1,443 karma · joined March 23, 2009
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kgrinberg; my proof: https://keybase.io/kgrinberg/sigs/WEI_d3HGjUIUBsOtsfBAyLlxPP2GxVWvgMAg5oxxwJE ]
On what basis do you make that claim? And doesn't the same hold true for men? (Maybe along a different axis, e.g. physical attractiveness - see "trophy wife")
Or, to put it another way, if I were the CIO of [generic agency] looking to move up in the federal government, getting more data out there is a good way to position myself for a higher-up CIO-type role.
It's a somewhat crass way to look at it, and that's certainly not how I'd make a public case to the agencies, but if we're talking about how CIOs are disincentivized from releasing data because it might make them look bad, we ought to also consider that they're incentivized to release some data because doing so makes them look good.
Certainly, there's often a great deal of value in breaking down these disciplinary barriers and attacking the problem holistically - which is why many institutions have interdisciplinary programs and the like. But there's also a value in fields of study retaining some identity as disciplines, with particular methodologies, mores and so forth.
So, can some of the extra staff be trimmed without affecting the academic experience? Absolutely. But in many cases it would affect the social experience (if you cut res life/student activities people), the ability of some students to attend (if you cut financial aid people), and so forth. Some of these things scale pretty linearly with enrollment; some don't. Still others scale linearly, but over 20 years colleges have just been doing more (e.g. college was cheaper, so you needed less of an infrastructure to help students deal with loans).
The phrase "academic experience" is a bit of a misnomer, too - certainly having a good IT help desk can contribute to the academic experience (let's consider the non-HN population that can't build their own routers), but those people aren't counted as "academic staff".
All that said, there are obviously useless positions, and like all large organizations, colleges are susceptible to waste, mis- and over-management. Pointing out the unsustainability of the current rate of growth is fair game; but I'd be wary of a rush to purge non-academic staff as extraneous.
Obviously personal income tax isn't the only one in town, but it's not significantly worse in MA than elsewhere.
This is one of the more startup-friendly features of living in MA as opposed to the Valley.
If you buy Jason's point, this pretty much had to be handled in a loud, public way. On some level, of course, there's no undoing what's done. Certainly a good number of 37s customers who got a bad impression from having their complaints "ignored" by 37s aren't going to notice this blog-spat, and their negative impressions will remain. That's life. But by bringing this to light publicly, and making an issue out of it, at least some of those people will have their impressions corrected, which is only fair.
All that said, could the phrasing have been a little more nuanced and less accusatory? Of course. Was Jason right to assume evil rather than genuine ignorance or lack of perspective? Probably not. (Though it might be reasonable to ask at what point ignorance, when it's so overwhelmingly in your favor, becomes negligence).
But the notion of "37s should have just talked to GS privately, which would have resulted in the same fixes" misses a good part of Jason's argument, which is that a public "offense" (for lack of a better word) ought to be addressed publicly.