HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on Is the social media bubble about to burst?
People miss the main point. The democratic voting of two countries was manipulated using social media, it puts at risk our rights, and freedoms. And this happened with collaboration, direct or indirect, from Facebook.

Privacy concerns are an important motivator. But we have already things a lot more tangible than that.

I like the concept of social media, of sharing moments with people I know but I don't have day to day contact, of communicating with my family that is in another country. But the way it's implemented is scary, and it has lasting world-wide consequences.

I would not mind paying X$ monthly to have quality social media. But this can't happen while it competes with free social media where your data is the product. Regulate the market, force it to move in a more healthy direction and let new companies grow and drive inside the new game rules, and make the old ones to adapt.

kartan··on Police chief said Uber victim “came from the shadows” – don’t believe it
> “Arizona welcomes Uber self-driving cars with open arms and wide open roads. While California puts the brakes on innovation and change with more bureaucracy and more regulation, Arizona is paving the way for new technology and new businesses. In 2015, I signed an executive order supporting the testing and operation of self-driving cars in Arizona with an emphasis on innovation, economic growth, and most importantly, public safety. This is about economic development, but it’s also about changing the way we live and work. Arizona is proud to be open for business. California may not want you, but we do.”

https://azgovernor.gov/governor/news/2016/12/governor-ducey-...

Politics can always be an explanation.

kartan··on The health care toll today’s work culture exacts on employees
>> I am not even allowed to tell a candidate (another human being that probably NEEDS a paycheck) why I didn't hire them and what they can do to improve their viability. > Policies like this exist because candidates have and will sue the shit out of you for any flimsy accusation of discrimination they can cobble together.

I thought that it was the other way around. You need to have always ready the reasons why a candidate has been rejected and give them on request. Otherwise, they can sue you as your reasons are not clean and transparent.

But, I guess that this depends on the country's laws.

kartan··on Redesigning: Architect vs. Team Consensus
> choose someone to do it their way and everyone else help out

If you choose wrong you are going to have a team following someone that nobody else thinks it's right.

The solution is to have an arbiter,some one that makes sure that compromises are reached and the design moves forward.

Document all decisions and stuck to them unless a major problem doesn't allows it. Some people will try to reopen closed discussions if the result was not the one that they wanted.

To find a great solution requires a lot of time, and trial and error. Don't get to change all the system at the same time. Do small improvements in the agreed direction. Get feedback often about the quality of the changes. If there is any major flaws you will need to go back to design.

In the future is better that redesign is part of the normal process. Don't let the project get old. Technical debt accumulates easily, remove it as soon as possible.

But it's going to be difficult depending on the state and size of the project. Follow up all decisions,and support the team if they break something while doing the improvements.

Depending on the size you can read The Phoenix project. It's a book on how to work with improvements to big projects.

kartan··on Self-driving Uber car kills Arizona woman crossing street
> What should be passed (but I can't see how) is a percentage of allowed deaths, at least in the early years, and set it to something like 5-10% of the current rate, reducing downwards to 1% after 20 years.

Whith so few self driving cars that number sold be zero. If you can't assure safety with a few cars whith a human as backup, you should not be in the streets. And it's not the first dangerous accident of an Uber self driving car where Uber was at fault.

kartan··on Self-driving Uber car kills Arizona woman crossing street
Again... 'Uber has temporarily suspended the testing of its self-driving cars following the crash of one of them in Tempe, Ariz. The ride-hailing company had also been conducting experiments in Pittsburgh and San Francisco.'

I was resumed shortly after.

27 Mar 2017 (1 year ago)

https://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sel...

kartan··on Why Cities Boom While Towns Struggle
> I learned to program, almost entirely, on my own, in a vacuum.

Innovation is what requires a critical mass. You can learn from books, or nowadays from the internet, any skill. But what makes you move thousands of kilometers to a more vibrant city is the opportunity to grow beyond the old trends to create new ones.

Your achievement is impressive, but it just benefits you and your employer. Innovation is copied and used by the community as a whole.

kartan··on The Nightmare Letter: A Subject Access Request Under GDPR
> The concern is the drip/drip effect of more and more regulation making those numbers even worse.

There are industries, like construction, that have a lot more regulations that this one. And small companies survive.

> What are the costs compared to the benefits?

Benefit: Citizens have the right to protect their privacy, to not be tracked without reason, to be notified when a data breach put their safety at risk, etc.

Cost: Companies need to have reasonable data governance that will increase short-term cost, but probably have a long-term positive impact on cost as bad data governance is just technical debt.

kartan··on 'Striking weaknesses' in adult financial skills
If you want capitalism to work, you need some kind of "homo economicus" that is able to look for their own selfinterest.

If what you have is companies powered by complex financial systems and artificial intelligence help while consumers are not able to get a discount right, you are going to end with all money in one side of the table with the other empty handed.

This is another reason to improve our education systems. We need to function in an increasing complex society and that requires an incresing education quality with more resources, better methologies and more time dedicated to build knowledge and less to build national identity. (To memorize the list of presidents is not as an useful skill as it used to be, I guess).

kartan··on Google will ban all cryptocurrency-related advertising
> Google is a private business and they can do what they want

No. They can't. Countries have laws that regulate what companies can and can't do. That's why so many companies have had to pay fines in the past. To assert that "private business ... can do what they want" deteriorates democracies and the rule of law.

update: My comment is not about if Google did right or wrong, or if it's legal or not for them to ban cryptocurrency ads. My comment it's just a response to the parent about how private companies "can do what they want". Sorry for writing a comment so open to misinterpretation. I hope this clarification helps.

kartan··on AWS documentation is now open source and on GitHub
> Well as a user of Amazon you have a vested interest in the documentation being correct.

As a Walmart customer it's in my best interest that the aisles are clean. But I will doubt the legality to ask customers to clean the aisles so they don't need to pay for a cleaning service. Actually using volunteers to replace employees is kind of illegal.

kartan··on AWS documentation is now open source and on GitHub
> documenting open-source code for free

Foundations that own the open-source projects are allowed to use volunteer work by law. Corporations with a for-profit interest doesn't.

> or answering a stack overflow question?

This one is more tricky. But it depends on who asks the question? It is an individual to get help on a problem? Or is it part of the ways of working of a company to avoid hiring experts? Evaluating intention it's usually hard.

kartan··on AWS documentation is now open source and on GitHub
> Can someone explain to me why people will inevitably put in countless hours of free labor for Amazon here?

Most people is good a heart and they want to help, even when it's bad for themselves or even illegal.

"Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (“FLSA”) and many state and local wage and hour laws, the use of volunteers and interns is strictly regulated." https://www.forbes.com/sites/richardtuschman/2012/08/24/usin...

Amazon strategy is just another example of "if it's online it's legal". Destroying jobs in exchange of "experience", "visibility" or "a better curriculum" is regulated and for good reasons.

Do they want their software to be free? That's good. Everybody can use it and anyone can collaborate. Do they want their documentation to be reviewed and expanded by voluteers? Why not hire Technical Writers?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technical_writer

Amazon evades paying taxes while expecting that volunteers do their job instead of employees. The world economy can't continue running like this for long.

kartan··on How Sweden is building the world’s second-longest road tunnel
> "The harder and stronger the rock is, the quicker we advance."...

I like how counter-intuitive is this statement.

I used to live in a place where the soil was part of a river delta. It was really easy to drill but impossible to keep the tunnel in place and free of water. And it sometimes just sinks the above-ground facilities: https://www.20minutos.es/fotos/actualidad/24-horas-en-fotos-...

> ..."Drilling and blasting isn't so time-consuming, but sealing the rock from water leakage is. If the rock is very fractured, we need a lot of concrete sealant or reinforcement columns to ensure integrity," said Brantmark, describing the work of the three Atlas Copco Drill machines in use.

Now I live in Stockholm and it's pure rock. These are pictures from the subway: https://www.boredpanda.com/stockholm-metro-art-solna-centrum...

kartan··on Ask HN: How Did You Find a Job Abroad?
> Did you find and contact specific companies?

That is an option. Companies I have been working for have hired people that contacted directly. If you want to come to Stockholm, these are some companies I know people in:

- https://king.com/sv/jobs?locations=stockholm&roles=all - https://www.netent.com/en/section/work/ - https://www.spotifyjobs.com/

If you know the company you want to work for, just apply for that. But before that, make sure that you like the culture, weather, city, etc. where you are moving in. If you know which city or country, but not wich company, other methods are probably better that investigating company by company.

A good option is to work for an international company with cross-country secondment offers. I did this. I worked for a company in my country of origin, and then applied for a position in another company. It was quite easy.

kartan··on Diesel cars can be banned from German cities, court rules
> And the German economy would crash That will also happen if you remove any major industry. And that's why you plan that in the long term. You start banning some use cases, and you keep increasing it. That's what is being done with tobacco, for example. But it is not a reason to not do it.

So I think that you both are right, and it is just a misunderstanding on the time-frame that this changes will happen.

kartan··on China Seeks to Repeal Presidential Term Limit
> The skeptic in me would say that the new rulers try to discredit their predecessors with allegations of corruption.

The public servants are the ones that do this, not the new politicians. These actions involve police, judges, etc.

The allegations of corruption are there for every political campaign. One party will try to discredit the other one to lower their amount of votes. It makes little sense for politicians to bring corruption cases out of a political campaign. And sadly enough corruption is usually not one of the top topics of political campaigns as all parties have some corruption cases and most voters react the most to other more divisive - and probably irrelevant - issues.

kartan··on China Seeks to Repeal Presidential Term Limit
> You are saying that the corruption is established during the rule (before the change of power) but is more likely to be uncovered upon the change of power, correct?

Yes. In the corruption cases the involved party is the exiting one. As it loses power it can't keep the grip on the public officials and justice is free to work again.

City councils are an extreme example, as they can hold power for decades.

> As opposed to the corruption coming about because of the change of power, which is how I'm afraid some people could read your comment if they skim quickly.

You are right. It's just that I found the concept so implausible that I didn't though about that misread.

Thank you for the clarification.

kartan··on Overconfident Students, Dubious Employers
> Confidence only works if you keep up the illusion so thoroughly that it ceases to be an illusion.

This was the same for me as new manager. I was less confident that I let interviewers see. But in the end I got that confidence for real. "Fake it till you make it"

kartan··on China Seeks to Repeal Presidential Term Limit
I have seen changes of power of governments after 16 years. The result is always that corruption is discovered. After 16 years politicians have had time to get used to power and to put friendly people as public service officers. When power shifts corruption surfaces. The longer the term, the more corruption is found. Some parties are worse than others, but all are worst at the end of a decade that when they began.

It is my experience, and it seems logical. But I don't know if there is studies about this effect.

kartan··on For AI to thrive, it must explain itself
Some people are missing the point.

> "In particular, machine minds that cannot explain themselves, or whose detailed operation is beyond the realm of human language, pose a problem for criminal law."

It doesn't says that the AI is NOT useful, but that it can't be used for the liability that it creates.

> "Dr Datta feeds the system under test a range of input data and examines its output for dodgy, potentially harmful or discriminatory results." ... " If the randomisation of sex produces no change in the number of women offered jobs by the AI, but randomising weightlifting ability increases it (because some women now appear to have “male”abilities to lift weights), then it is clear that weightlifting ability itself, not an applicant’s sex, is affecting the hiring process."

This is the most interesting part of the article. As it shows that it's possible to test the system for unlawful decisions without actually understanding how it thinks.

kartan··on Concerns that social media causes childhood depression
A better society will help us to be less depressed.

I have had some experiences with ill-behaving companies. Where bosses think that employees need to be in fear so they are more productive. Where people is told to "never make a mistake" or they will be fired. You get the picture. People is depressed. You see people actually crying at their job.

I have also worked for functioning companies. People is valued and get positive feedback on their job. Mistakes are investigated to get an understanding and improve the processes to help people but personal blaming is forbidden. Where the manager´s job is to help employees to achieve their potential and support them.

In the first situation people is depressed and unhappy. People is paranoic and don´t trust each other. A blaming culture rewards lying about the status of projects and their results.

In the second situation people is more happy at work. Meetings are constructive and ways of improving the company are found. People find themselves realized at work.

Social media is just a mirror of society. It magnifies its uglyness or its greatness. I love to get into social media and see nature pictures from one friend. Another one composes music and shares it on-line. Most people will react joining into a good joke and answering with some one has a practical question. I love to be on social media, but I can understand how different that experience will be for others. Like the two companies I described, the same personal circunstances can be seen as gloomy or fantastic by the influence of your environment.

Social media can, and maybe should be regulated, but the only solution to the problem is better education that values the indivual while encourage to work for the better of all society. And then society is going to be able to look at the mirror and like the image that is sees.

kartan··on No Causal Effect of Music Practice on Ability (2014) [pdf]
"A common operationalization of music ability is sensory discrimination of auditory musical stimuli of vari- ous types". Music ability is defined as "rhythm, melody, and pitch discrimination". So it´s not about being able to play music, but hearing and classification ability.

So it translatates in non-fancy-wording. Being able to differenciate rhythms and melodies depends on your genetics and can not be practiced for improvement. But it says nothing about the effect of practicing on being a better music performer.

kartan··on Google is buying Chelsea Market building for over $2B
I visited Chelsea Market Google offices by mistake. I was at the market, and not knowing so much about it, I though that was small. So me and a friend got into the elevator to go to the next floor.

The elevator just opens and there it is. It was Google´s offices with a big green Android figure. I took a picture and just went back to the market using the elevator.

As it was a weekend, I was on vacation, there was no one.

So "suddenly Google" is one of my memories to my travel to New York.

kartan··on Ikea founder leaves fortune to no one, structures it to ensure it lasts forever
> Because there is no point in being frugal if you have to pay significant corporate tax. And it helped expand "the empire" he was building, because he could reinvest everything.

Only profits are taxed, not sales. So if you "reinvest everything" you are not going to pay taxes.

You can hire more people, buy other companies, rent more equipment, etc. The net result is that the company grows but has no profits. It doesn't work if it buys real-estate, for example, as that increases the company value and the owner then needs to pay for the increase of the value of the company. But then it's on the share value increase, and not in profits.

High taxes can incentive grow as spending money to grow it's less costly than to capitalize profits. That's why lowering taxes is seen as an opportunity to withdraw money and reduce investment.

kartan··on US regulators charge three Bitcoin operators with fraud
> If someone wants to loose money on blatant scams with many warning signs, I say let them.

I find this an abhorrent behavior that predates the uneducated. We have failed as a society to provide some people, actually a lot of people, with a good education. That people has a hard time defending themselves. Your solution to our failure is to let them being victims of scammers as punishment for being born with a lack of resources.

This is not only morally wrong but even from a purely utilitarian perspective only creates an incentive for companies to move from normal business to legalized scam practices.

> I know saying this makes me unpopular Take this as constructive feedback. This way of starting your comment creates the same kind of feeling than starting your sentence with "I'm not racist but...". It doesn't add anything to the conversation and it looks like you are trying to excuse something that yourself find wrong to start with.

kartan··on Subverted Design
Companies that play nice can't compete with companies that abuse our human biases and flaws. There is a niche for customers that care, and actually get annoyed by this practices, but it's not representative of the global population.

Only a combination of laws that forbid the worst practices and better education for citizens can solve the problem. Because, as for today, improving our brains to remove our cognitive failures it's not an option. Animals evolved tricks, hacks and heuristics to deal with world rules that are completely subverted in the on-line world.

> If you look at a Product Manager’s performance reviews, you’ll see they’re often inextricably tied to metrics. Make this number go up. Now make it go up more. Make that other one go down. Ok, here’s your bonus.

This goes way deeper than UX design. A good read on the topic may be https://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/11/04/forget-more-re... . We need to rethink corporations, that will allow all citizens to have a moral behaviour at their jobs. Instead to have to wait to become "... immensely valued within the tech world. ... well compensated." to be able to afford it.

kartan··on Paying journalists to promote brands in articles
"2.1 Advertisements must be obviously distinguishable from editorial content, especially if they use a situation, performance or style reminiscent of editorial content, to prevent the audience being confused between the two. The audience should quickly recognise the message as an advertisement."

https://www.asa.org.uk/type/broadcast/code_section/02.html

kartan··on On the global survival of mafias
> depth of trust

I guess that it's more about the big boss is always right.

Written records are needed for a fair observance of contracts. With no fairness, contracts are useless because one side can change them without consecuences.

"I'm altering the deal. Pray I don't alter it any further." Darth Vader.

kartan··on LastPass is causing major JavaScript slowdowns in Chrome
Recently I had a lot of problems uploading content with Microsoft Edge, the cuprit was LastPass. Now I have it disabled until I need a password.

Lastpass is a good tool, I hope they fix this issues.

← PreviousPage 14 of 25Next →