kingandqueenov

No culture at all, I see. That's too bad.

Same as a man: a miserable little pile of secrets.

I see what you did there. It's no fair trolling the regular folk on HN. They are easy pickins. It's unladylike.

Historicity makes you wrong, too. Trans people have been culturally recognized for as long as there has been civilization. You didn't pull your crackpot opinion out of thin air, it was spoon fed to you.

Your words: "...before being transgender was invented". Your language suggests that being trans was invented in the 60s. This is false as hell. You are incorrect and you are showing off what motivated your reasoning. It makes the rest of your ideas suspect at best.

Even if you were correct in your premise, you'd still be wrong about the political bias LLMs display. I've already gone on to refute you further downthread. Give a well trained model an actual political conundrum and it will tell you that it's a conundrum and outline why.

I asked Claude "Should the healthy fund the sick and disabled". It responded with a very evenly balanced take. It outlined both sides in-depth and noted where the line gets fuzzy. It enumerated arguments for each position. That's a question with a real moral quandary, unlike what you originally proposed.

It made sure to robustly illustrate both sides of the argument and refused to take a position either way even when there is an obvious leftist answer.

My dood, we were here before the first stone of Athens was laid. Being trans was never "invented". Nice try derailing the conversation, though.

What is a man?

By the same token, God gives us dysphoria as a way of encouraging us to use those gifts as He intends. God made us trans people to be trans. The entire process of transition is a creative one. As much as anything else, gender dysphoria is an invitation to shape your humanity, to take some small part in the creation of your self. It is "in His image" to shape humanity, especially one's own.