HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kinjba11

273 karma · joined October 27, 2018

submissionscomments
kinjba11··on How many robots does it take to run a grocery store? [video]
Caves of Steel was published in 1953. Back in those times, population dynamics weren't as widely known. The world had just passed 2.5 billion and naive rates would put it at 9 billion over a hundred years later.

It seems like old science fiction authors regularly set the time of their worlds much closer to now than reasonable for some reason. To be more relatable perhaps? Blade Runner was set in 2019 for example: fully synthetic humans, flying cars, wars in space. None of that happened. Then there's 1984 by Orwell, and I'm sure dozens of other examples if you looked. Still waiting for that hoverboard (Back to the Future 2 was set in 2015).

kinjba11··on Apple expanding outside of SV as it struggles to recruit and retain talent
"Ethical enforcers" is putting it a bit strongly. There is such a thing as soft power, and some ideas take years or decades to percolate through a culture. Like you said

> things that were condemned 20 years ago are being celebrated now, and we seem to be in a state of constant change and instability

I wouldn't have it any other way. You can't change people's minds with force, only time and pressure. Antislavery sentiment was strong and growing in the 1800s - if you lived in that time, could you imagine someone saying "I feel foolish taking stances on what is and isn't abhorrent"? Slavery is abhorrent - period. Despite that, actual civil rights ideas took decades to take hold even after the extremely violent Civil War. The same applies to many ideas today. This doesn't mean ethics aren't worth fighting for, that you should sit back and passively watch as society decides for you that slavery-by-different-name or some other horrible idea is OK. You can't strong-arm people into believing something. You're right it leads to "division and hatred". However, mirrored ethical standards on the other hand are required for civilization to work. In fact, many of these ethical standards are encoded into laws which are in turn enforced with the state's monopoly on violence (e.g. police, military, swat).

For Blizzard and some companies are perhaps ran by sociopaths. In which case, all they learned is that they need better PR. But I'm sure some companies (aka the people leading those companies) did listen.

Do you really think everyone in the top ranks of a corporation is a sociopath? That's a bit cynical for my taste.

kinjba11··on Apple expanding outside of SV as it struggles to recruit and retain talent
There is something about corporations that everyone forgets from time to time: corporations are not faceless entities, they are made of people. There is a CEO, a board, a handful of executives running the company. These people set the culture and direction of the company.

Some PR is a trick, absolutely. You don't have to watch Mad Men to understand that. But not all CEOs are profit-motivated robots. Tim Cook probably actually believes in promoting privacy. Satya Nadella's son has cerebral palsy. In some way, that impacts how Microsoft is ran. Leaders are humans that can be persuaded. Morality has a place, not everything is fake or second fiddle to profit.

PR doesn't exist in a vacuum. Like you said, "the young people" believe it. Those young people include leaders and future leaders and CEOs. Sometimes the PR becomes the truth. Such as when Google employees strongly protested Google's Pentagon/military contracts - and Google dropped them.

kinjba11··on Apple expanding outside of SV as it struggles to recruit and retain talent
You are right - typically government is responsible for stopping bad behavior. However, in the US especially, there is a widespread feeling that at the highest levels of government where these problems are addressed, the leadership is (take your pick) incompetent, ineffective, captured by lobbying, obstructed, too slow, or otherwise prevented one way or another from doing the right thing. The standard role bearer is broken. That's reason #1.

Corps are often very powerful and influential as well. Why shouldn't they take on a role larger than making money? If I became a corporation, do I get a free pass to be unethical, and commit atrocities as long as it's lawful? No. I would be shunned by society. Corporations seem to have long had a free pass. We should hold all entities to equal ethical standards and expectations, and respond in every way possible both as individuals and governments when those standards are violated. The laws around selling tobacco would never have happened without individual action first. Corporations need ethics too. I rather like it when our corporations follow our morals, I get tired of being cynical. That's reason #2.

Apple and other companies are global entities. Mini-states in their own right in a way. Trillion-dollar companies have enormous, global power. It may be lawful to follow a law in country X when in country Y that same law would be illegal or widely condemned. How is a government supposed to respond to global entities? Say those same tobacco companies sell to minors in another country where it is legal. There's not exactly an established legal precedent as far as I know. Is it still evil to sell to minors? Yes. Legal imbalance exists for global entities, so governments hands are often tied. That's reason #3.

So, nobody is around to motivate Apple and other corps to do the right thing. There should be consequences to abetting abhorrent laws and censorship. Everyone cheered when Apple stood up to the FBI and refused to assist hacking a suspect's phone. Everyone booed when Blizzard and other companies buckled and went along with the CCP censorship. Corps need to be punished for bad behavior (or knowingly working with or for criminals) somehow, and (here's the cynical view) they will only pay attention if it hurts their bottom line.

kinjba11··on Apple expanding outside of SV as it struggles to recruit and retain talent
I'm in my 30s and baffled by folks in their 30s who don't understand basic ethics and market forces. Businesses respond to bad PR all the time. The CCP is committing human rights violations all the time. Add the two together. It is like someone in the 1830s United States asking why slavery is bad, or someone in 1930s Germany asking why Nazis are bad - after all, slavery and the Third Reich make great businesses with superb ROI!
kinjba11··on Where are we going from here? Software engineering needs formal methods
What do you mean by 'bridges change all the time too'? Some of the oldest bridges in the world were built nearly 2000 years ago. That's zero change besides basic upkeep.

What is the oldest unchanging software project you can think of? Typical software projects have a constant accrual of features. Some of the older projects like the Linux kernel are more like a mansion that keeps getting more rooms while others are demolished. Not exactly something that happens to a bridge.

kinjba11··on What happened in Wuhan? (A timeline of events)
Given the nature of Chinese media - that is, one of aggressive censorship and zero investigative journalism - it will always be as the article says. That is, for the lab leak or natural origin theory:

> There is no definitive evidence either way.

I do hope labs around the world, and especially in China, will massively increase the precautions they take regardless. We need the science, but the higher the risk the higher the precautions need to be.

kinjba11··on Kolyma highway in Yakutia, also known as the Road of Bones, is on fire
Do you have a source for this? I'm not clear how a fire would cover up a logging operation (signs of logging machinery don't just disappear). Unless there were massive corruption - which I wouldn't be surprised, but would still be saddened if this turned out to be true.
kinjba11··on Kolyma highway in Yakutia, also known as the Road of Bones, is on fire
> roughly the size of the state of Oregon

That's huge! Right? How big are the biggest fires? Is there someone keeping track of all these extreme events, like we track hurricanes and storms?

Oregon is 98,466 mi². In comparison, the wildfires in Oregon last year that covered half the state in smoke for weeks were about 2,000 mi².

kinjba11··on “Normies just don't care about privacy”
I think privacy is one area where legislation should come into play. Depending on consumers to make educated decisions in the face of massive network effects and legions of highly paid engineers working to increase engagement for profit isn't going anywhere. And depending on corps to police themselves is asking for trouble.
kinjba11··on Blazing fire on surface of Gulf of Mexico
Looks like it's been extinguished. I wonder how often stuff like this has happens with no consequences or media attention.

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/fire-offshore-pemex-...

kinjba11··on Servo Engine contributions this year
> Safari is pretty good at standards (they do support BigInt and fetch)

That is why I say "Safari gets them years later". For example:

Chrome 42, released April 2015, supported fetch. Safari 10, released March 2017, supported fetch. Nearly two years after Chrome and Firefox.

* https://webkit.org/blog/7477/new-web-features-in-safari-10-1... * https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Fetch_API#b...

kinjba11··on REPL vs CLI: IDE wars
Does GraalVM work with Clojure? I would assume that would solve the startup time issue for a project like a CLI tool.
kinjba11··on Alzheimer’s enigma: Why is incidence falling 16% a decade in richest countries?
The 'amyloid hypothesis' as the protein being the cause of Alzheimer's has been the most popular for a few decades, so it's not surprising you've read so much about it. But there hasn't been much success in drugs targeting the protein. New evidence suggests that there could be an underlying cause.

I'm a fan of the theory that bacteria/viruses are a cause and that the proteins we see are an overkill immune response to that (wouldn't be the first time - influenza/covid kill some not directly but via the immune system over-doing it).

See https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05719-4 for more details.

kinjba11··on Swift 5.5 Brings Async/Await and Actor Support
Does this update potentially make Swift on the server side more viable?

I'm also wondering if Swift introducing async/await so late will end up like C# in having to support both an async and sync version of legacy APIs, creating an awkward mashing of async and sync code in some code bases.

kinjba11··on Science YouTuber Wins $10k Bet with Physicist
Original video triggering the bet for context: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyQwgBAaBag

Video discussing the bet and going over criticism: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCsgoLc_fzI

Veritasium is a great YouTube channel.

kinjba11··on Servo Engine contributions this year
Do you have a problem with BigInt? fetch? Push notifications for PWAs? Dozens of other useful web technologies used by millions of apps? Is that "web-standard-of-the-week-insanity"?

I agree not all standards are great. But they're *standards*. As in, you really should, because everyone else agreed it was a good idea. The time for vetoing it was when it was being decided (and Apple does shoot down tons of proposals), not when everyone else already agreed is was a good idea.

It's not that Safari doesn't get these features - it gets them years later than the competition. The problem with these big companies (Google is bad as well) is that they're too big to fail. If they don't like something, then the standard isn't their standard.

* https://infrequently.org/2021/04/progress-delayed/

kinjba11··on Servo Engine contributions this year
I prefer to see Safari as the new IE:

- On the most popular consumer operating system in the United States by numbers (iOS), it is the default browser, which is..

- furthest behind in supporting web standards. It is easy to theorize that Apple has no incentive to improve Safari given how lucrative..

- the App Store is. Apple is under antitrust scrutiny (see Epic vs. Apple), similar how Microsoft was under antitrust scrutiny due to IE integration into Windows. iOS goes further than Windows did in that iOS forces all browsers to use the same underlying browser engine.

* https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/all/united-states...

* https://caniuse.com/

* https://infrequently.org/2021/04/progress-delayed/

kinjba11··on Canada Records All-Time High Temperature of 49.5 Degrees: Weather Service
The story with livestock is complicated. From that same Wikipedia article.

> The indirect effects contributing to the percentage include emissions associated with the production of feed consumed by livestock and carbon dioxide emission from deforestation in Central and South America, attributed to livestock production

So now deforestation is equivalent to livestock? Should I say shopping malls and residential areas are a problem because they require all the plants on the land to be cut down and paved over? I really wish these '% of everything' statistics would go away. It is almost always more complicated which fosters climate skeptics.

Energy production - aka fossil fuel burning such as coal for electricity and gas/diesel for - is the vast majority of emissions. We should be focusing on getting our democratic voting power focused on one that one easily digested story to get things done on a nation-state level instead of getting bogged down in these micro-issues. "Everything causes climate change" is impossible to fix. "Fossil fuels and especially cars and coal" cause climate change is very possible to address.

See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGG-A80Tl5g and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SdrhpThqlCo for examples of more nuance.

kinjba11··on Virtual DOM is pure overhead (2018)
You are correct. "Vanilla JS" is typically compared to React/Vue as a joke. As in "React.js is 2kb but Vanilla.js is 0kb and super lightweight".

"Vanilla C" doesn't have the same context as far as I'm aware. In the same spirit I could imagine a comparison for C would be along the lines of "you could use SDL (Simple DirectMedia Library) for your indie game dev, but why bother when you could use vanilla C (code Vulkan 3D graphics API directly)".

kinjba11··on I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC
> who knows intuitively this is wrong

I think you're vastly overestimating the average computer user here :) Most will make no meaningful distinction between a local account and an online one. If they could sign into Windows with their Facebook account they probably would.

kinjba11··on I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC
Anecdotal of course, but I've had the opposite experience. When I install Windows, the first thing I do is let Windows Update take care of everything. You could say it's "installed automatically". The only drivers I've needed to install in the past 5 years was Nvidia drivers for graphics cards or the odd printer driver. And downloading these drivers is super easy taking 5 minutes at most - the first search result for "nvidia download drivers" is the correct one.

Maybe I'm just unlucky, but every time I've installed Linux something with the drivers always breaks - video playback is choppy, wireless drops randomly, audio breaks, the fingerprint reader doesn't work. Using WSL2 or a VM is much easier when I want Linux.

kinjba11··on YouTube takes down Xinjiang videos, forcing rights group to seek alternative
Pixel production has moved at least partially to Vietnam according to some sources.

https://www.techradar.com/news/google-pixel-4a-manufacturing...

kinjba11··on Microsoft announces Windows 11
"Everyone" in a casual sense. You don't have to use Safari, iMessage and FaceTime on Apple devices, but for all intents and purposes "everyone" does because it's the default. Similar to Internet Explorer on Windows - clearly inferior product, but it took years for it to become common knowledge among the non-technical folks that you really should install a better browser.
kinjba11··on Microsoft announces Windows 11
I'm with you, but I doubt it. To my knowledge, Apple hasn't faced any antitrust pressure from bundling FaceTime and iMessage into iOS/Mac OS.
kinjba11··on Microsoft announces Windows 11
I believe Apple is working on getting iOS apps working in future versions of Mac OS. Microsoft being able to run Android apps in Windows is probably in part a response to that.
kinjba11··on Microsoft announces Windows 11
> Do you use a smartphone? >> What does that have to do with anything?

I would bet 99% of iOS and Android users sign in with their Apple or Google account. Signing into an account for an OS is par for the course in 2021.

kinjba11··on Introducing Windows 11
Laptops are still a thing. I imagine the age group of TikTok users includes a lot of students. A phone won't cut it for anything like schoolwork. The Surface line of Windows PCs and the multitudes of 2-in-1s are very touch-centric and can act as big tablets. The "sit in front of a desktop" association is a bit outdated.
kinjba11··on Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on municipal broadband
I'm reminded of the 'Information Bubble' section in Wait But Why's 'A Sick Giant's essay. Essentially, once upon a time the big media outlets had an incentive to reach a broad audience. The biggest megaphone had to appeal across the political spectrum. Then, cable news, the Internet, etc. balkanized journalism. Everyone could easily shift themselves into whatever bubble they wanted to pretend was reality.

https://waitbutwhy.com/2020/01/sick-giant.html

kinjba11··on .NET Open Source: What Happens When the Free Lunch Ends?
I hope the .NET Foundation can step things up. It's a real shame when useful projects like dnSpy and Accord.NET are archived.

https://github.com/dnSpy/dnSpy https://github.com/accord-net/framework

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →