HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kelnage

577 karma · joined May 21, 2009

submissionscomments
kelnage··on Horrible doors on British trains (2010)
That is likely the correct answer. I believe the problem is the machines use a resistive touch screen (which respond to pressure - and hence the finger nail is more effective) as opposed to the capacitive touch screens that pretty much everyone else has adopted.
kelnage··on Horrible doors on British trains (2010)
I travel from the south-west of England towards London every weekday, on a service that runs hourly. As far as I know, the trains that service this route only use this type of outside-only-opening train door, including the train I rode this morning. They are still very common here.
kelnage··on After 37 years, Voyager has fired up its trajectory thrusters
Thank you for this recommendation - just finished watching this on iPlayer and it was everything you promised.
kelnage··on Ask HN: Why are supercomputers all running Linux and not BSD?
Sadly that link is long dead, but the Wayback Machine comes to the rescue: https://web.archive.org/web/20000619092736/www.scyld.com/net...
kelnage··on Show HN: iOS music player, like a virtual record collection
I don’t suppose you’d be able to support Google Music on iOS? I am a big album person, and the number of hoops I have to jump through to find an album to listen to always frustrates me - so this looks great. The problem is most of my music is either ripped to FLAC or on Google Music these days.
kelnage··on Signal’s Moxie Marlinspike calls out Telegram founder Pavel Durov
Telephony is federated, in some senses. But not as is generally accepted when speaking about internet communication protocols. Compared to SMTP or IRC, the average person can't start their own telephony service provider - to do so is highly regulated and involves organisations such as the ITU. I'm sure, given such an infrastructure, Signal could be relatively easily moved to a "federated" set-up. But that wouldn't solve the issues that people who complain "Signal isn't federated" want fixed.
kelnage··on Signal’s Moxie Marlinspike calls out Telegram founder Pavel Durov
Moxie is talking specifically about making a secure (particularly, end-to-end secure) federated communication protocol. Making insecure federated communication protocols is pretty much a solved problem, yes.

(And I'm sure some people are very happy GPG users. But the majority of email users are not and will probably never be)

kelnage··on Se­cu­rity Keys
Wow, I had no idea YubiKey offered that mode of operation. I had assumed it was purely used as a OTP. Do you know of any documentation for it?
kelnage··on Se­cu­rity Keys
[-You would be correct if-] It seems you are correct when the protocol works as described in the parent comment.

[-But it so happens that the-] Of course in OTP mode, the YubiKey protocol protects against replay attacks by using a counter on the YubiKey. This (authenticated) counter value is included in the messages that are exchanged during the authentication - and hence any replays can be detected/ignored as the counter value will be less than or equal to the last received counter value.

Edit (deletions marked with [- -]): I had no idea people used modes other than OTP with their YubiKey...

kelnage··on (n+1)sec – a protocol for distributed multiparty chat encryption
Sorry, I didn't make myself clear there. Under-specified security properties. Although they (and TLS, honestly) do a better job than others, in their protocol documentation they really don't go to any lengths to describe what actual security the protocol provides - just that it is "secure". This makes verifying these protocols nigh impossible - and usually you end up with the analyst having to reverse-engineer what security properties they think the designers wanted the protocol to ensure.
kelnage··on (n+1)sec – a protocol for distributed multiparty chat encryption
I believe it is pairwise (i.e. every chat member does a handshake with every other chat member), although there is some debate about this in the academic community.
kelnage··on (n+1)sec – a protocol for distributed multiparty chat encryption
I would argue that the reason protocol errors are perceived to be "quite rare" is because the security guarantees that many (most?) security protocols offer are usually under-specified, if at all. When auditing protocols, analysts often have to infer what properties a user might expect.

A great example of this would be [1], where a number of ISO-standardised authentication protocols failed to give even the most basic authentication properties. And this kind of issue isn't limited to ISO - the same kinds of issues appeared when analysing TLS, Signal, and others.

The problem is that implementation errors are usually more clearly violations of confidentiality (i.e. it is obvious that an attacker is able to access something they weren't supposed to) - so they are generally held to be more valuable - and hence more eyes spend time looking for them.

(Disclaimer: I am doing a PhD in this field with Prof Cas Cremers, which might bias my views on this subject a little)

1. http://www.cs.ox.ac.uk/people/cas.cremers/downloads/papers/B...

kelnage··on Indictment of Marcus Hutchins aka "Malwaretech"
What Malwaretech has been charged with here would likely be illegal under UK law as well as US law (section 37 of the Computer Misuse Act [1] appears to be analogous to the charges being brought against him). And regardless, the UK-US extradition treaty is written in such a way that the US charges do not have to be illegal under UK law for an extradition to take place (although the converse is not true).

Now, it may well have been the case that when the inevitable court case to challenge the extradition in the UK took place, it might have gone all Gary McKinnon on them [2], due to public support after WannaCry etc. which I'd suggest is probably why the FBI chose to arrest him in the US rather than put in a formal extradition request or work directly with the UK authorities (AFAIK).

But yes, I do agree that with the advent of a worldwide communications network, travel to countries with oppressive, obscure, or stricter legal regimes has become more dangerous for some. The thing I find curious is that others haven't perceived this change in risk.

I wouldn't necessarily say this is a bad thing either - note there have been a number of (accused) botnet operators/cyber-criminals originating from Russia who were arrested whilst holidaying in the EU, and then extradited to the US. Since Russia has a reputation for being lax about prosecuting such "crimes" (especially if they only target people outside of Russia), and also tends to refuse to extradite Russian nationals, it doesn't seem that there are many other options.

1. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/48/section/37

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_McKinnon

kelnage··on Indictment of Marcus Hutchins aka "Malwaretech"
This is exactly why the "the Internet is a different place" arguments (such as [1]) make me sad. Because, without a formal worldwide treaty (seems unlikely), it will never be the case. Whilst you might perceive your actions on the Internet to be either only policeable on the Internet or in the worst case in the location you perform them from, the law (in multiple countries, over and over again) sees your actions as occurring in any place they affect. You may have initiated the activity in country A - but if that action is then caused to happen/repeated/perhaps even observed in country B, you probably shouldn't be surprised that if it breaks country B's laws then they might want to speak to you about it.

Guess what - if you (as an example) encourage Chinese dissent online and it gets past the Chinese firewall - you stand a good chance of being picked up by the Chinese authorities should you go there. The only way the Internet is a different place is if you never leave the Internet/your home jurisdiction. The good news for US citizens is an extradition along the lines you mention seems unlikely (unless you also broke US law). In the UK (for example), the situation is far more bleak as their extradition treaties with the US and others are less protective.

P.S. this is in no way commentary on MalwareTech's guilt - that is for a judge and/or jury to decide - just discussing a common perception

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Declaration_of_the_Independe...

kelnage··on Apple Watch sales up over 50% since last year
One of our most prolific runners put it best: "if it's not on Strava, it didn't happen".
kelnage··on Apple Watch sales up over 50% since last year
Based on what I've seen at a local running club with 60+ members, most regular runners seem to have picked up at least one wearable (although I haven't seen that many Apple watches - most have gone for either Garmin or TomTom). In fact, I'm certainly in the minority as someone who hasn't.

That said - the more professional members are generally also in that minority too - they tend to stick to using their phone or they don't bother tracking their runs at all.

kelnage··on Where’s all my CPU and memory gone? The answer: Slack
If its a "solved problem" then why aren't users flocking to IRC over Slack?

The answer is likely multifaceted, but part of it is undoubtedly the usability of the client - which may be resource intensive, but that was likely a trade off for speed/ease of development.

kelnage··on “We currently have no plans to support Xwayland”
Obviously not. But neither would most want to do HPC on a computer they are also running a graphical desktop on either. In my experience, most serious academic computation happens on headless servers that are certainly not running Weyland or anything similar.
kelnage··on Hidden dungeons of the London Underground
In this case, it's a legal requirement on the BBC. Their funding for iPlayer comes directly from the license fee that UK live-TV watchers legally have to pay annually. They do re-sell their content around the world and even have a commercial branch, BBC Worldwide, which creates content for the US and other markets, and also allows them to show adverts in those markets (which they can't do in the UK, again due to the license fee).

I guess they don't put everything on BBC Worldwide due to costs (getting permission from rights holders etc.) and instead prioritise those things they think are likely to sell.

kelnage··on Hidden dungeons of the London Underground
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DH5_jLrVfQU&list=PL2tufbjcRa...
kelnage··on The History of Alice and Bob
But in protocols such as TLS or PGP, the computational requirements of RSA means it is often just used to encrypt a symmetric key, which is then shared with the recipient, in a very similar way to how DH is used to establish a shared secret. I wouldn't say that conflating them in this way is so unrealistic.
kelnage··on The History of Alice and Bob
Shame the article doesn't mention [1] - a relatively recent piece from a leading cryptographer, which contends that the use of Alice and Bob (especially with the usual caricatures) makes light of the impact of cryptographic vulnerabilities, and in doing so, makes them less obviously important. I'm not sure whether I fully agree with that viewpoint, but it does seem like an important question to discuss.

[1] http://web.cs.ucdavis.edu/~rogaway/papers/moral.pdf

kelnage··on View Counting at Reddit
> Weird thing I have been seeing on Reddit is comment upvotes being off-by-one periodically on page refreshes. Reload, you get 3. Reload again, you get 4. Reload, you get 3. Seems like a replication issue?

This is done on purpose [1], to prevent bots from calculating exact post/comment scores.

1. https://www.reddit.com/wiki/faq#wiki_how_is_a_comment.27s_sc...

kelnage··on Ask HN: Is Telegram better than WhatsApp?
Define "better". If all your friends use one, then that is probably better for you. There is also functionality differences between the two (mentioned by others), which might force your hand.

That said, there are other quantifiable measures. In terms of security, Telegram has two main drawbacks:

1) it supports insecure chats - which means that for many (especially non-technical) users, they won't use the end-to-end encrypted messaging at all

2) whilst the encryption algorithms they use are standardised, the protocol they uses to transfer the messages is not well understood by the cryptographic community - and when it has been analysed, well-known flaws have been found [1].

In comparison, WhatsApp also makes use of standardised encryption algorithms, but also uses the Signal protocol - which has been studied by multiple groups, with better outcomes (such as [2]). One drawback to WhatsApp is they will generally make security decisions that are primarily based around avoiding sacrificing usability - if that is a problem, then perhaps Signal[3] or Wire[4] is a better choice.

On the encryption debate, using Russian algorithms vs US (Belgian) algorithms is somewhat academic - I believe that both are considered by the wider academic community to be strong when correctly used. I don't believe there is any evidence that Telegram or WhatsApp are incorrectly using them (beyond the attack found against Telegram, which may have been fixed by now?). This is the mostly the same for considerations about data storage location - if end-to-end encryption is enabled in Telegram, they are roughly equivalent.

[1] https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/1177.pdf

[2] https://eprint.iacr.org/2016/1013.pdf

[3] https://whispersystems.org/

[4] https://app.wire.com/

kelnage··on Carbonated beverages induce increased food consumption in rats
FYI, the paper says:

> Rats of each group were supplemented with different beverages: (i) tap water, (ii) regular degassed CB (DgCB), (iii) regular CB (RCB) and (iv) diet CB (DCB)

Where CB is carbonated beverages.

kelnage··on AsusWRT sends network traffic data to Trend Micro if certain features enabled
I am sad to say this, but this is not such an unusual event in home routers [1]. I'd do the same as you, if not for the fact that it seems impossible to recommend any make/model of router to a home user that doesn't require expert knowledge to properly secure.

[1] For examples: https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=router+RCE

kelnage··on For First Time Since 1800s, Britain Goes a Day Without Burning Coal for Power
Except that's a terrible argument (I wasn't swayed by Russian interference, therefore no-one was). Yes, the citizens of the UK voted (just) for Brexit - because it was a referendum - that's how they work (assuming no ballot stuffing etc). Would everyone have voted the same way without the (alleged) interference? Possibly not.
kelnage··on CAA checking becomes mandatory for SSL/TLS certificates
I'm not sure it "protects" anything, per se - more of a formalisation that CAs should verify that the domain owner is the one making the request.

I doubt browsers will ever check CAA, since it's even easier to tamper with than OCSP (since the majority of DNS requests are still over plain text).

kelnage··on CAA checking becomes mandatory for SSL/TLS certificates
...in September 2017, according to the linked article. Title might need a little tweak to reflect that fact.
kelnage··on Will Spotify go public without an IPO?
I'd also suggest trying Google Music. I moved to it originally simply because I could upload my existing music collection to it, and listen to it wherever. Then Google gave me 3 free months of the subscription service - and I'm seriously considering paying for it once that's up.

It runs in a web browser on Linux just fine - and I find a lot of their suggested artists/tracks are closer to my tastes than I got from Spotify.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →