HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kem

490 karma · joined May 14, 2016

submissionscomments
kem··on How Anker is beating Apple and Samsung at their own accessory game
I came here to say something similar.

I've become genuinely disturbed at how substandard generic peripherals have become. What's especially disturbing to me is that the problem often seems to be drifting from spec standards, adhering to specs just enough to be functional for most products for just long enough.

I have a audio system that I went through like 4 generic cables on. I was just about to get a replacement system when I saw Anker enthusiastically recommended somewhere, and thought I'd give it a last-ditch chance. It's worked beautifully, no problems.

I've seen similar issues with other types of cables. The scope of the problem is astonishing to me--it's like the manufacturing standards at 85% of producers just suddenly went out the window over the last 5 years or so. I suspect there's a good newsstory somewhere there.

kem··on We Need More Alternatives to Facebook
This touches on so many issues at once I don't even know where to start (private versus public, social medial popularity cycles, distributed versus centralized services...)

I think it's not just an alternative to Facebook we need, it's a distributed paradigm, with a distributed network, with distributed services.

The tension/problem as I see it is this: we need distributed networks, where people run their own services, and are servers as well as clients, but at the same time a large proportion of people do not or cannot run their own services. Solving that problem seems key to me--have people act as servers without realizing it (maybe something like with torrents).

The success of things like Facebook and Twitter has never seemed like that much of a mystery to me: they basically allow people to have a web page without needing to make one. There was MySpace that did that, and then people wanted to add on privacy and discussions, etc. to their webpage, so Facebook supplied that; Twitter was basically providing a way for people to post rss/Atom feeds, etc. But then you cede control to these large providers.

I don't think that model completely applies anymore, with messaging, photo sharing, and what not becoming so integrated, but I think the fundamental issues are the same, in that that the internet was developed with a greater ratio of providers:users in mind than is the case now. I think there was a much more federated model in mind when the internet was developed than is the case today.

kem··on The Making of Freeciv WebGL 3D
I agree 100%, although I've always been surprised that a game like Freeciv wasn't vector-graphics based, because it seems to fit so well. Maybe not Freeciv per se, but something similar. I haven't checked in awhile, though, so maybe they introduced something.
kem··on Ask HN: How did open source work before GitHub?
God this more than anything before has made me feel old.

Is GitHub that strongly associated with open source that alternate models for open source development are a mystery? Somehow that's really troubling to me in terms of the open source paradigm, even though I generally see GitHub as a very positive thing. I don't mean that as a criticism of the poster, just saying that it feels like maybe there's some room for more diversity and competition.

I think others have given pretty good descriptions of pre-GitHub models, so I'll leave that to them.

kem··on The FCC voted to start the process of eliminating net neutrality rules
Is this a surprise? Pai has made it abundantly clear he doesn't care what consumers think. Maybe I'm being too cynical, but the idea he would respond to their concerns always seemed naive to me.
kem··on The Dark Side of Doctoring
There's one big difference between software engineers and healthcare: regulation.

A software engineer is hired for their skills (at least ostensibly). No one is required by law to hire someone with a specific degree and specific post-degree training and specific exams.

Contrast this with healthcare. To do certain sorts of procedures, you have to hire a physician. Not because it's demonstrably necessary to have someone with an MD and a residency in such-and-such area do this, but because it's required by law.

As someone else pointed out, this is just the tip of the iceberg. That residency? Residents have no bargaining leverage over their conditions by fiat of residency rules--they cannot leave an abusive residency, for example, to change conditions. Financing the residency itself? Businesses won't cover the expenses because it's not actually worth the costs, so the government foots the bill. And once you leave residency? Well, subspecialty organizations are deciding that it's good to carve out even more regulatory capture with subspecialty credentialing.

People do not grasp how much of this insanity is codified by law and rule, and when they are informed of it, they shrug it off in the name of "safety." It's like terrorism or crime: no one wants to be branded as soft on terrorism or crime, so the government becomes more and more invasive and draconian, and the costs of maintaining the military-police-industrial complex increase and increase. Similarly, no one wants to be soft on safety, so the government becomes more and more invasive and draconian, and the costs of maintaining the medical organization-physician-insurance-industrial complex increase and increase.

There's something disingenuous for physicians to complain about being overworked, and then fight against the things that would alleviate their burden the most: letting perfectly competent professionals with different backgrounds do what they do just as well. But that would mean admitting that you don't need an MD at the apex of healthcare.

To some extent, financial market pressures are doing what I'm saying anyway, as hospitals are realizing that MDs are too expensive as they are. So maybe this is just the first sign of things to come. But the downside of the current system is that administrators aren't allowed to go elsewhere for alternatives, so they just crank up the hours expected of MDs. The upshot is they get devalued without even being given the benefit of being let off the hook.

I guess to address your comment directly: if healthcare were actually a transparent free market, my guess is physician salaries would go down, but their workload would also decrease also. What you'd see instead is much more diversity in who you see for any given service.

The biggest sin of the government in the healthcare debate is willfully ignoring the costs of healthcare, by failing to increase competition, choice, and transparency in pricing. We talk about who pays, but not why we're being charged what we are, and whether or not it's worth it.

kem··on President Trump Dismisses FBI Director Comey
Yeah, that was one of my first thoughts about this. I have no love lost for Comey but there's a huge conflict of interest here with Trump and I think the reasons for Trump firing Comey are not the reasons I would want him fired. Comey was doing a balancing act, playing one constituency against another.

It seems like Trump is purging everyone who might provide any level of oversight whatsoever.

kem··on Springer retracting 107 papers published in Tumor Biology with fake peer reviews
Good point.

Finding contact information for certain individuals is more difficult than it might seem initially, though. Especially if someone has left the academic setting per se: a common pattern is for people to leave and go to a business or hospital setting, where real contact information can be guarded heavily. You might see that so-and-so works at such-and-such place (maybe), but not be able to find a working contact address, and might not even see a reasonable way to figure it out.

You're right that using the author-supplied contact info of a potential reviewer is doubly problematic and probably shouldn't be done. However, at some level I can understand why that happens, because the process often devolves into some chain of contacts to get a working email address anyway.

kem··on Springer retracting 107 papers published in Tumor Biology with fake peer reviews
I'm an editor at a journal, and these fake review cases have one thing in common, which is that the journal is using author suggestions for reviewers to solicit reviews.

For those unfamiliar with the practice, this is common, and seems to becoming more standard at many journals, even (especially?) very reputable ones.

I almost always ignore the reviewer's requests for particular authors, because it always seems to involve a conflict of interest. I am sensitive to requests for a particular author not to review a paper, because of vindictiveness in academics, but requesting reviewers is a different story.

I've seen significant changes in this practice over time. Originally it seemed unusual, almost an option of last resort to cue the editor to bitter feuds or to help identify reviewers in areas that involve highly idiosyncratic issues. At a lot of journals this is still the case. Over time, though, it's seemed to turn into something different, a stopgap measure for overburdened, unconscientious, or harried editors to find increasingly scarce reviewers.

A lot of attention has been paid to the pressures on researchers to publish or perish, quality be damned, and how that affects science. The flip side of that coin, though, is changes in editorial practices at many journals, which have become very cursory, rubber-stamping affairs. Turnaround time on papers is very quick at many journals, which gives authors quick feedback, but at the same time (not necessarily as a result) the review process has become shoddy. Editors are often unfamiliar with the subject material and don't take time to learn it, will grasp at reviewers who might be unqualified or have conflicts of interest, and treat reviews very superficially, even though studies have shown that they are horribly unreliable. To be fair, even finding reviewers can be difficult: I've had conversations with colleagues who have been told not to review because it doesn't bring in revenue to the department. Everyone wants to publish, but not everyone wants to review.

Things are broken in science at the moment, at least in academics. Publishing through peer review has become extremely overvalued. I think it will maintain its place for certain reasons, but some change in mindset or culture around it is necessary.

kem··on The problem with superlatives in the history of science
I agree about what you see as the biggest problem with the "lone genius" myth, but the myth itself is so insidious to me, with so many facets, that volumes more could be said about it.

I agree with the OP that the article isn't as cogent as it could be, but it touches on a lot of problems with the myth, and I agree with its general argument.

People seem to have difficulty with the idea that just because ability and discipline are necessary to success in creative endeavors like science, doesn't mean that they're sufficient, and that a lot of other factors come into play, many outside the individual. There's also factors like the discipline of interest--some are undoubtedly much more difficult to make progress in at any given moment in time. I suspect you could take the most intelligent, conscientious, persistent individual on earth, and if you set them to task with certain problems, no one would hear of them because of the difficulties involved. You might argue that choosing the right task is part of the problem, but is that really the best argument? Do we wait until all the problems of chemistry are resolved before moving on to biology, etc.?

Sometimes I feel like society succumbs to surviviorship bias because the alternative is too bleak. We're willing to defensively ignore the problems with it because to do otherwise is to face the capricious reality of chance and society.

kem··on Wikipedia blocked in Turkey
I guess that's the thing: from what I can tell, Turkey ceased being a democracy with Erdogan. I do not believe anything pertaining to votes in Turkey for some time, since the time Erdogan was first elected. That vote was suspect, and so has everything that's happened since then.

In certain ways, what I find so disturbing about what's been happening in Turkey is how readily everyone seems to accept the official account of major events. The vote that initially established him, the "coup," the most recent vote... Things seem to be accepted at face value by the west without questioning it, even when major red flags are everywhere.

Erdogan isn't just a despot, he's a liar. And the West, especially Western journalism, seems to turn a blind eye.

Even if a large proportion of Turkey supports Erdogan, it doesn't mean a majority do. Even if Erdogan's government says a majority does, doesn't mean it actually does. And when a government establishes itself by subverting democratic or constitutional processes, it's not a democratic government anymore.

kem··on 68% of high-performance employees get new job opps at least once per month
So... you identify HPEs by saying "Are you a HPE? If so, fill out our survey"?

There's a certain circularity to this, in that people are probably more likely to self-identify as a HPE if they're getting lots of offers. It may have little to do with their performance per se, and more about their skillset or connectedness.

kem··on Why I published in a predatory journal
Eh ... in my experience as an editor, author, and reviewer, this varies quite a bit.

Sometimes you can take a pretty good guess who it is based on the topic and the references (e.g., citations to in-press papers on obscure topics is usually a give away). Other times, though, it's difficult to tell who the authors are.

People often also think they know who the author and/or reviewers are when they are really totally wrong. I've reviewed papers and seen other reviewers cite my papers in a way that I thought "damn, that looks like something I'd write" when it was not. Similarly, I've seen reviewers think they know who the author is when they're completely off.

I personally think anonymous reviews are critical, because it keeps some modicum of shielding of reviewers against retribution for negative comments. It's not 100% anonymous of course, but it's anonymous enough to create enough doubt about who the reviewers and authors actually are.

kem··on Analysis of the United Airlines passenger removal incident
Not an expert, but my understanding after reading that article was that at an important level, whether or not Dr. Dao was obligate to exit depends on whether or not he was appropriately told to exit. If he was, he was trespassing; if not he was not.

In this way, it does come back to the police action, because they should have treated it more as an investigation, asking all the parties involved about what was going on, and attempting to mediate, and then when that failed, taken him off the plane.

Overbooking policy in the US is heinous, but at some legalistic level this seems to me to be more about how Dr. Dao's removal occurred, rather than about the overbooking per se.

Honestly, I'm disturbed by the classism that's run rampant throughout the coverage of this and subsequent events. Airline overbooking practices, security unprofessionalism, etc. are all just part of the system until it happens to a physician (whose services for a day or so should not in fact be critical, even if they are inpatient or critical care--a hospital or clinic needs to be able to cover for illness, etc.), or as in the case of a subsequent LA Times story, a wealthy businessman. But for everyone else? The plumber whose livelihood depends on scheduled appointments? Who cares.

kem··on Nim programming language
Nim looks great, but I have to admit after looking through the website it's unclear to me why I would use this over similar alternatives.

In particular, why Nim over Go (or why Go over Nim)?

Is the Python's established presence and resource base (not trivial at all) the only reason one would prefer it over Nim?

kem··on Should we move to a system where every scientist gives grant money away?
Damn, I'm a tenured professor and reading through the comments it seems like I'm the only one who thinks this is a good idea at some level. The reasons I think it probably wouldn't work are things I haven't seen anyone mention, though.

This is really not too different from the current system, except for one critical thing, which is that instead of decisions being based on nepotistic review panels, they're based on everyone. So this has the benefit of everyone getting funding, and decisions on who to fund based on some highly democratized process rather than the old boys club.

The issue you're raising is important, but making funding decisions totally anonymous would help. Of course, I don't know that you could make it totally anonymous, and what you're suggesting would still be an issue, but anonymity would go a long way. Also, the thing you're suggesting would probably still happen anyway even in today's system.

The problem in my mind is deciding who gets to participate in the system. Everyone who's a tenured professor? Tenure-track? What disciplines? My guess is this would just shift the funding decision from a per-project issue to a per-researcher issue.

My favorite idea for remedying the current process is to randomize rewards. That is, everyone above the median gets thrown into a pool and everyone has X% chance of being funded.

Also, I'd like to see "term limits" and more randomization of review panels. Make it more akin to jury duty, where, if an institution receives federal funding, their researchers are all put into a pool, and review panels are randomly selected for fixed periods of time.

Finally, indirect costs need to be eliminated, sharply curtailed, or reorganized to require explicit justification. Republicans are finally drawing attention to this, and they're right: it's slush funding. Universities wouldn't give as much of a crap about funding if it weren't a profit margin for them.

kem··on Optical illusions that flummox computers
The issue is that the networks are using a trivial, nonessential stimulus feature to base classification decisions on. It's like basing the decision on a very small-eigenvalue feature eigenvector. That could be a training set issue, or it could be something about the network structure.

The article was kind of interesting to me because it reveals that networks are probably sometimes making decisions on highly discriminating but non-essential stimulus features.

It's like the networks might have a high success rate with large number of replicated examples, over sample size, but not over a large number of distinct examples.

They're overfitting, but in a way that isn't immediately obvious because the test stimuli tend to be limited.

My guess is the answer is to incorporate into the training set a lot of quasi-random or structured but abstract images as controls for training.

kem··on Like Tweeting, but You Can't Use the Letter E
It seems to me that Vice casually mentioning Mastodon suggests something about a level of achieved status as a communication platform.
kem··on IoT Market Projected to Grow 12x by 2023
This is just an anecdote as a consumer, but our interest in it when we were looking in to it heavily stemmed from environmental control products, broadly defined.

I'm not sure if I care about my fridge connecting to the internet, but I did care about the lights being off and not wasting energy, the thermostat being under our control when we were gone, controlling humidity and temp in different rooms, door locks, cameras, and so forth and so on. I suspect that as things like solar panels become more of a standard part of home heating & ac, people will become more concerned about regulating energy use, and so forth. And they won't want to micromanage, manually, they'll want it all networked, the components with each other, with whatever central sources are useful (e.g., the energy utility), and their phones and computers.

The concerns we ran into were really fourfold:

1. Idiosyncratic proprietary standards and lock-in. We wanted to buy lightbulb A from company X without being wedded to them forever, and without worrying about whether or not it would be compatible with thermostat C from company Y. Everyone instead seemed to be trying to lock you into something.

2. Security. Everyone here seems to get why that's important.

3. Autonomy. We ran into problems with the following scenario: what if company Z goes under? What if there's a power outage and we need to control device D without connecting to an outside server? A disturbing number of companies seemed to just suggest you're SOL in those situations, which wasn't acceptable.

4. Throughput/bandwidth/resource use. A lot of these things consumed a surprising amount of energy and/or bandwidth. Maybe not the one lightbulb itself, but all of them together with the routers, etc. to control them. It all seems reasonable until you realize what's involved in having your whole damn house reliably communicating with you 24/7 by first going through some router and possibly outside server.

kem··on Ask HN: Will Rust ever become a mainstream systems programming language?
The industry I see Rust making headway into first is actual security. E.g., encrypted communications, etc.

The problem with aerospace, automotive, etc. is that there's substantial physical risk associated with errors. So there's not a lot of incentive to go with something brand new. Things like network security, etc. are a place where people are maybe a bit more concerned about safety than in some other areas, but also need performance, and notions of risk are more vague.

The interest of Tor developers in Rust is not surprising to me at all, for example.

Nothing is going to happen overnight, and I don't see C/C++ going anywhere, but I wouldn't be surprised at all to see Rust gaining a foothold in certain places, and expanding from there. I could also see it being a flash in the pan too, but it's unpredictable really.

kem··on The Utter Uselessness of Job Interviews
There are many, many studies showing the same thing. This study is just one example. See, e.g., meta-analyses of your choice:

http://psycnet.apa.org/journals/apl/79/4/599/

They're predictive, but not very.

Structured interviews are better, but not really by much.

The problem with all of these things is they work, but not very well, and people make too much of any one thing. An interview is a very small slice of behavior, even if it's structured very well.

People make too much of them.

kem··on Python vs. R: The battle for data scientist mind share
I've been using R intensively for almost two decades, and Python for about half that time. I enjoy using them both and think they're great languages. I don't think it's an either-or thing, because they both have something to offer.

At the same time, they also have a lot of weaknesses, most of which are summarized by the Julia benchmarks (https://julialang.org/benchmarks/). You can criticize these particular benchmarks, but similar patterns emerge in lots of other benchmarks.

R was never meant to do the heavy lifting it's doing today. Ihaka sort of lamented this fact for a while, and then got ignored as people went on to use it anyway.

Sure, you can wrap things around low-level C/C++/Fortran in either language, but eventually if you find yourself getting into nitty-gritty stuff, the computation and/or memory use of R and Python becomes a problem. It also complicates a task to rely on juggling two platforms at the same time.

Julia is new, but it reminds me a lot of R in its early stages. I started using R when it was in beta because it offered something new, and Julia has a similar feel at the moment. Maybe Julia will die away but it doesn't seem that way to me at the moment. I've seen lots of prospects come and go, and none of them had the same traction as Julia.

If anything will stem the growth of Julia, it probably will be Python. Javascript saw a lot of performance gains after Google and other players invested heavily into it as part of the mobile ecosystem. It seems like Python is getting similar investments now with ML/DL, and I wouldn't be surprised if Google, et al. started dumping tons of resources into PyPy or something in the same way you saw javascript implementations getting that investment. At the same time, if you look at benchmarks of PyPy, it seems like you might get to the same level as javascript, which isn't the same as Julia (or C++, which is maintaining its relevance, or Rust or Go, which are growing and relevant).

I guess my point is if a student asked me, sure, I'd recommend they prioritize R or Python first, but I would also explain Julia to them and recommend they become familiar with that as well.

kem··on Zi2zi: Master Chinese Calligraphy with Conditional Adversarial Networks
Funny, I had the exact same question, and spent the last hour or so looking into it before I saw your question.

In something I've been writing lately, I've wanted to be able to use certain typefaces, but they lack mathematical symbols or characters. It's something I run into repeatedly. Earlier today, before I saw this post, I was thinking maybe I should just add them, because they're open source, but then when I saw this I wondered "could you just do this with an autoencoder or AN or whatever?" It seems very doable. There are typefaces with them; the issue is creating the missing characters for the typefaces that don't have them, but have other characters.

kem··on Ask HN: Do you still use browser bookmarks?
I think this quote of yours summarizes why I still use bookmarks extensively:

"If I come across a deep link that's so important that I want to keep it, I email myself the link along with maybe a short description, and it will be searchable forever."

I have tons and tons of things that I probably could google/ddg search for, but were really difficult for me to find initially and that I know I would never find again. Some things, sure, no problem, and I search; other things no, I want to bookmark them because I'm not sure I'd find them again. Search engines are really not as perfect as I'd like them to be.

The other reason I have bookmarks is to kind of remind myself "hey remember this thing--you should look into it in more detail later. Like soon."

So I kind of have two sets of bookmarks. One are kind of like "recent things that I need to remember," sort of like a todo list, but or sites or reading, and then will delete quickly, and the others are references that were hard to find initially.

I could email myself things, but to me that's not easier, and it wouldn't help with reminders, because I'd have to go looking for them (if I have to search for it, it's out of sight, out of mind). I don't see the point of something like Pocket, because my browser already syncs across all my devices everywhere. I suppose I could save it to a text file that is synced across devices, or something on a note system, but it doesn't seem better than bookmarks. There was something else I tried that I don't even remember anymore, that in theory would be perfect, but it wouldn't let me organize them in a way that made sense (it insisted that things be sorted alphabetically or something like that).

I do think there could be something better, something that is kind of like synced bookmarks, something like a notes program, something like an RSS reader, but I haven't seen it yet. Ideally what I'd want is something that syncs across devices, allows me to bookmark things for reference or later reading, reminds me of "urgent links," basically acts as a news aggregator/rss feed reader, and gives me useful suggestions for new feeds, and is open source or at least has some sort of open API.

I've noticed recently--as in the last year--I've started using Google Keep kind of like how I use bookmarks, but that often is cumbersome in its own way.

kem··on Every attempt to manage academia makes it worse
As a professor, I probably agree that a lot of academia probably isn't that valuable, and probably could be reorganized.

However:

1. I think the same arguments could be made about just about anything anywhere. People forget that.

2. I think there's a collision of reality with assumptions about how progress works. We tend to think that supergeniuses come in and revolutionize everything, and I think things are instead very piecemeal and incremental. As a result, we fret about worthless academics when the real problem is our expectations about how things work. I realize that sounds a bit like "we should downgrade our expectations" but what I really mean is that great work requires a lot of small contributions that don't look important at any given point in time, but we expect great work to be lots of big contributions all the time. It's sort of like expecting building construction to happen by waiting for one mutant superhuman to come in and put the pieces together, and then blaming the workers for not building quickly enough.

3. Relatedly, it's impossible to know what's important and what not at any given time. I'm struck by the number of times obscure results from decades ago are dragged out and used as the basis of some new finding.

4. About psychology and neuroscience: there's the bootstrapping problem. Let's say you want to explain something like attention. At some point you have to invoke neurons. But to get there you have to have a way of measuring attention, a definition of what attention even means. To do that you have to have a model of the thing you're explaining. We're nowhere near a clear framework for that sort of thing. Similar sorts of arguments could be made about philosophy. Sure, philosophy's great when it intersects with other fields. But there are some problems that wouldn't have any sort of outlet anywhere else other than philosophy publications. Emergence is a good example of this.

kem··on Tor in a safer language: Network team update from Amsterdam
I wish people understood this better.

I'm not a Go programmer, but I have a lot of respect for it.

If you're wondering "why Go"? Think of it as a modern version of C, at a slightly higher level, developed by the same people for slightly higher-level tasks. They made C for low-level stuff, and then picked up with Go for higher-level stuff. It's like C+.

C has been very successful in part because it's so simple in certain respects (although not in others) and I think Go will be successful for many of the same reasons. Go does what it does very well.

I think Rust is actually a great choice for something like Tor, but I wouldn't use Rust for some of the things I'd use Go for.

kem··on A researcher's response to people pointing out 150 errors in four of his papers
Speaking from my own areas of experience, I've been struck by how much some celebrated methods and results in machine learning, broadly speaking, basically amount to tinkering without any hard generalizable proofs. In at least one case I'm aware of, there was a statistical proof later that made it clear the original researchers were close, but if they had a different dataset they would have come up with a different result. In fact, as I write this, I think I recall that different researchers did come up with different results, and it was in large part due to tinkering on different datasets.

So yes, even in computer science you run into similar things. Maybe not the same, but similar processes leading to similar problems.

kem··on A researcher's response to people pointing out 150 errors in four of his papers
I've had this same conversation with colleagues. I think there's a mixture of things going on.

There's a lot more of this going on in a lot of fields, especially the biomedical and social sciences, but probably everywhere.

I think conservatives are correct to pick up on this general phenomenon. They know there's a lot of systemic problems with research and academics, and approach things from that perspective.

The problem, to me, is that they then overstep and use that to justify an equally pernicious position, which is to denounce or dismiss science in general, rather than to encourage fixes or constructive change. Of course, depending on the conservative, they're more likely denounce scientific research on certain topics and areas of research than others.

It's throwing baby out with bathwater, basically.

The scientific community then reacts poorly, in my opinion, by denying the kernel of truth there is to their concerns, and not addressing them.

You can see this playing out in some conservative blogs. They're aware of the replication crisis, discuss it, and point to things like the email leaks by climate scientists, which in my memory were scientifically sort of moot, but did reveal how much scientists are very much human with human flaws and motivations.

Maybe I'm wrong, though, and the typical response from the scientific community is best, though: maybe it's better to treat the problems with science separate from the conservative attacks, to tackle one problem at a time.

I guess I see two problems, one being problems with academics and science, the other being the involvement of politicians in science. I think the second thing only makes the first problem worse. It's not like the politicians aren't serving their own unholy masters.

kem··on C++ 17 is Done
I have nothing against C++, Rust, or Go--I like all of them for different reasons and see them serving different goals, and see room for all sorts of languages. I also agree that there's a discrepancy between how Rust is discussed and how it is used, and don't see C++ going anywhere for a long time.

However, I think that post from Reddit was a bit misleading in its own way. Go has been much more mature from the beginning, given its authors and origins, and in some ways had an easier target, in being a slower but simpler, safer version of C, or a faster version of Python (as far as new users of the language are concerned). It's also in many ways sort of a modern version of C, so very familiar to potential users. Finally, it had its 1.0 release in 2012.

Rust, in contrast, had less of a head start. It is newer in a lot of ways in terms of its characteristics and features, and had a more difficult target, at the lower level and with the performance characteristics of C++. Finally, its 1.0 release wasn't until [less than] 2 years ago, in 2015. Go has been post-1.0 for over twice as long as Rust, which is a significant length of time in IT.

kem··on Research suggests elite scientists impede progress in their field until they die [pdf]
I think it's less about universities and more about grant agencies and publications.

The last sentence of the abstract points to the broader problems in academics, of which this is a part:

"Intellectual, social, and re- source barriers all impede entry, with outsiders only entering subfields that offer a less hostile landscape for the support and acceptance of “foreign” ideas."

The issue is access. It's not enough to do research, or even write the paper, you have to publish it or get the grant, and that means the approval of peers. That often increases the quality of the publication or grant, because it has to run the gauntlet of criticism, but it also means that if peers don't understand something or aren't open to it, it dies before it sees the light of day. It's sort of like "if a tree falls in a forest, does it make a sound"? If research is conducted, but isn't allowed to appear in a peer-reviewed journal, did it happen?

What's really necessary in academics is something closer to what happens in comp sci, where people post to blogs regularly, and peer review is left for the hard work of proofs and whatnot, to force detailed scrutiny. Grants also need to be restructured dramatically, so that indirect cost requests are eliminated or minimized, and that grants are given by lottery or something for grants above a certain score, and that grant review panels are more randomized, to reduce nepotism within grant-panel agencies.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →