HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kakwa_

1,465 karma · joined August 10, 2015

submissionscomments
kakwa_··on LTS kernels are no longer supported for 6 years because no one used them
> LTS kernels are no longer supported for 6 years because it turns out no one used them.

Looking quickly at Debian, old old stable (10) uses 4.19, old stable (11) 5.10, and stable (12) 6.1. All these versions are LTS kernels.

I don't think Debian uses LTS kernel branches as is, instead cherry picking patches, but it seems they do leverage LTS branches, at least to ease the back-porting I presume.

I'm probably missing something, and looking through the Debian mailing lists, I've not seen any discussion about the end of long term LTS kernels, but it seemed they did rely on it to a degree.

Maybe it was more of a nice to have, but from the outside (I'm neither a kernel or Debian maintainer), it leaves me a bit confused.

kakwa_··on Asahi dev found off-by-one bug in M2 MacBook Air bass enhancer
Given the bug went unnoticed for a year by millions of customers, I doubt 'the most banale Q&A testing' would have caught it.
kakwa_··on War Thunder user leaks restricted military documents for AH-64D Apache Longbow
Don't attribute to malice what could be attributed to stupidity.

Most or War Thunder leaks were basically "the in game stats are wrong, here is the proof: [CLASSIFIED DOC]".

And in other cases (like the Ukraine War leaks on Discord) it's just flexing like "I know things you common folks don't know".

It doesn't mean nefarious leaks for money or sympathy don't occur, but there are generally far less visible.

kakwa_··on A.I. and the Next Generation of Drone Warfare
It's more the case drones have not meet their counter yet.

It's kind of logical to see expensive AA systems designed to shoot down expensive planes struggling to answer swarm of cheap drones cost effectively.

But the good performance of very old systems like Gepard indicates solutions exist. For example, systems with a decent and modern radar plus a few short range low caliber and cheap AA guns will probably get designed and fielded in the near future.

And new weapon systems is not the only answer. Jamming also has proven to be effective. And even simple doctrine changes can be effective.

Drones are enjoying an happy time, but it will end and to a degree already has (tb2 is far less prevalent for example).

kakwa_··on I digitalized Berlin's registration form
Given the project will probably take 10 to 15 years to be completed, honestly, they are probably not wrong.

By the time it's ready for production, the latest Raspberry Pi will probably be about as powerful as the fancy cluster.

kakwa_··on Unity's Self-Combustion Engine
Is it legit profits?

Iirc Uber had some creative accounting practices in the past offsetting loses from one quarter to another, and making a single quarter look good.

kakwa_··on Java 21 makes me like Java again
Honestly, just find yourself a project and just Go for it (sorry for the pun).

The syntax is easy enough you can start coding just after having looked at basic examples.

Personally I actually like Go because it's so boring.

I tend to see languages more like tools rather than valuable knowledge I must learn, so a simple yet powerful enough language is a perfect fit for me.

kakwa_··on Linux on a MacBook Pro (M1 Pro): How Good Is Asahi Now?
Have been doing the secondhand laptop+Linux for 15 years and I have never felt like I was missing out on OS features.

And while true circa 2006 (these Broadcom wifi cards...), I have not experienced compatibility/lack of drivers in ages.

kakwa_··on Linux on a MacBook Pro (M1 Pro): How Good Is Asahi Now?
I kind of did that with PowerBooks back in the days.

The hard truth was that used Thinkpads were a better option.

For the same price you could get 3 years old ThinkPads which were more powerful and in better condition than 6 years old PowerBooks.

But I did installed Gentoo on my PowerBooks G3 and G4 (it just took 2 days to compile Firefox). And ironically, this knowledge proved useful in my first job when I repurposed old IBM Power servers with it.

kakwa_··on Unity's Trap
It seems Godot is getting quite a lot of traction these days (I see a lot of "Godot introduction for Unity devs" videos these days).

The Godot engine might be less complete than Unity, but calling it immature is a bit strong IMHO.

For devs having been burnt by a proprietary engine, namely Unity, the Open Source aspect alone is a good reason to switch.

So Godot is bound to get far more users, and consequently, develop and improve significantly.

kakwa_··on Tesla FSD Beta tried to kill me last night
> Roads may have problems but the alternative you're proposing is far worse.

Sorry, but "far worse" is simply excessive.

Living in a large European city, namely Paris, and having experienced both car and mass transit, I prefer the second option a lot, to the point I sold my car without replacement about 6 years ago after 2 years of barely using it.

There is of course the ecological aspects, but even in terms of quality of life, I much prefer public transports: it's cheaper, it's less stressful, it's more predictable and I'm able to do other things like reading while transiting.

By comparison, in this context (dense urban area), cars, with their needs (maintenance, parking, etc) are actually more constrain than freedom.

And that's not like I'm a unique case, most of my colleagues either use public transports or (e)bikes, car users are a minority (~20%).

In Paris, there is even a large proportion of the population who didn't even have a driving license at all.

Doesn't it means that mass transit is the perfect solution? no. But in dense urban area, it's probably the best compromise.

kakwa_··on Software engineering lessons from RCAs of greatest disasters
Pre-war, it was more a case of "Penny wise and Pound foolish" partly due to budget limitation (they did things like testing only with foam warheads to recover test torpedoes).

But after Perl Harbor, a somewhat biased BuOrd was reluctant to admit the mark 14 flaws. It took a few "unauthorized" tests and 2 years to fix the issues.

In fairness, this sure makes for an entertaining story (ex Drachinifel video on yt), but I'm not completely sold on the depiction of BuOrd as some sort of arrogant bureaucrats. However, bias and pride (plus other issues like low production) certainly have played a role in the early mark 14 debacle.

Going back to software development, I'm always amazed how bugs immediately pop-up whenever I put a piece of software in the hands of users for the first time, and that's regardless how well I tested it. I try to be as thorough as possible, but being the developer I'm always bias, often tunnel visioning on one way to use the software I created. That's why, in my opinion you need some form of external QA/testing (like these "unauthorized" Mark 14 tests).

kakwa_··on Railway Safety Posters (2022)
In France, during the late 90ies/early 00ies, we got a bunch of "quite direct" Road Safety ads.

The one that traumatized me the most as a child was:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpNMrcgiAdw

kakwa_··on Israeli Researchers Produce Green Hydrogen with 90% Efficiency
Indeed, this effect is not a given, specially if the resource is scarce to begin with.

But regarding your example, personally, I'm actually kind of "keep adding light bulbs" thanks to LEDs. I'm no longer using one central 75W incandescent bulb per room, but rather 4 or 5 Philips Hue lights (bulbs & led strips) in an indirect fashion. Hue bulbs & these new usages would not have existed without the LED efficiency gains.

This counter example, of course, has many flaws, firstly, it's only my specific situation, not an average case. The efficiency gains (energy and longevity) is only part of what enabled these new types of lights. And lastly, I think my energy consumption is still lower non-the-less. But it demonstrate how things might not be so clear cut.

kakwa_··on Software engineering lessons from RCAs of greatest disasters
The Mark 14 ended-up being a really good torpedo by the end of WWII.

It even remained in service until the 80ies.

In truth, and going back to this subject, the Mark 14 debacle highlights the need for a good and unbiased QA.

This also holds true for software engineering.

kakwa_··on Israeli Researchers Produce Green Hydrogen with 90% Efficiency
Efficiency gains can even very well be detrimental to resource consumption.

Efficiency gains generally lead to lower cost, which in turn lead to higher demand. And this increased demand can very well be in excess of the efficiency gain.

This was observed as early as the 1860ies and theorized in concepts like the Jevons Paradox/Rebound Effect.

This doesn't mean efficiency gains are not desirable, but they must be implemented in conjunction with other factors like environmental policies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rebound_effect_(conservation)

kakwa_··on How real is America’s chipmaking renaissance?
For the "can" part, looking at the numbers, it looks possible.

If I take TSMC, they have:

* $73b revenue

* $32b income

* 73000 employees

(2022 numbers from wikipedia)

That's a really high margin, and a really high revenue per employee. This means there is probably room to accommodate for higher wages.

The concern I have revolves more around the US work culture. Employees tend to switch company frequently. Given how critical institutional knowledge is for running these fabs, this is a handicap.

I also cannot shake the feeling that the lack of regulations regarding working conditions might also be detrimental. Better regulations and compensation rules regarding night shifts or on-call for example could improve things greatly and attract far more workers in this field.

kakwa_··on Aeroflot deactivates brakes on nine aircraft, relies solely on reverse thrust
Indeed, Iran got their F14s during the Shah era.

But what is fascinating is how Islamic Iran managed to keep these planes flying, including through an 8 years long war, despite the embargo and the lack of parts.

Through back-channel deals with Israel or even the US (Iran-Contra deal) or good old smuggling exploiting mismanaged military surplus handling in US, plus domestic reverse engineering & production, the Iranians were incredibly resourceful in getting parts for these birds.

In comparison, finding parts for civilian planes is a piece of cake.

kakwa_··on Aeroflot deactivates brakes on nine aircraft, relies solely on reverse thrust
Iran (Iran Air and Mahan Air) is flying mostly Airbus and Boeing, but really, really, really old planes.

Given these are rather old planes, with a wide international distribution, I'm kind of expecting it's not too hard to find second hand parts cannibalized from retired planes and coming from neutral countries.

They were even able to smuggle parts to keep some of their F14s flying. In comparison, civilian airliner parts surely are easy to get.

Cuba is flying Russian except for a few ATR 72. I guess finding parts after 60 years to keep these Super Constellations flying is beyond reasonable.

These two countries are in a bit of a pickle actually. Parts can only help you up to a point, they will need new planes. With the EU and US mostly aligned and inter-dependent anyway, if you are under embargo, the only place you can get a full aircraft is Russia, but their industry is lagging behind (particularly engines and avionics). Their most modern planes cannot be built without using western parts currently.

China might be another provider in the future, but they are still dependent on foreign parts, engines in particular.

And in both cases, while they have regional jets (ARJ21 and Sukhoi Superjet) and 737/A320 equivalents (Comac 919, Irkut MC-21), the long range offer is more sketchy (Soviet era IL-96 and still in design phase Comac 929).

kakwa_··on Stopping at 90%
> Getting stuff out there to be noticed is difficult, a lot of work, and going the the last 10% does not guarantee any more success.

If your benchmark is number of stars on Github, then yes, things might get depressing when "JS toy framework number 45" easily gathers hundreds of stars.

But, personally, I have half a dozen reasonably polished projects on less trendy topics. While not huge, I know they were useful to other people. Some are packaged in linux distributions, others I've got requests for improvements, or were used as cross-reference for concurrent implementations, or were forked and continued a life of their own.

It's not huge, but by spending ~30% more time on things like documentation, tests, proper build system, a post here or on Reddit, I've enabled these projects to be more than an unapproachable pile of code.

And if it saves even one person the effort of implementing these projects, that's a result well worth the ~30% more effort for polishing the project in my book.

Lastly, users/interested people are often not developers. Personally, I have two websites related to a video game (one displaying some stats, the other being a loot box simulator). Both projects sit a 0 star on Github, but the access logs tell a different story, there has been thousands of (non-bot) visits since both went live, being useful to quite a few players of this particular game.

It's hard to measure impact, but it's extremely easy to underestimate it.

kakwa_··on LK-99: The live online race for a room-temperature superconductor
Yes, that's what's happened.

I was using this example to illustrate the disconnect between the market (which was trading oil like some immaterial stuff) and reality (oil is definitely a product you need to store properly, plus oil storage is not infinite).

In fairness, because it occurred during COVID, i.e. a really abnormal situation, this is a bit of a weak example.

kakwa_··on LK-99: The live online race for a room-temperature superconductor
To extend, interesting read on the subject of the soviet economy:

https://chris-said.io/2016/05/11/optimizing-things-in-the-us...

HN discussions:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14515225

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25084479

kakwa_··on LK-99: The live online race for a room-temperature superconductor
Vast topic.

Markets definitely have their issues.

Here are a few:

* The most obvious one is the fact it's an overhead, it doesn't produce goods or services by itself. That's not a major issue, but for example in the US ~5% (~7M of ~150M) of the workforce is dedicated to this overhead.

* It's prone to internal instabilities. Too often, the markets disconnect from the underlying economic reality, sometimes with only mild effects (for example, that time petroleum prices went negative), sometimes with more serious ones (2008).

* It can lead to overly quantitative views, ignoring the qualitative. It's the "metrics becoming the objective and thus compromising the value of the metric" (example: tech stock prices).

* It over-emphasizes individual interests over the collective one (think for example: environmental issues & global warming).

Markets definitely have their issues. But so far, the other systems we experimented with (planned economy) were even less able to cope with the incredibly difficult task of balancing an economy.

Lastly, it is to be noted that we are not operating in a pure market economy.

We are in an hybrid system where States (hopefully representing their people) definitely have a lot of say in economic matters and that's probably for the better.

kakwa_··on IRC is the only viable chat protocol (2022)
Yes, I know :)

My comment was ironic, solution like that are not practicable for common users.

The rise of alternative chat platforms (discord, matrix, slack) really demonstrates IRC was too limited.

I will remember it foundly but the era where IRC was the dominent open channel chat platform is at its end.

I just hope Discord will not be it's long term replacement.

kakwa_··on IRC is the only viable chat protocol (2022)
This was not a really issue... as long as you had access to a shell on a reliable server to screen+irssi (or tmux+weechat if you felt fancy).
kakwa_··on Kill dwm.exe on Windows for less input lag and better performance
So, not killing dwm suckless?

(sorry, dwm (X11) having served me well for years, I had to make that joke).

kakwa_··on After Raising $235K, Abode Remains Committed to Taking on Adobe
In Europe at least, developers having a Master's degree (~5 years of tertiary education) or equivalent is fairly common. From the stats I could find, that's roughly 50% of developers.
kakwa_··on After Raising $235K, Abode Remains Committed to Taking on Adobe
> I'm not going to name names, but if you are thinking about the "outsourcing nations", then I don't know about you, but I think most of us here have experienced the poor quality coding output from those developers.

I've experienced "poor quality coding outputs" caused by outsourcing in general... regardless if it was abroad or not.

With properly hired employees, in my experience, what they output is actually quite impressive both qualitatively and quantitatively. And their average salary is a fraction of mine, which is in turn a fraction of a US one (I'm West European).

kakwa_··on Intel returns to profitability after two quarters of losses
Honestly when I see the extremely high power consumption of Nvidia cards, I feel there are some inefficiencies and consequently an opportunity for Intel.

It remains to be seen if Intel can deliver reasonably affordable GPUs with enough hardware efficiency gains while not being too far behind Nvidia on the software tooling front.

But they have a card to play here.

kakwa_··on Apple Vision Pro developer kit
It's stretching it by a lot.

But Apple used to be pretty great for gaming. I remember playing tons of games like pong or snake clones, dark castle, shufflepuck cafe or airborne on our Mac SE when I was a child.

← PreviousPage 4 of 19Next →