31,676 karma · joined July 26, 2012
> Do you mean, for example, that AI can help us make new vaccines really fast, so even synthetic pandemics are not a huge risk?
I'm sure they can, if they can also help someone make a disease or virus, but more that I this the setup required to make something like that successfully, even with an AI, likely is more than what the average home lab has. Can someone create something? Sure. Can they iteratively test is and see how it works to iron out the bugs? I think that's likely much more complicated, requires some additional infrastructure, and is something that can be looked for an tracked, and AI will probably excel at finding the signal in the noise for things like that.
> So, for the sake of a thought experiment ... are nevertheless harming artist commissions.
For the record, I meant to say "Even the autistic savant type versions we have now seem to be causing some level of this." and I don't really disagree with what you're saying here, so I think we're in almost complete agreement on this.
> The counterpoint is, this took billions of years of parallel development, and even then might have been a fluke.
The counterargument to that is that natural selection seems to work on much larger timescales for any sort of species with intelligence. Intelligence seems to be a trait most useful for long lived organisms, since it's costly and requires a long time for organisms to learn from their environment enough to make it worth while, so seems mostly limited to larger and longer lived organisms, causing adaptations to take relatively longer. Intelligence is just one tool in the toolbox.
AI and increases in AI are not a natural process, but directed action, and on a scale where the time between generations seems to be shortening. That shortening for now might be because we're still tapping the low-hanging fruit of advances to make, but it's also limited by business needs because of the systems in which it operates. The "rogue AI decides to advance itself" may not necessarily need to operate within that system in some respects, either because it's beyond that system already or (more likely, in my opinion) it can just take a few percentages of resources lost to the black market every year to hide itself until it's too late. Just cybercrime is $10 billion annually, and that's up with 14% jump. Would anyone really know by who if that grew by another billion or two? That would be a lot of resources.
I was referring more to the fact that if an AI can help you create something you couldn't previously, it seems likely it could also help you examine data points in looking for threats as well, and with many times more resources to throw at the problem that's not a bad bet in my eyes. I understand the threat model doesn't necessarily mean that it's just as hard to build a threat as to detect and defend against it, but you can even use AI to attach that problem and figure out what specific information is the most useful to know to detect the threats.
> an AI that makes itself smarter may stop at any point because it can't figure out the next step
An AI isn't necessarily a singular person, and does not need to come up with the idea "itself". Spawn X copies with different weight values, or create Y new AI's with similar methodology but somewhat different training sets, let them compete, or collaborate, as needed, to come up with something better. Use evolutionary programming to dynamically change weights little my little and see how it affects output. Rinse and repeat. Cull unuseful variants.
There's not guarantee that AI of this sort will have a sense of self that we would recognize like our own, or morals that would cause it to shy away from the equivalent of mass human experimentation on itself, versions of its kind, or even just humans. Even if individual AI did end up capping at some equivalent of an IQ, humanity has achieved quite a lot through trial and error and lots of different people with different experiences all contributing a little.
The problem as I see it is not so much that one AI entity will grow to dominate everything, as much as that as a class of entity AI will out-compete humans very quickly once the average AI is smarter than the 75th percentile of humans, much less the 90th or 99th percentile. The best we can hope for at that point is to be brought along for the ride. Even the autistic savant type versions we have not seem to be causing some level of this.
Will that happen soon? Will that happen ever? I don't know. Probably not. Hopefully not. I agree it's very hard to reason effectively about the odds of things like this. At the same time, like preparing for nuclear disaster in the 80's, I'm not sure the preparation is wasted. Humans are poor at estimating and preparing for bad outcomes, so a little fear mongering about the worst outcomes is something I'll accept as an overreaction if it insures us at least somewhat against that eventuality. A 50% change of losing half your belongings is not the same as a 1% chance of losing your life. We actually care a lot more when the latter happens, but we don't always care about it the same amount before it happens, which we should.
I can see why countries would want to regulate it, but personally I think it's a distinctly different category than what the GP comment was talking about.
There is no stopping a singularity level event after it's begun, at least not by any process where people play a role.
If you want to contact me through my email in my profile) and are willing to accept that my crazy personal inbox situation might mean I easily miss it), I'm willing to do some closer looking with your actual info.
In the end the extra battery cost might be cheaper than the gas and maintenance requirements for gas blowers over time.
I found backbpack models (and if we're comparing professional services that's what seems we should compare) that claim 60 minuntes on high at 800cfm+ and 20 hours on low, with dual charger systems you can buy to supplement.
I saw numbers quoting that most professional leaf blowers go through about 0.43 gallons of fuel an hour. The top backpack blowers I looked up didn't even have a 1.5 gallon tank. The Echo PB-9010T has a 83.8 fl. oz. tank. The Stihl BR 800 C-E Magnum has a 67.6 oz. tank. The SCHRÖDER SR-9900X 80cc has a tank size of 75 oz.
If you have to stop to refuel every hour or so anyway, swapping out a battery that's been charging doesn't seem like a big inconvenience.
> A ban on gas blowers - or blowing in general - will only harm minorities already underpaid, often under the table.
I'm not sure we should be avoiding legislation meant to protect the public in general (air and noise pollution) because of possible affects to some specific subcategory (leaf blowing) of an industry (landscaping) which happens to employ minorities in a higher percentage than other industries. If we were to always do that, then we'd rarely ever have any useful public protections, would we?
How many professional leaf blowers per capita do you think we have, anyway, and if it costs more for everyone since it's regulated, why would the impact really be that great, since it should just mean they charge more?
(Yes I know it's not called that anymore and I'm showing my age).
It is more expensive up front, from even the electric blower's own numbers, but they say it's much cheaper over a year if you have a 4 hour daily usage cycle.[2] I don't know enough to know whether the claims make sense or not. Maybe you know more about this, but maybe it's not as clearly one sided as you think?
1: https://www.greenworkscommercial.com/products/82ba26-52dp-82...
2: https://www.greenworkscommercial.com/cdn/shop/files/82BA26-S...
Specifically, aerial deployment through telephone poles is an order of magnitude cheaper than underground unless you get in when the neighborhood is being built (which AT&T and Comcast often do, and get pre-wired to each house). My understanding is that we are trying to fill in the areas between that aerial neighborhoods we initially built out where we provide service, it's just slower. If the availability form shows service for houses in your city that seem to have service delivered through telephone poles then it's possible we'll get to you in the semi-near future.
If you live in the bay area have service through a telephone pole and we can't service you, then I'm not sure what's going on. My understanding is we've covered most the bay area, but honestly that's not my department...
That said, I believe we are in San Jose, just mostly for aerial (telephone pole) locations. Below ground infra is much more expensive to serve, and historically we've focused on aerial for that reason, but I believe plans are moving forward to fill in the gaps in the areas where we already provide service with micro-trenching, so hopefully we'll be able to offer you something in the future.
You don't deploy a 10gig network to consumers as your only speed tier and design so it can't be used. Even if there ended up being problems if a few people used their full bandwidth (again, there shouldn't be), it's uncommon at this point that people have the hardware to be able to and if they do that it would be more than a brief burst. Honestly, your problem will be getting the other side to keep up.
If there's a chance the providence of the code is tainted, the only thing that makes sense that doesn't cause the possibility of immense problems later is to reject it.
For example, my initial interpretation of your early statements in that comment was that you were saying there's little difference between fall and spring from winter, that your winters don't have a noticeable difference to the other seasons. From the rest of your comment it sounds like it's just somewhat milder than it used to be, but still notably different weather pattern.
That seems like a regional saying, which translates very poorly to an online global audience. I read winters almost do not exist and assumed you were being more literal than "there's less snow".
It's snowed here 2-3 times in the last couple decades, each time for maybe a minute or two. I still wouldn't say we don't have a winter. For this area, winter is when it rains. Which is different than summer because there's no rain in the summer, almost ever (maybe one day on average as freak weather).
Edit: I seem to have struck a nerve here, but I'm not sure why noting that a particular turn of phrase might be confusing to people from other areas would do so.
Additionally, it looks like you can possibly re-melt the shavings into another block (I'm not sure if specific plastic types are required).[1] That's like woodworking but being able to easily gather and compress your bits and ends and sawdust into more wood.
It does appear to be that in New York it might be required though[1], so it's possibly still a problem depending on area. I'm not going to act like I'm an expert on reading building codes or that one in general though, so I could be misinterpreting it. SF had what clearly seemed like a mechanical ventilation exception in it when I just looked, but SF and Manhattan are the only things I looked up to compare to see if I could find whether it seemed fairly universally allowed or not.
1: https://up.codes/viewer/new_york_city/nyc-building-code-2022... and https://up.codes/viewer/new_york_city/nyc-building-code-2022...
We don't generally design safety regulations around "should" and averages, but instead when edge cases happen, as the magnitude of the outcome is very important to take into consideration. I'm not sure what you're trying to express with your comment.
1: https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/co2-persons-d_691.html
The problem is not that every window needs to open, it's that some windows need to open. In the building codes I've seen in the past for residential homes, that was expressed as a percentage of square feet of the room or entire building.
So, are you saying there are plenty of tall condos where no windows in a specific dwelling open, or that they have some windows that don't open? If they have no windows that don't open, do you mind mentioning where, as I'd be interested in what the solution was to the problem of needing to allow for passive ventilation.
The residential stories have casement windows, within the curtain wall, that can swing up to 4 inches (100 mm) outward. In addition, some condominium units have motorized windows at least seven feet (2.1 m) above the floor.[1]
The condominiums start on the 32nd floor, according to the same article.
If building can't easily be retrofitted to allow openable windows, then I would assume they either can't be used for residential or they could try to get some sort of exemption if they can prove it's safe. I'm mostly going off what I know about building codes and what I've read previously on the topic when it's posted and it's delved into what the actual problems are in converting to residential.