HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

keiferski

33,971 karma · joined November 15, 2010

"The street finds its own uses for things."
submissionscomments
keiferski··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
So just to recap here:

You haven’t produced any summary of an argument, or even a real link to one justifying the claim that all academic philosophy is obscure on purpose, in any of your comments.

Instead you’ve linked to a blog post about AI and academic publishing; and a paper from 15 years ago that says social sciences and humanities are plagued by a problem with obscurity.

This isn’t how actual philosophical debate works. But it’s a perfect example of how LW is not a serious intellectual community.

keiferski··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
And you still haven’t made any real point, other than drop a couple names.

What do they have to say? What is their argument? Why is a behavioral economist’s opinion relevant in a discussion about academic philosophy? Etc.

“Academic philosophy is obscure on purpose and X two people say so.” is not an argument.

keiferski··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
I’m not arguing against the average holder of the idea.

I’m saying that the argument that “academic philosophy is verbose and obscure on purpose” isn’t a good argument, and is most often repeated by people with little knowledge of the field, so often that it’s become something of a culture war trope. At the very least it’s a well-known quality of LW and similar spaces.

As in the comments above, there is often no actual paper, no argument, just vague assertions and a couple random name drops, as if that’s an argument.

keiferski··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
Yeah I’m gonna guess 99.9% of people making that criticism against academic philosophy don’t know those names.

The LW/rationalist space, and other spheres adjacent to it, have a disdain for traditional philosophy, but have spent very little time engaging with that philosophy and giving sufficient reasons as to why it’s not important, or not even worth engaging with.

keiferski··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
I was being the term academic philosophy to mean the entirety of historical and contemporary thought, not specifically just papers published recently.

That said, I don’t agree at all that authors are incentivized to be obscure. That is a typical criticism from people that don’t have actual experience in the field, but are just repeating culture war tropes.

I also really don’t think you can just hand wave away the entire history of ideas with vague statements like “from the standpoint of a contemporary observer most of them contain trivial logical mistakes.”

This attitude is exactly why rationalism is a goofy internet thing and not an actual intellectual movement.

I also have a degree in philosophy, and IME the idea that papers published in leading analytic journals are obscure on purpose is nonsense. There is no tolerance for the kind of handwavy arrogance you’ll find in “internet thought” on blogs and social media.

keiferski··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
You cannot claim that your search for knowledge is deep while simultaneously dismissing most previous work on the topic. In the rationalists case they have little knowledge of historical and contemporary philosophy.
keiferski··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
A big part is that the rationalist community has little respect for traditional philosophical arguments. Consequently they don’t really understand how to make an argument, in the sense of a formal logical framework that can be summarized and critiqued.

Instead they seem to take one premise and just run with it, and tens of thousands of words later, they think they’ve made some profound point.

I’d say that 99% of the rationalist essays I’ve read wouldn’t be given passing grades in an academic philosophy class on the topic.

keiferski··on Ask HN: What is the most obscure book you own?
These probably aren't super obscure outside of central/Eastern Europe, but: I have a bunch of Soviet-era guides to different countries in the former Eastern Bloc, written in local languages. So for example, a travel guide to Yugoslavia written in Polish.

My favorite one is an East German guide to useful trade-oriented words in eight different languages. Basically it's a bunch of columns with words like "consumer goods" or "deck cargo" in German, English, Czech, Russian, etc. The introduction especially has some interesting lines like:

"This book is mainly intended for business with capitalist countries."

keiferski··on Ask HN: What to Build in the AI Era?
I think the answer to this question, and broadly to AI in general, is to focus on building yourself.

By that I mean focus less on creating some external thing, and focus more on “sculpting” your self.

That can mean anything from learning how to repair cars, how to draw, a foreign language, getting in amazing physical shape, etc.

The point is that as people rely more and more on some external tools to create things, you’ll be less dependent on them. Such a person will stand out more and more as time goes by.

Someone that speaks five languages and can draw well is immensely more impressive and capable that someone using Google Translate and an AI image generator.

keiferski··on I wish you the best in the Offline
It’s really kind of a pervasive attitude, akin to fish and the concept of water.

“But why would you do that if you can’t make any money from it?”

It’s so difficult to overcome this tendency to dismiss ideas because they don’t lead to income, especially if you aren’t financially secure/have years of savings in the bank.

keiferski··on European Alternatives
These sites are not really representative of the average European person, who will continue to use American and Chinese etc. products because they are cheaper or better quality than local alternatives.

The real European alternatives need to be better products, full stop, than the competition. And there certainly are many - personally I really like Allegro more than Amazon. But I use it because it’s better, not because I’m trying to make a political statement.

keiferski··on Why were Victorian elites so effective?
One of my favorite series is the Asia Saga, which is basically set in different parts of South and East Asia from circa 1600 to 1980.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asian_Saga

It’s a fictional series of course, but one of the smaller details that I am always aware of is how individuals and corporations seemed to be more geopolitically aware, and deliberately trying to “help” the British Empire, directly or indirectly. And the governmental structures were equally as interested in their local interests succeeding. (Often at ethically horrible things, I should add.)

I feel like in the contemporary era, this dynamic doesn’t really exist. American corporations abroad don’t seem particularly interested in supporting the American empire. They are more disconnected from the state they ostensibly belong to, and are far more international and selfish. So there really isn’t the same kind of singular cohesion that was there in the British empire.

keiferski··on 'Pull the plug': protesters resort to direct action against AI firms
A lot of young people are pretty unhappy with the state of the world and the future they’ve been given. I don’t really blame them for targeting various different things that represent that future.
keiferski··on Treachery in the Rodin Museum 3D scan verdict
I don't think it's that complicated. The museum wants people to see the original works in the museum.

The rest of what you wrote is unnecessarily pedantic.

keiferski··on Treachery in the Rodin Museum 3D scan verdict
Rodin has been dead for a long time, and the museum is obviously the closest thing to his representative. He specifically donated the buildings and his work to the French state on the condition that they make it a museum of his work.

Lynch also wasn’t talking about only his movies, he was talking about cinema as a whole.

keiferski··on Treachery in the Rodin Museum 3D scan verdict
It’s not a totally crazy idea to insist that certain artworks should only be viewed in certain ways. I’m reminded of David Lynch saying something similar about watching movies on your phone:

https://youtu.be/OQiQk8AJ0YI?is=Wiwxeok0Hg4jMdJu

Off the top of my head, I can think of at least a few artists whose works are somewhat belittled by being digitized and viewed on a screen: Monet and Rothko. Both have monumental size paintings that really don’t work if you aren’t there in person. But since the only way most people interact with them is via a screen, they are often criticized (Rothko specifically.)

So in other words, some art necessarily has a physical dimension which cannot be appreciated in a non-physical way.

keiferski··on Mike Tomlin spent 12 years building a Minecraft city
That’s the thing with AI: it doesn’t lead to a good story. No one cares that you typed some prompts and made something generic.
keiferski··on Frog and Toad and the Increasingly Capable Machines
Yeah I find it so distasteful when people just use AI to copy and morph something that a real person spend years of their life crafting.

But I also think fan fiction is equally terrible, so YMMV. This stuff is basically just fan fiction but made faster.

Make something original!

keiferski··on An AI sovereign wealth fund isn't progressive – it's techno-imperialism
Isn't it usually "it's not just x, it's y"? As in, it's X but even more than X.

The title has the opposite meaning: it's not X, but it's Y.

keiferski··on Returning from vacation? The government can search your phone without a warrant
Yeah, in that case I agree. I didn't realize you only meant Polish citizens.
keiferski··on Returning from vacation? The government can search your phone without a warrant
Poland border agents do ask why you're visiting. Don't know where you're getting that info.
keiferski··on September 2026: The world today, as seen by one Polish guy
Yeah I struggle to think of a time in the last three hundred years that Poland was in a better position than it is today. Maybe like 2019 or so? And that is basically still the same era.
keiferski··on September 2026: The world today, as seen by one Polish guy
I'm sure you can throw out statistics that prove otherwise, but I think the average living standard of Poland is already better than America. Again, anecdotally, but I'm American and I've lived in Poland for about a decade. Food, healthcare, housing, access to parks, public transport, etc. are all better quality here at the average-person level than most places the US.

Americans just end up paying for a lot of things that are either undesirable for many Poles (e.g., a huge McMansion in desolate suburbs and the car to drive there) or paid for via other means (e.g., healthcare.)

keiferski··on You Are No Longer Invited to Dinner
I think you are agreeing with me. Retired = not worried about career. People aged late 20s to say, mid-50s tend to be very career-focused.
keiferski··on Everybody’s home. No one’s coming over
Fair point, although I do think it’s fairly typical generally for people to become less social as they get older, find a partner, get more serious about their career, etc. with the trends aside.
keiferski··on Everybody’s home. No one’s coming over
I do think it’s possible to move between categories though. I used to have potlucks and house parties every month in my twenties, but now a decade later I just don’t really have much interest in the idea.

It might just be a rationalization, but the way I justify it is that as I’ve gotten older, I’ve realized more what actually matters to me, and being a party host / spending time at parties doesn’t fit that category. I’d rather spend my time doing something else.

keiferski··on Does Reddit have an astroturfing problem? What the data suggests
Not really, if you want to ask a question. 9/10 times it gets locked for breaking some obscure rule. If anyone answers, that answer is just deleted immediately as well.

This type of subreddit specifically is almost entirely useless since the advent of AI.

keiferski··on Does Reddit have an astroturfing problem? What the data suggests
It is really odd/shocking how bad Reddit is, and how there don't seem to really be any seriously funded competitors. I know that in theory, X and its new competitors like bluesky are alternatives, but I really don't see them as the same kind of forum-first site.

Is it because Reddit as a business is just generally a bad idea dependent on the free labor of mods?

keiferski··on Ask HN: Who is smarter than you that you listen to what they have to say?
Intelligence is pretty overrated when it comes to making predictions about the future, especially when the person making the prediction has financial motivations for saying one thing or another. Everyone on your list fits that bill, with the added downside that most are extremely partisan in their worldviews.

I'd suggest instead reading books by historians, especially ones that are fairly old and have focused on a particular topic. IMO, breadth is more useful for looking at long timelines.

keiferski··on 'That's so AI ' What gen Alpha's biggest insult tells us
> I wonder if any movie special effects that you notice will be considered AI?

Zach King is a YouTuber to watch on this topic.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →