HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kartan

4,940 karma · joined July 5, 2015

submissionscomments
kartan··on Japan set to allow gene-editing tools for research into early human development
> It's going to be depressing if we get to a point where the next generation is vastly superior both in intelligence and physical fitness

"intelligence and physical fitness" are overrated. Think of a generation without mental illnesses. People that is balanced and happy. People that has no malignant fobias and does not get fat just because does not know when to stop eating.

You are still right, that they should also be smarter and healthier and better looking that us if they can. But I see a bigger change if we adress our mental problems first.

kartan··on The First Photo Ever Created by a Japanese Photographer (2016)
I visited Nagasaki a year ago. I was surprised how open the city was historically to outsiders. After some reading I understood why. Previously I only knew the city in reference to the atomic bomb. European and Chinese influences are noticeable all over the place.

It is only in Nagasaki where you could have bough an European machine.

This year I am planning to visit Kagoshima. I wonder if the photo is still there after it was found.

kartan··on “So the silence from Facebook over the weekend is.. deafening.”
> Why would facebook suffer any consequences from this whatsoever? When has a data breach actually affected the company?

Facebook is too big. It does not play against its customers or users, but against governments and legislation.

Sooner or later legislation is going to catch up with all the potential risks and abuses that Facebooks facilitates. Each misstep takes it closer to an stronger legislation.

For all the big tech companies it is better for themselves to slap on their own hand than to let the government do it.

kartan··on Police to Seattle’s techies, streamers: Sign up for our anti-swatting service
> you just can't beat that price

That is interesting information.

What is the limit? Free air to air missiles? The argument should not be that it is pricey but that it is dangerous.

kartan··on Did I just waste 3 years?
Around 2,256,508 books (data is not up to date https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Books_published_per_country_pe...)

But I guess it will be fair to compare also with Movies. As some games have budgets on that scale.

That is around 730 movies per year for USA and Canada. https://www.statista.com/statistics/187122/movie-releases-in...

> I don't say this to minimize the pain of indie devs that find themselves suddenly deluged with competition... but that's where things are headed, yeah?

Yes. In the 90s there were not so many people with the skills and equipment to create games. Nowadays is a global market where everyone can give it a try. From cheap computers to Unity3D it is easier and cheaper than ever to create games.

kartan··on UK intelligence agency admits unlawfully spying on Privacy International
I think that historically law enforcement and intelligence agencies are strongly leaning to the right. They use the power granted by citizens to do their jobs and use it to pursue their personal political agendas.

"The activist, Kate Wilson, had a two-year intimate relationship with Mark Kennedy, who was known to her as Mark Stone. She only found out in 2010 that he had been an undercover officer tasked with infiltrating environmental protest groups." https://edition.cnn.com/2018/09/21/uk/uk-police-spy-activist...

Instead of investigating power corruption, the relationship between far-right groups and Russia, etc. UK thinks that infiltrating "environmental groups" and using government resources to allow an spy to have sex with an activist is more important, because "environmental activists" are bad...

Law enforcement and intelligence agencies around the world have a problem with lack of professionalism were personal political agendas triumph doing the duty that they have been tasked to do. That is why they are so inefficient and things like the Russian meddling with Brexit and the USA elections happen.

kartan··on Hundreds of academics at top UK universities accused of bullying
> “Some students were driven to attempt suicide as a result, others broke down and simply vanished from science.”

It is hard to evaluate how much talent and how much suffering bullying causes. In every company I have been there had been some level of bullying. The result usually is that options were not discussed, people left or get depressed, long non-paid hours produced no real results as work was done in the wrong projects, etc... Bullying in school or politics has even worst consequences.

There is a lot of untapped potential in human society. Bullying has a high toll on society.

kartan··on Facebook Network Breach Impacts Up to 50M Users
> Working for Facebook is a morally bankrupt position.

Facebook offers a service that people wants. A service that is not morally bad, if any connecting people is a positive thing.

The monetization of that business is what has proven problematic. As it is offered for free, it is people's privacy what is being sold.

Who should solve it?

The problem with "just don't work for Facebook" is that it shifts the responsibility to policy companies from governments, that have the power and resources, to individuals that have not. Of course individuals have a moral responsibility, and that is why whistle-blowers are so important in all industries.

But it is the government that has the responsibility to assure that the industry remains a positive force in the country. Tech giants are a new phenomenon. Regulations have not still catch up with its problems. But governments around the globe need to shape up and get up to the challenge of letting companies offer services that people wants and needs while minimizing the harmful impact that some business models have.

If you do not like the ethics of the company that you work for, change jobs. You are going to be happier. But that is not going to make the company more ethical, if any it is going to be less ethical as people that worries about such things move out.

kartan··on Many who crafted regulations after the 2008 crisis now work for Wall Street
> The financial industry showed its might in other debates, as well. In one example, Republicans in the Senate joined with moderate Democrats in 2009 to defeat a plan to allow judges to set new terms of mortgages, a measure that could have also allowed Americans to get more favorable terms amid the housing crisis.

This is a very important point. Wall Street is getting power and knowledge directly from the source. Who is defending Main Street needs?

> But the effect of the banks’ influence, according to former lawmakers, was to dilute the legislation.

This is one of the reasons we get so bad legislation. The original ideas and goals were good. But they get lobbied out of existence.

So, I do not know if working for the Wall Street is a bad thing per se to do for legislators once they finish their terms. But the result is an unhealthy economy. And that needs to be addressed.

kartan··on Beyond Spotify and iZettle: How Sweden became Europe’s capital of startup exits
> Would you say that I’m being foolish?

No, it is not foolish. I know a few Swedish people that made that move over three years ago, and they have not come back yet.

The best company in Barcelona or Madrid is going to be better than the worst in Gothenburg. You may find something really good. It is just that you need to be more selective.

The other thing to take into account is that most Spanish people do not speak English. If you speak Spanish, that is not a problem. Otherwise, you need to find an international company that uses English as its primary language.

To move to another European country is a very easy way of living in a different culture.

kartan··on Beyond Spotify and iZettle: How Sweden became Europe’s capital of startup exits
Flater management helps. I have seen developers telling managers that they disagree with some requirement or similar in a way that was not possible in Spain. You will have been fired. Also, the mindset in Spain is that you are lucky if you have a job and people keeps bad jobs as family and friends will not understand "why do they complain if they are far better than other people".

Sweden has been better off economically, and it has a safety net that allows developers (and other workers) to say NO to very stupid things.

When people ask me why I emigrated to Sweden, the answer is easy. It has a healthier work culture than most parts of the world. What use is 20% more salary if I got to live a stressed and miserable life?

kartan··on They raised $400K for a homeless vet. There’s none left to give him, lawyer says
This is why state welfare is so much better than random charity. People hate goverment bureaucracy, but it is there to make sure that money ends in the right hands. It is not 100% foolproof, but it is way better than this.
kartan··on The New Old Age
> How can retirement funds survive people working for thirty years and collecting benefits for forty?

One part of the answer is productivity. (https://data.oecd.org/lprdty/gdp-per-hour-worked.htm)

You need more production to fulfil the needs of the non-working elders. You can achieve that by increasing the number of workers (producers), or by increasing the amount produced by unit (productivity). But then the problem is how to distribute the result.

This was Stephen Hawkins position when he stated that we should be more frightened of capitalism than robots. https://www.cnet.com/news/stephen-hawking-says-we-should-be-...

In a very efficient and automated world distributing wealth is a bigger problem than creating it.

kartan··on 20M historical artifacts destroyed in Brazil National Museum fire
Yes. It's convenience and cost vs risk.
kartan··on Military robots are getting smaller and more capable
An interesting video talked about in the article: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CO6M2HsoIA
kartan··on Why Read the Classics? (1986)
> "A classic is something that persists as a background noise even when the most incompatible momentary concerns are in control of the situation."

The article is more poetic than informational. I am so used to technical readings that I translate the sentences into something more concrete, maybe more journalistic.

I guess that this sentence means that "classic books" define our cultural background, differences between the east and the west, between countries and cultures independently of what you can see now on the news.

Translating it into more plain concepts allows for a better understanding. With this new wording, I can reflect on how current events, video games, streamed videos are shaping our society and will be identified in the future as "classic".

> Every reading of a classic is in fact a rereading.

I interpret this as you have already "read" the classic as it is part of other works that you have read or seen. That our culture has been influenced by "classic" works to the extend that you can feel like you have read them before.

> The classics are the books that come down to us bearing upon them the traces of readings previous to ours, and bringing in their wake the traces they themselves have left on the culture or cultures they have passed through

This confirms my previous interpretation. But, I have then to open the question. Do "classics" shape society or are only a result of it? If a "classics" was never written our society will be different our we will just miss a recorded piece of cultural history?

> If the spark doesn’t come, that’s a pity; but we do not read the classics out of duty or respect, but only out of love.

I do not agree. I am reading "classics" books out of curiosity or even duty towards being responsible to improve my own education, and last but not least for pleasure. Different people will have different motivation.

Can anyone try to explain this other one? It sounds good, but if feels kind of bullshit. :)

> We use the word “classic” of a book that takes the form of an equivalent to the universe, on a level with the ancient talismans. With this definition we are approaching the idea of the “total book,” as Mallarmé conceived of it.

This post is an interesting read for a change.

kartan··on India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet Giants
> The main reason the government wants data to be stored locally and is also looking at controlling companies is for surveillance. But unlike China, not all platforms have Indian created equivalents. Fortunately for the citizens of India, regardless of the state of surveillance in the U.S., the U.S. companies do fight a lot more against these controlling measures than any Indian born company ever would.

There is a national security component that you are missing. The day we do not needs borders for people, we will not need a border for data. But we are not there yet.

> “There is a strong feeling in many quarters that the reason that India has not been able to develop a Tencent or Baidu or Alibaba is because we have not been nuanced in our policies.”

This is very reasonable. Your country does NOT need a new Google or Tencent. Because they already exist. The only way India can develop its own companies is by creating an artificial scarcity thru regulation. I see quite often asked Why does Europe not have tech giants? The easy answer is that they already exist and there is no way that small start-ups can fight them.

This does not mean that to create that needs is good for the citizens. Maybe it is good that Europe depends on Google, Apple, etc than to try to create new local ones, as non-tech businesses can benefit early from their technology. But if the goal is to create your own tech giants, it is not possible when you are competing against well established cash-rich monopolistic companies.

> "They also warned that India has fewer legal protections than the United States against government searches and data requests, so private data stored in the country could more easily end up in the hands of the police." The central government has shown that it has very little interest in getting a good privacy law in place.

From my perspective, you may prefer that your data is in hands of another country, not even because they are more ethical but because they are just less interested in what you are doing. Local police in NewYork does not care what you are doing in New Delhi. So, the effect is the same. Your data may be safer in hands of people that have no political nor policial power over you.

kartan··on Web Design Museum
It is impressive how design has changed thru the years. Just compare the 1996 Space Jam web https://www.webdesignmuseum.org/gallery/space-jam-1996 with its current design https://www.warnerbros.com/archive/spacejam/movie/jam.htm
kartan··on Assertions in Production Code? (2008)
> assertAndContinue

We had a similar setup. assertAndContinue will add a trace in memory. When the app crashes it will dump the trace to a file and quit. (similar to https://stackoverflow.com/questions/8233388/ios-crash-log-ca...)

On load the app checks if a dump file exists and sends the contents to our server.

So we will get the last N assertions for any crash plus other info gathered in the exit routine.

No fallback thou. Just continue until the crash happens, if it happens.

kartan··on Can Beethoven send takedown requests?
> They took down the song because I could not "prove" I was the owner.

Because it is not about rights, it is about power.

kartan··on Can Beethoven send takedown requests?
> A longer exclusivity term makes it possible to recoup more investment costs

I go to the bank. I ask for a loan. I tell them that I will small marginal profits after 75 years. I do not get the loan.

Even if in some cases this was actually possible. Still, we need to evaluate if it is worth it. All the stories, movies, characters that are part of your formation and your culture will be privately owned and restricted until way after you are dead.

Characters, music, and other cultural assets only become free when nobody cares anymore about them.

We are evaluating the possibility of the creation of some cultural assets against the reality of other cultural assets that are not created because the government sets monopolistic restrictions on them.

There is a sweet spot where creators can live out of their creations. And were citizens can make their own vision of characters that personally meant a lot to them.

kartan··on Can Beethoven send takedown requests?
> in one case it is a physical object, and in the other - immaterial.

In one case or you live in the house or I live in the house. In the other, you can listen to music and other million people or 1 billion at the same time.

Physical ownership is required because it is a limit resource. Copyright is not limited by any physic constraint.

So, I agree that ownership has nothing to do with the original creator. But copyright has nothing to do with a house ownership but a legal monopoly created by the state with some goals in mind that may require or probably not to extend it beyond a few years.

kartan··on Emails while commuting 'should count as work'
> Requiring off-hour access is admitting project management failure.

You are completely right.

Management lack of competence is pushed down and transforms in extra working hours for everyone else. In this kind of company, people are always putting down fires instead of working strategically. That causes more fires and more extra work at any time of the day.

kartan··on ‘Overtourism’ Worries Europe. How Much Did Technology Help Get Us There?
> This comment falls directly into the "things never change" fallacy.

That sounds interesting. I looked for it, and I just found references to the "tradition fallacy" that only deals with resistance to change.

Can you provide a link?

> Picking one sample piece of anecdotal data from another period that can roughly be lined up with some other vague impressions of today does not refute the claim.

I provided an anecdote example as a means to be more pedagogic. It is easier to understand concepts from the concrete to the abstract. So you are completely right, my anecdote does not refute the claim.

kartan··on ‘Overtourism’ Worries Europe. How Much Did Technology Help Get Us There?
> I too keep travel pictures with stuff like tickets, flyers etc. The purpose is not to build a brand or show off but to better remember the experience later.

That is my point. In the past, people did the same things, if that does not make them superficial we are neither. We should not judge our contemporaneous travellers so lightly.

kartan··on ‘Overtourism’ Worries Europe. How Much Did Technology Help Get Us There?
> “You can’t talk about overtourism without mentioning Instagram and Facebook — I think they’re big drivers of this trend,” Mr. Francis said. “Seventy-five years ago, tourism was about experience-seeking. Now it’s about using photography and social media to build a personal brand. In a sense, for a lot of people, the photos you take on a trip become more important than the experience.”

The article falls directly into the "good old days" fallacy. No, people in the past were not looking for "more authentic experiences".

I bought in a flea market a photo album of a trip of some Swedish couple in the 60s. It is awesome. It could be posted picture by picture on Facebook and nobody will notice. Except by details like that the plane tickets, included in the album, were printed by a mechanical typewriter. Also includes tourism flyers, tickets for the theatre, and a menu from a restaurant. Sounds familiar? Because people are people in all places at all times.

https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Good_old_days

kartan··on Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intolerant’ Liberal Culture
This thread is way out of control. Created by an anonymous account. And with a lot of comments written in bad faith.

Can someone remove this so we can move on and continue with rational discussions? Please? :)

kartan··on Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers
> If you split the CEO pay across all the mass of workers, it won’t come out to much.

I agree that if you split the CEO pay it does not affect so much the employees.

I just wanted to highlight is that the CEO does NOT want the employees in the board as they may see the CEO's salary as unfair. So, to protect his own salary, the CEO keeps employees out of the structures of power.

Then we can argue if is that lack of power the one that keeps or not workers salaries low. But workers are not represented becuase is against the CEO best interest so her own salary can grow unchecked.

kartan··on Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers
> And executives

That is the key. Executives are taking the lion's share.

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/22/heres-how-much-ceo-pay-has-i...

kartan··on Toyota Investing $500M in Uber in Driverless Car Pact
> inefficiencies of government

You misspelled lobbing.

← PreviousPage 9 of 25Next →