HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

k0k0r0

209 karma · joined January 1, 2022

submissionscomments
k0k0r0··on The Go Programming Language and Environment
About that slice indexing problem I wrote a bug-report for the language specification like two years ago. The language specification itself is not clear about what types can be used as indices. Accepting int32 and similiar could be regarded as a feature of the compiler.

The problem was recognized (like a year later), but then claimed to be fixed and simply ignored. Immediately, I wrote a follow-up issue providing a concrete example how the spec could be improved. No response to that, yet. Now another year has passed.

k0k0r0··on Eye contact between musicians
The irony of your user name is great. Is that a throw-away account?
k0k0r0··on Grothendieck's Approach to Equality [pdf]
See my comment to a sibling.
k0k0r0··on Grothendieck's Approach to Equality [pdf]
That's maybe true in some fields of mathematics. In others that's misleading, and the usual understanding of canonical as unprecisely defined "obvious choice" is definitely more helpful.
k0k0r0··on Grothendieck's Approach to Equality [pdf]
Thank you very much!
k0k0r0··on Grothendieck's Approach to Equality [pdf]
Yeah, that's somewhat correct but misses the intention. Back than classical algebraic geometry started to get extremely messy and mathematicians got lost in a maze. And would prove wrong theorems and stuff, a lot of notions they used were not (possible to be) properly defined. Redefinig the geometrical aspect of algebraic geometry in purely algebraic terms using rings clearified the previously used notions and provided a firm basis for the mathematics that already had been studied. Furthermore, it provided a way out of the algebraic geometry mess mathematicians had been doing and lead to completely new insights.

Before, we mathematicians considered spaces like R^n or rather preferably C^n and then vanishing sets of polynomials in them, which form nice geometrical objects. E.g. The set of points (x,y) in R^2 such that x^2 + y^2 = 0, which gives a circe. At least if we only consider real values for x and y, but just that you know mostly people from algebraic geometry prefer the complex numbers C. Then, we asked questions about intersections of those, about what function one might define on them using algebraic terms, and how many straight lines they contain. The geometrical aspect of this provided a great intuition for this kind of mathematics, but it started to get really messy and mathematicians started to get stuff wrong.

Then, Grothendieck came along and turned everything upside down. He stopped talking about for example the circe, which is described by the algebraic equation x^2+ y^2 = 0, as the geometric object. Instead, he said: from now on our geometric object of considerations is the set of prime ideals in the polynomial ring in two variables that contain the polynomial x^2 + y^2. And together with some more structure that's what is today known as an affine scheme.

For the sake of this explaination its not really important what a prime ideal is, and you might want to look that up later, cause its actually a very simple thing. Also any further definitions would rather confuse any reader, that is not familiar with the subject. From now one the theory gets surprisingly abstract. For example, polynomials and polynomial rings quickly get replaced by arbitrary ring. The main point is: Now, the circle was replaced by an object that was defined in purely algebraic terms. From now on, in the field of algebraic geometry even the geometry was purely algebraic.

On the first glance, that algebraic object seems to have nothing or little to do with the geometric object of the circle. And definitely the theory seems to be overkill, even when you have a look from the insight. However, grothendieck was suddenly able to explain a lot of the mess other mathematiciam where doing up till then, and even more, he proved theorems in algebraic geometry that where completely out of reach for any mathematicians before him. With Grothendiek in algebraic geometry a turning-point was reached.

At that time people were hungry for answers and hungry for abstraction. They absorbed his theory as thirsty plants absorb long awaited rain. The nice properties of rings allowed to develop a massive machinery of abstract mathematics. That's what most of algebraic geometry had turned into after Grothendieck.

I find its a beautiful theory and a lot of it is still very close to geometry. For anybody interested, there is this nice book about the huge field of toric varieties (a subfield of algebraic geometry) for example. Its from Cox, Little and Schenk. Even though it covers basically the whole subfield it also assumes no or very little familiarity with algebraic geometry from the reader. However, one needs to get through that abstract basics of algebraic geometry. You wont get far in algebraic geometry without it. Countless mathematician have tried and failed miserably, before Grothendieck came along with his fancy theory.

k0k0r0··on Grothendieck's Approach to Equality [pdf]
Any recommendation for a (short) introduction to HoTT for a working mathematician?
k0k0r0··on Embracing Modern C++ Safely, Book Review
Not a professional here - by my own standart at least - however I also program in C++ for a living (among other languages).

Definitely Stockholm-Syndrom in my case. Was the first language in which I was forced to work on some larger codebase. Since then I can't take the complexity of any other object-oriented language serious. All of them are basically a subset of C++.

k0k0r0··on Programming in the Apocalypse
That's true until people are suddenly hungry odr thirsty. Hunger or thrist will force them to act. And not necesserily nicely.
k0k0r0··on Programming in the Apocalypse
As someone else put it nicely:

People seem to rather fight the sun than capitalism.

k0k0r0··on Grothendieck's Approach to Equality [pdf]
That's a valid and good question.
k0k0r0··on Grothendieck's Approach to Equality [pdf]
Exactly that the point. It's not clear. Except for whenever the main theorem of global class theory applies. Then it's clear up to a minus sign.
k0k0r0··on Grothendieck's Approach to Equality [pdf]
TL;DR

To objects/sets are equal if and only if there is a canonical isomorphism/bijection between them. What that is is not necessarily clear, but there is an exception regarding abelian groups accotiated to a field, where the canonical isomorphism is clear up to a minus sign by the main theorem of global class theory[0].

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_field_theory

k0k0r0··on What is our hidden consumption of microplastics doing to our health?
Indeed, this was very interesting. However, I missed a bit what changes to my diet I could do to improve myicrobiome. I would be glad to hear a scientist like her discussing this.
k0k0r0··on FairEmail stopping development after Google falsely flags app as spyware
Seems like you found yourself a new hobby.
k0k0r0··on FairEmail stopping development after Google falsely flags app as spyware
I'd argue choosing to use PlayStore for downloading Apps is already abuse. It's negligience towards the creators.

On the other hand you don't need to put your app there, except for maybe if you want to attract some users./s

k0k0r0··on FairEmail stopping development after Google falsely flags app as spyware
FairMail is an insanely good Email-App. I have little to compare to, but it's sick how good FairMail is. I'd be surprised if there is something comparably good.
k0k0r0··on FairEmail stopping development after Google falsely flags app as spyware
Did you actally read the thread? His rage-quit feels actually quite tragic right now. Additionally to the insane problems with Google and the PlayStore-enviroment/ecosystem, his girlfriend is currently sick, and taking care of her is his priority.

I'd find it more appropriate if the (current)top-comment doesn't casually criticize some simple looks of the app as if nothing. I mean if somebody's drowning right now next to me, I don't want to hear commentary about how shitty her/his shoes look like. Well, you didn't choose to be top-comment right now for everybody to see this like on a silver plate, but to everybody else... In real life I'd suggest: maybe discuss this on some other day.

Edit: Not top-comment anymore.

k0k0r0··on Taskwarrior
Oh, yeah that issue with the date related urgency calculation. I couldn't figure that out, too. I even started skimming through the code, but gave up since I couldn't find it within 10 minutes.

I really love using taskwarrior, but certain things like that just drive me nuts.

If anyone can explain, how that date related urgencies are calculated, I would be very thankful!

k0k0r0··on What about a Thunderbird mobile app?
FairMail impressively good. I am truly amazed by FairMail.
k0k0r0··on Git-privacy redacts author and committer dates to keep coding hours more private
Seems like a cool project. However, what I definitely would need is to set dates to be within a specified time frame. Sometimes I write till like 3 am in the morning, and I would like to hide that. So like a hook, that makes some linear rescaling to a previously defined time frame like 8 am to 8 pm would be really nice.
k0k0r0··on A dirty dish by the sink can be a big marriage problem
I don't entirely agree with the framing of this comment, but I'd like to share an expierience which is related.

A couple of years into our relationship my significant other finally realized, that if she wants me to do specific tasks in our household, then thats her desire and not mine. I.e. that I for example leave "a mess behind in the kitchen" since I am totally fine with that, and its only her desire to have a cleaner kitchen, and not some general rule I had broken.

This lead to a huge change in our relationship. Since then she mostly starts negotiating rules that we both can agree upon instead of starting a fight. I am very thankful for that.

k0k0r0··on A dirty dish by the sink can be a big marriage problem
Wow. I never considered this before:

Explaining certain kinds of behavior as the result of society-wide (patriarchaic) conditioning may be sexist itself, because it denies the womans individual agancy.

k0k0r0··on You can do a lot with an empty file
This is worth its own post on HN
k0k0r0··on Inside London's first Ketamine therapy clinic
Actually I am a sorry for this dismissive answer. This was inappropriate.

And after only a couple of seconds of thought, I noticed (at least) one of your points is not related to the danger of addiction and indeed very interesting. Even without danger of addiction patients might confuse short term and long term effects. On the other hand this doesn't seem to be the case with anectodal expieriences I read about the use of (hard) psychodelics, e.g. LSD, mushrooms, etc.

Edit: Also as my dismissive answer already suggested, my question was not clear.

k0k0r0··on Inside London's first Ketamine therapy clinic
See my comment to a sibling.
k0k0r0··on Inside London's first Ketamine therapy clinic
Yeah, this didn't clearify my question. So the problem is addiction. Not the fun in itself.
k0k0r0··on Inside London's first Ketamine therapy clinic
I had some strange change of mind about this. Previously, I was shocked about long waiting times as well. I must note that in my area the waiting time is rather a low 1 digit number of months, so the situation here is much less severe. But my opinion on this changed over the years.

As in any peer group, I guess, there is some broken people in mine, too. I draw all my experience from that. Sometimes I feel there is way to many in my peer group. But aparently this is normal among young european people with higher aducation, I don't know. Maybe simple people talk about his more... Anyways.

Waiting at least three months for somebody with a median-type depression seems hard even without suicidal thoughts. I guess, that waiting time is even harder for the people who suddenly notice how they live their life is fucked up, and they need help. E.g. due to sudden realization of their own toxic behaviour, sudden realization of their terrific past and its effect on them, burnout (surprisingly, I have not expierienced that within my peer group, yet, apart from once rather tangientally) or even simple realization of a highly unhealthy relationship to work or significant other.

However. Aparently, finding a therapist with whome effective treatment is possible, is extremely hard. In particular, those with - let's call it - interesting past, seemed to switch therapists once or twice before finding someone with whome to work yielded noticable changes in their life. Also a good fraction of those in my peer group had questionable therapists. I can not jugde this, but I believe that achieving the art of being a good therapists (at least for some people) is among the most difficult skills one might aim for.

After finding a therapist that treatment often lasted for years. And with that as a support, they changed their life. Sometimes, entirely. Of course, this is not true for all of them, unfortunately. And maybe even only for less then half of them. Nevertheless, for some relevant fraction of them it lead to invaluable gains in their life. It lead to something, that is definitely worth to wait for a couple of months.

I noticed a problem is missing opportunities for non-pharmaceutic intermediate help for "non-urgent" cases waiting for "real" therapy. E.g. group-therapy with the clear intent of being for people that wait for something else. While this doesn't solve the problem of too little "supply" when compared to the "demand", it may help those people a lot. Even if only to show them, we care, even though resources are scarse (or terribly organized, whatever of these two).

Also I wrote "demand" with some kind of thruth behind this. At least for some in my peer group zi feel like their desire to be "sick" and their demands for help is a (possibly pathological - I cannot jugde this) problem in itself.

k0k0r0··on Inside London's first Ketamine therapy clinic
Honest question: Why should we kill the fun? I mean addiction is a problem, but having a great time definitely isn't, right? Or do I miss something?
k0k0r0··on Amazon worker chat app to ban words such as “union”, “pay raise”, “slave labor”
As a mostly private teacher of mathematics with 7 to 10 years experience for both, children at schools and adults at university, and both, individuals and groups, and both, those who struggle and those who do not, I'd like to share my narrow experience and disagree.

Most people I worked with struggled with something entirely different than the actual content they are trying or forced to learn. I am certain the biggest obsticles are stress, fear and and hopelessnes. And often not towards the methematics, but rather something entirely different. E.g. issues in the family, fear of the consequences of bad grades, and no hope regarding their own future, regardless of whether they learn or not.

I expierienced some challenges as ADHD and expierienced them as somewhat orthogonal. And definitely additionally challenging for me as a teacher. I also expierienced people who did struggle a lot, independent of anything I mentioned so far. So I am sure, there is differences among people (you may measure that in IQ or whatever, I prefer not to). But for most people I met they are not the problem.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →