HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jyunwai

2,078 karma · joined June 23, 2023

From/Du Canada.

Submissions I've made that led to my favourite discussions:

1) AI Detection Tools Falsely Accuse International Students of Cheating (Aug 2023) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37127003

2) The Philosophy of Humor: What Makes Something Funny? (Oct 2023): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38049451

3) How to delete your data from data brokers (Jan 2024): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38990755

4) Hospitals that make profits should pay taxes (Apr 2024): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40032233

5) Grief is not a process with five stages. It is shattered glass (Jun 2024): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40717448

submissionscomments
jyunwai··on Feynman's Garden
A lack of necessary prior knowledge is often a major reason for struggling with a problem. As a relatable example, suppose you're taking an exam. There's a problem near the end that you don't know how to solve—and the reason is that you haven't studied that topic enough. No matter how smart (as in, fast at learning) you are, you need to practice with similar or related problems to solve that issue.

But suppose you're outside of an exam environment and have time to look up the relevant material. I've known a PhD candidate in a non-mathematics field who had to find a mathematical solution to a certain research problem. That person is smart but still needed a few months to learn the mathematical fundamentals to understand and solve the problem. In contrast, someone with a math background could have solved this far more quickly. But that person would have taken at least some months to get up to speed on the research literature for the non-mathematics part of the research problem, in order to properly understand its constraints and bigger-picture significance.

Lara Alcock's book "How to Study as a Mathematics Major" touches upon this topic more directly. She encourages readers not to be too intimidated if other students in a course seem really smart: much of the time, the reason is not due to an innate difference in smartness, but rather prior exposure by other students to concepts in the course. Students who seem to find the material effortless often have already studied many of the topics in another course or could even be retaking the course after a previous attempt.

jyunwai··on Feynman's Garden
For insomnia and sleep problems, a good approach is to try out additional techniques from the lists in CBT-I (Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy-Insomnia) treatment manuals. This is a well-studied, non-medication approach, with large parts that a person can learn independently.

A specific technique that helped me was to challenge the thought that "If I don't sleep for 8 hours, the following day will be ruined," as that was a common thought that kept me up. There are a couple of PDFs of treatment manuals online that list the techniques:

UNC School of Medicine: https://www.med.unc.edu/neurology/wp-content/uploads/sites/7...

United States Veterans Affairs: https://www.mirecc.va.gov/docs/visn6/Improve_Your_Sleep_Self...

jyunwai··on Google delays third-party cookie demise yet again
Previous discussion on an older decision in 2021 to extend the deadline to 2023: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27617620
jyunwai··on Chemists Invent Drugs and Drugs Save Lives
Chemistry has been uniquely difficult as a subject to study in my view. You need to be good at all of memorization, problem-solving with theory, and laboratory experiment: it's difficult to succeed with a weakness in any one of these. Though one could technically try to be a computational chemist for people who didn't enjoy the experimental work, you'd still have to go through a lot of labwork as a student. I have a special respect for people who've succeeded as chemists as a result.

Also, as a side note of personal curiosity that's on a bit of a tangent in case anyone with experience in chemistry is reading this: I heard an anecdote about improving results in teaching labs once that I've thought about from time to time, but I'm not sure if it's credible.

A chemistry undergraduate was running experiments at a teaching lab, when he decided to go the extra mile and look up how to calibrate his equipment. He then calibrated his equipment carefully before running the rest of his experiments each time that semester. His experimental results were so consistently close to the theoretical results, that he was accused of falsifying data by his instructor (though ultimately, he didn't receive any penalties). Would this be plausible, or a tall tale? I was always wondering since then, if taking the time to calibrate all of one's tools before an experiment could have such a big impact for experimenters—or alternatively, if the student actually was manipulating the data. But then again, maybe this was some kind of statistical fluke, and he attributed the randomness to his calibrations.

jyunwai··on Chemists Invent Drugs and Drugs Save Lives
A software developer who earned a Bachelor's in chemistry once told me that he didn't find that the pay in chemistry was worthwhile considering the expertise and training involved. He said that the most available job for chemical research for someone with a Bachelor's was as a lab technician, which roughly earns about $40,000 USD a year: not bad, but far below an engineering or computer science graduate, despite the comparable difficulty for completing the degree.

For chemists who complete a doctorate, a brief search shows that a PhD graduate (after 4–7+ years of low pay as a graduate student after a Bachelor's) can plausibly earn about $125,000 USD with some luck as a starting salary as a scientist in industry. A Master's graduate can likely earn close to that. But I've heard that the job market is tougher for research positions—a fair number of people switch into other fields such as medical device sales and sales engineering (with eye-wateringly large salaries of plausibly greater than $400,000 USD a year from what I've heard), data science, or software.

But careers aren't only about the money, though. It sounds like the author of the submitted article has lived a fulfilling life without a primary focus on salary, and it certainly looks like people who enjoy chemistry research won't struggle financially for their efforts. However, there's still a salary gap, especially at the level of a Bachelor's: it looks clear that other fields pay a lot more for similar amounts of effort. Note that I lack personal experience in this field, though—people who have gone through this path likely have better, more specific insights about the career.

jyunwai··on The Dictionary of Obscure Sorrows
This looks like it's a compound noun derived from the German words Ziel (meaning "goal" in English) and Schmerz (meaning "pain" in English). A raw translation could possibly be "goal-pain," though the true definition has a deeper meaning.
jyunwai··on I setup my terminal for max productivity
A couple of these tools—the git plugin for ohmyzsh and SCM Breeze)—are intended to make it easier to use git commands.

For people interested in these kinds of tools, I recommend trying out magit with emacs. In addition to also providing git command abbreviations, magit’s interface makes it easy to see the git status with automatic updates. It’s also a nice reason to learn emacs for anyone curious about its popularity.

Some screenshots of the interface are at: https://magit.vc/screenshots/

jyunwai··on Google threatens to cut off news after California proposes paying media outlets
> 1) Most people don't want to pay for news. Even $1/year is too high.

Alternatives to increasing advertisements have been tried and found to work. However, these approaches may not be feasible for all publications—especially local news outlets that may not have as many resources. These approaches are to:

i) Start selling other services besides news. The New York Times—one of the most currently financially successful newspapers—has found a lot of success in its Games section. This was famously seen in their acquisition of Wordle, though this has already been popular with their Crosswords section. The company has also found success with its Recipes section. (This is not the only reason behind their financial success, but it's a significant part of their strategy.)

ii) Focus on financial news, which lets the publication frame their reports as having a financial value that arguably exceeds the subscription price. The Financial Times is also a highly profitable newspaper today, with one of the highest-priced subscription prices that can be about $500 USD a year for a standard subscription (depending on one's region). The Wall Street Journal similarly charges a high subscription price. Both are seen as important resources for well-funded companies to buy group subscriptions for. (Once more, this isn't the only reason for their success, but it's a major factor.)

iii) Focus on a specialized, niche area of reporting that other publications can't or won't cover—ideally appealing to institutions or large audiences willing to spend money. For example, several publications in Canada focus on providing detailed reports on federal politics (such as The Hill Times and iPolitics), which is useful information for their readership that fills a gap by less-frequent reports from the country's main newspapers—this lets them charge high subscription prices. The Athletic also used to be financially successful by standing out with its sports-only reporting, which led to its acquisition by The New York Times. These specialized publications can charge more, because certain audiences find these reports financially valuable.

---

However, a major drawback to thinking about news through the lens of financial value is that many important news stories don't have financial value. While an outlet can attempt to use one of these approaches to subsidize the rest of their stories, it's also costly. It's usually not feasible for many local newspapers to fund the software development of a Games section (especially as this would need to compete with all the other online alternatives for one's attention).

It's also pricey to offer competitive enough salaries to create a newsroom to compete with The Financial Times, The Wall Street Journal, and Bloomberg. However, it's not impossible—there have been a few alternative publications that have found success by focusing on a niche, such as business news in a country outside of the US, or focusing on a sector such as biotech for the publication STAT.

It's a tough problem to try and fund local news. There is civic value for one's community to have a platform for providing a check against corruption by various institutions—yet in practice, oftentimes not enough for most local residents purchase subscriptions. Alternatives to support local news can include funding (such as through taxes), but that makes the outlet reliant on government funding, which is subject to change (and the perception, real or not, that the outlet is less independent from the government).

Increasing advertisements seems like a short-term solution for local news outlets trying to stay afloat, but it's hard for me to see this as a long-term solution for sufficient funding.

jyunwai··on A Cautionary AI Tale: Why IBM's Dazzling Watson Supercomputer Made a Lousy Tutor
The author remarks that "The No. 1 factor in a student’s tutoring success is simply showing up consistently, research suggests," and this matches with my own personal experience. I've tried various tools for learning foreign languages (though most of them did not use AI), but an issue was that they weren't "sticky" or interesting enough for me personally to consistently use them day-to-day or week-to-week.

The approach that helped me break through the beginning stages of learning Spanish was taking the traditional advice to enrol in an introductory course in a university setting, which motivated me to complete homework and meet with live teachers in a classroom setting week-to-week. I previously tried online courses that had automatically-marked exercises, but I had trouble motivating myself to regularly practice with them. I'm now self-motivated to continue my language studies, so the selection of tool matters less for me now (though stickier methods that insisted on daily practice such as Pimsleur or using spaced repetition software like Anki helped me along the way). But it's a useful idea that consistency is one of the most important factors for learning, and beginners can most straightforwardly achieve this by regularly seeing a live teacher who they pay for.

That said, consistency is certainly not the only factor: it can be frustrating to consistently spend lots of time and energy with an ineffective learning approach. However, consistent studying should be one of the first steps, and study should not be put off out of fear of beginning with the wrong approach. I believe that while sayings like "practice doesn't make perfect, only perfect practice makes perfect" can be useful for higher levels of learning, they drive the wrong message for beginners or struggling learners.

A better message for most learners before the advanced stage would be that: "To get most of the way–if not all the way–to your learning goals, the most important factor is consistent study."

jyunwai··on It's not what the world needs right now
Most other comments so far have viewed this artist's lifestyle negatively, as he wrote that he got by via abusing various policies and tax fraud (via "[hallucinating] a DJ software skin" to claim as a business expense). But he's an interesting person for sticking to his craft for close to a decade now: he has persisted in working hard to produce artwork and submit it for exhibition.

However, to what extent is this lifestyle necessary as an artist? A common piece of advice for many artists is to consider developing a steady career independent of one's art, which lets them afford their lifestyle as an artist (such as by writing, creating artwork, or performing during the evenings and weekends). But the effectiveness of this advice must vary for the individual: it's also common for many people to drop their artwork or stop taking it seriously in favour of their paying career.

For this artist in particular, I wonder if a steady job would have been a positive or negative to his art. In this case, the income would have reduced his suffering especially as he's dealing with medical debt. It could have even granted him additional artistic freedom, as he writes about the pressures to "defect" and his acceptance of more commercial work for money. Yet at the same time, it's possible that part of the desperation is behind his drive as an artist—though it's also risky to romanticize this desperation.

jyunwai··on What do you do if a hacker takes control of your ship? (2023)
What are some of the solutions to an cybersecurity incident in-progress that involves taking over a moving ship? Much of the article talks about how it's important to prepare for this incident and that there's a simulation developed for this scenario, but the recommendations at the end look preventative instead of intended to fix an active incident.

The article's preventative methods include "Install security updates as soon as they come and automatically as much as possible," "Do not assign administrator rights to end users," "Do not allow the use of weak passwords," use multi-factor authentication, don't install non-approved software, conduct risk assessments for computer systems in use, and make plans for cyber incidents in advance.

jyunwai··on How Couples Meet
I respectfully disagree, having grown up at a time when online dating became mainstream. Though some people might give this advice due to the motivations you've mentioned, I've also heard people share this opinion due to their poor experiences with online dating.

I've written more about this in another comment in this discussion, but I've known people who have had experiences where they were more likely to get stood up, broken up with unexpectedly, and especially ghosted from online dating versus by people they've met in-person. The process can also be draining for many people: I've talked to people who have been exhausted by regular rejection, or by spending lots of energy and time on bad dates (in contrast to dates that are likely to go better with people they've met in-person). They've then found themselves happier by dating people they've first met in-person, instead of online.

For a wider perspective, a 2023 US survey found that online dating has been positive for 53% of respondents, and negative for 46% [1]. So, people have had mixed experiences with online dating in general. I think online dating can work great for many people (I personally know a few people who've been very happy with their experiences), though it's not necessary for having a good relationship, nor a positive experience for many others.

[1] https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/02/02/key-findi...

jyunwai··on How Couples Meet
These are all good points. For the last one, there is a separate study by Pew Research Center conducted in 2022 (reported in 2023), which likely reduces this bias by recruiting respondents by sending physical mail "to a stratified, random sample of households" that invites them to complete an online survey: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/02/02/key-findi...

Pew's results were different than the findings by Rosenfeld et al.: while 53% of people aged 18–29 in the US "have ever used a dating site or app," only 20% of partnered people aged 18–29 reportedly met their current partner "on a dating site or app" (I've also made a similar comment elsewhere in this discussion).

jyunwai··on How Couples Meet
To add a different, independent study for more context on the same topic, Pew Research Center ran a survey conducted in 2022 and reported in 2023 about online dating in the US: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/02/02/key-findi...

In contrast to Rosenfeld et al.'s research, Pew reported that 53% of people aged 18–29 "have ever used a dating site or app," but only 20% of partnered people aged 18–29 met their current partner "on a dating site or app," though this statistic does not include "those who did not give an answer."

jyunwai··on How Couples Meet
I half-jokingly say that what motivates many couples to stay committed in a time of hardship is the idea of the possibility of "fate."

Anecdotally, just within my social group, I've seen a trend of people deciding to avoid online dating and preferring to meet others in-person. There may be a tendency for people to break up more easily after meeting online and commit less to the relationship in tough times, in contrast to people they've met in-person—perhaps in part due to the idea that fate led them to meet each other.

I also know of a few couples who met online and have made it work. For one couple, they happened to meet by coincidence a couple times due to already having mutual friends, who have had a great relationship that continues to be strong. I have an intuition that these circumstances gave the relationship a sense of being special and difficult to replace (in addition to their personalities being a great fit), strengthening their commitment to each other.

The process of online dating can also be exhausting, from the accounts of a few people I've known who tried it for a while. Dating apps are often designed to be addictive to encourage you to check often: even then, the number of rejections or failed dates can also wear you down. In these ways, online dating for many users can be high-effort and draining.

jyunwai··on Job boards are still rife with 'ghost jobs'. What's the point?
The bank J.P. Morgan recently published an analysis about employment in the US [1] (this is the best source I could initially find with no paywalls and a non-superficial, sector-by-sector look at the data). According to the report:

* "The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported that the U.S. economy added 275,000 jobs in February." However, "unemployment rose to 3.9% in February, the highest rate since January 2022." In January 2024, the overall employment rate was 3.7%.

* "A spike in construction, retail and food services jobs contributed to the surprising gain in employment in February."

* "Payroll gains in February were distributed across many areas of the economy. Health care, leisure and hospitality and government led the way, contributing to almost three quarters of the job gains."

This matches with the anecdotes that I've been hearing from day-to-day conversation: certain sectors such as health care and the service industry are short on people, whereas openings are far fewer in other sectors such as technology. However, I couldn't find employment data specific to the tech sector in this brief report.

[1] https://www.jpmorgan.com/insights/outlook/economic-outlook/j...

jyunwai··on Ask HN: Is Scratch a good tool for teaching coding?
It's a nicely designed course, and you can find a version free for any person to take online and receive a certification (with the submission of auto-graded assignments within a certain timeline): https://cs50.harvard.edu/college/2023/fall/syllabus/

The lectures are well-produced and come with detailed lecture notes, though the assignments are technically difficult to complete. You can find the materials for Week 0 on Scratch is at: https://cs50.harvard.edu/college/2024/spring/weeks/0/

jyunwai··on Ask HN: Is Scratch a good tool for teaching coding?
Harvard’s introductory-level computer science course, CS50, teaches Scratch for the first week. The course then uses Scratch like pseudocode to outline the high-level structure of programs for students to write in C. This is a proof of concept that Scratch can be part of a good introduction to programming, though the introductory coursework I took at university went straight to learning with Python instead of with Scratch.

For teaching a child, it depends on the person’s interests. You can’t go wrong with Scratch (it looks fun, it’s easy to start with, and it’s immediately accessible within a browser), but the child might eventually want to move on to a more flexible language like Python for more complicated programs.

jyunwai··on The U.S. Just Expanded by the Size of Two Californias
Good point, as the edit should be within the site guidelines intended to reduce clickbait in favour of clarity. I've done so as it's within the edit window.
jyunwai··on The woman behind Strindberg's Miss Julie and her male alter ego
That would be great. Moderation is likely the toughest part. However, it’s easier when the community is below a certain size. I hope you succeed, as a website like this would be useful for many people.
jyunwai··on The woman behind Strindberg's Miss Julie and her male alter ego
For finding interesting articles, you can try Arts & Letters Daily: https://www.aldaily.com. Literary Hub also publishes a daily newsletter that includes some external links to articles by other publications: https://lithub.com/

Another way to find readings is by subscribing to various literary magazines and journals. Examples include Granta, The Paris Review, n+1, Ploughshares, The Kenyon Review, The Hedgehog Review, The New Yorker, The London Review of Books, The Times Literary Supplement, and many others.

For forum discussions, there unfortunately aren't too many options. You can try the following forums on Reddit: r/literature, r/TrueLit, and r/AskLiteraryStudies. GoodReads also has online discussion groups. An alternative approach is to find or create an in-person or online book club.

jyunwai··on Silicon Valley is pricing academics out of AI research
A related read is by Fei-Fei Li, who wrote more details about her point of view in a November 2023 article in The Atlantic [1]. The submitted article in The Washington Post focuses largely on the funding disparities, which she does highlight in her own article.

But her article in The Atlantic places a greater emphasis on the effects of a brain drain of AI researchers from academia to industry. She gives examples about how 40 roboticists left Carnegie Mellon for Uber in 2015, and how her close collaborator Andrej Karpathy chose OpenAI in its earlier days over "a faculty offer from Princeton."

She most notably recalls a quote said by someone at an OpenAI meeting that said that "Everyone doing research in AI should seriously question their role in academia going forward," and added the reflection: "To be honest, I wasn’t sure I even disagreed."

[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2023/11/ai-et...

There was also past discussion on HN about her article at: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38362242

jyunwai··on Doctors Are Using the Apple Vision Pro During Surgery
The headline chosen by the publication is a bit misleading, as the surgeons didn't wear the Vision Pro during surgery. But it does sound like the tool has potential, from info emphasized by 9to5Mac [1]:

"The surgeon, Syed Aftab, said that because the scrub nurse could see all of the information from the surgery plan, referencing it in real time during the operation, it effectively allowed them to work as efficiently as someone who had worked alongside him for years. Mr Aftab praised the software and said it turned a scrub nurse he had never worked with into someone with ten years’ experience. He said that the technology would ‘superpower’ his operating team into the equivalent of a Formula One pit crew."

The surgeon's opinion is glowing, but does not explore the disadvantages of the technology, nor if viable alternatives exist. I'd be interested to hear about more details on the potential downsides of the technology, and what plans there are for redundancies if the software or hardware fails during surgery.

[1] https://9to5mac.com/2024/03/12/vision-pro-used-in-surgery/

jyunwai··on The new science on what ultra-processed food does to the brain
Though these aren't direct accessible links to the WSJ's report, the following non-paywalled articles provide coverage about the same research paper (which itself can be directly read at https://www.bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2023-077310 ):

* The Conversation (takes a stronger focus on the paper's methodology): https://theconversation.com/ultra-processed-foods-largest-ev...

* Medical News Today (also takes a more technical perspective, though includes more emotionally charged words in the opening): https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/ultra-processed-fo...

* The Guardian (general news coverage) https://www.theguardian.com/society/2024/feb/28/ultra-proces...

jyunwai··on Being a Fast, Cogent Writer Is Useful
It turns out that your point is part of a fair criticism of the OED, as critics such as Oxford linguist Roy Harris [1] claim that dictionaries should be descriptive instead of prescriptive. The OED itself has also varied on its presentation of itself across its history as a resource that describes versus prescribes proper English usage.

I still believe that OED definitions are reliable for checking usage in formal writing, though its definitions are less important for personal articles such as the author's. But in any case, the author still makes a good point that clear writing is useful when solving engineering problems in a team.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford_English_Dictionary#Rece...

jyunwai··on Being a Fast, Cogent Writer Is Useful
To clear this up once and for all, we can refer to the much-respected Oxford English Dictionary (OED) [1].

The current definitions are: "1.a. Constraining, impelling; powerful, forcible."; "1.b. esp. Having power to compel assent or belief; argumentatively forcible, convincing."; and "1.c. [as part of certain] dependent [phrases]."

A historical definition of "cogent" was: "Of persons: Employing force or compulsion, peremptory. Obsolete. rare," which includes an example phrase from 1672 that demonstrates this usage as a descriptor for people.

This confirms that "cogent" is no longer a strictly valid descriptor for people according to the OED, though this usage was once valid in the past. However, I agree with other readers that this doesn't take away from the article's substance, which draws from the author's experience in software.

[1] (Paywalled) https://www.oed.com/dictionary/cogent_adj?tl=true

jyunwai··on Self-control signals and affords power
> "For me, I have greater admiration and respect for someone who has failed majestically at being great, than for someone who deals purely with median or below median expectations. The former will have amazing stories to tell, the latter usually don’t."

This helps give me words to understand my mixed feelings about an old post I found on a language learning forum recently, about a person who shared an ambitious goal that appeared unrealistic to achieve on their proposed timeline of six months. The person aimed to start studying as a complete beginner with a language and achieve a 'C1 level' certification by that time (this is an advanced exam that evaluates for fluency in a spoken debate on a scholarly topic, thorough comprehension of spoken debates on the radio, and the ability to write a timed persuasive essay with a limited number of flaws on a nuanced topic).

The responses to the post at the time were largely discouraging. On the one hand, I quietly agreed from personal experience with the other users that the goal simply wasn't feasible for most people: it would have been ambitious (but doable) to employ the same stretch of time to go from the B2 level (the level just below, which is sufficient for immigration to major countries that used the language officially) to the C1 level. But on the other hand, I did feel sympathetic toward the idea of the person setting an ambitious personal goal. The person even tried to make this concrete by including a plan of intense hours of tutoring and television watching per week. The post was a year old when I read it, so I checked the person's user profile to see if they reported the outcome. But the person never gave a written update (neither a post, nor a comment, nor an edit), though the account was active with recent unrelated comments.

My conclusion is that it's best to be supportive of people with ambitious goals to better themselves, but it's most practical to draw a distinction between goals in the short, medium, and long-term. Ambitious goals for self-betterment on any of these timelines ought to be celebrated. But there are risks with short-term goal that skirt too far outside of realism: this can cause someone to push themselves too much to the point of burnout and quitting (it's unclear, but possible, that this might have happened to that person). In my week-to-week life, I've personally seen beginner's burnout happen with overly-eager novices in martial arts.

A set of attainable short-term goals in service of ambitious goals over a longer timeline would be more sustainable. But if one wishes to pursue an ambitious goal in the short-term, that ought to be okay too—as long as the individual understands the burnout risks upfront, to lower the odds of abandoning their goal if they fall short.

jyunwai··on Self-control signals and affords power
I hadn't considered the aspect of 'looking powerful/competent' before, but I have found setting limited goals useful for thinking strategically.

The practical benefits of a limited versus highly ambitious short-term goal from the outset include an avoidance of 'feature creep' where you're tempted to add more nice-to-have features partway through, more self-confidence that you can achieve the goal with a little effort, and a clearly-identified decision point upon achieving the goal, where you can decide whether to continue on with the project for more ambitious goals, or satisfyingly call the project complete.

In educational psychology, this is known as the "zone of proximal development" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zone_of_proximal_development), which I've also heard as called "i+1 planning."

jyunwai··on Inside the miracle of modern chip manufacturing
That is excellent, thanks for the information and work to produce a very nice feature.
jyunwai··on The most physically demanding jobs in America
A gift link is at: https://wapo.st/431v3AE
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →