HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on Tenstorrent and the State of AI Hardware Startups
> Nuvia has been conned by Arm

> So Arm attempts to use or abuse whatever was written in their ALAs

> Even if Arm had been cunning enough to have included paragraphs in their ALAs

Clauses requiring consent for transfer of IP rights (or on change of control) are standard everywhere and Nuvia would have been fully aware of this at the time of signing the ALA.

klelatti··on Tenstorrent and the State of AI Hardware Startups
My comment wasn’t really around legal or business merits but rather the bad faith nature of these actions which would apply whether using open or closed source ip.

However, the ‘dangers of building on sole-source’ licensed IP is true in general but a bit overdone in this case. Qualcomm had a large number of options using Arm IP including developing their own cores in house. However they chose to do something that was - on the face of it - in breach of license agreements that Nuvia had signed.

klelatti··on Tenstorrent and the State of AI Hardware Startups
It is informative to note the contrast between the fact that 22 companies (Microsoft, Google, Samsung, etc, etc) were all given enough notice in advance of the Nuvia acquisition, to be able to come up with a quote endorsing it. [1]

And the treatment of the 'partner' upon whose IP the deal depends:

> Neither Qualcomm nor Nuvia provided prior notice of this transaction to Arm [2]

[1] https://www.qualcomm.com/news/releases/2021/01/qualcomm-acqu...

[2] From Arm's initial court submission.

klelatti··on Stanley Kubrick's the Shining Maps of the Overlook
> he only needed the story as a vehicle of meaning

Agreed and I wonder if the same could be said of 2001?

klelatti··on Intel's Death and Potential Revival
Dylan Patel comes to essentially the same conclusions (and this is a better post I think):

https://semianalysis.com/2024/12/09/intel-on-the-brink-of-de...

The problem is there are two distinct objectives:

1. Maximise shareholder value

2. Maintain and extend Intel's (close to) leading-edge fab capability.

These are not necessarily consistent!

The Intel Board (bad as it is) is trying to deliver 1. and probably now doesn't care about 2. That's not what the US needs, so some sort of government intervention is inevitable if 2. is to be achieved.

And I'm not convinced that PG's IDM 2.0 strategy would have delivered either.

klelatti··on Intel on the Brink of Death
Best analysis I've read so far of how Intel got into this mess and how it could (and won't) get out of it.
klelatti··on What Arm's CEO makes of the Intel debacle
There is an interesting discussion on Optane on the Oxide podcast that I linked to. Long story short Oxide was interested but Intel's culture of secrecy got in the way. Not surprised the cloud providers weren't interested either.
klelatti··on What Arm's CEO makes of the Intel debacle
Didn't 'Gelsinger era' Intel abandon Optane and Tofino?

And listening to the most recent Oxide podcast [1] I can't think the Oxide team would want to stay long at Intel unless the new CEO took radical action.

[1] https://oxide.computer/podcasts/oxide-and-friends/2218242

klelatti··on Intel’s board, and an example of when boards and short-termism fail
So Gelsinger personally did all the technical work on 18A? Of course he didn’t and the work on that will continue.

He also didn’t really deal with the other issues you’ve highlighted and the ‘didn’t have time bit’ is just an excuse.

I mean how much time did it take to say eg Gaudi is a distraction and we should end it?

klelatti··on Intel’s board, and an example of when boards and short-termism fail
I’m not sure how it’s possible to come to a firm view on this decision on the basis of the information that is now public.

For example whilst there has been apparent technical progress eg on 18A - which is central to Gelsingers track record - it will mean nothing without IFS customers. It wouldn’t take a technical background to evaluate whether Intel is making progress in actually signing firms up for IFS.

Will technical progress continue without Gelsinger - surely yes. But a new CEO might also deal with issues that he was clearly slow to such as costs and getting rid of products that are going nowhere.

klelatti··on AmpereOne: Cores Are the New MHz
Ampere cores are not ‘most Arm cores’
klelatti··on AmpereOne: Cores Are the New MHz
> but has hyper-threading (!!!) meaning you get 384 threads... So this means that AMD is essentially on par with ARM cpus

So you’re saying ‘essentially’ an AMD thread is the same as an ampere core?!

klelatti··on Intel announces retirement of Pat Gelsinger
If Qualcomm loses to Arm in the courts then they have a big problem in 2025 which switching to RISC-V at some point in the future will not solve for them.
klelatti··on Intel announces retirement of Pat Gelsinger
Hypothetically, if Qualcomm have broken their Arm licenses in a way that damages Arm’s business do you think Arm are supposed to just let them carry on? Should Arm say ‘legal action won’t look good so we’ll just let it pass’?

And the fact that Qualcomm got just about everyone to endorse the acquisition ahead of announcing it but didn’t even tell Arm is a bit of a tell.

klelatti··on Revisiting the DOS Memory Models
At the very start of the post:

> At the beginning of the year, I wrote a bunch of articles on the various tricks DOS played to overcome the tight memory limits of x86’s real mode.

With link to an article.

klelatti··on Pushing AMD's Infinity Fabric to Its Limits
Dupe:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42230355

klelatti··on How the ZX Spectrum became a 1980s icon
Loads of inexpensive quality games - so kids wanted one, but also programmable with a decent enough BASIC for the era - so parents could see it as an educational tool too.

Plus, cheap enough to be affordable for most families.

klelatti··on Qualcomm RISCs, Arm Pulls: The Legal Battle for the Future of Client Computing
I think I would rather characterise it as hardball action by Qualcomm that got an expected response from Arm. The fact that Qualcomm told everyone except Arm in advance of the Nuvia deal is a tell.

I think settlement is unlikely - we are two years into the lawsuit. Arm really doesn’t want Oryon cores dominating - I think independent of price - and Qualcomm probably feels it has little to lose.

(I’m the author of this post)

klelatti··on The rise of the U.S., the rise of China
The point is that the US got a huge jump start in 19C from copying - and often improving - other countries technology. Sure lots of fundamental inventions - like Edison came at the end of that period but it doesn’t negate the jump start.

So ‘the US invented its technology’ really doesn’t describe the position accurately. Nor is the contrast with China as stark as you imply.

klelatti··on Microprocessor's Romance with Integers
From Wikipedia it sounds like the closest English equivalent would be Lord John Neumann of Margitta.

Reasoning: the title was hereditary and knighthoods aren’t but peerages can be. Also peerages are often associated with with a place but knighthoods aren’t.

klelatti··on The rise of the U.S., the rise of China
Not really. As the top voted comment here says

> A parallel that was not mentioned has to do with intellectual property. In the 19th century the US did not respect foreign copyrights or patents; smuggled British machinery was cloned to produce the American industrial revolution, and Charles Dickens was the most popular author in the US but he didn't get a dime from American publishers, who could just take and print his works.

I mean where was the railway invented for example.

klelatti··on Inside the Transport for London cyberattack
Agreed and interesting and good to see it has > 1k paying subs (out of 7k total) after a little more than a month - probably as a result of some great stories already. A promising start.
klelatti··on Why breaking Intel in two is the only way to save it
Also relevant, in response:

Former Intel CEO Craig Barrett: Splitting up America’s leading chipmaker is a bad idea

https://fortune.com/2024/10/25/former-intel-ceo-craig-barret...

klelatti··on The Lion of St. Mark's Square in Venice Is Chinese
Maybe an archaeologist will discover your phone in 1000 years, and lo tests will confirm that it came from China!
klelatti··on Arm is canceling Qualcomm's chip design license
> but you can refuse to license them for their next product

That might not be legally possible - or deemed to be anticompetitive. Cancelling an existing license if a firm has breached it would probably be less problematic.

klelatti··on Arm is canceling Qualcomm's chip design license
Reasonably sure that Qualcomm aren’t claiming their X Elite cores are free of Nuvia created IP. Rather that Arm can’t prevent the transfer of that IP to Qualcomm.
klelatti··on Arm is canceling Qualcomm's chip design license
Not quite. Qualcomm had an existing architecture license but with lower royalty rates than Nuvia’s. They claim they can sell Nuvia derived designs under that license with it’s lower royalty rates.
klelatti··on The mystifying, acrimonious battle between Arm and Qualcomm
> Arm’s other customers lose either way.

Sure Arm has done things - eg pricing v8 to v9 that customers hate. But do you really think Mediatek for example wants to compete with Qualcomm selling Nuvia based cores with a low ALA based royalty.

klelatti··on Arm is canceling Qualcomm's chip design license
What’s missing from most of these analyses is the perspective that Arm really doesn’t want Qualcomm to become a dominant - architecture license (ALA) based - vendor of Arm based SoCs. Bad for Arm and for Arm’s other customers and the ecosystem.

Whilst Qualcomm has a wide ranging ALA that’s always a possibility. This might just be an opportunistic move to remove that threat to Arm’s business model.

klelatti··on Have McKinsey and its consulting rivals got too big?
> Excitement among clients over this type of “generative” AI is also creating opportunities for new work. Mr Schweizer says that BCG has already completed hundreds of projects with clients around the technology. Accenture has booked $1.1bn-worth of generative-AI work in the past six months.

During a gold rush teach people how to use their shovels.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →