HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

karaterobot

21,592 karma · joined October 22, 2009

         __
    (___()'`;
    /,    /`
    \\"--\\
submissionscomments
karaterobot··on Gurus of 90s Web Design: Zeldman, Siegel, Nielsen
I don’t think designers hated Nielsen. I was doing web design at the time, and the general sentiment seemed to be: “Sure, he’s probably right—but the client wants it done their way instead, so…”

Still, his bite-sized advice stuck around and continues to shape the conversation. That’s where everyone learned about Fitts’ Law, Hick’s Law, optimal text column widths, the value of usability testing with just a few users, and the deep shame you should feel for making text hard to read. He may not have invented those ideas, but his articles popularized them. And because he was one of the few doing serious usability research and publishing it online, his authoritative voice gave those ideas real weight that designers could leverage to make the case to their bosses and clients.

karaterobot··on Japan Post launches 'digital address' system
> Japan Post plans to spend about a decade to promote broad adoption of the new system.

The actual feature doesn't seem mind-blowingly useful to me, in the era where most of my form fields get populated for me automatically anyway. Doesn't seem bad, just I don't see it being a life changing thing. I'd hope it does not work as a way for the Post to learn a little bit about my shopping habits. Probably not. Who knows.

But what I think is cool is a ten-year commitment to any computer-based system, which is sadly rare to see these days.

karaterobot··on Trying to teach in the age of the AI homework machine
> The fact that AI can do your homework should tell you how much your homework is worth.

I mean... if you removed the substring "home" from that sentence, is it still true in your opinion?

That is, do you believe that because AI can perform some task, that task must not have any value? If there's a difference, help me understand it better please.

karaterobot··on I salvaged $6k of luxury items discarded by Duke students
College students may have no concept of how much stuff costs when their parents buy it. But to be fair, I'm in my 40s, and throw out a lot of expensive stuff too. When you're moving house, you're often tired and anxious, and thinking more about the burden of hauling crap around than you are with the price of replacing it. For me, I actually appreciate the forcing function imposed by the size of a moving van or a storage space, it works better than Marie Kondo to help get rid of stuff I've accumulated. I may believe the underlying reasons justify my behavior, but I can't judge anyone else for doing the same thing on the biased assumption that their reasons are less defensible.
karaterobot··on The UI future is colourful and dimensional
> Airbnb announced a new design and we’ve all just collectively accepted that it’s the future?

Don't overindex on one guy with a newsletter. My read on this article was this is someone trying to be the guy who called the next trend. He cites no evidence supporting the claim that it's the next trend, he's just trying to be the guy who puts a name to it so that he's an influencer if it does.

He also mentions how he's been designing icons in this style for decades, which should make a skeptical person wonder whether there might be some wishful thinking going on here.

What I can tell you for sure is that, as a professional designer, I have not received any memos mandating the use of this style of icons. I'll let you know when I do.

karaterobot··on Duolingo CEO tries to walk back AI-first comments, fails
I sort of wonder whether they realized gamification works for certain kinds of tasks, but not for others, and then decided to design their language learning app for gamification, rather than designing a gamification system to support language learning. In other words, I don't think Duolingo's system can really make you fluent in a language, but what it seems to excel in is making you use Duolingo every day. In other other words, you always hear people talking about how long their streak is ("500 days!") rather than how well they speak the language.
karaterobot··on Nick Clegg says asking artists for use permission would 'kill' AI industry
I'm the kind of creative whose job is threatened by AI, but if I'm being honest and cold-blooded, I'm not actually sure that I'd call what AI training does stealing—apart from any illicit acquisition of the data, that is. I'm open to being persuaded. I just have not read a really persuasive argument that when a model is trained, what it's doing is closer to stealing than it is to being influenced and then recapitulating the general form of those influences.

The latter is something we have no problem with in our culture. Every generation of artists do this. Every artist does this, in fact. It may be how creativity itself works, for all I know. But we never call it stealing, or when we do we say things like "great artists steal" and acknowledge it as a process rather than a problem.

It feels to me like when people make the "AI is stealing" argument, they're really arguing about something else and using this as a proxy for it. Not exactly sure what that other thing is. Fear of losing work and being displaced is the obvious one, and it's a valid fear. I share it! But, if that's what it is, I think we should be having that discussion directly, rather than talking around it. We always do the thing where we piss around talking about proxies, rather than going right to the agon.

karaterobot··on Lottie is an open format for animated vector graphics
Your comment reads like you're questioning their right to have an opinion based on demonstrating their qualifications to your satisfaction. That, and they have to reveal their identity on the internet to satisfy your requirements. I don't know if it was clear to you that that's how it sounds.
karaterobot··on Denmark to raise retirement age to 70
I didn't see them say it's not harder getting hired over age 50, I think they're questioning that the reason is really job hopping.
karaterobot··on OpenAI to buy AI startup from Jony Ive
Sometimes two collaborators make each other better than either are alone. I get the sense that's how Steve Jobs and Jony Ive were. I've not seen anything Ive has done since be as good as what he did before. Someone has to hold the spike so the other one can swing the hammer. My guess is that's not how this relationship with Altman will work. And that picture is terrifying, please take it down and destroy the camera that took it.
karaterobot··on Ask HN: When will managers be replaced by AI?
I think this is true. There was an article on HN the other day about how Moderna has already re-organized its leadership structure around AI.

It makes sense to me that AI could conceivably already be as good at making the hard, data-based decisions that CEOs make, and that, therefore, they could one day be replaced by AI. Meanwhile, you've got the soft skills part of being an executive, which humans are better at (as long as the people they deal with are also humans). So, you could split that CEO role into two parts, each specializing in half of what a CEO today does. Both roles would probably do a better job than the median CEO today, and get paid less overall.

But that "not anytime soon" part is the only thing I disagree with. Because I just don't know how long the timeline is for stuff like that. It can change pretty fast.

karaterobot··on Dilbert creator Scott Adams says he will die soon from same cancer as Joe Biden
Oh no, I'm sorry to hear that. In the early 90s, my family didn't get the newspaper, so my friend who lived in town would save the comics page for me to read every week. Dilbert was one of the big ones! It was funny and subversive, and I'll remember all the laughs Scott Adams has given me.
karaterobot··on Remarks on AI from NZ
I like the taxonomy of animal-human relationships as a model for asking how humans could relate to AI in the future. It's useful for framing the problem. However, I don't think that any existing relationship model would hold true for a superintelligence. We keep lapdogs because we have emotional reactions to animals, and to some extent because we need to take care of things. Would an AI? We tolerate dust mites in our eyelashes because we don't notice them, and can't do much about them anyway. Is that true for an AI? What does such an entity want or need, what are their motivations, what really pisses them off? Or, do any of those concepts hold meaning to them? The relationship between humans and a superintelligent AGi just can't be imagined.
karaterobot··on Why Moderna Merged Its Tech and HR Departments
> The biotech company late last year announced the creation of a new role, chief people and digital technology officer, promoting its human resources chief Tracey Franklin to the spot.

I've been wondering recently when boards of directors will realize that the role of CEO might quite acceptably be split into two parts: an executive, who makes decisions to implement a high-level vision based on data and cold-blooded analysis, and (for lack of a better word) a culture head, who is the public face of the company, and keeps relationships with people, and gives inspiring speeches, and so on.

The executive part, it seems to me, might quite adequately be replaced by an AI. I don't even mean a hypothetical future AI, I mean literally the level of GPT models we have today. People's response to this is often "but what about genius visionaries like Steve Jobs?" and I admit that they can't be replaced. But, I'm talking about the median CEO, of the median corporation. Or even the bottom 80%, maybe. I don't think that part of their job is safe from AI in the medium term, except by gatekeeping and inertia. I firmly believe AI could do as good a job at that than most CEOs, and better than many, more cheaply, and more predictably.

(Everybody else's jobs aren't safe from AI, of course. It's just a matter of AI agents working up the ladder of complexity, from intern-level work, to junior, then senior, and so on. An important assumption here is that the executive part of being a CEO is not particularly difficult, or different from what AI has been shown to excel at already. Just that once the decision maker's job is in danger of being replaced, there will all of a sudden be a lot more skepticism about AI's ability to do human tasks.)

The other half of that split, the inspiring networker with amazing soft skills, who is good at driving the company culture and building relationships, would be harder to replace with an AI for the foreseeable future. Because they're not as good at it right now, and because people don't want to be led by a machine. That'll be true for a generation at least, but I imagine that could change as well. Things get normalized, and people's expectations change when their experience changes.

What Moderna just did is not what I've described above, but it does feel like a step toward it.

karaterobot··on Sci-Net
Well, I'm responding to someone who said one of the purposes of the coin was to make money to pay for infrastructure, which the article specifically says is not true.

It sounds like you're making a separate accusation, which I have no opinion about. There's nothing in that statement about them owning a significant part of the token supply, though it may be true for all I know. Do you have any evidence for it, or is it just your expectation of what will happen?

karaterobot··on Sci-Net
> I'm not accusing Elbakyan's character or ideals in any way.

It really seems like you are though. The linked page says the transaction is between the article requester and the article contributor, and that she's not taking any money, even to support the platform. So, it seems like you're saying she's lying about that.

karaterobot··on Sci-Net
They make it very clear they aren't taking a cut. The quote in the linked page is "payments go to fellow researchers, not to the platform."
karaterobot··on Sci-Net
It seems like this coin mechanic is just for people who want to request specific articles that aren't already on Sci-hub, and those who upload requested papers. So, for everyone who doesn't want to engage with that system, there's no change, right?

I hope so, because it sounds dumb.

karaterobot··on LLMs are making me dumber
I bet they do, but it's not a question of learning the skills in school. It's more about using those skills, which I don't think is as common today.
karaterobot··on LLMs are making me dumber
Looking around, I don't see too many people exploring higher order skills using that spare brain power. I think at the margins, you've probably got really smart scientists/engineers/philosophers doing that, but what does the ordinary person in the street do? This is the grumpiest thing I'll say today, but it seems like they just scroll social media on their phones while streaming media plays in the background.
karaterobot··on LLMs are making me dumber
> No one lamented the advent of calculators.

It's interesting that he lists a number of historical precedents, like the invention of the calculator, or the mechanization of labor in the industrial revolution, and explains how they are different than AI. With the exception of chess, I think he's wrong about the effects of all of them.

For instance, people did lament the invention of calculators, saying it would harm kids' ability to do mental arithmetic. And it did. People also said that GPS navigation would hurt people's ability to use a map, or create one in their heads. And I'm old enough to say: it absolutely did. People (in aggregate) are worse at those skills now.

Fortunately for us, we replaced those skills with technology that allowed us to do something analogous to them, but faster and more easily.

The question is: what are the second- and third-order effects of losing those skills, or not learning them in the first place? Is it crazy to think that not memorizing things because we can access printed (and digitized) material might have larger, unforeseen consequences on our brains, or our societies? Could mechanizing menial labor have induced some change in how we think, or have any long term effects on our bodies?

I think we're seeing—and will continue to see—that there are knock-on effects to technology that we can't predict beforehand. We think we're making a simple exchange of an old, difficult skill for a new, easy one, but we're actually causing a more far-reaching cascade of changes that nobody can warn us of in advance.

And, to me, the even scarier thing is that those of us who don't live through those changes will have no basis for comparison to know whether the trade-off was worth it.

karaterobot··on U.S. nuclear base hidden under Greenland's ice for decades
No need to ask. As mentioned in the article, the U.S. has the right, by treaty, to build military bases in Greenland already.
karaterobot··on One hundred and one rules of effective living
I think that's a lot of rules to try to carry around in your head. If it works for this guy, more power to him.

For my money, Do unto others as you would have them do unto you shows up in some form or another in most major civilizations, and there's probably a reason for that. It's simple, makes sense, and covers a lot of situations.

If I had a number two rule to add, it would be slower traffic keep right. That's deep wisdom with a practical application.

karaterobot··on Coffee for people who don't like coffee
In general, I think having an unrefined palate is one of life's great gifts. I admit there are areas of food where I'm a snob, but that just means I can't enjoy examples of that food which I consider sub-par, which is more of a curse than a blessing.

And, for all the areas where I have no particular expertise or discerning taste, I can just enjoy the cheapest and most easily available version of that thing. It's awesome!

Take chocolate for example: at this point in my life, every piece of chocolate I eat is a treat, and when I'm with someone who just can't eat cheap chocolate (Hersheys) my reaction is "sucks to be you, nom nom nom". If I went down a rabbit hole where I could only enjoy a subset of all chocolate, I'd consider that a worse situation than being able to enjoy all chocolate.

I think people believe there is something like a magnitude of enjoyment, and when you are an expert eating something you consider perfect, you enjoy it more. I think that's probably dead wrong, and nothing has empirically disproven that for me. Certainly in the long run you'll enjoy fewer things than people with no (supposed) taste.

karaterobot··on The great displacement is already well underway?
It's hard to say for sure without knowing his whole situation, but I will agree with you that when I hear someone say they've submitted 750 applications, my first thought is that they're taking a machine gun approach, applying to a lot of jobs in a short time. I was always taught that you tailor your resume to the position you're applying for, and apply only after doing a lot of research on the company to know whether you are suitable for their position. I'm older than the author of this post, and applied for my most recent job at about his age—though it was a few years ago, before AI was really a consideration. In my entire life, I've probably applied to ~25 positions, made it to the final round 8 times, and been hired 6 times.

Knock on wood that he's wrong about the cause of his current frustration, because that means it's fixable.

karaterobot··on No mass shootings so far this year in America
https://archive.ph/aC1el

> As of May 10, there have been four shootings in the United States in which four or more victims died this year, compared with 11 at the same juncture last year.

...

> The truth is these events are exceedingly rare. Moreover, nearly half of all mass shootings take place in private dwellings

Presumably the reason the headline says zero, and the article says four, is that the distinction between public and private mass shootings. If there's some other reason for the confusing headline, I missed it in the article.

It's still great news, and I happen to agree with the author of this opinion piece that the media have overstated the severity of the problem. Obviously the ideal number is zero, but the anxiety around mass shootings is out of line with the actual magnitude of the risk in comparison to other risks we could be talking about instead.

karaterobot··on US vs. Google amicus curiae brief of Y Combinator in support of plaintiffs [pdf]
For the sake of argument, let's grant the implication that Google is in danger of going out of business. Even so, if our economy is at the point where one company going out of business would cripple it, it's almost certainly worth the pain of decoupling from that company. It would hurt, but we would get through it, and it would be better in the long run. On the other hand, if we just threw up our hands and said "do whatever you want, Google, you're too important for us to tell you what to do" then we're pretty much at their mercy. I can't imagine things getting better or fixing themselves in that situation.
karaterobot··on The Deathbed Fallacy (2018)
> What I want you to take away is this: Don’t bother with the Deathbed Fallacy. Look at happiness research...

Right, don't make the mistake of overindexing on what people say as they're dying, instead base your life on something accurate, reliable, and unchanging, like happiness research.

karaterobot··on Former Supreme Court justice David Souter has died
> What I worry about is that when problems are not addressed, people will not know who is responsible. And when the problems get bad enough—as they might do for example with another serious terrorist attack, as they might do with another financial meltdown—some one person will come forward and say 'give me total power, and I will solve this problem'. That is how the Roman republic fell: Augustus became emperor not because he arrested the Roman Senate, he became emperor because he promised that he would solve problems that were not being solved.

> If we know who is responsible, I have enough faith in the American people to demand performance from those responsible. If we don't know, we will stay away from the polls, we will not demand it, and the day will come when somebody will come forward, and we and the government will, in effect, say 'take the ball and run with it. Do what you have to do.' That is the way democracy dies, and if something is not done to improve the level of civic knowledge, that is what you should worry about at night.

karaterobot··on India launches attack on 9 sites in Pakistan and Pakistani Jammu and Kashmir
There aren't a lot of examples of a country being unwilling or unable to fight in a full-scale war, and instead launching nukes at their next door neighbor. I don't think this is part of the playbook, or based on evidence, I think it's coming from anxiety.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →