HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kaeporan

31 karma · joined April 2, 2014

Twitter: @kaepora Github: @kaepora
submissionscomments
kaeporan··on CryptoCat iOS Application Penetration Test [pdf]
Hi there,

The fix for the MITM bug is to offer proper notice via the user interface when a user re-keys with a different public key. There's a demonstration of the user interface element in the blog post.

kaeporan··on CryptoCat iOS Application Penetration Test [pdf]
Hi Thomas,

OTF provides a form projects like ours can fill to commission this type of audit. So basically, we asked OTF to commission it for us and they accepted. TextSecure, a great encryption app that I've seen you recommend, also approached OTF and obtained an audit from iSEC via this same process. However, TextSecure decided not to publish their audit results.

You can read about OTF's reaction to these audits here: https://www.opentechfund.org/article/bringing-openness-secur...

kaeporan··on CryptoCat iOS Application Penetration Test [pdf]
We commissioned this audit in late December and iSec began working on it in January. They audited a pre-release prototype that we provided. This is noted in the audit document, but it's hard to spot unfortunately.

The reason we commissioned this audit is to make sure our prototype was audited before release on the App Store. We're very happy to have benefited from this audit, but linking to this PDF alone de-contextualizes the effort and makes it seem like it's an audit of the production version of Cryptocat for iPhone, whereas the version we provided was an early prototype. The audit did find some issues with the (already-released) desktop version and server configuration, and those were also fixed and documented in our blog post.

I sincerely appreciate you taking the time to read our blog post on the matter and thank you for your understanding.

kaeporan··on CryptoCat iOS Application Penetration Test [pdf]
Hi, I'm the lead developer for Cryptocat. I strongly urge you all to please read our blog post regarding this audit: https://blog.crypto.cat/2014/04/recent-audits-and-coming-imp...

This audit document alone does not give enough context. This audit was commissioned by us and concerns a pre-release version of Cryptocat for iPhone. Many of the bugs it found are due to the fact that it was reviewing a prototype with debugging features (such as NSLog) turned on. While this audit definitely does find some vulnerabilities and room for improvement, none of the critical bugs in this audit ever made it to Cryptocat for iPhone's release.

It's very unfortunate that this audit is being taken out of context like this and used to attack our effort. I'd appreciate it if you could please upvote this comment and help me contextualize this audit. Again, please, read the blog post for context (and also for the results of another audit we comissioned in parallel.) We've done our best to address these issues and are working towards an open discussion on how to improve accessible encryption. https://blog.crypto.cat/2014/04/recent-audits-and-coming-imp...

The blog post's last section ("On the Significance of Audits") discusses why it is that Cryptocat has seen more audits published about it than other encryption projects. Please, dare to discern. Read what we're doing to improve the security of accessible encryption and our reasoning for publishing these audits. I'll be grateful for you taking the time to read on what we're doing and I am more than happy to discuss with you and answer your questions.

kaeporan··on CryptoCat iOS Application Penetration Test [pdf]
It's important to note that this audit concerned a pre-release, debugging version of Cryptocat for iPhone. The audit document alone doesn't give enough context; I strongly urge reading our blog post: https://blog.crypto.cat/2014/04/recent-audits-and-coming-imp...
kaeporan··on CryptoCat iOS Application Penetration Test [pdf]
Fixes and improvements to this, and more, are covered in our blog post. I strongly urge you to read it. This audit alone doesn't give enough context. https://blog.crypto.cat/2014/04/recent-audits-and-coming-imp...
kaeporan··on CryptoCat iOS Application Penetration Test [pdf]
Thanks for linking to the blog post. This audit concerns a pre-release version of Cryptocat for iPhone. Many of the bugs were due to debugging code and were fixed before release.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2