HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kazoomonger

133 karma · joined October 1, 2020

submissionscomments
kazoomonger··on Earth's energy imbalance removes almost all doubt from human-made climate change
> "I'm not being political, you're being political!"

Your original comment had factually incorrect information, as demonstrated. Please don't try and hide that behind name calling or distractions.

kazoomonger··on Earth's energy imbalance removes almost all doubt from human-made climate change
I'm not responding to anything other than the rebranding myth, because that's what I originally responded about. Going beyond that scope would involve walls of text that HN is ill-suited for, as evidenced by the amount of text already written for a narrowly-scoped topic.

I'm here because I saw a comment repeating a falsehood, and wanted to call it out. I dislike seeing blatantly wrong things such as this:

https://i0.wp.com/wattsupwiththat.com/wp-content/uploads/201...

kazoomonger··on Earth's energy imbalance removes almost all doubt from human-made climate change
The crucial aspect you're missing is from the latter half of the skepticalscience.com link I posted above. Here is the particular graph that shows usage of "global warming" vs "climate change":

https://static.skepticalscience.com/pics/climate-change-v-gl...

Both terms were in common usage, with "climate change" existing before "global warming". It's not "rebranding" to realize that of the various terms in common usage, one of them is more accurate. "climate change" started rising relatively in popularity around 1994 after being roughly equal to "global warming", a decade before Watts' conspiracy theories.

> https://wattsupwiththat.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/4141.... > https://wattsupwiththat.com/2020/03/14/the-conversation-ther...

Anthony Watts dances around understanding here, and writes "It is an unequivocal fact that the terms “climate change” and “global warming” have both been in use for a long time." So he agrees with the link I posted above. The PDF doesn't disagree, much as he'd like it to. Saying "climate change might be a better labelling than global warming" isn't saying "therefore we should rebrand it". It's agreeing that "climate change" is better than "global warming", but then detailing why "climate change" doesn't even capture everything going on.

> https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/news/a30524/renaming-g...

That's honestly just a bad title. The article can be summed up however by the last sentence: "Rebranding a complex issue that most people think has already been rebranded ...". In other words, it disagrees with you: there was no rebranding from "global warming" to "climate change".

> https://www.cnsnews.com/news/article/obamas-science-adviser-... > https://green.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/09/20/a-rebranding-for-... > https://www.nationalreview.com/planet-gore/global-warming-re...

Holdren is saying why "global warming" isn't a great term. He's not arguing for a rebranding, he's pointing out why it stopped being as popular of a term 15 years prior to his speech. He does argue for rebranding to "global climate disruption", but that's irrelevant to your claim about "global warming" vs "climate change".

> https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/may/17/why-the-... > https://www.euronews.com/green/2019/05/20/guardian-style-gui...

This is a rebranding, from "climate change" to "climate crisis". We can argue about whether it's a good change, but it's irrelevant to your claim about "global warming" vs "climate change".

> https://www.quora.com/Why-did-people-start-using-the-term-cl...

Almost all of the answers there point out that it's a myth, agreeing with the skepticalscience.com link I posted above. The few answers that try to push that myth are diatribes that don't cite any supporting evidence.

kazoomonger··on Earth's energy imbalance removes almost all doubt from human-made climate change
> There was definitely a name change

If you read the second link I posted above, you will see that there was no name change. You have not provided any evidence or links to the contrary.

kazoomonger··on Earth's energy imbalance removes almost all doubt from human-made climate change
It's weird that you bring up responding with a non sequitur when that's exactly what you've just done:

- You alleged some vague conspiracy about renaming global warming to climate change ("a name change, a rebranding if you will")

- I responded with two links that clarify that there was never any such name change.

- You ignored that and started talking about how you think the models are wrong.

So do you agree that there was never a name changing or rebranding?

kazoomonger··on Earth's energy imbalance removes almost all doubt from human-made climate change
I don't understand how you can be this cocksure about being absolutely wrong when the first hit on google for "global warming vs climate change" leads to this page:

https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/what-difference-between-global-war...

The term "global warming" doesn't capture everything involved in the climate change that is caused by global warming. This was already known as a myth almost a decade ago:

https://skepticalscience.com/climate-change-global-warming-b...

You should not repeat "talking points" without at least trying at least a little bit to verify them. Please.

kazoomonger··on Facebook creates new unit to build a “metaverse”
This reads like some weird submarine FB ad for their Metaverse™ Experience™©.

What exactly do you mean by metaverse? I can't think of a definition that matches what you're talking about.

kazoomonger··on Element raises $30M to boost Matrix
Looking at https://matrix.org/faq/, I see this:

    Can I run my own identity server?
    See also: What is an identity server?
    Yes - the reference implementation is sydent and you can run your own ID server cluster that tracks 3rd party to Matrix ID mappings. This won't be very useful right now, though, and we don't recommend it.
    If you want your server to participate in the global replicated Matrix ID service then please get in touch with us. Meanwhile, we are looking at ways of decentralising the 'official' Matrix identity service so that identity servers are 100% decentralised and can openly federate with each other. N.B. that you can use Matrix without ever using the identity service - it exists only to map 3rd party IDs (e.g. email addresses) to matrix IDs to aid user discovery.

As someone that really likes Matrix because of its decentralized nature, I'm not really seeing a problem here. TBH, I don't really care about mapping a foo@bar.com to @foo:bar.com. All of my matrix contacts I've just asked them what their username is, then started chatting with them.
kazoomonger··on Show HN: WrittenRealms – a modern platform for text-based games
I like the interface in general. However, as someone that has played some text-based games but is not super familiar with the genre, I think this log captures my confusion:

    kill spider
    You stab a small spider for 6 damage!
    stab spider
    Unknown command: 'stab'. Type 'help' for help.
    kill spider
    You're already in combat!
    attack spider
    You're already in combat!
I can see a floating box that says that I'm in combat, but it doesn't help me figure out what to type, because the only option is "FLEE"

If I try to flee, I get a loading bar that then becomes full and then doesn't do anything. If I try to flee again, it says I'm charging an ability.

I'm honestly not sure how to proceed. help didn't give me any useful commands.

kazoomonger··on Google Drive bans distribution of “misleading content”
Ok fine:

    Their next claim is that the June heatwave was enhanced by 2°C by global warming, which is not out of the realm of possibility.  

    But think about it.  Considering that they state that the heatwave had maximum temperatures 16-20°C warmer than normal, by their OWN ADMISSION only about 10% of the heatwave was the result of global warming.  Thus, a record-breaking, unique heat wave would have occurred without global warming.   

    Imagine if they had stated that.  You would not have seen many headlines: Global warming contributed 10% of the heatwave!
This guy is frankly so wrong and misunderstands what he's talking about so badly that he should be completely ignored and you should not cite him any more.

Imagine that global warming dries out a forested area to the point where it catches fire due to being so dry. This guy is saying the equivalent of "the fire burned at 800°C, and global warming only accounts for 0.25% of that!"

I gave the article a fair chance, and facepalmed repeatedly at his inane arguments. He's a crank and you should ignore him.

kazoomonger··on Google Drive bans distribution of “misleading content”
I tried reading the article you linked to. I honestly can't get past the intro:

    As noted above, the first bullet of the main findings states that the heatwave was "virtually impossible without human-caused climate change."  Sounds very certain, doesn't it?  Virtually impossible.

    Then read their next bullet:  

    "The observed temperatures were so extreme that they lie outside the range of historically observed temperatures.  This makes it hard to quantify how rare the event was"

    On one hand, they say it is hard to quantify how rare or unusual the event was, but on the other, they claim the event was virtually impossible without human-caused climate change. 

    Both statements can not be true.  You can't be uncertain and certain at the same time.
What? The writer seems intent on purposefully misunderstanding the study. "This makes it hard to quantify how rare the event was" is equivalent to the situation of not being able to speak about a "100 year storm" because there haven't been any storms that strong in recorded history. In other words the data is so different from historical data that there's only one reason why: human-caused climate change.
kazoomonger··on Don’t submit to conformity
You have that wrong about rule of thumb:

https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/rule-of-thumb.html

kazoomonger··on U.S. to add ‘X’ gender marker on passports
I'm not really sure what to make of your second paragraph (Mentioning Chaucer again when he's irrelevant because he didn't use singular they in the sense that is now being promoted).

Regardless, I appreciate the straightforwardness of your first paragraph.

kazoomonger··on U.S. to add ‘X’ gender marker on passports
Thanks for linking to a quote. Here's what that article shows as using singular they:

    "There's not a man I meet but doth salute me / As if I were their well-acquainted friend"
That's still not referring to a single, known person. The gender is known in this case due to "man", but it's still an unknown/unspecified man or men. I don't have a strong opinion about the recent push towards using singular they in this way, but I do really dislike the arguments for it that falsely try to add historical significance to their claims by invoking Chaucer or Shakespeare.
kazoomonger··on U.S. to add ‘X’ gender marker on passports
I don't see an example of what you're talking about in your link, can you post a specific quote?

I'm honestly not sure what your point is in your second paragraph. My point is that Chaucer did not use "they" in the sense you're talking about. You're saying that people are now trying to use it in a very similar sense to how Chaucer used it. So we agree?

I don't disagree that it's a very similar sense, but that doesn't mean it's identical. So instead of invoking Chaucer, just say "it's close enough already, so let's just use it"

kazoomonger··on U.S. to add ‘X’ gender marker on passports
Singular they in the sense you're talking about is a very recent invention. The sense of "an unknown or unspecified person" has been around that long, yes. However using "they" to refer to a known single person is a recent invention that's been pushed with this bad argument about how it's been around forever.

I don't really have a strong opinion on this new sense of the word, but I do really dislike falsely involving Chaucer when pushing it.

Edit: This is the sort of disingenuous argumentation I'm talking about. Every single usage I saw skimming through did not refer to a single, known person:

https://pemberley.com/janeinfo/austhlis.html

kazoomonger··on In Karachi, hot weather is normal but 44°C feels like you’re going to die
There are well-documented rising temperatures. TBH, it sounds like you've made up your mind and are unwilling to examine the mounds of evidence that exist to support that. This visualization from NASA directly contradicts any notion of a generational memory explanation:

https://climate.nasa.gov/interactives/climate-time-machine/

As a bonus, it also demonstrates that climate != weather. Even as the whole map is turning red, there's still a few cooler spots in any given year. There's just less and less.

kazoomonger··on Intuit sabotages the Child Tax Credit
You just made me roll my eyes back into my head. If the situations were reversed, you'd be saying "you're expecting a tiny country to compete with the vast resources of the United States?!".

Fact is, there's literally no reason we can't or shouldn't be doing this. My tax returns are super boring, and the IRS already knows what they are. Just send me a damn form that says "this is what we think you owe, if we're correct sign and return it".

The only way your argument has any merit is if we start talking about going back to no income tax. Which is an argument worth having, but your current argument is simply absurd.

kazoomonger··on Sorry, we replaced that old technology, “see-through glass”
> generates more attention

Fuck you.

That's really all I have to say about that. I'm sorry this comment doesn't pass the general HN guidelines, but I hope someday you realize why you should feel ashamed for even thinking that this is a good idea.

kazoomonger··on As religious faith has declined, ideological intensity has risen
That's not a good definition of religion. It allows one to sneak in a history-laden term with a relatively innocuous definition, have someone accept the given definition, and the introduce the rest of the history without having to prove it.

For prior art see arguments that "something must be the first mover, and that thing we call God". Curiously, the sudden leap to "therefore the Judeo-Christian deity is proven to exist" keeps getting snuck in there without any extra proof.

In other words, you're attempting to define a term of art using an existing word, and this just obscures the argument because most people will use its common definition, and not the meaning you're defining for it.

kazoomonger··on As religious faith has declined, ideological intensity has risen
That is a bad definition of religion. I will accept a field of study's conclusions in the absence of time myself to investigate. However, if it turns out that field is incorrect (say with the reproducibility crisis), then I won't "have faith" and believe anyways. In other words, belief != faith, and I'm willing to update my beliefs based on new evidence.
kazoomonger··on As religious faith has declined, ideological intensity has risen
I think the issue you're facing in thinking that these aspects exist but are implicit is that you're looking at the world through religion-colored glasses, which distort the way you're viewing things.

I'll admit that in the absence of religion, some people pick up ideological causes and treat them as a religion. However, I'm interested in knowing what "rituals, origin stories, deities, saints, priesthood, blasphemy, vice & virtue" you think I have.

kazoomonger··on As religious faith has declined, ideological intensity has risen
It's actually very simple. There is no such thing as objective morality. However, social norms are explained by people acting in their own rational self-interest. For example, I want to live in a society where I don't get murdered. Therefore, I want to live in a society that criminalizes murder. That's all there is to it. That is your "Why?" answered.

To go one step further, the why of questions like "Why don't you want to get murdered?" are because I come from a long line of organisms that didn't get murdered because of a high drive to not get murdered. The ones without that drive got weeded out. There's still no morality involved, I just axiomatically don't want to get murdered.

kazoomonger··on Microsoft Retires Azure Blockchain
I didn't say anything about disrupting everything shrug. I just said I'm kind of bullish on it for this use case.

That being said, "it eliminates one possible source of malicious behavior" is exactly derived from "irrevocable timestamps and ordering for cryptographic signatures provide a level of audibility and traceability that wasn't there before." so I'm not sure what your complaint is there. The auditability and traceability are exactly what eliminates that avenue of malicious behavior. Again, it's not going to revolutionize everything, but it seems useful here.

kazoomonger··on Microsoft Retires Azure Blockchain
> Malicious actors don't have to "destroy or modify paperwork"

Sure, they don't have to, but it eliminates one possible source of malicious behavior. I'm not saying that using a blockchain will eliminate all malicious behavior, so I'm not sure what you're getting at.

kazoomonger··on Microsoft Retires Azure Blockchain
I'm actually kind of bullish on blockchain for these sorts of scenarios, because yes, the malicious actor can claim that someone else in the chain screwed up, but all parties involved can verify all claims that were made in the entire chain. In other words, the malicious actor can't destroy or modify the paperwork and then claim something different.
kazoomonger··on The Repeated Deaths of OOP (2015)
I don't think ECS as such would really make a language on its own, but languages that use traits instead of inheritance would be approximately that. Both ECS and traits eschew using the inheritance-style "is-a" thinking. ECS goes for "has-a" thinking, and traits go for "acts-as" thinking. A few popular trait-based languages that would feel comfortable to someone familiar with ECS are Rust or Go.
kazoomonger··on Strong Towns Has Filed a Lawsuit Against the Minnesota Board of Engineering
Thanks, that's helpful. I have no love for the Koch brothers or libertarians in general, but TBH I think this is a "broken clock is right twice a day" scenario. After reading the case PDF, I'd have to agree with the decision that "engineer" is such a vague term that it shouldn't be restricted like that. It's like trying to limit calling yourself a "thinker" or something. I can see how the radical anti-government folks picked up on that case. FWIW, if he had tried claiming he was a "licensed professional engineer", I would definitely see that as a false/fraudulent claim that the state absolutely has the right to disallow.

Regardless, thanks for actually listing names of who's involved. No offense intended to the GP, it just annoys me when people use terms like "heavily suspect people", as that casts aspersions without actually saying who or what. Your links were much more helpful.

kazoomonger··on Strong Towns Has Filed a Lawsuit Against the Minnesota Board of Engineering
Sorry if I'm being dense, but can you be more clear? I looked at the ij.org link as well as the linked case document, and don't see anything nefarious?
kazoomonger··on Strong Towns Has Filed a Lawsuit Against the Minnesota Board of Engineering
1) The case in question is about "engineer", not "professional engineer". The legal system agreed with him, so I'm not sure what your complaint is?

2) That's very vague. Can you elaborate?

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →