HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kevinnk

799 karma · joined March 25, 2012

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kkiningh; my proof: https://keybase.io/kkiningh/sigs/i245-gK_dv4Qc5VWTlErrKFhl9_TEsxfD3WbLDeD4As ]
submissionscomments
kevinnk··on The US has forgotten how to do infrastructure
Almost all of those things are already implemented in the US.

> cap individual donations

Direct contribution cap for individuals is $2,700

> forbid companies from donating

Direct contributions are not allowed, although PACs can give up to $5000.

> create a government entity whose goal is to ensure donations are respecting those rules

Aka the FEC

> candidates having to deliver their list of donors to said entity

Already required for federal elections, also candidates must detail how they spent the money as well.

> Make it actually illegal to get private money from PACs and other complex setups.

PACs aren't complicated and for the most part are a positive step towards fair elections (that's why they were created in the first place).

> And eventually reimburse part of the campaign past a certain percentage of votes.

Federal elections already have public funding and the system in place is much better than reimbursement after the election.

kevinnk··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
To reiterate: Most people's thinking on the minimum wage hasn't progressed past "if poor people got paid more they'd be better off, therefore raise the minimum wage." Many people's thinking on walfare haven't evolved past "I don't want to give money to lazy poor people". Sure, someone who's taken Econ101 may not have the ultimately nuanced opinion, but at least their understanding is going to be far closer to reality than someone who hasn't. The ideas in 101 are simplified, but the truth is that they're almost certainly better than whatever was in the person's head before, even if they aren't a complete description.

That being said, if you haven't read Mankiw you really should. He goes into far more detail than you seem to think, on many of the exact subjects you listed. Maybe econ101 has progressed since you last took it.

> Economics is the one field of study in America today where someone who reads three blog posts thinks they're an expert

Ha. It's funny how many fields think this way. A friend of mine who's an MD in sports medicine says the same thing ("People read one exercise book and think they know everything!"). Another friend of mine says the same thing about law. Another says the same about foreign policy. Etc, etc, etc.

If your goal is to get people to people to stop pretending like they know econ after reading one pop-economics​ book, well I don't know what to tell you except that in all likelihood human nature isn't going to change; people have been overconfident about things they don't know "dick" about since the beginning of human history and probably will continue to do so regardless of whether they read your books or not.

By the way, if you really believe that exposure to "complex market failure after complex market failure" is really the answer, there's plenty of places on the internet that do just that. Go to /r/latestagecapitalism or /r/socialism and observe all the nuance and humility that results. In reality, people just as readily end up overconfident in the opposite direction.

kevinnk··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
Prices are high because demand is high and supply is low. Yes, that gets covered.
kevinnk··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
Any libertarian who takes Econ 101 will find their beliefs challenged tremendously, and not just by the "simple models" you're talking about. To be perfectly blunt, it sounds like you're trying to criticize something that you have an preconceived notion of, but no direct experience with, which is exactly why I was recommending you read Mankiw in the first place. I think you'll be surprised with the amount of time he spends on things like case studies of market failures or why the federal reserve system is a good idea.

As to your link, Noah (whom I respect tremendously) does make a good point, but I think he overstates his case; true, simple supply-demand models don't work in every case (and the minimum wage is a good example of that, although I would counter that most of the non econ101 parts are somewhat short term and restricted to small increases) but for the vast, vast majority of cases people encounter in real life they work surprisingly well. Additionally, supply and demand is only a part of econ 101: Why can't I get tickets to Hamilton without paying a lot? Why do some restaurants charge more for dinner? If we put a tariff on Mexico, who pays? What are the pros and cons of free trade? What does deadweight loss mean? What does the federal reserve do and how does it affect me? What's the relationship between the money supply and inflation? What are the arguments for targeting non zero inflation? Why did we leave the gold standard? Is government debt bad? How is GDP measured? Why does the exchange rate change? Why doesn't the employment rate go to zero? What does the employment rate even mean? How do taxes affect the economy? Do different taxes have different effects? What are the arguments for and against using tax policy to encourage saving? What options does the government have to fight a recession? My city wants to reduce driving downtown, what are some possible policies? What economic policies can we use to fight global warming? What are the arguments for and against rent control? What is a monopoly? All of these questions are easily answered with macroecon 101 level knowledge and most are hard to answer without (we haven't even started talking about micro!) That doesn't mean econ 101 is always applicable, but it does mean you'll have a far better understanding of the world after taking it, even if you do come in with some preconceived notions.

I will say that Noah's suggestion that econ 101 should be more emperical is a good idea, and I especially believe that there should be a stronger emphasis on stats. I actually think that's true of all the social sciences though, and its a separate issue from what you're talking about.

kevinnk··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
I don't really care if people understand "real econ" (whatever that means) but most people haven't even progressed past a folk understanding of economics. Having at least a cursory understanding of why, e.g., price controls lead to scarcity is really a requirement to create an informed criticism of any part of Econ 101. To get to that point, reading through an intro level textbook is exactly what is needed.
kevinnk··on When the Patient Is a Gold Mine: The Trouble with Rare-Disease Drugs
I've recommended to plenty of people that they read "Principles of Macroeconomics" by Greg Mankiw, but weirdly enough no one has. Maybe I just didn't urge urge urge them enough?

Actually, if you believe economics hasn't changed since the 18th century you really should read it. Who knows, maybe you'll even reevaluate your understanding of economics.

kevinnk··on The Class of 2017 – Raising America's Pay
There's a reasonably large body of evidence that a (small) increase in the minimum wage to e.g. 40% of median local income doesn't have many negative employment effects (or if it does, they are very small). That being said, minimum wage is not a particularly good way to decrease inequality since it's not very well targeted and the negative effects it does have (higher prices, less employer training, etc) seem to mostly hurt the poor. A much better policy would be increasing the EITC.
kevinnk··on We’re Getting Close to Full Employment
Labor force participation doesn't take into account demographic changes so it's almost categorically worse than U3. Look at U6 for something that takes into account discouraged and part time workers.
kevinnk··on States are moving to cut college costs by introducing open-source textbooks
Average annual state University tuition for residents is more like 10k. Cutting 10-15% of that doesn't seem marginal to me.
kevinnk··on Quantifying the performance of the TPU, our first machine learning chip
Training is inference, except over model space instead of possible outputs. Depending on what models you're looking at, the two can have very different computational properties, so treating them separately is not surprising even if what they're doing is conceptually similar.
kevinnk··on Gravity: a new programming language and VM written in C

    λ> map acos [2] == map acos [2]
    False :: Bool
Interesting.
kevinnk··on Apple’s Devices Lose Luster in American Classrooms
It has a built in terminal called crosh, which might have an SSH client built in (I'm not sure). What most people do is download a chrome extension like Secure Shell[1] that lets you ssh from a tab.

[1] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/secure-shell/pnhec...

kevinnk··on DeepCoder: Learning to Write Programs
Circuit designers didn't lose their jobs to EDA tools any more than software developers lost their jobs to compilers.
kevinnk··on Announcing the first SHA-1 collision
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-way_compression_function

Cryptographic compression is not related to data compression.

kevinnk··on Reflecting on one very, very strange year at Uber
That's incredibly sexist.
kevinnk··on Bill Gates Wants to Tax Robots
Teachers still pay income tax. It may be true that the amount of money the government pays out increased, but the amount of income tax didn't go down.

Regardless, I took his argument to be about a more general shift to service work rather than about teachers specificlly.

kevinnk··on Bill Gates Wants to Tax Robots
Bill Gates is a super smart guy, so I'll assume there's an argument I've missed, but how does this make any sense? If automating factory jobs "frees up labor" (as he says) to become teachers and healthcare workers, wouldn't the income tax from the new teachers and healthcare workers just replace the lost tax from the factory workers?
kevinnk··on Raising the American Weakling
Without a deadlift suit[1]. Some people also use "raw" to mean without straps as well[2].

[1] https://gometal.com/product/pro-king-deadlift-suit/

[2] https://www.paulcheksblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Wri...

kevinnk··on Tesla factory worker calls for a union: “We need to stand up for ourselves”
... do you have any firsthand experience working those jobs? I happen to know a number of pilots for major airlines and it's probably one of the nicest middle-upper class jobs you can get (assuming you can handle the responsibility).

> leaning on pilots to fly with the absolute minimum fuel they can get by with, despite regulations

You mean, asking pilots to use the minimum amount of fuel that is safe. Do you have any evidence that a major airline has ever pressured pilots to use less fuel than the (generous) regulated minimum?

kevinnk··on Tesla factory worker calls for a union: “We need to stand up for ourselves”
Few people who would describe working as a teacher, an airline pilot, or a professional athlete as a "living nightmare".
kevinnk··on Ask HN: What is the most exciting development in your field right now?
I'd also like to hear more about what tools you're using/looking forward to.
kevinnk··on Welcome, ACLU
Women are more likely to support abortion restrictions than men.

http://www.pewforum.org/2017/01/11/public-opinion-on-abortio...

kevinnk··on C++11 FAQ
How does adding an operator help? There are two main advantage of having move semantics in the language and at least one of them relies on the fact that moves are implicit; you can write code that will move objects if supported and copy/destroy if not (for example, when returning an object or using an intermediate value in an expression). Adding an operator erases that advantage.

The other advantage is that you can force only move semantics which allows enforcing things like ownership. Adding an operator doesn't destroy this advantage, but it is a bit silly since you're just adding line noise for something that really should be implicit anyway.

Unless you just literally don't like the spelling of "std::move" which seems pretty lame since it should be relatively rare anyway.

kevinnk··on China has built the world’s largest bullet-train network
But the estimates the footnote is referring to are in the first table. Those are not per year but already summed; there's no corresponding fiscal year to refer to (I think?).

Regardless, this is a tiny point so I'll drop it. I still feel confused though :(

kevinnk··on The Google Brain Team – Looking Back on 2016
> It should be intuitive that analog is more efficient for representing analog abstractions (neural networks, which inherently copy analog structures).

That's not necessary true; again, see the DARPA project you listed.

> Digital hardware adds an additional abstraction layer built out of components that do not behave like the desired structures (neurons) and are basically running simulations.

The analog hardware doesn't necessarily behave like the desired components either (for example, due to manufacturing errors). With digital you get to choose your accuracy and with much greater control.

> Digital is more efficient for some problems in the sense that it's the only way to achieve precise computational results, but even when it comes to mathematical arithmetic, the circuitry to add two analog signals is much faster and simpler (two wires and a resistor), as is the design of a multiplier (one transistor).

Unless you don't care about noise at all, your design will be much more complicated than a single transistor. Either way, it's actually much easier to do this sort of "approximate computing" in the digital domain.

> It's definitely a complex subject, but I don't see why you would find it so difficult to believe -- the most intelligent machines we know of are analog and decentralized (like human brains).

A bird has feathers yet our most efficient airplanes don't use them; there's no reason at all to believe that just because the brain is analog, our design should be as well.

kevinnk··on China has built the world’s largest bullet-train network
I'm pretty sure you're correct and those numbers are total since 1950. However, the study does seem confusingly worded - in the footnote on page 1 it says:

"All estimates quoted are in constant 2010 dollars, unless otherwise noted, and refer to actual expenditures in the relevant fiscal year, rounded to the nearest billion"

At least to me that reads like "all estimates refer to expenditures from the relevant fiscal year only". However, they later quote the same numbers as being "total spending since 1950". Am I just missing an obvious interpretation for the footnote?

kevinnk··on The Google Brain Team – Looking Back on 2016
The way I read your second post was that analog computing is more efficient in general; it sounds like you don't actually believe that. Fair enough.

However, I still take issue with your overall point.

> Efficient, large scale neural nets will require fundamentally different hardware, like the programmable mixed signal Samsung boards used by Synapse.

I think it's at least plausible that we'll see gains from fundamentally different architectures (namely combining memory and computation) but where's the evidence that we need to switch from digital to analog? Where's the evidence that analog is even better for an architecture like that? Again, the DARPA project you linked actually gave evidence of the opposite.

> The next generation boards are likely to contain memristors and self organizing memory, with a structure somewhere between the organization level of FPGA LUT blocks and biological nervous systems.

You keep talking as if there's some obvious reason that analog is more efficient/faster/better for the types of architectures you're talking about. I'm not seeing that reason.

kevinnk··on The Google Brain Team – Looking Back on 2016
The main problem with analog computation is lack of reliability (analog is not always deterministic and manufacturing defects are more difficult to eliminate) and density (analog components are usually much larger, in part to increase reliability). That's a huge blocker for faster chips. How do you think we will get around those problems?

Also, perhaps I'm misreading their paper[1], but that DARPA project is still using digital logic. In fact, they specifically say that they decided against using analog computation due to the increased density of digitial (one of the main problems with analog computing, as I mentioned). Regardless, it's pretty clear that the project doesn't have the goal of replacing general purpose computing, so I'm curious why you consider this evidence that analog computing will replace digital computing?

Finally, in what way are FPGAs much closer to analog computing than microprocessors? The advantages of FPGAs (configurability) are orthogonal to analog vs digital.

[1] http://www.modha.org/papers/013.CICC2.pdf

kevinnk··on The Google Brain Team – Looking Back on 2016
I'm a hardware engineer and I downvoted you because your comment is shallow and uninformative. The "Von Neumann bottleneck" has nothing to do with digital vs analog hardware (rather it's about the separation between storage and computation) and the idea that analog computation is the way forward requires a much longer argument before it's even surface level plausible.
kevinnk··on World Energy Hits a Turning Point: Solar That's Cheaper Than Wind
You can't transport power that far without massive transmission losses. Communications cables use repeaters and fiber optics, so they don't have nearly the same problem.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission#...

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →