HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kgrin

1,443 karma · joined March 23, 2009

kevin at activefrequency.com et al

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kgrinberg; my proof: https://keybase.io/kgrinberg/sigs/WEI_d3HGjUIUBsOtsfBAyLlxPP2GxVWvgMAg5oxxwJE ]

submissionscomments
kgrin··on Boston College 3L Asks for His Money Back; Hilarity Ensues
tl;dr: structural adjustments are hard, transition costs suck.

It's easy to judge the author for feeling "entitled" to a high-paying post-law-school job, and - just to get this out of the way - obviously he isn't (entitled). Yes, he made his own choices, and just like he would have been screwed getting his telegraph-repairman certificate circa 1900, there's always a certain amount of risk one takes choosing a career.

That said, the way many law schools - particularly top-50 schools like BC - market themselves is indeed as pathways to high-paying Big Law jobs, and indeed is the only way they can justify the tuition. His complaint (which I obviously have no way to really evaluate) about BC Career Services being less-than-helpful is very relevant here.

All that said, the underlying problem is more complex than "BC is greedy" or "the author made a boneheaded career choice" - there's a structural shift in the market for lawyers (there were too many, market was oversaturated), and a bunch of people who made choices based on market conditions in 2007 are pretty screwed. Yes, they all bear some responsibility; what now, though - does this guy go back to teaching and have $100K+ in debt while pulling down "normal-person" wages? Law school tuition, to a large extent, reflects expected earnings. You radically change half of that equation, and things start to break (and yes, you can declare personal bankruptcy... except that student loan debt is among the most difficult to dispose of, even via bankruptcy).

Over time, I suspect (though who really knows?) that either salaries or tuitions or both will adjust, if not in nominal than in real (inflation-adjusted) terms. But what about the several "lost generations" of JD's with mountains of debt but no jobs? I don't have an easy answer - "universal JD loan amnesty" doesn't sound like a great idea either, and who would fund such a thing anyway? - but it's a problem worth considering.

This is actually somewhat similar (though of course not identical) to the structural problem confounding many health care reformers. Medicine in the US is really expensive; part (though by no means all) of the problem is that doctors, especially specialists, are paid a lot. A big part of the reason why (though maybe it's more accurate to say it's a correlation - I'm not really sure what the causal direction is) is that after a really long time in school, you graduate with ~$500K of loans, and then (in most cases) live in penury during your residency. You sort of have to be able to cash out at the end of the rainbow, otherwise it's not just unattractive but borderline impossible for anyone who isn't otherwise independently wealthy.

So what do you do? It's straightforward and simple to say, "doctors should just make less, and tuition should be correspondingly lower." But of course we're not in a giant central planning system, and even if we were, it's not like that's a switch you can flip overnight. If you suddenly started paying all doctors less, how would the class of 2010, with that half-mil in loans, make good on those? Everyone (or at least a great many people) realize that there's a structural problem, and the vague outlines of a better equilibrium... but how you get from A to B is a lot less clear.

(Disclaimers: there's all sorts of other reasons why medicine isn't really a proper perfect market, etc. It's not a perfect analogy, etc.)

Fun exercise for the reader: why are new minted MBAs not in the same boat? Anecdotally, many are, but not as many as new lawyers.

kgrin··on Ask HN: HIPAA Hosting?
Yep - we're aware of all that, and we can handle the various app-level changes... we just don't want to be in the "ongoing server maintenance" business.
kgrin··on Ask HN: HIPAA Hosting?
Happy to use Rackspace or another dedicated server provider... the trick is that we don't want to be responsible for, say, security patches to the kernel.

So really the question is: is there a company that'll manage the damn server(s) for us so that we get to deal with a nice, clean abstraction similar to shared hosting?

Basically I want a HIPAA-compliant Heroku (though in this case not for Ruby).

kgrin··on Why I'm not hiring
To elaborate a bit - it just really struck me as bizarre that he's basically giving his insurer a pass for raising his prices, because it's "business", and business can do no wrong - as a fellow businessman, he understands the plight of the insurance company. But all the money that's collected in taxes, in his mind, goes into the black hole of Washington & Trenton - including not just the somewhat-opaque things like income tax (which indirectly funds his and Sally's roads, schools, police force and wars abroad) but things like disability & unemployment insurance, which it seems like Sally might need if he has a bad day.
kgrin··on Why I'm not hiring
Fair enough; perhaps we should make the system a bit more progressive. Perhaps if FICA weren't capped at ~$100K, we could reduce Sally's share of the burden? Or if we eliminated any number of corporate-tax loopholes, or agribusiness subsidies, or defense spending, we could reduce personal income tax rates?
kgrin··on Why I'm not hiring
It's interesting how his private insurer raising rates is obviously "ObamaCare"'s fault. Like all businesses, insurers raise prices because they can, thanks to market position, scarcity and all the other usual factors (distorted, as the health insurance market is, by oligopoly-entrenching state regulations that have little to do with the Affordable Care Act).
kgrin··on Please review my startup - Flowshark
Random feature idea: export to blank properly named templates for Balsamiq, Mockingbird, etc.

It seems like once you have a good idea of the interaction flow in Flowshark, the next step is to actually wireframe the individual pages - having something save me the 6 minutes it would take to essentially outline the pages in (e.g.) Balsamiq would be nice (though it's obviously a pretty random request).

kgrin··on How LearnBoost listened to teachers, built new Web-based gradebook
Curious whether these guys will have Blackboard waving its (many bogus) patents at them...
kgrin··on Thoughts about Rails from a Django guy
Just like Rails has some drop-in "fixes" (i.e. the admin) that don't come with the core, Django does as well.

Dependency management: pip requirements files. Migrations (which the author doesn't like, but are pretty useful on a non-trivial project): South Various other goodies: django-extensions

There are constant debates over whether XYZ should be in the core (see: South), or at least better discoverable, but if you're going to use a framework seriously it's worth it to evaluate as "framework + its stable and commonly accepted extras".

kgrin··on New York governor approves short-term apartment rental ban in NYC
"All the neighbors have to do is sue you in court..."

Even for small claims court, it's a pretty big burden to file suit. This regulation may not be the best answer, but let's not pretend that short-term rentals don't engender problems for the neighbors, or that all those problems can be ameliorated with more lawsuits.

kgrin··on Jumping Ship from iPhone to Android: A Switcher's Guide
FWIW, a few of the items seem to be specific to Sense UI; the unlock swipe, for instance, is L > R on my Nexus One, not top-down.
kgrin··on [dead]
I was mostly responding to the comment, which was about the income tax rates.

That said, while some of the HCR provisions resulted in new limits and exemptions on tax-free HSA/FSA accounts and the like, there really isn't a new "health care" tax.

Some of the other items on the list, like the AMT thing, has little to do with the current administration - it's a perennial issue that Congress "fixes" every year. (Which isn't to say that it's not a problem that they should just address one way or another, but it's silly to blame the AMT on anything new from Obama - it happens every single freaking year).

A few of the other items are downright laughable - they're expirations of temporary tax cuts or programs that were part of the stimulus (the stimulus that, FWIW, most conservatives opposed).

kgrin··on [dead]
Yes, taxes will rise to the draconian and economy-stifling levels we suffered under in the 1990s.
kgrin··on Supreme Court Strikes Down Part of Sarbanes-Oxley
That's because it's not really meant to be "English"; think of it as a DSL for the law.
kgrin··on Supreme Court Strikes Down Part of Sarbanes-Oxley
It's not a company's board of directors - it's the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, a regulatory body established by Sarbanes-Oxley "to oversee the auditors of public companies in order to protect the interests of investors..."

In short, it's a pretty inconsequential ruling relative to the meat of the law.

kgrin··on Bilski v. Kappos
Summary: the court ruled narrowly on the patent in question (over-broad), while punting on the actual issue of "business methods" patents. Result (for everyone but the actual litigants in this case): no change from the status quo.
kgrin··on Rethinking the Whiteboard
This isn't deeply relevant to the profiled product, but I found the following characterization of YC rather odd:

"Y Combinator is the early stage investment fund that uses a biannual, weekend-long pitch and demonstration competition to find investment-worthy companies."

Isn't it more or less the other way around? (Demo Day is a "result", not the source, of YC companies)

kgrin··on Titans Of Industry Don't Really Like Free Markets
At one point in the article he makes the correction that it's technically a "duopoly" - but certainly not a free market.
kgrin··on Titans Of Industry Don't Really Like Free Markets
"Finance" is a pretty broad word; the payment card market (at least until recently) has been pretty free of regulation, certainly of regulation that would prevent the sort of abuses highlighted in the article.

One interesting point is that the form of regulation that currently exists - the various laws and rules that led to the billion-dollar settlements - still don't have enough teeth (sort of like the "cost-of-doing-business" fines that gross polluters pay that are barely a day's worth of profits).

kgrin··on Living with a long sales cycle
The Ned Lamont featured in the article is the same Ned Lamont that ran for Senate in Connecticut in 2006 (beating Joe Lieberman in the Democratic primary).

Do note that the article is from 1996 - perhaps a "[1996]" in the title would be appropriate?

kgrin··on Cheater Cheater
I wonder - is there an English class out there that focuses on "rewriting, rephrasing, riffing, and appropriation as real tools of the writer’s trade"?
kgrin··on IPad 3G owners account information compromised
I'm pretty sure that exclusivity ends soon; it's a question of renewing it or not.
kgrin··on [dead]
There's really nothing magical about 10 years vs. 4 - the further out you go, the more you have to discount the predictive value. Is there some evidence that, in general, there's market skepticism about MS' long-term future? Sure. But this "4-year" business is just absurd.
kgrin··on [dead]
As the author points out, by the same logic Apple and Google have approximately 10 years left, which seems about as dubious as... well, Microsoft having 4 years left.
kgrin··on Airlines Work to Catch Up to the Digital Age
For all the crappiness, you do have to appreciate the difficulty and complexity of swapping out these systems more or less on the fly.
kgrin··on Why Taxing Carried Interest As Ordinary Income Is Good Policy
Main point: while there's a good argument to be made for incentivizing people to invest their capital, there's no good reason why one kind of money manager (or, really, professional of any sort) should be taxed less than another. Just because you work with money shouldn't entitle you to lower taxes, unless you're actually investing your own.
kgrin··on House Backs Tax Increase for Venture Capital
As others have pointed out, this has little to do with the capital itself, but with the compensation that VCs get essentially as money managers. So the impact on actual investment is likely to be close to zero, even if there are reduced incentives to being a VC. Look at it this way - if a plague struck and killed one of every 10 VCs, chances are that the amount of capital wouldn't radically change - it would just mostly get reallocated among the survivors (I'm sure it would change in some marginal case, it might depend a bit on who the affected VCs were, etc.)
kgrin··on Django 1.2 final out on Monday
Specifically with Webfaction, that's exactly what's going on; it has to do with the particulars of their typical Django setup on the shared hosting. (I've had the same "Bad Gateway" errors from PHP sites at Webfaction... it's very much a server setup issue, not anything to do with the code it's running.
kgrin··on Facebook outs hacker with 1 million+ accounts
Of course the real trick is for Facebook to automagically know the answer to your secret question rather than having you pre-populate it like you do for banks. That wouldn't be creepy at all!
kgrin··on Google Voice invites for students
When the heck are telcos going to support number portability to services like Google Voice?
← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →