HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kanetw

468 karma · joined April 10, 2016

submissionscomments
kanetw··on Meta's Subpoena Dropped – Simula One vs. Quest Pro
Typo. We'll fix it

i7-1265U and Wi-Fi 6E is correct.

kanetw··on Meta's Subpoena Dropped – Simula One vs. Quest Pro
I'm not fundamentally against ARM. But ARM in the VR world is Qualcomm, and they both didn't want to deal with us + their support for regular old Linux is (AFAIK) nonexistent.

Apart from that, x86 is IMO just easier to adopt. I wouldn't buy an ARM laptop right now (except for possibly a Macbook).

In a different tangent, I think the only way to get good ARM performance in a mobile format is to have custom-tailored silicon, like the Apple chips. Commercially available chips just don't compete with a i7-1265U or the Raptor Lake equiv.

kanetw··on Meta's Subpoena Dropped – Simula One vs. Quest Pro
The Quest Pro wasn't announced when they subpoenaed us.
kanetw··on Meta's Subpoena Dropped – Simula One vs. Quest Pro
A sour attitude definitely wasn't intended. Meta has some misleading marketing and we wanted to correct that. Apart from that we're just comparing our products, as the Quest Pro (unlike the Quest 2) does indeed intrude on our niche.
kanetw··on Meta Quest Pro
This is our (SimulaVR's) vision, basically. Our target is to have pixel density/optical quality and comfort good enough to work comfortably.

The pixel density is there (and better than quest pro), and we just need to finish the comfort features -- passthrough, mechanical comfort, integrated host.

kanetw··on Decompiling x86 Deep Neural Network Executables
There's no fundamental reason it can't be decompiled. Vivado uses white-box crypto for their IP keys, and they're all over the Chinese internet.

No one in the West will publicly mention touching them, for good reason. In China they're everywhere.

E: not just China, but it's easier to find them there

kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
Prescription inserts (we're working with vendors on this) are possible, and the focus distance of our headset (and most headsets, I think) is in that region.
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
Yeah, I agree. I distinctly remember open source becoming more corporate as the years got by, and corporate becoming more open source aligned.
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
Yeah, Immersed popped up alongside us. A big reason of why we went the hardware route (as an originally pure software product) was that the existing hardware was not good enough.

Having worked with the prototype headset, I can fairly confidently say that at least the picture quality is now good enough (with our optical train/displays)

kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
We made our weekly blog post about it (because it's worth talking about, IMO) and someone else posted it on HN. It blew up and we're responding to comments as necessary.

We're letting our legal counsel handle the actual details, the rest is just talking about it.

kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
Responding to any legal request without legal counsel is a good way to fuck yourself up. There's no "just do x" unless you enjoy playing with fire.
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
We ran it past them and they ok'd it. We as a company are fundamentally very open. It is quite literally a core facet of our business, and that includes not just the technical parts.

Of course there's stuff that's internal, but something that's literally a matter of public record isn't it.

kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
Hiring a lawyer was the first thing we did. For the rest, I'd gladly do this if we had the funds to do so. We don't.

Plus, we as a company are (maybe excessively) open. Of course we're going to get involved in legal proceedings, that's a fact of life. Doesn't mean we won't talk about it.

kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
Yep. It's easily going to be in the 5 digits.
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
We aren't throwing a hissy fit lol. We're just stating the facts and are working with our lawyers to resolve this.
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
It's a bit tooting my own horn but when I first put on the prototype it was really satisfying. Incredibly crisp.
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
First thing we did was get a lawyer.
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
Yeah, of course, it's a tough space to be in. Just saying that we need to carve out a niche where Meta can't compete vs try to fight Meta head on.
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
We're going to absorb the legal expenditures as part of our overall expenses, but you can crowdfund us by preordering a headset :)
kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
Of course anything Meta does is a bit worrisome. I just don't think we're in the same niche-- IMO Meta is fundamentally built on data collection, and VR is just a side effect.

Unless Meta decides to abandon that, I think we'll have a niche.

kanetw··on SimulaVR Has Been Subpoenaed by Meta Platforms, Inc
We already have standing legal counsel. George made it sound like we're just now seeking a lawyer, but we already reviewed our policies etc in the past.
kanetw··on Pre-exposure to mRNA-LNP inhibits adaptive immune responses in mice
I know 1 person who got SARS-CoV-2 twice, unvaccinated. And another who had it thrice, also unvaxxed.
kanetw··on Quest 2 no longer requires a Facebook account starting today
It's a significantly different segment than the Quest or Valve Index-- somewhere in between a Varjo and a Valve Index.

With better economies of scale, we would be able to drop the price more/introduce more segmentation. As is we just have too many NRE costs that drive the price up.

kanetw··on Keysight UXR 110GHz Oscilloscope Teardown [video] (2018)
PCIe gen4+ compliance testing and debugging
kanetw··on EU reaches deal to make USB-C a common charger for most electronic devices
I'm just talking about end devices here (source/sink).
kanetw··on EU reaches deal to make USB-C a common charger for most electronic devices
Yeah, it always gives you default power. It's just such a low amount that I kinda forgot.

Sometimes it's just fine to yolo it, but it adds to the confusion-- "I plugged in my device and it doesn't work??"

kanetw··on EU reaches deal to make USB-C a common charger for most electronic devices
A compliant USB-C source will not provide more than 5V/3A without PD negotiation period, and is only guaranteed to provide default USB power. So if you can potentially draw more, you need to check whether it's allowed.
kanetw··on EU reaches deal to make USB-C a common charger for most electronic devices
Yeah, that's about the only thing you can do without ICs. 500mA max, high-speed lanes unused.
kanetw··on EU reaches deal to make USB-C a common charger for most electronic devices
Without CC line sensing, you don't know how much current you're allowed to draw.

Screenshot from the standard: https://i.kane.cx/EI4HtM

Specifically, the sink has to detect vRd to determine how much current it can actually draw.

E: sorry, to clarify: 2 resistors is fine, but you also need line sensing. So that's at least a few comparators or an ADC or whatever. Or a dedicated IC.

kanetw··on EU reaches deal to make USB-C a common charger for most electronic devices
I'm considering TBT3/4 for our VR headset's tethered mode. It's a bit of a pain to implement, but the data rate is worth it.

For reference, we need 2-4 lanes of DP HBR3 (depending on compression) + PCIe Gen3x4 for the camera passthrough. TBT3/4 could do it over a single cable.

Feeds into the nightmare that is implementing that entire ecosystem though...

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →