HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on AMD could enter ARM market with Sound Wave APU built on TSMC 3nm process
It’s a false rumour. Arm has decades of ISA design experience and their chief architect has talked about designing Aarch64.

Sure they Apple and Arm worked together but it wasn’t developed by Apple and given to Arm.

klelatti··on AMD could enter ARM market with Sound Wave APU built on TSMC 3nm process
Very unlikely. Moving to Arm allowed Apple to have a single architecture across all their hardware and leverage iPhone designs as the starting point for Mac SoCs.
klelatti··on AMD could enter ARM market with Sound Wave APU built on TSMC 3nm process
> The chip is expected to power future Microsoft Surface products scheduled for release in 2026.

They would have to persuade MS to create Windows for RISC-V in this case.

klelatti··on State of Embedded: Q4 2025 Overview
You might like the AMP hour podcast that had the team behind the RP2350 on. Lots of interesting stuff on what was involved in making it. One of my favourite podcast episodes this year.

https://theamphour.com/687-the-rp2350-with-the-raspberry-pi-...

klelatti··on State of Embedded: Q4 2025 Overview
Not to disagree with your critique but just to note that they are a microcontroller vendor with the RP2040 and RP2350.

I do wonder if there is a long term wish to break their dependency on Broadcom but I suspect creating an SoC for the main Pi series is probably in the 'too difficult' category.

klelatti··on Easy RISC-V
Sorry, Apple didn’t help to develop ARM originally. They were an early investor and customer of Advanced RISC Machines when it was spun out of Acorn.
klelatti··on Easy RISC-V
It's clear that Arm worked with Apple on AArch64 but saying it was basically designed 'by Apple' rather than 'with Apple' is demonstrably unfair to the Arm team who have decades of experience in ISA design.

If Apple didn't need Arm then they would have probably found a way of going it alone.

klelatti··on Easy RISC-V
Probably closer to RISC-1 which shouldn't be surprising given Patterson's role in both - as Patterson himself sets out:

https://aspire.eecs.berkeley.edu/2017/06/how-close-is-risc-v...

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/risc-on-a-chip-david-pa...

klelatti··on Easy RISC-V
https://github.com/dramforever/easyriscv/blob/main/emulator....
klelatti··on The pivot
You might enjoy the Incautious Optimism Substack. Recent articles are paid but earlier ones are free and it’s full of fascinating technologies with an optimistic flavour.

https://jordanwtaylor2.substack.com/

klelatti··on David Byrne Radio
The Byrne 'solo album' number Big Business [1] has long been my favourite track (actually outtake) from Stop Making Sense. Byrne's eclectic collaborations and willingness to learn from others (eg Fela Kuti) have always amazed me.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYFqdrOMqk4

klelatti··on Testing the Raspberry Pi 500+'s new mechanical keyboard
Fair enough. Previously the commercial arm was 100% owned by the foundation and the foundation didn't make computers.

Not true that nothing has changed though. Commercial arm has to answer to outside shareholders now which wasn't the case before.

klelatti··on Testing the Raspberry Pi 500+'s new mechanical keyboard
Not really true any more. You've linked to the foundation but the computers are made by Raspberry PI Holdings which is listed on the London Stock Exchange.

The foundation still owns part of the quoted company and retains its educational purpose but it doesn't make the computers now.

klelatti··on A history of ARM, part 1: Building the first chip (2022)
IIRC Arm licensed 'short instruction' encoding from Hitachi where it had been used SuperH to create Thumb which was key in getting Arm into phones.
klelatti··on A history of ARM, part 1: Building the first chip (2022)
Agree 100%. I think that without Saxby there would be no Arm as we know it today.

IIRC Steve Furber and colleagues considered the licensing model and decided it would never work. Saxby made it work. All credit to him too for standing down before he overstayed his welcome and keeping out the limelight since.

Yes, re Sophie it was Firepath I think as per this presentation (2014).

https://old.hotchips.org/wp-content/uploads/hc_archives/hc14...

klelatti··on A history of ARM, part 1: Building the first chip (2022)
May also be of interest on the history of ARM - up to 1997:

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/the-arm-story-part-1-fr...

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/the-arm-story-part-2-ar...

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/the-arm-story-part-3-cr...

This interview with ARM's first CEO Robin Saxby is also really entertaining and informative. His energy is really infectious:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FO5PsAY5aaI&t=1823s

klelatti··on The PC was never a true 'IBMer'
> The PC Division was expected to make a lot of money while paying what was internally called “the blue tax.” In other words, corporate hit us with effective tax rates and metrics that basically made it impossible to compete with Compaq or Dell

Thank you for confirming the precise point that I made in the post!

klelatti··on Dissecting the Apple M1 GPU, the end
> I’m 21 now. I’ll be blunt: if not for gender-affirming care, I don’t know if I would be around. If there would be FOSS graphics drivers for Mali-T860 or the Apple M1.
klelatti··on 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC
> 'The UK’s Online Safety Act didn’t come from Parliament or the public'

It was debated at length in parliament and it was voted into legislation by parliament. It was developed by a Tory government and has been implemented by a Labour one.

I don't like the OSA but the whole 'robber baron' organisation thing in that video is just .. well Andrew Carnegie died more than a hundred years ago. He funded a lot of charitable organisations including one that has funded work in this area.

klelatti··on Staff disquiet as Alan Turing Institute faces identity crisis
The people (about 2,000) are London based and work for a UK registered company so in both practical and legal senses the work is in the UK (eg employment taxes are paid in the UK). That the product of that work may be sold to another country for a price that transfers profits elsewhere doesn't change either of these facts.

I don't agree with the statement that you're challenging but Google DeepMind's operations in London make it (still) an important centre for AI research and is probably why the UK is ranked third on many international AI country rankings.

klelatti··on Staff disquiet as Alan Turing Institute faces identity crisis
> The registered HQ and a large research center are in London ...

> so the work is, in practical and legal senses, U.S.-based...

These two statements literally contradict each other in both cases.

klelatti··on BBC Micro, ancestor to ARM
The interpreter is doing a lot that you’ve not mentioned here; parsing the BASIC source code for example.
klelatti··on BBC Micro, ancestor to ARM
Thanks for the quote which is very interesting. Not being pedantic but this isn’t quite what your original comment said. Sophie is saying ‘same type’ of results and not having to use assembly for certain applications which doesn’t imply that BASIC on ARM would be faster than 6502 assembly just that it was fast enough for their purposes.

I think it’s possible that some applications would be faster - floating point for example due to the ARM’s 32 bit registers and the 6502’s lack of even 16 bit arithmetic - but probably not in general.

klelatti··on BBC Micro, ancestor to ARM
With Datapoint’s own ISA of course!
klelatti··on BBC Micro, ancestor to ARM
100%! There is clear lineage back to the Datapoint 2200 which is remarkable given that it wasn't even an Intel design and CTC gave away the rights IIRC.
klelatti··on BBC Micro, ancestor to ARM
BBC BASIC wasn't JIT'd etc so not sure how all the Android comparisons come in!

Just to make the comparison more concrete the ARM1 ran at 8MHz and was 32-bit and with a lot more registers compared to the BBC Micro's 6502 running at 2MHz. It was a lot faster but not fast enough to make BBC BASIC run at BBC Micro Assembly language speed.

klelatti··on BBC Micro, ancestor to ARM
> Well the ARM's original goal was to run BBC BASIC faster than the BBC B could run assembly code.

That seems an unlikely goal given BBC BASIC was interpreted! Happy to be proven wrong but I've never heard one of the original team say that.

klelatti··on BBC Micro, ancestor to ARM
8080 -> 8086 not compatible although assembly code translation was possible.
klelatti··on BBC Micro, ancestor to ARM
I can remember attending a meeting of the Cambridge University Computer Society (in 1985?) when a presenter from Acorn (Steve Furber?) talked about the new CPU they had developed.

I think the right adjective for the reaction of those present was 'incredulous'. A small team with no previous experience had created a powerful 32-bit design from scratch when 8-bit architectures were still commonly used.

Had anyone told us that 40 years later we'd all be carrying around the 'descendants' of that first Acorn RISC Machine in our pockets then we'd have been utterly astonished.

klelatti··on Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act
So you’re saying that someone who worked in government on online regulation has carried on that interest outside at a charitable foundation and has had some influence in drafting this legislation?

Not that surprising really is it? And all that is advertised on the individual’s bio online.

The only dubious thing you allude to are ‘financial ties’ to Yoti which are completely unsubstantiated. In fact I took the trouble of looking at the Carnegie Foundation’s accounts [1] and for the last two years at least they have had virtually no donor income at all so they are certainly not being funded by Yoti. Perhaps you would like to be more specific about these ties?

I don’t like this legislation much but creating a controversy when there isn’t one isn’t going to get it changed.

Edit: Just to add that the Carnegie Foundation seems to be about as independent and transparent as you can get which might be why it’s been influential. If you don’t think Google, Meta et all have all been lobbying furiously behind the scenes then I don’t know what to say.

Happy to take downvotes for calling out a fake conspiracy theory (‘there’s something going on’).

[1] https://carnegieuk.org/publication/annual-report-and-account...

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →