HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kanetw

468 karma · joined April 10, 2016

submissionscomments
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
Unfortunately still not high enough for low-compressed (DSC 3:1 ~= 9.2Gbit/s) or uncompressed video (~= 27.5Gbit/s) at least at our resolution. But might be viable for lower-res displays.
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
No other headset except the Varjo Aero use this technology, and only the high-end Varjos have a focal view display (1920x1920 in the central 27 degrees). Rest is basically uniform throughout.

We use the peak PPD for the Aero.

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
About +-15 degrees. This accounts for 86% of saccades.

I need to confirm how sharply it drops after that, but in any case it should be above 20 PPD +-(15 to 30) degrees and above 12 PPD for +-(30 to 50) degrees.

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
Yeah, the only way this is remotely feasible without massive latency and compression is a 802.11ay link, if it works when you're moving around. And since it's mmWave you'd need a base station in every room and 100Gbit ethernet to connect to it.
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
Yes, exactly. We want people to just put on a headset and use it, instead of having to boot Linux and plug everything in. God knows it's a pain when I'm developing with a tethered headset.
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
Latency and bandwidth.

We push about 3.4 GByte/s (or 27.5Gbit/s) to our displays. Even a 26Gbit/s DP1.4a HBR3 link needs display stream compression for that. So a wireless link will absolutely need strong compression.

H.265 can push that to maybe (ballpark) 200Mbit/s, which is fairly feasible. But that will need to be evaluated and optimized for text quality and latency. Some googling suggests 100ms end-to-end latency as good. That's pretty high for VR, IMO.

[Edit: fixed the DP1.4a bandwidth)

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
$1999 for the tethered version, which is in line with other upper-end headsets like the Varjo Aero (and that one doesn't have AR passthrough)
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
The computer is on the back of your head. We target a weight of about 800g* balanced evenly, so it shouldn't be more straining than an Index

* Preliminary number, might change as we make tradeoffs of battery life vs thermal solution vs weight.

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
We use variable magnification for the lenses. That is, the foveal region has a higher PPD and the periphery has a lower PPD. As your eyes follow the same pattern (your fovea has a high resolution, everything else drops off sharply), it's basically a free PPD gain.

I put a link to the paper [1], but it's paywalled.

[1] https://www.spiedigitallibrary.org/conference-proceedings-of...

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
I'll talk with George about introducing a refund policy. In fact I'm pretty sure we had it in the original drafts for the webshop, but since we moved to Kickstarter funding we haven't thought about that yet.
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
To give a comparison, 35 PPD is equivalent to a 1080p screen 60cm away from you.

So the resolution is basically there, but what about latency? Output-to-photon is as direct as possible (NUC Displayport -> DP-to-MIPI -> Displays), so the only question is how low we can get the motion-to-output latency.

Unfortunately that's not a question I can answer yet. Tracking is hard, especially when you're designing for a portable headset. But I'm pretty sure we'll be able to get it to sub-frame latency if my mmWave idea works out.

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
I'm experimenting with mmWave RADAR to get depth mapping without the idiosyncrasies of stereo RGB cameras. Especially in wildly varying environments I think that's the way to go over traditional camera-based SLAM. But if it turns out to be unfeasible, nothing's stopping us from adding more tracking cameras and doing it that way.
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
The heat should be fairly manageable. Most of the front side components are low-power and we'll be managing the climate in the face part so you don't get sweaty due to low circulation.

The compute pack will be at the back of your head with the airflow going away from you, so it shouldn't be too noticeable. Thermal design is definitely a priority for us.

Putting it on your head reduces the amount of cables on your person, so you don't accidentally tangle yourself or something. Also, it improves the balance so it might actually feel better than a front-heavy headset (compare a Vive with an Index for example).

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
It will be. We'll be demoing the AR mode in our Kickstarter ad, but basically the entire background will be replaced by passthrough.

No depth mapping yet, so it'll only be in the background, but first things first.

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
Several reasons:

* Square displays are what's readily available in the VR form factor (2-3" diagonal)

* Rectangular displays will murder your minimum IPD, which kills accessibility for a lot of users

* Reducing the size/increasing pixel density makes the optics exponentially more complex. We're already pushing the limits of what's possible without pancake lenses.

* Pancake lenses are a nightmare of complexity when you want high-quality images. Ghost images, low transmission, etc. all increase development cost by a lot. And the unit cost is significantly higher, but that's not an issue here (the NREs are the main cost driver)

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
We put in a lot of effort into the optics and we use variable magnification tech to get the most out of our displays (i.e. there's more pixels per degree in the foveal region, and less in the periphery where you can't see them anyways).

The drawback is that the optical train is long and there's 3 complex lenses as opposed to 1 glued assembly (not sure if it's 1 or 2 lenses). Adds per-unit cost and assembly labor, and at a $300 ($800 realistically) price point that's a lot.

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
We don't promote the weight because we aren't yet at the stage of integration where we can promote it at. However, you can expect it to be around 800g front+back combined, so around the same as an Index.

In our experience, a balanced headset is more important than a light one.

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
I guess it depends? I bought my P14s at basically MSRP and it didn't drop much. The X1 Carbon did drop a lot, though. We might adjust it to be "$2k current price, $3.4k MSRP" though.
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
It is removable. In fact, we plan to have it dockable so you can use it separately and reuse it for e.g. homeserver purposes when the hardware gets older.
kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
> Looking at the details of the article I still can't see what the breakout feature is that keeps me from just getting an Oculus Quest and using the Immersed app to do basically the same thing. The biggest "negative" the article seems to be focusing on is that you need a Facebook account to use Oculus Quest but I don't see many limits on the basic experience.

Compared to a Quest/Immersed combo:

* we offer significantly higher PPD (and better optics with no ghost images, Fresnel rings, etc.; but that's hard to quantify) than any other headset on the market except super-high end ones. You would not be able to read text on a Quest like you can on a normal 27" monitor; you can with our headset.

* Immersed does not do window management. We support unlimited, actual windows. Immersed only does a handful (up to 10 at reduced resolution? need to check) virtual displays, which is pretty annoying from a UX perspective.

* Immersed needs to be tethered, which is reduced quality and higher latency due to the WiFi connection.

kanetw··on Why is the Simula One so expensive?
Even if you reduce it to it's sale price it's favorable. It's not like we aren't on "sale" either via Kickstarter discounts.
kanetw··on Simula One (Linux VR PC) Pricing and Kickstarter Goal
There will be a tethered version priced at $2k without the builtin PC. Cameras are gonna be included, though.
kanetw··on SimulaVR – The Simula One's Pricing and Kickstarter Goal
What platform do you consider the right one?
kanetw··on SimulaVR – The Simula One's Pricing and Kickstarter Goal
You don't need to touch type, since AR passthrough is available. And a mouse is supported as well (probably the best method of pointer input; hands are too unreliable and tiring for continuous movements). Eye tracking might be a mouse alternative, though.
kanetw··on Simula One vs. Quest 2 vs. Valve Index
M/KB for 2D windows with AR passthrough should handle it I think. I'll think about some solution for people that want AR passthrough turned off.
kanetw··on Simula One vs. Quest 2 vs. Valve Index
- We plan to do the MP in Germany or the US, so most doesn't apply. Especially for a first product I do not want to have to deal with a language/culture barrier on top of everything else. - Yep, we have the mold costs factored into our BOM estimates. - Re; distribution, we plan to ship out of our own warehouses directly. DHL Express prices are fairly reasonable if you have a large volume.
kanetw··on Simula One vs. Quest 2 vs. Valve Index
It's accounted for. Eye rotation is not very severe; 86% of saccades are within 15 degrees.
kanetw··on Simula One vs. Quest 2 vs. Valve Index
The displays are a semicustom Sharp part.
kanetw··on Simula One vs. Quest 2 vs. Valve Index
That's exactly what we do to achieve our 36 PPD figure.
kanetw··on Simula One vs. Quest 2 vs. Valve Index
Outside and dark environments, primarily. A stereo RGB camera approach isn't satisfactory when the conditions are less than ideal. I've also talked with people working in the space and they mentioned that a custom-integrated SLAM (i.e. not a prepackaged all-in-one module) is a big time-sink of corner cases if you want high-quality tracking, which is why "just use a module" is our fallback if we run into a complexity explosion.

Front-facing cameras, hmm. I'm not sure I like it from a usability POV, but it's something to consider. I think going the extra mile and including internal cameras for a seamless UX is better, though.

← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →