HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on Google and Facebook should be regulated for news content, UK government report
> We are talking of censorship conducted by the government, the worst kind there is.

Why the censorship is done by a corporation is so much better than the one done by an elected government? I think that censorship is the wrong thing not who does it.

> So on to the idea that Google and Facebook should be regulated, I think it's an absolutely horrible idea.

For what it seems the USA election was deeply impacted by a foreign hostile government using Facebook ads. There are countries where sectarian violence is on the rise thanks to how Facebook prioritises stories for engagement.

Facebook or Google need to be regulated because they are radicalizing people in search of more engagement to sell more ads. That is not a good situation, and there is no incentive for them to stop doing it. As it is the best way to get more money.

Should these companies be allowed to run what accounts as psychological experiments on big portions of the population without any supervision? For me, the answer is no. It is unethical and it will impact negatively the people affected.

> Just fucking educate people on fact checking and elementary logic.

This supposes that the fault is in the individuals not in the system. And that it is easier to change all the population than to regulate a handful of companies. I am all for better education, but to solve the problem with the big tech companies regulation is needed.

kartan··on Public hacker test on Swiss Post’s e-voting system
> tens of thousands of important decisions

I think of myself to be a well-informed person. I will not be able to cope with that level of decision making. Probably makes more sense to scale it up slowly, adding more and more issues to be voted as the citizens learn the consequences of their vote and are able to keep themselves informed.

But, I do not think that ever we will be taking tens of thousands of votes. That also looks like a very centralized system where all decisions are made from one place. If an issue is local it should be delegated locally.

kartan··on Mobile networks caught selling your emergency location data to bounty hunters
> Privacy advocates stunned that explicit rules ignored, blame head of FCC

A fox guarding the henhouse.

kartan··on London pushes to take Saudis off EU dirty money blacklist
> The problem is that unrestricted movement disrupts culture and lowers a lot of social statistics all at once - in a way that can be really disruptive to the host culture.

So, free movement inside the UK should be restricted? The UK should be divided by countries and block free movement? And what happens if two cities have different cultures? I'm different from my neighbors and I feel I have more in common with people from other countries, how to done that? My country is Christian, but I'm an atheist. I am disruptiny the country culture. I'd that bad?

Global communications and exchange of people and ideas has brought riches to the world that were impossible to think of one century ago.

Tribalism has a romantic appealing, but it's based in the falacy of the Noble Savage.

You are right that there is people that will abuse the system. But, that is true for any system. So, is better to try to improve it instead of throwing it away without an alternative.

People should be concerned about losing their jobs, losing wealth, etc. And look for the causes instead of using a straw man.

kartan··on London pushes to take Saudis off EU dirty money blacklist
> The people who want to leave the EU and not necessarily the same people pushing for this.

I think that you are right. But, why is not these kinds of topics part of the political discourse?

It is elected officials the ones pushing for helping Saudis without first asking them to change their methods. Why is not the same people that do not want to be in the European Union because they are afraid of immigrants being more critical to this real threat to their country?

So, citizens have removed "I am worried about inequality" and "I am worried about terrorism" that will make Saudis intervention part of the concerning trends from their thoughts. And they think just about "I am worried about immigration". Without realizing that ending immigration was never a goal. That racism and xenophobia were packaged for them as an easy solution that problems that nobody talks about.

In engineering is important to state the problem to solve before discussing the solutions. Citizens of the UK talk about solutions, that are not real ones, without realizing that they miss the problem.

kartan··on London pushes to take Saudis off EU dirty money blacklist
> that pose money-laundering and terrorism financing threats

So, Uk is fine with a country that finances terrorism in the UK itself as long as the elite gets a good chunk of money. At the same time, the UK wants to leave the European Union because immigration is "bad".

What about letting immigrants in, but keeping state-sponsored terrorism out?

All discussions have become so monetary centric that politicians publicly support the vilest of actions if there is money to gain (see Khashoggi torture and murder). The public should bring back some idealism and fight for a better world, not just for money. Otherwise, one day, we will wake up in the Middle Ages.

kartan··on Google hired microworkers to train its controversial Project Maven AI
> Well if people can keep justifying working for companies acting in unethical fashion.

I see quite often shifting the blame to employees. Does not make more sense that is the powerful companies that are expected to do the right thing instead of people with children to feed and mortgages to pay? It is way harder to do the right thing when your family wellbeing depends on it. Even worse when you need thousands of employees acting in a coordinating way to get any effect at all.

kartan··on Google hired microworkers to train its controversial Project Maven AI
Yes. In a perfect information market, this will not work. The people that can do the job for 0.40 will do it directly for that amount or they will get it for 0.60. But information is a scarcity for poor people and that makes the market very very inefficient with a lot of people getting part of the cake without adding any value.
kartan··on Google hired microworkers to train its controversial Project Maven AI
> Though market forces should generally push unskilled labor wages high enough to be livable

I do not see how the market forces can do that.

In the USA there is a lot of non-livable paying jobs that need to be complemented by public spending. For a person that has nothing, a salary that is not enough to pay for their basic needs is better than nothing. That creates a race to the bottom.

You get the lowest price independently of if people that do the job can make ends meet or not.

kartan··on Google hired microworkers to train its controversial Project Maven AI
> What would be news is if Google were paying $11/hr + social security, etc. just to have people tell an algo which pictures have a dog in them. That would put them at a competitive disadvantage.

Yes. Sometimes maximizing profits and having a functional society where everyone has a meal and home is incompatible. I would prefer to see that the long term viability of countries is put higher up than the short term profits of companies. And that is why it is so important to set all countries to the same standards of living (on the high-end preferably).

kartan··on Philippines tops world internet usage index with an average 10 hours a day
> at what point does personal responsibility take over?

Maybe a good approach can be:

- When there are millions of people with otherwise functional lives falling for unhealthy behaviour then you blame the carriers.

- When there is a very small percentage of the population engaging in that behaviour, then is personal responsibility.

For example, personal responsibility cannot be asked for when people lack education.

kartan··on Japan's Rail Workers Pointing at Things (2017)
> While some workers point-and-call more enthusiastically than others

Yes, I have seen this. Rail workers are great at it, but in other places, it can get worse. I saw a guy pointing to both sides of the sidewalk - to assure that it was free of people - before letting a truck get into a parking lot. His colleague will barely move the hands. It looked slightly awkward.

> Japanese commentators have theorized that Western employees feel “silly” performing the requisite gestures and calls.

I guess that this is what humans are bad at. We overvalue our awareness, and we put a lot of much weight on any act with social implications.

While I was at Fuji, I saw what it seemed a guy training alongside the train driver. He laughed time to time at his own movements. They both had a great time. So, even for Japanese, seems that the situation is slightly awkward.

kartan··on Perceptions of Randomness: Why Three Heads Are Better Than Four (2009) [pdf]
> the subjects just answered a different question than the one the researcher asked them.

I completely agree with your interpretation. And that is why science education is so important. Thinking like a scientist is not natural. It is a learned skill. You need to stop asking yourself what it feels is the correct answer and analyze it to get a universal truth.

A lot of "controversial" political topics raise from the difference of perceived reality and reality itself. We suck at statistics and we suck at getting the right answer. And, even educated professionals fail to apply that knowledge to all the domains in their lives.

kartan··on Why are the Maltese so competitive?
> Year after year, followers of respective patron saints attempt to outspend and outdo their neighbouring parish in a contentious crusade for showmanship

It looks like a set of very bad habits. A place where signalling power and wealth is more important than self-growth.

Malta is a tax haven and famous for the assassination of the anti-corruption journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia.*

All that does not hint a healthy society, but a society that needs to get away from tribalism and embrace better ways.

* https://www.theguardian.com/world/daphne-caruana-galizia

kartan··on A new generation of environmentalists is learning to love atomic power
I'm writing this from Japan. I do not have the numbers, but as I cross the country in the Shinkansen I see a sea of solar panels.

Fukushima has been a lesson here. Strategically, Japan has to import it's energy, except for solar energy. With a float of trains electricity is already at the core of their transportation system.

Here, at least, nuclear doesn't look like it's the future.

kartan··on YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M
> I think its because you feel included since most of the show is back-and-forth gossip on family issues where its common for the people in the scene to try and find a solution to a problem where the problem person is excluded from the conversation.

Yes. I see this kind of shows as social pornography. But meanwhile pornography is seen as something that you see in private and you are kind of ashamed to recognize that you see it publicly. This social pornography is widely accepted and even children watch it with, usually, their mothers.

Society needs to create a taboo about this kind of shows. It maybe OK to watch them on your own if you need it. But not to include children and not to make it the center of your life.

kartan··on YouTube top earners: A seven-year-old making $22M
> If the content creator chooses to optimize the money-making persona, it eventually leads to sensationalized content to generate the maximum possible number of views.

In the past brand prestige protected the media from this to happen. A backslash on a TV will make all advertisers to flee.

YouTube does not suffer from this. They host radical, xenophobic, and misogynistic content without consequences. Because they label themselves as a tech company, a middleman that has no responsibility on their own content. But are they? Meanwhile we buy what YouTube advertisements show they have no reason to stop.

When you optimize society to generate money instead of generate value you get to this weird situation.

kartan··on Making a Ransomware Payment May Now Violate U.S. Sanctions
Ramsomware (like any ransom) is a typical "tragedy of the commons" situation.

To pay is beneficial for yourself, as you get your data back that is more valuable than the amount of money that you pay.

Society losses as a whole as you are incentivizing their business model. But, you bet that it will not happen to yourself again.

> With the rise of ransomware, we have also seen a rise in data recovery companies who claim that they are able to recover ransomware victim's files for a fee. It has long been suspected that these companies are not actually using any home grown techniques to recover victim's files, but are negotiating with the ransomware developers and simply paying the ransom on your behalf while tacking on a fee for their work.

And it makes sense. As it can become a big business.

Forbid the payment of ransoms and society is better-off as a whole. Even that some victims are going to be in a worse situation.

kartan··on Tumblr will ban all adult content on December 17th
I posted this 1 day ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18583017) "YouTube, for example, can show advertisements for well known companies in videos about Anti-vaccination, far-right conspiracies, etc. without consequences.

Why is that? Because all that happens in the privacy of your own computer. Usually any newspaper that publicly have printed such bullshit in their pages will be dead. Public will react to it.

What is different? Facebook, YouTube, etc. are personalized. You are shown what you are interested in without public accountability. Niche radical content gets a lot of views for its own controversial nature. Views and money.

Who wants to investigate, hire good writers and expend the money that it takes to write a good article when you can hire some one without ethics for a fraction of the price and get as many or more views as radicalization grows?

YouTube, Facebook and others say that they are not responsible of the content they offer. I think that it should be true for things like comments. But for the monetized content they are 100% responsible of incentivizing that radicalization and killing good journalism in the process. "

Tech (apps) companies cannot solve so much problems as they think. But, they can solve the problems that they have created.

kartan··on Unknown Civil War Faces are Being Identified Through Facial Recognition App
I always though that this was gonna happen in the future. That someone 100 years from now will check zettabytes of videos, pictures, posts and is going to create complete profiles of everyone that has lived in our time.

Each time that you are in the background of a picture of an stranger. In the broad panoramic videos from sport stadiums. From fingerprinting you writing in all social media. From government documentation. From text of other people talking about you... all your digital traces to know who were you.

Now is happening with past pictures, even that there is no so much to mine compared with the present.

kartan··on Mozilla hit with takedown request for anti-paywall addons
> Stop enabling the destruction of journalism?

My two cents is that advertisement is what is killing journalism.

YouTube, for example, can show advertisements for well known companies in videos about Anti-vaccination, far-right conspiracies, etc. without consequences.

Why is that? Because all that happens in the privacy of your own computer. Usually any newspaper that publicly have printed such bullshit in their pages will be dead. Public will react to it.

What is different? Facebook, YouTube, etc. are personalized. You are shown what you are interested in without public accountability. Niche radical content gets a lot of views for its own controversial nature. Views and money.

Who wants to investigate, hire good writers and expend the money that it takes to write a good article when you can hire some one without ethics for a fraction of the price and get as many or more views as radicalization grows?

YouTube, Facebook and others say that they are not responsible of the content they offer. I think that it should be true for things like comments. But for the monetized content they are 100% responsible of incentivizing that radicalization and killing good journalism in the process.

kartan··on The last true knight on Malta
> But a year later when he was arrested for his participation in what many assume to be a brawl, the knights imprisoned the artist at Fort St Angelo and expelled him from the Order.

For the only things I know Malata now are gambling, as a tax haven, and for the assassination of a journalist (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/apr/17/malta-protecti...).

Not so much to do with the idealized world of knights and gentlemen.

kartan··on Poverty in America: Greater Than Statistics Indicate
> EDIT: I read this wrong. I agree with what you're saying, "related to" would have made more sense as "leads to".

Yes. Thank you. "Leads to" is what I meant. :)

kartan··on Poverty in America: Greater Than Statistics Indicate
> To me, it feels like the alternative, even if you could fix it, would result in eliminating swathes of currently provided services.

I see your point. But, in my experience, it is the opposite. I have worked in Sweden and Spain, two very different job markets.

Sweden is way more effective because employees have more rights and more possibilities to look for another job. In Spain, a lot of companies used to be very bad at what they were doing, but were using very cheap labour so they were able to have a profit anyway.

It is the selection of the fittest. When you have abundant cheap labour the most abusive companies succeed. What that is not the case, smart responsible companies have an advantage.

Poverty and stress is not a winning bet.

kartan··on Poverty in America: Greater Than Statistics Indicate
> Luckily, there is just such a concept: It’s called material security.

This is really important. There are people that are one paycheck away from not being able to afford rent and basic necessities.

I have lost my job in the past. I was calm and just enjoyed the time while I was looking for a new job. I have money saved. For a lot of people that will have been an extremely stressful situation. That kind of stress is related to bad-decision taking and reduced life expectancy.

I have seen the rise of the credit card in my country. People used to have assets, a modest life and salary increases above inflation.

Nowadays they depend more and more on credits and increase the amount borrowed from their loans. Salaries do not grow, but debt does. That is not a good life at all.

kartan··on Google Tried to Patent My Work After a Job Interview
> It’s down to individuals rather than culture in these things. By purely statistics, an organisation of any size has less than ethical people in it even if they have the best outward impression.

How the organisations react to that bad apples is what matters. I have seen companies ruined by half a dozen people that bully others, play office politics and blame games. Most of the people were fantastic, but the CEO will do nothing about this bullies in high positions.

If a company has no way of dealing with these people, the company does not deserve to survive. So, yes there are bad apples. But, the companies have the tools to make them correct their behaviour or get rid of them.

> It’s probably better to file patent first though.

Yes. Completely agree. Companies should play nice, but you should protect yourself just in case.

kartan··on How one Indian city cracked the problem of urban spread
The solution looks good. But the remaining problem is density. The higher the density the easier is to provide services for the population. New York, Tokyo, Paris, etc, have several store tall buildings with people living in apartments. For what I see these new cities are more similar to Los Angeles or Mexico City than anything else. Single-family homes spread all over the place without access to trains or subways.

I have lived all my life in apartments. So, for me, it feels normal and it is very practical. I guess that if you are used to single-family homes that is a difficult step to make.

kartan··on The Most Important Non-Programming Skills for Programmers
That are good characteristics for anyone. Be a decent human also while at your job your life and other's life are going to be better. (And probably you also will get better products and be economically successful as a side-effect).
kartan··on Why suicide is falling around the world, and how to bring it down more
"more curbs on the means of self-destruction"

This means guns. And that is why right now this post is full of mean spirited comments. It is a shame that cannot be a sincere discussion about guns even when it relates to suicide and the lives it could save.

kartan··on The Human Brain Is a Time Traveler
> It's funny how language shapes our thinking.

Yes. We need to change "I need some rest" for "I need some introspection". I agree that is a change from "lazy" or "not-doing-anything" towards "profound" and "self-improvement".

← PreviousPage 7 of 25Next →