[1] https://taxfoundation.org/comparing-returns-tax-favored-reti...
66 karma · joined January 12, 2017
[1] https://taxfoundation.org/comparing-returns-tax-favored-reti...
Where you're right: yes, you need to foster the conversation. It's a skill that one develops with practice.
Where you're wrong: I negotiate for my consulting business and I can guarantee you that the companies don't have "the power." The power is held by whoever is better at negotiating. If you're good at negotiating, you will hold the power.
a) The buyers want to look at multiple properties as quickly as possible; b) The sellers don't want to or don't have the time to be manage all of the requests for viewings. c) If there is no viewing opportunity, then the buyer might miss a good property that matches their needs or the seller might miss a buyer.
The real-estate agents have a pool of properties that they manage and they can provide quick access to the properties. They meet the needs of both the buyer and the seller and increase the probability of a transaction.
Of course, if you can find a way to do that without a real-estate agent, you got a breakthrough innovation. However, it's fairly difficult to crack this problem since the transaction inherently tilts towards human interactions. This is why nobody has figured out an effective way to get rid of the real-estate agents yet.
Why would they buy?! You're saying it as if the market-wide sale of a share of every billionaire's stocks that year would just be absorbed by the market without any negative economic consequences (at best) or without a massive economic crash.
> Another example is McKenzie Scott selling billions in Amazon stock. There's no shortage of buyers for that.
That wouldn't be the case if every "McKenzie Scott" is selling billions worth of stocks simultaneously. There would certainly be a shortage of buyers.
So who is going to buy the existing investor's wealth? Are they just going to buy each other's wealth?
I suspect these two things will happen on the market:
1. You'd need to have a wealthy enough buyer for the assets - it's going to be kinda hard to convince the wealthy to buy back their own assets. 2. In the absence of sufficiently large market makers, the prices of these assets will certainly tank since these assets will have to be liquidated.
So where is the government going to find the buyers of the assets? What are the economic effects?
Well, we can look to Switzerland for that answer. It is one of the only countries that have wealth taxes, but it's on the canton level (the equivalent of the state level). It has no national wealth taxes. The difference in wealth tax rates makes a huge impact on the behavior of citizens and the wealth distribution:
"According to our baseline estimate, a 1 percentage point drop in the top wealth tax rate raises reported wealth by 43%." https://voxeu.org/article/wealth-taxation-swiss-experience
"The evaluations with both datasets lead to similar estimates: an increase in the wealth tax rate by one tenth of a percent, whether this be at the cantonal or municipal level, reduces the amount of declared wealth by around 3%. This implies that the tax elasticity of wealth is at least twice as large as that of personal income.4 In other words, wealth reacts more sensitively to taxes. Our estimates also exceed the wealth tax elasticities of other studies, which is presumably due to the higher quality of the data available to us (panel data) (Seim 2017; Zoutman 2015)." https://www.ifo.de/DocDL/dice-report-2018-2-bruelhart-schmid...
In essence, it second article highlights your point: the behavior isn't changed much in terms of productivity because wealthy people simply hire competent accountants to minimize their wealth tax burden with better accounting structures.
BTW, we do have a wealth tax in the US in terms of private property. Most states have private property taxes which are a form of wealth tax. The effect of that is that each person has to generate an income high enough to afford the tax or else they will get a lien on their assets.
"Extremism" is in the eyes of the beholder. We saw 6 months of violent insurrection by BLM and Antifa, which were organized on Twitter and Facebook. Apple, Google, and Amazon didn't ban either apps. People on the left called them "mostly peaceful protests."
The Jan 6 events were organized, shared, and streamed on Facebook and Twitter. None of the Jan 6th events were organized on Parler, yet Parler gets removed. See the problem?
Enforcing it is free: you can send your own cease and desist for free. The only time you need a lawyer is if they refuse and you want to sue them. If the court rules in your favor, you can even sue them for the legal costs and costs of damages.
MacStadium isn't doing short-term rentals not because it can't but because the EULA doesn't allow it. Anybody doing short-term rentals is doing it on Mac hardware so they can just as easily sell long-term rentals. Aside from MacStadium being a major player in this field, I see absolutely nothing that favors them compared to their competition. In fact, it seems to have created Amazon as a competitor.
And the Hackintosh thing is the reason a Mac hosting companies exist in the first place. If Hackintoshes were allowed, there would be no companies offering Mac hosted hardware. I don't see how that's related to this particular situation tho. Apple created the need for Mac hosted hardware so blaming Mac hardware hosting companies for this is a bit backward.
> Hacks on VMs are a pretty direct competitor I’d think.
The VMs have to run on Mac hardware as well.
> It is Southwestern Bell, which bought the AT&T brand in the bankruptcy fire sale and renamed itself.
Southwestern Bell was the same subsidiary that broke off from AT&T Corporation. AT&T Inc was the merger of the companies that were originally broken up from AT&T Corporation. Here is the org chart: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT%26T#Chart_of_AT&T_Baby_Bell...
AT&T became even bigger after the breakup: https://www.businessinsider.com/att-breakup-1982-directv-bel...
You think that AT&T Corporation going broke and selling to a company that originated from the AT&T Corporation, which later renamed itself to AT&T Inc is a good example of a government-imposed corporate breakup?! It literally divested from those companies only to have most of them merge under the same name again.
The intended purpose is to help the new entrants, but I don't see Microsoft or AT&T losing anything or their smaller competitors gaining anything after the regulatory action against them.
> An example closer to home is that entrepreneurial activity in Silicon Valley is often attributed to California law forbidding non competes in employment contracts. This is regulation, without which, as you see in nearly every other state, workers are severely bound by their employment contracts in the work they can do while and after being employed by a company.
That's a matter of negotiation. I always (successfully) negotiated with my employer to exclude my personal projects from the contract. I find that employees have a lot more negotiating power than they realize.
> If regulations seem to benefit incumbents, it’s because incumbents exist and therefore can play a role in setting regulations.
I think that's synonymous with the original statement made by OP. You're just providing another reason why it's true.
I don't know how any competition would be negatively impacted by Apple implementing these terms, unless the competition was already selling services that were on a short-term basis (below 24 hours).
And to circle back around, this EULA enables MacStadium's hardware hosting competition to enter the market... thus comes Amazon into the playing field. I just don't see how having to compete with Amazon is, all of a sudden, a better deal for MacStadium. If anything, it just highlights the volatile nature of running a business in the Apple ecosystem.
> For the record in no way I think that Apple took this decision to favor you or anyone else except themselves. It just seems that you won a regulatory lottery.
"Congratulations, you're a winner... your prize is to compete with Amazon!" Some would certainly wear it with a badge of honor!
Given how many people actually don't even bother to vote, I doubt voter suppression is the problem. It seems like an issue of implementation and limitation of the current political system. In contrast, "voter" turnout by consumers is 100%. Every product you buy is a vote you cast.
With regards to tracing the origins of a product: you're trying to fix a problem that's even worse with government. If you're so concerned that you aren't able to identify the origins of a product with 100% certainty, then we ought to compare it with the baseline: what is the trust factor with government? At any rate, the traceability of a product can get as accurate as you want it to be... so long as you pay enough money to establish it. If you want, you can be flown to every part of the world and you can personally ensure that every fiber of your clothes is not coming from a sweatshop. Of course, that would be insanely expensive, but it is possible. 99.99999999999% of consumers don't want that much transparency.