HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

karma_vaccum123

818 karma · joined July 3, 2016

submissionscomments
karma_vaccum123··on Douglas Crockford Out as Keynote Speaker at Nodevember
Can't wait until these people try making a kernel patch.
karma_vaccum123··on Palo Alto mayor pushes for ban on large tech companies taking over downtown
You cannot compare SF and Palo Alto. SF is a major metro with a high-density downtown with corresponding infrastructure.

The people who are opposed to greater density in Palo Alto ARE TECHIES. Who do you think lives there?

karma_vaccum123··on Palo Alto mayor pushes for ban on large tech companies taking over downtown
Wrong. There are codes describing density and building height. Palo Alto city council will never change these rules, indeed, they seem intent on making them more stringent.

You go ask the billionaires in ProfessorVille how many of them are interested in changing zoning to triple density in downtown without any corresponding improvement in transportation infrastructure (most of which is not under the control of Palo Alto)

karma_vaccum123··on Palo Alto mayor pushes for ban on large tech companies taking over downtown
Google moved out of University Ave as soon as they exceeded the capacity...they didn't try taking over downtown, they took over boring office park space north of 101 in PA for a while.
karma_vaccum123··on Palo Alto mayor pushes for ban on large tech companies taking over downtown
Where? Downtown Palo Alto is saturated...and building up won't solve saturation on Alma, University, Page Mill etc.

Palo Alto has simply maxed out its carrying capacity...businesses like Palantir would be better off looking at areas like the emerging business park near San Jose Airport, where Apple has already committed to building a campus with even more square footage than the Spaceship campus.

karma_vaccum123··on Palo Alto mayor pushes for ban on large tech companies taking over downtown
They are worried that a tech company will collapse or move and leave downtown in a shambles.

This happened in Mountain View with SGI.

Tech companies will also cause rents to explode, driving away many independent businesses....so oddly enough, tech companies may create a dead zone accidentally.

karma_vaccum123··on Google shelves plan for phone with interchangeable parts
Interesting theory but Fuchsia seems years away (unless they have a non-public repo that is much further along)
karma_vaccum123··on Google shelves plan for phone with interchangeable parts
Was anyone really hoping for this? It seemed pretty clear that this was a a technology exploration.
karma_vaccum123··on Google shelves plan for phone with interchangeable parts
As the Moto Z will likely confirm, no one is really interested in modular phones.
karma_vaccum123··on PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS
You can run a variant of GNUStep today, yet no one does.
karma_vaccum123··on PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS
Hire a designer to make Lumina less ugly. Sorry I know that sounds harsh, but it looks very 2005.

Make this install on modern laptops. I'm tired of being recommended five year-old Thinkpads.

Fix those and I would consider overwriting my Ubuntu installation

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
Of course you can violate your EULA in your own home and get away with it...but you are still violating your EULA and that has absolutely nothing to do with linux or Linus or the GPLV2 anyway
karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
The GPLv2 has absolutely nothing to do with the EULA for a product.

Your beef is with device vendors, not Linus.

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
You answered your own question - linux is GPLv2 and always will be. It will never be GPLv3; Linus hates GPLv3.

GPLv2 doesn't grant you a right to hack, period.

karma_vaccum123··on A SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket has exploded at Cape Canaveral
You can just say explosion, we're not at the Cape.
karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
> If you're someone who has a shitty Bluetooth light bulb running a version of GNU/Linux, the person who has given you that device has taken away your software freedom

How? You don't have a right to modify the device you purchased. You don't have a right to manufacture a clone of the device and run your patched code on it. The vendor can happily decline patches from you. So can Linus.

All you will have is the right to inspect code they used and learn from it or reuse it in a lightbulb you choose to manufacture that doesn't violate some other IP the original vendor has on the original bulb.

There is absolutely nothing about the GPL that grants you any particular freedom regarding the specific light bulb you purchased. If it sucks, it will continue to suck.

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
There is no catch 22. You simply have to figure out what the goals actually are. Linus' goal is to have a vibrant community that has access to the changes he approves in the kernel. The FSF's goal is to eradicate non-free software.

Linus doesn't care about the odd scofflaw because they don't interfere with his goal. The FSF on the other hand cannot abide scofflaws because their only goal is to eliminate them.

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
By that argument, every non-copyleft licensed codebase is "dead" with respect to the "people".

In reality, the opposite is true even though it burns up FSF folks. Linux is alive and well. You can download, read, edit and contribute back to the kernel for free. Maybe your patches won't be accepted, but the license doesn't guarantee that they will be anyway.

It is true that you may periodically experience a scofflaw that sells you a router that hides some kernel code, but this should only bother you on philosophical grounds. The vendor has no obligation to allow you to "repair" or modify the device. The vendor is under no obligation to accept a patch from you if you find a flaw. Putting linux in a device does not grant the end user any specific right to change the device's behavior. People seem to be confusing "hackable" with "has GPL code". A shitty router with linux code will probably remain a shitty router.

I can see why the FSF and SFC might be throwing a fit; Clang and LLVM can replace GCC, and Linus isn't at all militant about license enforcement. The effective power of the FSF is in rapid decline.

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
> Enforcement of the license people agreed to will cause people to avoid using the license?

If it means lawsuits, yes. Companies will either seek out a non-GPL solution, or they will be even more secretive about their use of linux. Either way, linux loses and 95% of linux users lose....and the violations will continue anyway.

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
The vendor isn't obliged to make their device hackable even if they do publish the source. Some do, and that's neat, but in most cases, access to the source might, at best, only result in the next iteration of device having some change in a year's time. Your little box will continue to make you unhappy. You should just get a refund.

The kernel developers aren't on the hook at all here. No one told you to buy a specific device.

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
....and Linus' point is that the victory will be pyrrhic, since people will simply avoid the GPL altogether.

We've already seen this with the GPLv3/AGPL. Really outside of the FSF, the only adoption is in dual-licensers who use it to drive purchases of the alternatively-licensed sources.

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
They can already hide behind legal firewalls like the Chinese border. If the Software Conservancy continues, they'll just push more development to places where scofflaws can ignore them.
karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
The phone makers don't care about specific the kernel used in Android. They care that they can access AOSP. AOSP could use other kernels and other licenses, it wouldn't impact Android's success or value at this point.

Go look at the kernel version in Android, even Android 7.0...kernel 3.10. We might be overestimating how important linux is to Android.

OEMs that produce devices end up doing non-free things writing checks to companies like Micorosft for intellectual property, so it isn't like AOSP delivers on the promise to let anyone make a phone, GPL kernel or not.

If Google actually follows through with this Fuchsia project, do you think OEMs will balk because the kernel isn't GPL'd? No one will care.

karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
This is one of Linus' main points in the discussion, it will change the tone and signal to partners that interactions with the kernel community will carry with it interactions with the Software Conservancy, which most companies will see as an expensive, frustrating and pointless waste of resources.
karma_vaccum123··on The kernel community confronts GPL enforcement
I see this as a stealth attempt by the Software Conservancy to hijack the direction and tone of kernel development, dragging it more to FSF-style militancy.

Linus is right, there is no crisis in GPL violation. There will always be violators. Any law or contract or license will be violated. Becoming more militant about enforcement will simply cause most corporate partners to disengage. Most users comply with the license. Users have access to interesting and useful source code and have never been restricted from accessing the kernel. The kernel team is on good terms with most corporate users. Going after the 5% of violators will change how the kernel team interacts with the 95% of good partners.

The only thing Linus seems to be disingenuous about is his claim of support for the GPLv2. My guess is he secretly wishes he had chosen a different, non-copyleft license.

karma_vaccum123··on Network programming with Go (2012)
This book appeared very shortly after Go hit 1.0. It was an invaluable resource at the time. Now, maybe not so much, but thanks to Jan for putting in the work when it was dearly needed by the community.
karma_vaccum123··on Doreen Valiente: The story of the mother of modern witchcraft
She supplanted mainstream gibberish (monotheistic religions) with fringe gibberish, that's all.

I've never understood the lofty attitudes of people who engage non-traditional supernatural beliefs. You're just a different idiot.

karma_vaccum123··on The Google X moonshot factory is struggling to get products out the door
It doesn't, but if Google keeps feeding moonshot stories to the press, they should expect the press to circle back and see if there is any follow-through.

If Google X is really just a nerd-PR exercise, let's call it that.

karma_vaccum123··on The Google X moonshot factory is struggling to get products out the door
Or maybe you can't just put people in a room and say "invent stuff".

It may sound hackneyed, but I believe necessity is the mother of invention and it doesn't seem there is that kind of motivation here...it feels forced.

karma_vaccum123··on The Google X moonshot factory is struggling to get products out the door
This feels like the type of operation better suited for a tier-one educational institution like Stanford or MIT.

In a academic context, there is no subtext of creating products. Yeah, churning out papers is as contrived...but I still feel like the timelines in academia are more generous.

Google talks a good press event, highlighting their embrace of failure, their desire to take on crazy moonshots etc...but its all in the context of quarterly reports. Something has to give.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →