL do not mix. The common way of saying it is that you can have two of the three: FTL, causality, or relativity. You cannot have all three. Here is a very nice explanation of why:

http://thebestforumever.com/community/threads/tachyon-pistol...

Also, I've never understood how the Novikov self-consistency principle would work in reality. Causality violations can be a lot simpler than killing your grandfather. Say, for example, you set up a pool table with a pool ball and hit it through a time machine such that it went back in time and hit itself, making it miss the time machine? Would the pool ball be suddenly acted on by some invisible force? Would it explode? Would the universe just end? The whole scenario seems so implausible that addressing this theoretical concern is a lot more relevant than worrying about the energy levels required to manipulate space time.

jxcole··on Apple's New Pinch-To-Zoom Monopoly is Bad News
And yet the wright brothers were not granted a patent on "things that fly". They were granted patents on some specific machines they invented that could fly. But the patents were about the mechanical machines themselves. If someone else had come along and invented a totally different means of flying (like a helicopter) they would not have been infringing on their patents. This is a patent on "things that fly".
jxcole··on Why Explore Space? A 1970 Letter to a Nun in Africa.
I don't know if this makes me cruel, but whenever people talk about donating money to starving children in Africa, I always imagine the following: If I were to donate some amount of money to starving children in an impoverished nation every year I could, theoretically, bring some of them out of starvation. However, these children would then grow into adults, and then these adults would have children of their own. The number of these new children would almost certainly be higher than the number I originally helped bring out of famine, so at that point there would be just as many if not more starving children than we had to begin with. So in my mind the question really goes the other way, how does donating money to buy food for starving children in Africa improve Africa's condition in the long term? What problems caused these nations to produce more children than food and what is being done to eliminate the source of these problems, rather than just the symptoms?
jxcole··on I build High Availability Platforms so Cloud is not for me
I think the real reason people like Amazon cloud is for people like me who are decent programmers but who don't know or don't want to know how the system works internally. This guy sounds like he has a lot of what I would call "ops" knowledge which is great for him, but if I decided to start running my own website today I probably wouldn't have the chance to learn all of that stuff.
jxcole··on 9 year old's DIY Cardboard Arcade gets Flash mobbed: Video
I disagree. If you live any where near a university, you can usually walk right into their library, even if you aren't part of the university. I don't do it on a regular basis, but the breadth of knowledge available at say, the UW, library is vastly greater than whatever Sir Isaac Newton had access to.
jxcole··on HaXe - Code Once. Deploy Everywhere.
Having been writing in Haxe for a long time, I think the "Code once deploy everwhere" line is an exaggeration. However, it is a nice framework and has some advantages. In Haxe, you can easily break out into the native language with c-like # compiler directives, so you can do #if platform=ipod. Now, this isn't a perfect solution but it does mean that you can keep a good portion of your code the same source which could save you some time. For certain elements like the UI, though, you probably have to write a custom version for each platform no matter what programming language you use.
jxcole··on Why a career in computer programming sucks [2007]
This is one of the stupidest articles I've ever read. Any half decent programmer, regardless of his experience level (just graduated from college to veteran 60 year old) can learn and be effective in programming a completely new language in one week (please note that when I say completely new I mean within the family of c-like languages). After one month, he'll have most of the libraries memorized.

This author seems to believe that experience in programming essentially boils down to experience in a language. That a 10 year veteran java programmer will have to start over from scratch if they switch to programming in c#. Totally untrue. Experience in programming makes you better at design, project planning, professional relationships, and project delivery. None of these have anything to do with what language you use.

Perhaps what he's trying to say is that if you are a terrible programmer with very low intelligence, your experience won't get you very far. And with that I agree. This author has done little but show he has low skill in the field, so it's unsurprising he finds his work to be below par.

jxcole··on Canadian Digs Out Basement Using Only Radio Controlled Scale Tractors and Trucks
The fact that he was able to do it at all means that this should be a logical next step. There may even be a business idea here. Program good enough Computer Vision and planning AI you could loan a set of autonomous robots to someone and pick them up after 6 months when the job is complete. It would probably be much cheaper than the human alternative.
jxcole··on How Far Can You Get From McDonald's?
Not only is this an interesting factoid, but the author is also a very good writer. I recommend reading the follow up articles.
jxcole··on We are sorry
You seem to define a mistake as 'an error in the code'. However, their use of the term mistake to be 'an error in judgement' or 'an error in the value of user's privacy', is also valid. When someone does something immoral, saying that it was a mistake because they didn't think it was immoral at the time (but now they realise it is) can, in many situations, be a good response.

Of course, there are some things for which no amount of apology could ever bring about true forgiveness (think godaddy). I personally don't feel this is one of those times, but everyone is entitled to their opinion.

EDIT: Switching "amoral" to "immoral"

jxcole··on Farewell Stack Exchange
I deeply respect Jeff's decision to put his family first. I have a general question though. I am an ordinary programmer at an ordinary job working ordinary hours. From those of you who have started their own project full time, is it impossible to run a start up and work ordinary hours? Or is it really necessary to sacrifice all other aspects of your life to be successful?
jxcole··on You’ll Download Physical Objects Sooner Than You Think
While it's an interesting subject, this article is terrible. No actual news was contained within. A bunch of hyperbole about what "might" happen, without any evidence besides hearsay. Your time would be better spent reading the wikipedia article:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3D_printer

← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →