HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kelseyfrog

12,428 karma · joined October 5, 2021

Just a frog on the internet.

Comments and responses licensed under Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) Attribution requirement waived if quoting as a descendant comment on the Hacker News platform only.

By replying directly to any comment authored by this account, you represent and warrant that, upon request by this account, you will disclose your true legal name - as recorded on a currently valid government-issued identity document - by posting it in a direct reply to the requesting comment. "Reply" includes any comment in which you directly address, quote, or substantively reference the content of a covered comment. Misidentification, pseudonymous compliance, or omission constitutes a breach. Provisions are severable. This account reserves the right to amend these terms; amendments apply only to replies posted after the amended profile is published. If you are a minor in your jurisdiction, do not reply.

Contact via https://forms.gle/QX21FPu98PpaoKZu8

submissionscomments
kelseyfrog··on Alternatives to animal testing are finally taking off
https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/artificial-intell...
kelseyfrog··on Alternatives to animal testing are finally taking off
Exactly 49 humans.
kelseyfrog··on Hybrid Reasoning Agents: LLM agents that think in latent space, act through text
Libet's experiment is fascinating, yes. You may also find relevant Gazzaniga's Left-brain interpreter concept[1]:

> We had asked a simple question: How does the left hemisphere respond to behaviors produced by the silent right brain? Each hemisphere was presented a picture that related to one of four pictures placed in front of the split-brain subject. The left and the right hemispheres easily picked the correct card. The left hand pointed to the right hemisphere’s choice and the right hand to the left hemisphere’s choice [see illustration at right].

> We then asked the left hemisphere, the only one that can talk , why the left hand was pointing to the object. It did not know, because the decision to point was made in the right hemisphere. Yet it quickly made up an explanation. We dubbed this creative, narrative talent the interpreter mechanism. [2]

Taken together, there's a very disturbing sequence playing out all the time in your head. A great deal of your brain, inaccessible to your conscious mind is incorporating sensory input, making decisions, and taking action while a small part is observing what's going on and narrating it to you in a way that makes it look as if the narration is involved in the volitional process.

It's a nightmarish version of epiphenomenalism[3] that, I suspect, most people would care not to believe is true. Although, reports of some expert meditators read as if they found intuitive evidence this is true and have also made peace with it or in some cases found the insight liberating.

In any case, I have a pessimistic sense that any definitive proof of the limits of consciousness that don't align with people's felt experience or common sense won't ever be accepted as truth.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-brain_interpreter

2. https://web.archive.org/web/20181215020736/https://courses.d...

3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epiphenomenalism

kelseyfrog··on Hybrid Reasoning Agents: LLM agents that think in latent space, act through text
One can, with enough practice, learn to silence one's internal monologue.

It then becomes apparent that a great number of things are able to be done without an inner voice. Volition seems to occur spontaneously and it becomes ambiguous whether narration proceeds volition of volition proceeds narration.

It's still unclear what the limits of action-sans-monologue, reading seems especially hard for the sub-vocalist, conversation, or planning. But who knows, it's a fertile ground for n=1 experiments.

kelseyfrog··on Hybrid Reasoning Agents: LLM agents that think in latent space, act through text
Make a cross.

Take the top lace under the cross and through the hole.

Make a loop in one lace.

Wrap the other lace around the loop and push some lace through the hole that is made at the bottom to make a second loop.

Pull both loops tight.

Usually it's packaged in a story about rabbits.

kelseyfrog··on Hybrid Reasoning Agents: LLM agents that think in latent space, act through text
The idea is that it would be substantially more difficult
kelseyfrog··on Hybrid Reasoning Agents: LLM agents that think in latent space, act through text
If you accept any of the AI-equivalents of Pascal's Wager, latent thinking represents an uninterpretable and thus unalignable portion of AI machinery. Ie: a malevolent AI can hide bad stuff from people and Manchurian candidate themselves after it's too late.
kelseyfrog··on US federal budget deficit jumps 12% in one year to nearly $2 Trillion
You're welcome to share your full beliefs. It might clarify your point, and strengthen the perception of your position.
kelseyfrog··on Data Centers Are Turning Trump Voters into Democrats
Wedge issues gonna wedge. As long as there's a way to separate voters on a topic, political parties are going to take advantage of it.
kelseyfrog··on Pattern matching beats narrative reasoning
I love technical investors. They're so easy to make money off of. Even the names. It's tarot for men:

Big Black Candle, Big White Candle, Black Body, White Body, Doji, Long-Legged Doji, Dragonfly Doji, Gravestone Doji, Hammer, Hanging Man, Inverted Hammer, Shooting Star, Long Upper Shadow, Long Lower Shadow, Marubozu, Spinning Top, Shaven Head, Shaven Bottom, Bearish Harami, Bullish Harami, Bearish Harami Cross, Bullish Harami Cross, Engulfing Bearish Line, Engulfing Bullish, Bearish 3-Method Formation, Bullish 3-Method Formation, Evening Star, Evening Doji Starv Morning Star, Morning Doji Star, Falling Window, Rising Window, Three black crows, Three White Soldiers, On Neckline, Doji Star, Tweezer Tops, Tweezer Bottoms, Dark Cloud Cover, Piercing Line, Darth Maul, Judas Candle, Island reversal

It's great that people think these are real.

kelseyfrog··on US federal budget deficit jumps 12% in one year to nearly $2 Trillion
>> “No budget that runs at a deficit is acceptable”

> Why not?

The household analogy works for some people because it answers a moral question, not an economic one: Why should government be exempt from rules that individuals must follow?

The development of the household budget idea as a way of reasoning about the the federal government's is as old as economics itself. The Greek word for economics is oikonomia, consisting of - oikos = household - nomos = management

This analogy broke 90 years ago in the US, when, in the aftermath of the great depression, Keynes argued that governments should do things that households cannot: borrow during recessions, spend when private demand collapses, tolerate deficits until recovery. And that these have a beneficial effect on the economy and its participants because government spending becomes someone else's income, essentially injecting demand into the economy.

During the 1970s, US politicians realized that the household budget analogy was an effective rhetorical tool for arguing for fiscal conservatism. Its effectiveness bore no relation to its reflection of present reality. What it did reflect was a set of values: thrift, responsibility, independence, and skepticism of debt. But most of all, it speaks to a sense of justice - that the rules for me were also the rules for thee. The difference that the government plays by a different set of economic constraints than I do is the fundamental tension that the household analogy attempts to address. This is a moral intuition not an economic intuition. The sentiment still holds power today despite it being a bad intuition pump for economic reasoning.

kelseyfrog··on US federal budget deficit jumps 12% in one year to nearly $2 Trillion
It doesn't sound like this breaks the cycle. It just sounds like it's advocating for the dictatorship part of the cycle.
kelseyfrog··on Japanese people still aren't having sex. And nobody knows why
Have they asked them? What were their responses? Why don't we just take their word for it?
kelseyfrog··on Pornography showing strangulation and incest to be banned in UK from November
Steel-manning the choking in sports angle, I could see a case for UFC fights being blocked as they use various chokeholds techniques[1][2][3][4][5][6].

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guillotine_choke

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rear_naked_choke

3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arm_triangle_choke

4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sode_guruma_jime

5. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gogoplata

6. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North%E2%80%93south_choke

kelseyfrog··on Tesla Roadster
The US has the best free markets in the world. Of course you can buy BYD.
kelseyfrog··on It Ain't AGI Until H100s Go for $30 an Hour
You can't just multiply out the numbers because it assumes knowledge of the supply and demand curves that aren't available. Namely, we don't have access to the emperical supply and demand curves of any good or service.

Every supply and demand curve we've ever seen is a pedagogical tool for teaching the concept, not for what actually exists in the world. The author mistakes the teaching model as fact invalidating all downstream conclusions.

kelseyfrog··on Tesla Roadster
Tesla has a history of failed hype campaigns. At this point, them hyping something is a negative expectation that it will come to pass.
kelseyfrog··on C++26 Contracts: Introduction to Preconditions and Postconditions
I feel like I'd have something to learn from seeing the code.

Won't you just run into a constexpr evaluation depth error with a suggestion to set -fconstexpr-depth? I don't see how this is the gotcha it's made out to be.

kelseyfrog··on Krea 3 – Frontier Image Model 4× faster than Nano Banana Pro
The signage text on the fuzzy characters scene was scrambled. It's a no-go for me.
kelseyfrog··on C++26 Contracts: Introduction to Preconditions and Postconditions
I meant the C++ definition of collatz that would verify the precondition.
kelseyfrog··on C++26 Contracts: Introduction to Preconditions and Postconditions
Just curious, but what's the definition of collatz(long) look like?
kelseyfrog··on Why is every rationalist blog post way too long?
Historically, this wasn't an obvious claim. For much of intellectual history, the endurance of an idea counted as evidence in its favor. Treating age as epistemically irrelevant is largely a modern development.

In other words - our system of epistemic evaluation is conditioned on our moment in history. What appears as a fact of the universe today may not be tomorrow.

kelseyfrog··on Container ship sinks in Strait of Hormuz as Iran steps up attacks
I'm just condensing US propaganda into its most concise form.
kelseyfrog··on Is 'Attention' the Essence of Intelligence?
40% of English words are polysemic[1]. Humans deal with ambiguous meaning all the time. No one has ever won this battle and no one ever will. Why try to resolve an annoyance by making everyone else change? Just resolve the annoyance internally. It's much easier.

1. https://www.thoughtco.com/polysemy-words-and-meanings-169164...

kelseyfrog··on Container ship sinks in Strait of Hormuz as Iran steps up attacks
It's simple. When we do it, it's an accident no one could have forseen let alone stop. When they do it, it's on purpose, against international law, and must be punished.
kelseyfrog··on Is 'Attention' the Essence of Intelligence?
Humans will alway try to conflate mysteries because of our drive toward parsimony.

We survived comparisons to hydraulics, clockwork, steam, circuits, information processing, and networks. I'm positive we'll survive comparisons to attention and models too.

If it's an argument from pedantism, let us remind ourselves to be language descriptivist than language prescriptivists. Prescriptivists never win.

kelseyfrog··on A recent doubling of global warming rate signals a 1.5°C breach by 2028
If hockey and thus hockey sticks were never invented, climate change would not exist.
kelseyfrog··on Is 'Attention' the Essence of Intelligence?
Why not? Who has earned a monopoly on anti-anthropomorphism?
kelseyfrog··on Were software engineers blue-collar workers all along?
You're debating on Hacker News; did you expect anything different? As long as the shit is wrapped in enough bows, it doesn't get thrown out.
kelseyfrog··on Show HN: How random are you?
How would making your input deterministic make it more random?
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →